Chinmayanand case: The law student denied permission for semester exams
Maharashtra: Supreme Court orders floor test by open ballot tomorrow
Karnataka: “Federation of Student organisations for Free education” calls for Nationalisation of Education
How can we support the struggle of JNU students?
Student organisation representatives and their leaders leaving aside their party and ideological disagreements had attended the meeting at Gandhinagar office demanding free education for all from primary school and Ph.D degree along with the question of how can we immediately intervene and support JNU’s Student Struggle. The meeting, which lasted for about two hours, involved a long discussion on many issues. “It was decided to call and invite more people who are concerned about the issue,” CS Dwarkanath said. Srinivas from Bahujan Vidyarthi Sangathane (BVS) told his experience of studies in JNU and how coming from poor family it helped him a lot. – I completed MA, M.Phil, and Ph.D. from 2002 to 2010 at JNU, Delhi. JNU offers an excellent education at a very low cost. That is why there are poor talented students from all corners of India. I also went to JNU from my village and completed my studies with 300 rupees a year. Otherwise, I would not have been able to get through this. They do not impose their doctrine on anyone, even though there is much communist influence there. There is also ABVP, NSUI. We also started an organization called Bahujan Students Front. In spite of having several organizations, nobody forces their ideology on to others. The freedom that we get in JNU, makes us to realize the true reality of India and inspires us to build strong India. The BJP government is concerned that those who come out will sow the same thoughts in society. For this reason they are trying to finish off JNU. For saving it we are uniting in Karnataka.SC asks for governor invitation letter to BJP while Shiv Sena-NCP demand floor test
How the midnight coup unfolded in Maharashtra?
How was President rule revoked in Maharashtra?
Many in the opposition have questioned the revocation of President rule in the state at 6 AM. Union Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad answered that it was done under Rule 12 of the Allocation of Business Rules 1961. The rule says the Prime Minister can take a call on the matter to “meet a situation of extreme urgency or unforeseen contingency”. According to rules, the imposition or revocation of President’s Rule needs a go-ahead from the Union cabinet. But in this case, it was Prime Minister Narendra Modi who gave the green signal.But nobody has been able to tell what were the extremely urgent circumstances that made PM Modi to use his special powersOfficials said under Rule 12, the Prime Minister has special powers to bypass the need for Union Cabinet’s recommendation for revocation President’s Rule in Maharashtra. The rule also stipulates that to invoke it, the proposal should be accompanied by a “detailed justification clearly bringing out the urgency involved in the matter and the exceptional circumstances that require it to be processed under Rule 12”.
What’s next?
Since then NCP has sacked Ajit Pawar as its house leader but not expelled him from the party. Seven of the 11 MLAs who had initially gone with Ajit Pawar have come back to NCP fold claiming innocence of Ajit Pawar’s ploy. Now the questions ahead of BJP Ajit Pawar combine is how will they prove majority if most NCP’s MLA still pledges loyalty to NCP. Meanwhile, Congress, NCP and Shiv Sena are ferrying their legislators to other states or to hotels with security outside to prevent poaching from BJP. Fadnavis has to prove his majority by November 30.Devendra Fadnavis takes oath as Chief minister of Maharashtra
Speaking to Media, Devendra Fadnavis said that the state did not need a ‘khichdi’ government the way Shiv Sena was trying to form. Sharad Pawar and Uddhav Thackrey might address a joint press conference today.#WATCH Mumbai: NCP's Ajit Pawar takes oath as Deputy CM, oath administered by Maharashtra Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari at Raj Bhawan. pic.twitter.com/TThGy9Guyr
— ANI (@ANI) November 23, 2019
Karnataka: Students organisations across the state protest condemning the attack on JNU students
Students organizations across Karnataka protested in eleven districts including Bangalore condemning the attack on JNU students yesterday. Students want to raise their demands and highlight problems with their colleges, university departments and also wanted to express their deep solidarity to students of Jawaharlal Nehru University. Some student organisation has planned to protest tomorrow the nationwide call from JNUSU.
Bangalore

In support of protesting JNU students SFI, AISF, AIDSO, KVS, and many other student organizations have registered their protest at Mysore Bank Circle in Bangalore.
Social activist B. Sripad Bhatt while speaking at the protests said, “The current central government is trying to take over JNU like other institutions. But, JNU is resisting this assault on them and hence the central government is attempting to destroy JNU”.
“94 thousand crores of education cess has been collected. Eight thousand crores have been raised in the name of research and development. Where has all this money gone?
One thousand research papers are published from JNU every year. There are 8,000 students studying there and it costs around 500 crores annually. The central government, which spends over Rs 2,000 crore a year on its campaigns, is unfairly raising fees on these students” he questioned.
He also questioned the government “In Banaras Hindu University the police and the government are backing the protests to disallow Sanskrit teacher Feroze Khan from teaching. Students are performing a ritual ceremony to create trouble. Though this constituency is that of Prime minister himself he hasn’t uttered a word yet. But here in JNU, the students who are protesting to save democracy are being Lathicharged” he expressed his agony.
“The central government has decided to abolish University Grants Commission. UGC gives funds for research to different departments and research scholars. The government wants to control higher education by controlling the funding agency. The JNU fee hike is part of this conspiracy” He said expressing his anger.
V Ambarish and Gururaja Desai from SFI, Jyoti from AISF, Ashvini K.S and Ajay Kamat from AIDSO, Sarovar Benkigere and Gurumurthy from KVS and many others participated in protests.
Sarovar Benkikere, state convener of Karnataka Vidyarthi Sangathane (KVS) says- The students from Dalit, Adivasi and poor families cannot afford education in private universities that charge exorbitant fees. The government wants to demolish the public sector completely. After destroying primary education and government schools, the next target is higher education. Students from Dalit, Adivasi and poor families cannot afford the expensive private schools and universities. This push for fee hike and privatization is just a means to push marginalized further out of the education sector. The government is cutting our thumbs to ensure that Dalits and Adivasis cannot study and education remain a stronghold of Upper castes. The government is following the tenets of Manusmriti and varnashram. RaichurThere were protests by KVS, SFI and other progressive organizations in Raichur against the increase in fees for JNU students, the new education policy and privatization of education.
Students expressed their anger and condemned the police brutality in Delhi on JNU students. They appealed to the district authorities to express their concerns on student matters.

Laxman Mandalgera of KVS- The government wants to silence the voice of youth. Police who were supposed to protect the peaceful students protest march towards Parliament, lathi-charged and used water cannons against the JNU students at the behest of the central government.
Sindanuru
A coalition of progressive organizations protested in Sindhanur condemning the fee hike in universities and physical assault by the police on JNU students. Samad Chaudhry, Nagaraj Pujar and many others participated in a protest in front of the Sindhur Taluk office by aDavanagere
A protest at Davangere University was held yesterday condemning the attack on JNU students’ and supporting their struggle. Veena from AISF and SFI leaders attended the protests.

Pavitra of KVS gave a statement- Normally you would see the percentage of women is low in higher education. But in JNU it is 50% because it is enshrined in its admission policies. Women in JNU are fighting for their right to study, a right that is often curtailed by families for lack of finances. It will be a huge setback to many women students who come to higher education with big hopes of making a career for themselves.
Many students cannot afford to buy books and all publications are not available online. Many students without resources lag behind because of this. So demand to have libraries open for longer periods to time is a valid demand and students across country have been demanding it for many years. But many TV channels and on social media, we see this demand is being made to look like students want to enjoy all night and want to be outside. What kind of people are these? these people are anti-education!!
In the police action against the protesting students, many students were dragged, attacked, one blind person was also attacked, women were molested. This is shameful of Delhi police to act this way and we condemn such actions and we are in solidarity with the demands of JNU students.Kalaburgi
In Kalbarugi( Gulbarga), progressive organizations organized a procession and protested in front commissioner’s office in support of the JNU students. Activist and intellectual K Neela and KVS’s Rajendra Rajwala were present.


Ayodhya Verdict: Couldnt Mandir – Masjid stay together?
Some things take their own sweet time to take the desired form; Sangh Parivar knows this truth very well.
Nation’s social and secular fabric was destroyed by the Babri Masjid- Mandir dispute in Ayodhya in recent decades. This was given an end by Supreme court.
Supreme court said this in clear words.“The exclusion of the Muslims from worship and possession took place on the intervening night between 22/23 December 1949 when the mosque was desecrated by the installation of Hindu idols. The ouster of the Muslims on that occasion was not through any lawful authority but through an act which was calculated to deprive them of their place of worship.”
“After the proceedings under Section 145 of CrPC 1898 were initiated and a receiver was appointed following the attachment of the inner courtyard, worship of the Hindu idols was permitted. During the pendency of the suits, the entire structure of the mosque was brought down in a calculated act of destroying a place of public worship. The Muslims have been wrongly deprived of a mosque which had been constructed well over 450 years ago.”
Despite saying this in clear words, how could it happen that the disputed land was handed over only for Mandir construction? Many of the retired judges ask this question.
As an answer, the supreme court has said this in paragraph 799. “We have already concluded that the three-way bifurcation(Sunny waqf board, Ram Lalla Virajman and Nirmohi Akhada) by the High Court was legally unsustainable. Even as a matter of maintaining public peace and tranquillity, the solution which commended itself to the High Court is not feasible. The disputed site admeasures all of 1500 square yards. Dividing the land will not subserve the interest of either of the parties or secure a lasting sense of peace and tranquillity. “
What happens outside the court related to a case which is subjudice is totally irrelevant for us. Law and constitution are our supreme pinnacles. Our justice, our judgement process is based only on these two factors’ law and constitution. Thus the supreme court has reiterated in hundreds of cases.
But one can see many glaring exceptions to this stand of the supreme court. Emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi is one example. ‘Court could not avoid getting influenced by outside environment’ for this opinion, a glaring example made its presence in history forever. The right to freedom of human being and right to live are the fundamental rights given by our constitution. (Though these are not unfettered).
During the emergency, a five-member bench of the supreme court gave a majority judgement saying these two rights can be dismissed.
Justice H R Khanna wrote this judgement
In civil society, the right to life and personal freedom are fundamental rights of human beings… to surrender these rights to executive will not be allowed by the constitution and our laws.
Because of this dissenting judgement, he was denied promotion to the post of the chief justice, neglecting his seniority in service, a junior justice was promoted to the post and that was one of the egregious extremes of emergency.
In a later day, chief justice of supreme court apologized for this judgement. PN Bhagwati repented and said, he should have resigned than being part of such judgement.
This judgement is cited only as an example that the atmosphere outside the court can have an effect on a court judgement.
Even in Mandir Masjid dispute judgement, one cannot rule out the possibility of external factors influencing the verdict. But it is possible that, behind the current influence, a higher objective of ‘goodwill’ of maintaining social peace and harmony might have been there. The atmosphere outside the court that we see today was never seen in India before. Fierce Hindutva and aggressive nationalism have built a giant and ruthless majoritarian argument. The fact that from 1989, this dispute has spread communal polarization, violence, and hatred throughout India, must have been in the minds the judges. A good intention of avoiding another such trouble must have worked in delivering the judgement. Whatever the judgement, we must avoid feeling someone has won and someone has lost, this was said by the ruling party and the parivar behind it and it does look laudable from outset. But the ruling party and its back bone Sangha Parivar have already instigated the collective mood of majority of the country in favour of an idea of communal Hindu Rashtra. The ruling party and the parivar very well know that some things cannot be made to happen overnight. Then is it even possible that the apex court did not know this bitter truth? Thus, pros and cons that are possible if another work of hatred and violence were to affect the nation. That is why, the noble principle of delivering justice must have reduced itself into mere dispute settlement agreement. We should remember that delivering justice and dispute settlememt are two different things. If delivering justice was given priority, mandir and masjid both would have stayed together in that 2.77 acre space.
¡Evade!: How Chile’s student movement led the end of Neo-liberal tyranny
Chile- Welfare state to Military Dictatorship
In the 1930s, the elite of Chile was concerned about a revolution and began to support a modern welfare-style economy. The Chilean government then became a modern democracy. Socialism began to grow in popularity in Chile. After the Cuban revolution established a Soviet ally in the Western Hemisphere, the Americans were concerned that Latin America would see more countries shift. In the 1960s, many countries in Latin America saw military takeovers of formal democracies. In Chile, anti-socialist candidates were supported and funded by the American government. The appeal of socialism and the propaganda system were in a tussle for the popular spirit of the country. In 1970, a member of the Chilean Socialist Party, Salvador Guillermo Allende Gossens, was elected President in Chile after many failed attempts. Immediately, Allende raised the minimum wage, and increased the public sector, and increased spending on education and healthcare. The American government targeted Allende. American copper companies operating in Chile lost when Allende nationalized the mining sector. Allende advocated a parliamentary path to socialism, as opposed to a violent revolution. At a time where socialism was linked with violence in anti-left propaganda, the Americans feared this would create the threat of a good example. The American government actively started an anti-Allende campaign in Chile even before the election. This resulted in the polarization of Chile. The United States also engaged in a series of economic tactics to increase inflation in Chile, reducing the average wages in spite of raising the minimum wage when Allende was in power. In 1973, leaders of the army staged a coup. Military leader, Augusto Pinochet was established as the leader of Chile. Allende opted to commit suicide rather than negotiate. It is not clear if the American government had any direct role in the coup, but the military leadership could not have survived without American support. Pinochet’s Chile aggressively undid Allende’s reforms and pushed Chile to an unregulated market system, in the spirit of the Chicago school of economics. National industries were privatized. Trade Unions and progressive movements were violently suppressed, through torture and massacres. One of the most fascist acts was the conversion of the Estadio Nacional (National Stadium) in Santiago, Chile’s capital, to a prison camp where thousands were detained, tortured and executed for supporting Allende. While criticizing the regime internationally, America supported the changes economically, alleviating many of the ill effects of privatization. Chile controlled inflation and stabilized wages, though inequality and development in the hinterlands suffered. This came at a cost as IMF debt which rose to the point of crisis, leading to the downfall of Pinochet. In 1980, Pinochet agreed to devolve power, by establishing a new constitution of Chile, which would be the governing framework of the country.The Chilean Constitution and the Campaign for “NO”
The constitution was primarily drafted by supporters of Pinochet. It gave the military a lot of power. It kept laws restricting organizing in ways that were considered a threat to the country and kept a number of checks on representative institutions. The constitution was ratified by a controversial plebiscite, which was criticized for excessive military oversight. As Pinochet devolved his power, the political leadership of Chile gradually shifted a group of center-left parties, who opposed the plebiscite, began to share power under the banner of the Concertación por el No, or Concertación (Campaign for the No, or Campaign).
Student protests (2006-2019)- A timeline

In 2006, the famous Penguin revolution broke out, when up to 8 lakh students began a national strike, demanding free bus travel for students, reduction of fees, waiving of entrance tests, nationalizing education and universal quality education. A lot of focus was on abolishing the Organic Constitutional Act of Teaching, which made the state a regulatory body in education, rather than a provider. The Act was something that the Concertación opposed. The strike began with Secondary School students and was called the Penguin revolution on account of their school uniforms. It then spread to universities.
The protests were largely peaceful, though in one instance when 2000 students marched through Santiago, there was a confrontation with the police. Some students threw rocks at the police, and the police firing tear gas and water cannons at the students. The strikes were considered successful, and many of the demands were met, though with strong resistance.
Education became a focal point in protesting the state. In 2008, more protests followed. This time, the protests were more effectively contained, but this led to the Concertación losing the elections in 2010.
In 2011, the Chilean Winter protests erupted. Again, the protests focused on education funding and were mostly by the school and university students. This time, the protests included more spectacles, with Flash Mobs, banging of pots and pans, pictures of students kissing at demonstrations circulating. Internationally, pictures of the protests spread on social media. The protests consolidated the leadership of school students, university students, and indigenous student leadership. Agitations continued for years. Regional protests began to gain momentum on other issues, such as gas prices, healthcare, minimum wages, and the rights of the fishing community. They died down with the return of the Concertación to power. The Concertación promised to end the for-profit education system and made a series of proposals, which were rejected by the Chile constitutional court.
The Concertación lost the 2018 election. Two factors in their loss this time was the term limits on the popular Michelle Bachelet (who was in power for two non-consecutive terms by this point), and infighting within the coalition. Pro-business Sebastián Piñera won his second non-consecutive term in 2018.
In October 2019, a group of students in Santiago protested a hike in the metro fare shouting the slogan ¡Evade! (evade!) where they would use the bus without paying. After confrontations with the police, the protests became more militant. The protest escalated to the point where students began to take over 80 metro stations. Police response began to involve tear gas and water cannons, and the protests began to inspire many others across the country within a few weeks. The state responded by declaring an emergency, but the protests only grew in strength.
The protests began to hit at the root of the education problem. The constitution of Chile had to be changed. The protesters demanded that the Piñera resign and that Chile adopts a new democratic constitution.
So far, the government has agreed to hold a referendum in April but many also fear that the repression might increase.
Also Read: Ecuador rejects IMF, Neoliberal agenda, protests all over the capital
Bolivia: Another US backed military coup in Latin America
Rosa Luxemburg, a german revolutionary in a 1916 anti-war pamphlet wrote- “Bourgeois society stands at the crossroads, either transition to Socialism or regression into Barbarism”. Now, more than a century of people’s struggles and political upheavals for a just and equitable society, the world is at crossroads again between Socialism for all and Barbarism of the rich.
Latin American political landscape is no stranger to class conflicts. Lately, the continent is witnessing a resurgence of Pink Tide after a series of right-wing governments (Argentina, Ecuador, Chile, Brazil) came to power in the last five years.
Recent elections in Argentina show that people have rejected right-wing Macri’s austerity politics. Similarly, the neighbouring country Chile is also witnessing unprecedented protests against its billionaire right-wing President Piñera. Massive protests have erupted in Ecuador against the IMF introduced austerity measures by Lenin Moreno and Venezuela has managed to withstand multiple coup attempts since January 2019.
Now, we see similar upheavals in Bolivia, where President Evo Morales who weeks after winning record 4th term presidential elections has resigned after a US-backed right-wing military coup.
Evo Morales: The first Indigenous President to be ousted in a US-backed coup
Evo Morales is the first indigenous leader in Bolivia’s history who came to power in December 2005 elections in a landslide victory through his Movement for Socialism (MAS). Till then, two-third of the population which consists of various indigenous communities was ruled by the country’s wealthy oligarchs. In his 13 year rule, he stood up for the poor, workers and peasants, opposed US imperialism and championed environmentalism by pushing through rights for the Mother Earth whom the indigenous population revere. His government reduced Bolivia’s poverty rate by more than half while quadrupling GDP per capita and sustaining one of the highest economic growth rates in the region.
How OAS and US-trained leaders help overthrow Morales
The OAS or Organisation of American States is a continental organization that was founded for the purposes of solidarity and cooperation among its member states within the Western Hemisphere. During the Cold War, this meant opposing leftism as a European influence; since the 1990s, the organization has focused on election monitoring.
As the results of Elections started pouring and it looked like Morales is winning the fourth term. On October 21, a day after the election, OAS issued a statement casting doubt on the process due to an “inexplicable” change in the trend of the vote count.
This statement was thoroughly debunked by the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR), which found that the trend did not change and that Morales widened the gap over his rivals due to late reporting rural precincts, where he enjoys a tremendous advantage. However, the damage was done: protesters took to the streets decrying electoral fraud. The OAS stoked protests despite their statement being debunked and ensured that the coup was successful.
These claims were echoed by the US State Department and US Senator Rubio on Twitter.
Morales fell for OAS trap and invited OAS to conduct an audit. THE OAS instead of releasing results of the full electoral audit on November 12 repeated the older claims from the October 21st statement and called for new elections. The OAS behavior in Bolivia was condemned by several countries called it shameful and manipulative.Meanwhile, the oligarchic right-wing opposition started rioting on streets in an organised manner. They went on to attack Morales supporters, kidnap some politicians, attacked Venezuela’s embassy and have burnt their homes over some vote recount irregularities. So far the right-wing has insisted removal of Morales but has not offered any evidence to the Vote miscount/irregularities and insisted removal of Evo Morales. They mobilised the right wing groups into streets and started attacking government buildings and destroying properties.
Despite being victorious in the elections, Morales announced to hold fresh elections to control the chaos on the streets.
The military and police still asked him to resign, forcing Morales to step down to “avoid further escalating violence and bloodshed”.
Due to threats to his life, Evo Morales with the help of his supporters has managed to reach Mexico City after he was granted Political asylum by Mexico’s President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador.
Earlier this year, a coup was attempted in Venezuela by a political unknown Juan Guido. A similar political outsider, Luis Fernando Camacho has risen to the international spotlight as the main opposition leader in Bolivia. This openly racist and misogynist opposition figure is known to incite people with his anti-indigenous and racist rants. He is a white supremacist who is always seen with a Bible in hand and denounces the Bolivian indigenous beliefs. He comes from the country elite and his family is associated with many Far right anti-democratic movements in the country. His family was also been involved in the Panama Papers scandal through the registry of three offshore companies: Medis Overseas Corp., Navi International Holding, and Positive Real Estates. According to El Periodico, the coup was orchestrated by three US senators Ted Cruz, Bob Menendez, and Mario Rubio along with Bolivia’s Clergy, right-wing elites and supported by military and Police.
Some of Morales’s decisions have not gone done well with the country elites. Morales had tried to change the country’s constitution through a referendum. The older constitution was pro elite. Lately, Morales has also decided to nationalise the country’s lithium reserves. This has also angered the country Elites.

Bolivia holds one of the largest Lithium reserves along with Argentina. Shortly before the coup, his government announced plans to nationalise the highly profitable lithium industry and to deal directly with the international market instead of exporting it at bargain prices to the West. Global demand for lithium, used to make cell phone batteries, parts of laptops and electric cars, is expected to triple in the next 15 years.
The right wing opposition has resorted to widespread violence attacking the state TV station, radio stations and Morales supporters and indigenous population of the country. In Chile, where the protesters waved Indigenous Mapuche flags, in Bolivia, the protesters, together with the police are seen burning the Indigenous Whipala flag. After the coup the security forces and right-wing para militias are rounding up and beating Indigenous people and Leftists in impoverished neighborhoods in La Paz. They have also arrested several government members threatening to kill them.
World leaders and organisations have condemned the coup and have expressed solidarity with Evo Morales and Bolivian people. After offering to resign he ended his resignation speech stating: “la lucha sigue” (“the struggle continues”). Bolivian people are fighting back against pro-coup police repression. Police stations have been burned down in several working class neighbourhoods in Cochabamba and El Alto as well as smaller municipalities. In spite of international condemnation, the opposition is threatening to kill the Anti-Coup protesters.
President Trump has supported the coup and has warned democratically elected Venezuela and Nicaragua governments of serious consequences. It only remains to be seen whether Bolivia will continue to support Evo Morales against the coup or plunge into a civil war fighting the security forces.
Also read:Crimmigation: Making the Immigrant a Criminal in the United States


