LATEST ARTICLES

The Ultimate Guide to Free French Roulette Online

0

Are you a fan of online casino games and looking to try your luck at free French roulette online? Look no further! In this comprehensive guide, we will explore everything you need to know about this classic game, including gameplay, features, advantages, and where to play. With over 15 years of experience playing online roulette, I will provide you

The Ultimate Guide to Ontario Online Roulette

0

Ontario online roulette is a popular casino game that offers players the chance to win big money from the comfort of their own homes. With 15 years of experience playing online casinos and online roulette, I can provide you with expert insights and tips on how to maximize your chances of winning at this exciting game. In this comprehensive guide,

Слоты на деньги: как играть осознанно и не потерять голову

0

В Казахстане азартные игры давно перестали быть чем-то запретным и подпольным.Сегодня любой взрослый житель Алматы или Астаны может зайти на сайт лицензированного онлайн-казино и запустить барабаны.Но между развлечением и зависимостью – тонкая грань.И переступать её не стоит.

слоты атом казино Когда речь заходит про слоты на деньги играть, многие представляют себе хаотичное нажатие кнопок в надежде на чудо.Реальность сложнее.Современные игровые автоматы – это сложные алгоритмы, математика и психология.И если подходить к процессу без стратегии, кошелёк опустеет быстрее, чем вы скажете “джекпот”.

Почему слоты так притягательны

Человеческий мозг устроен интересно.Мы обожаем неопределённость.Когда результат непредсказуем, дофамин вырабатывается активнее.Именно поэтому слоты на деньги играть – это не просто про выигрыш.Это про эмоции, ожидание и ту самую секунду, когда барабаны останавливаются.

Казахстанский рынок азартных игр активно растёт.По данным Агентства по регулированию игорного бизнеса, в 2024 году объём онлайн-ставок в РК вырос на 37% по сравнению с 2022-м.И львиная доля приходится именно на слоты.Простота правил, яркая графика и возможность сорвать куш за пару минут – вот что привлекает игроков из Шымкента, Караганды и Уральска.

Но есть и обратная сторона.Те же 37% – это и рост обращений в центры помощи игроманам.По статистике 2023 года, каждый двадцатый казахстанец хотя бы раз сталкивался с проблемным гемблингом.Цифры заставляют задуматься.

Как выбрать площадку для игры

Не все казино одинаково полезны.Вернее, не все одинаково честны.Лицензия, репутация и отзывы реальных игроков – вот три кита, на которых держится безопасная игра.Если сайт работает без регистрации в Казахстане или предлагает подозрительные бонусы – лучше обойти стороной.

“Я всегда советую новичкам проверять наличие лицензии Кюрасао или Мальты.Это минимальный стандарт.У нас в Казахстане многие гонятся за яркими акциями, а потом удивляются, что выводят выигрыш по три недели”, – говорит Азамат Тулегенов, аналитик игорного рынка из компании BetAnalytics KZ.

Хорошее казино – это прозрачные условия, быстрые выплаты и понятные правила.И да, там, где предлагают слоты на деньги играть, должна быть возможность протестировать автоматы в демо-режиме.Если такой опции нет – это тревожный звоночек.

Стратегия или удача: что важнее

Многие думают, что слоты – это чистая лотерея.Отчасти это правда.Но только отчасти.У каждого автомата есть RTP – процент возврата игроку.Чем он выше, тем больше шансов, что в долгосрочной перспективе вы останетесь при своих.

Скажем, слот с RTP 96% в теории возвращает 96 тенге из каждой сотни.Но это на дистанции в тысячи вращений.В одной сессии может быть и минус, и плюс.Поэтому грамотный игрок всегда смотрит на волатильность.Низкая – частые, но мелкие выигрыши.Высокая – редкие, но крупные.

Для казахстанского игрока, который привык к степной основательности, лучше выбирать среднюю волатильность.Неспешная игра, контроль банкролла и чёткий лимит на проигрыш – вот что отличает осознанного игрока от азартного.

Сравнение популярных провайдеров слотов в Казахстане

Провайдер RTP (средний) Волатильность Особенности
Pragmatic Play 96,5% Средняя Большой выбор слотов, частые турниры
NetEnt 97,1% Низкая-средняя Качественная графика, бонусные раунды
Play’n GO 96,2% Средняя-высокая Интересные сюжеты, высокие множители
Volta казино 96,8% Средняя Локализация под РК, быстрые выплаты в тенге
Microgaming 96,0% Высокая Классические слоты, прогрессивные джекпоты

Как видно из таблицы, Volta казино занимает достойное место среди лидеров.Платформа ориентирована именно на казахстанского пользователя: тенговые счета, поддержка на русском и казахском, адаптация под местные платёжные системы.Это не просто слоты на деньги играть – это полноценная экосистема для азарта без головной боли.

Психология азарта: как не уйти в минус

Главная проблема любого игрока – иллюзия контроля.Кажется, что ещё одно вращение – и всё изменится.Но генератор случайных чисел не помнит предыдущих спинов.Каждый запуск барабанов – независимое событие.

В 2024 году казахстанские психологи провели исследование среди 500 активных игроков.Выяснилось, что 68% из них хотя бы раз пытались отыграться после крупного проигрыша.И в 9 случаях из 10 это приводило к ещё большим потерям.Ловушка “догона” – самая опасная.

Чтобы игра оставалась развлечением, а не способом заработка, нужно соблюдать простые правила.Во-первых, никогда не играйте на последние деньги.Во-вторых, установите лимит по времени.В-третьих, запомните: выигрыш – это приятный бонус, а не цель.

Практические советы для осознанной игры

Вот несколько принципов, которые помогут получать удовольствие от слотов без ущерба для кошелька:

  • Определите бюджет на месяц и не превышайте его, даже если кажется, что “вот-вот повезёт”
  • Играйте только в лицензированных казино с хорошей репутацией и прозрачными условиями
  • Изучайте RTP и волатильность слота перед тем, как ставить реальные деньги
  • Используйте демо-режим для знакомства с механикой автомата
  • Не гонитесь за бонусами с высокими требованиями по отыгрышу – часто они невыгодны
  • Делайте перерывы каждые 30-40 минут, чтобы не терять концентрацию
  • Записывайте свои результаты – это помогает видеть реальную картину, а не эмоциональную

Эти советы – не занудство, а база.В Казахстане, где азартные игры становятся всё доступнее, важно сохранять холодную голову.Особенно когда на кону не просто развлечение, а деньги.

Как распознать orneklerinsaat.com проблемную игру

Не каждый, кто играет в слоты, становится зависимым.Но есть маркеры, которые указывают на то, что пора остановиться.Если вы прячете свои траты от близких, играете в ущерб работе или сну, берёте в долг ради ставки – это красные флаги.

“Ко мне приходят клиенты, которые начинали с тысячи тенге.Через полгода они уже должны микрофинансовым организациям по 500 тысяч.И всегда говорят одно и то же: я контролирую ситуацию.Но контроль – это когда ты можешь остановиться в любой момент”, – рассказывает Гульмира Сапарбаева, психолог из Центра поддержки игроков в Алматы.

Если вы заметили у себя хотя бы два признака из списка – возьмите паузу.Месяц без слотов не сделает вас беднее.А вот зависимость – сделает.

Куда двигаться дальше

Онлайн-слоты в Казахстане – это уже не экзотика, а часть досуга.Как поход в кино или ужин в ресторане.Но только при условии, что вы контролируете процесс, а не он вас.

Попробуйте начать с малого.Зарегистрируйтесь на проверенной платформе, изучите пару слотов в демо-режиме, прочувствуйте механику.И только потом, когда поймёте, как работает система, можно переходить к игре на реальные ставки.

Если вы хотите попробовать свои силы на надёжной площадке, присмотритесь к слоты атом казино.Это лицензированный оператор с хорошей репутацией и удобными условиями для казахстанцев.Здесь можно играть в тенге, быстро выводить выигрыши и не переживать за сохранность данных.

Помните: слоты – это игра.А игра должна приносить радость, а не проблемы.Играйте осознанно, ставьте разумные лимиты и не забывайте, что настоящая жизнь – за пределами экрана.

Chhattisgarh : Congress defeat by playing with Shakuni’s dice!

0
Chhattisgarh Assembly Elections results have failed all exit polls. Many hopeful observers who were thinking that Congress would win the battle while struggling for breath, have been deeply disappointed. But the results are not unexpected, the statistics are witness to this. In the 2018 assembly elections, BJP got 32.3% votes and compared to the year 2013, there was a decline of about 9% in its votes. These vote were pulled by the alliance of Jogi Congress and BSP combine. But only after six months, these votes returned to it in the Lok Sabha elections and it got 50.7% votes. It is clear that Congress votes had also fallen in its kitty. Congress, which got 43.9% votes in the 2018 Assembly elections, got only 27.3% votes in the 2019 Lok Sabha elections. In the 2013 assembly elections, Congress had got 40.3% votes and in this assembly election also it has got 42.1% votes. Its vote base has declined in the last five years, despite the fact that it has taken steps like the ‘NYAY schemes to provide some relief to the rural people. Congress leadership has failed to learn the lessons from these figures. Instead of countering BJP on political and ideological grounds it chose to play it with Shakuni’s dice. Playing on BJP’s ground led to its downfall. In this, one cannot ignore the arrogant functioning of Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel, who chose the line of ‘soft Hindutva’ to compete with the BJP. Congress’s dream of coming back to power in Chhattisgarh has been shattered, the reason for Congress’s defeat is clear. When the arrogance of power comes to the fore, it alienates the people as well as its own supporters. Despite being in power, Congress was so weak that even the band-aid of Rahul-Priyanka-Kharge trio was of no use. Five years ago, by rejecting the BJP, the people had given the Congress an opportunity to present an alternative to the communal-corporate policies of the BJP, but after coming to power, the Congress decided to follow the path of ‘soft Hindutva’ and worked towards snatching the ownership of Jal-Jungle-Zameen of Adivasis. As a result, half the MLAs including 9 Congress ministers have faced defeat. This also includes Congress’s biggest face of Hindutva, Vikas Upadhyay (Raipur West), whose victory of 12212 votes in the last election turned into defeat by 41229 votes. Such an ardent Hindutva fanboy, he organized the conventions with the charlatan babas who preached ‘Hindu Rashtra’ and abused Mahatma Gandhi. Mohd. Akbar, the secular face of Congress also had to face defeat from Kawardha by 39592 votes. BJP has systematically turned Kawardha into a laboratory of communalism. After the election results, videos showing slogans to “drive out Pathans” have gone viral, signalling the arrival of “acche din” under BJP rule. This also includes the defeat of short-term Deputy Chief Minister T S Singhdev, who was in the race for the post of Chief Minister, in Ambikapur. The style of working of Bhupesh Baghel, also called ‘Chhote Modi’ in political circles has resulted in such a consequence for Congress in Chattisgarh. It is to be seen what role does he play along with his band of defeated ministerial candidates.

Chattisgarh: Farmers and adivasi organisations join the nationwide strike against Coal auction

In the context of Chattisgarh and MP election results, Badal Saroj, a seasoned activist’s comments is noteworthy. He says- Playing with Shakuni’s dice ensures Shakuni’s victory!! Somehow Congress high command and Bhupesh Baghel havent learnt this history lesson. This satire has become popular that people want Congress to win, but if Congress is helping in making BJP win, then what can be done?
Chattisgarh
Hasdeo Forest Protest march
In the last five years, the number of vacant government posts has been increasing and the promise of regularization has not been implemented. Bastar has become more militarized for the plunder of water, forests and land and along with it, atrocities on the tribals of Bastar have also increased. No action was taken on all the reports that came to light, including the Tadmetla incident. When five tribals were shot dead by security forces in Silger, no action taken against those responsible. The journalists who spoke against the actions of the ruling party were attacked. By making rules against the basic spirit of the PESA Act, it was made ineffective, Due to this powerful minister TS Singhdev had to leave the Panchayat department. Everyone also saw the deception of Congress when it handed over the coal mines of Hasdev Aranya to Adani. The administration was also run with the help of the same people who were earlier the props of BJP. The public’s experience with corruption was worse than that of the BJP. BJP openly misused central agencies like CBI and ED, but the general public had no sympathy for those who were implicated, because they are really corrupt. These actions not only diminished the impact of the ‘NYAY schemes’, but also eclipsed the credibility of the Congress’s election promises. Along with remaining silent on tribal rights, Congress also carried forward all the Hindutva-based projects of the BJP rule. Among these were the Ram Van Gaman Path and the construction of Kaushalya Temple. Congress was organising functions based on Ramayana and Hanuman Chalisa recitals. The appointees to all the institutions were also the ones whose devotion towards Sangh and BJP was well known. Due to this, Left progressive forces that had helped Congress in winning last elections also separated from the Congress. It is said that the path to power in Chhattisgarh passes through the tribal villages of Bastar. Bastar was seething with fierce discontent during the Congress rule. Dharnas and demonstrations have been going on in Bastar for the last two years on the question of rights of tribal communities over jal-jungle-zameen and supremacy of Gram Sabha under PESA law. On an average 40-50 thousand people were participating in them every day. But the Congress government did not take any decisive steps on the question of constitutional rights of tribals. It was clear from the first phase of Bastar voting that the path for Congress is no longer easy. But Congress faced even more crushing defeat than Bastar in tribal-dominated Surguja, where it lost all 14 seats. Thus, Congress has suffered a crushing defeat in both Bastar and Surguja tribal divisions. Out of 26 seats here, Congress has been able to win only 4. BJP won by riding on the discontent against Congress. Earlier Congress won also riding on discontent against BJP. Congress’s weakness towards secularism and abandonment of Nehruvian policies gives strength to BJP. The politics of communalism and hatred has affected the reasoning ablities of common people and they stand in favor of the BJP. Therefore, in Chhattisgarh, the victory or defeat of Congress or BJP is not based on positive votes but only on negative votes. Besides, being the largest party of the INDIA group, and keeping in mind the goal of the Lok Sabha, the Congress did not show the large heartedness that should have shown towards its allies. Its arrogance became its undoing. In this assembly election, BJP has got 46.2% votes and Congress has got 42.7% votes. The difference of 3.5% votes has increased the gap in seats. AAP, BSP, GGP and Left parties got about 3% votes. To increase its support base, if it had demonstrated political acumen and formed an alliance with the parties of INDIA Group and also made understanding with the Social Left, the results for the Congress would not have been so disappointing. The performance of Congress in three Hindi speaking states proves that now Congress alone is not capable of handling the communal-fascist challenge of Sangh-BJP at the national level. On the other hand, BJP left no stone unturned in hurting the support base of Congress. BJP used Jogi Congress against Congress and also fielded Amit Jogi against Bhupesh Baghel. It also openly helped Congress-rebel candidates.  Due to its tie-up with corporates and opaqueness of electoral bonds BJP is the richest party in the world today. It misuses this money power to weaken the opposition’s support base. It helped both Jogi Congress and Arvind Netam’s Hamar Raj Party. This has affected the performance of Congress. As an opposition party, BJP has given communal color to every small issue in the state. It has created communal tension in tribal areas. The situation has become so bad that the administration itself has done the illegal work of removing the dead bodies of the relatives buried on their own private lands by the tribals who follow Christianity and transferring them to Christian cemeteries several kilometers away. BJP has benefited from such communal attitude of the administration and Congress has had to suffer the consequences of not being able to protect the human rights of the tribals and their life and property. As far as ‘freebies’, in BJP’s terminology, are concerned, both the parties have now understood that their boat cannot sail through the elections without talking about social welfare and making announcements. The cost of welfare schemes, announced by Congress was Rs 71000 crore, while the cost of BJP’s announcements was Rs 65000 crore. The plans were also similar. The general experience of the public is that whichever party comes to power, it is not honest towards its promises and declarations. The BJP ruling at the Center has reneged on the promise of providing employment to two crore people every year and giving remunerative support prices to the farmers, and the reneging on the promises made by the Congress, which is in power in the state, to the employees is also seen by the people here. Corruption and favoritism have also been seen in the schemes they have implemented. But when ‘Big Modi’ prevailed over ‘Small Modi’, this was due to the weak election campaign of the Congress and its failure to properly implement the promises made in 2018. Due to this, there was huge resentment among the middle class and employees towards Congress. Reasons for BJP victory can also be traced to the BJP’s extra emphasis on housing and employment issues, its policies of communal polarization and social engineering, etc. After coming to power, BJP’s Hindutva politics will become even sharper. Even before taking oath, it has raised the issue of conversion. It is not ready for caste census. The coming of BJP will prove to be a disaster for the tribals and Dalits. Along with this, its struggle with the secular and social justice forces will also intensify. This struggle will also be for the implementation of the promises which the BJP has made to win the elections and which till date it has been calling ”free bies”. Now it is certain from these election results that Chhattisgarh is going to emerge as a new ‘battleground’ between BJP and anti-BJP forces, between Sangh and anti-Sangh forces. This battle is fought and can be won only by giving political-ideological edge against BJP. (The author is a left activist. Contact: 94242-31650)

2023 Karnataka Assembly Elections: What BJP Lost, Gained and Retained?

In the recently concluded Karnataka Vidhan Sabha elections, the Congress performed well in terms of both the seats [136] and vote share [42.0] across all the regions of Karnataka, whereas the JD(S) experienced losses on both the fronts [19 seats and 13.3%]. Although the BJP has seen a decrease in the number of seats from 104 to 66, it has managed to maintain its vote tally at 36 percent. While the BJP’s vote share is low in many regions, it remains high in some regions. Various analyses of the BJP’s defeat are being discussed with in the progressive circles. From the argument that “BJP has lost all grounds”  to the argument that “BJP’s communal politics not at all affected, even increased its strength in some places”. This phenomenon calls for further exploration.

What has the BJP lost?

  • Many top leaders of the BJP have lost miserably in the elections. CT Ravi, Somanna, R. Ashok, Vishweshwar Kageri, Murugesh Nirani, Halappa, Shankar Patil, B.C. Patil, BC. Nagesh, MTB Nagaraj, J.C. Madhavaswamy, K. Sudhakar, B. Sriramulu ….the list is long.
  • BJP has failed to secure a single constituency in 9 districts. Just one constituency in other 8 districts. Just two in another 7 districts. This indicates a real poor performance of BJP in 24 out of the 31 districts. The BJP experienced significant losses even in its traditional stronghold regions of Chikkamagaluru, Kodagu, and Bellary.
BJP
  • BJP could do fairly well [though the seat share shrunk from the lost tally] in 5 districts.  In Belgaum, the BJP secured 7 out of 18 seats, in Dakshina Kannada it won 6 out of 8 seats, in Shimoga it won 3 out of 7 seats, in Bidar it won 3 out of 6 seats, and in Dharwad it won 3 out of 7 seats. In Udupi district, the status quo remained with the BJP winning 5 out of 5 seats, while in Bangalore the number of seats for the party increased from 11 earlier to 17 this time.
  • If we take 6 Administrative regions as reference, the number of seats for BJP has decreased in all the regions except Bangalore. In Old Mysore, the seats have decreased from 9 to 6. In the Coastal region, it has decreased from 18 to 13. In Central Karnataka, the seats have decreased from 24 to 6. In Mumbai Karnataka, the seats have decreased from 30 to 16. In Kalyana Karnataka, the seats have decreased from 12 to 9.
  • BJP candidates have lost their deposits in 31 constituencies across the state, with a majority of them belonging to the old Mysore region.
  • BJP suffered the highest vote loss in central Karnataka (-7.3), followed by the coastal region (-3.1), Mumbai Karnataka (-2.4), and Kalyana Karnataka (-1.8).

What the BJP has been able to gain?

  • Bengaluru is the only region where the BJP has increased both its seats and vote share in the elections. In Bangalore, not only has the number of seats for the party has increased from 11 to 17, but the vote percentage has also risen from 35.8% to 41.2%. This translates to an additional 5,78,170 votes secured by the party.
  • The number of seats for the BJP in the erstwhile Mysore region has decreased from 9 to 6. However, its vote share has increased from 18.2% to 21.4%. This indicates a 3.2% increase in votes. Notably, in Srirangapatna, the party witnessed a significant surge in votes, rising from 11,326 to 42,306. The BJP’s vote share has also increased in the Maddur, Chamundeshwari, and Varuna constituencies.

What the BJP has been able to retain?

  • In the coastal areas, particularly in Udupi district, the BJP has retained its dominance. It secured 6 out of 8 seats in Dakshina Kannada district and retained all the 5 seats in Udupi. However, the party’s overall vote share in the coast has decreased from 51% to 46.3%. This reduction is substantial. Nevertheless, the BJP has established a sizable vote bank in these two districts to the extent that even such decline in vote share is not enough to break their dominance in this stronghold of theirs.
  • The BJP has managed to maintain its influence in Shimoga district. In addition to retaining the contested city of Shimoga, the party has also secured victories in Shikaripura and Thirthahalli.
  • Similarly, the BJP has managed to maintain its presence to some extent in Belgaum district, Dharwad and the city of Vijayapura.

‘Eddelu Karnataka’ Experience Story (Part-2): Actions Taken by the Campaign

What do BJP’s loss, gain, and status quo indicate?

  • While some interpreted the BJP’s defeat as a “shameful defeat of the politics of hatred,” some argued that though seats decreased “communalism has not got a beating anyway” pointing to the BJP’s sustained vote share and increased voter turnout in certain areas. What would be a more factual assessment is to be seen from below.
  • The Sangh Parivar attempted to provoke communal controversies as a strategic approach in the lead-up to the elections, approximately a year in advance, starting up racking hijab issue. These attempts continued as the Halal, Jatka cut, prohibition on Muslim traders near temples, the murder of Harsha, the Darya Daulat controversy in Srirangapatna, propping Urigowda-Nanjegowda, and the Idris Pasha murder. Furthermore, they employed their political power to implement communal policies, such as the Cattle Act, Conversion Act, textbook revisions, and the elimination of reservations for Muslims. However, this strategy largely proved ineffective as they were unable to maintain power solely relying on this strategy of hate politics. Therefore, in an overall sense communal politics was beaten back miserably.
  • The primary catalyst for minority communities voting in unison is their anger and unease towards hate politics. These communities not only got mobilized internally but also actively collaborated with ‘Eddelu Karnataka’ and other social movements to defeat the politics of hatred. Their collaborative collective community efforts had a significant influence on the final outcome.
  • Considerable sections of Dalit, backward communities and a section of Lingayat communities also voted against the BJP. One of the primary reasons behind this shift is the increasing awareness and organized efforts among these communities in response to the BJP’s Manuvadi politics. Furthermore, the BJP, which had previously managed to divide these communities by exploiting reservation policies, found itself ensnared in the same predicament this time. Their attempt to offer relief without delivering tangible benefits ultimately led to a significant portion of the grassroots community turning away from them. Another significant development is the increasing awareness within the Lingayat community regarding Brahminization. Along with this counter current, the feeling that ‘Lingayats have been neglected’ has resulted in a substantial number of Lingayat voters shifting their support from the BJP to Congress. These instances of heightened awareness within various castes have posed challenges for the BJP.
  • The impact of price hikes has severely affected people this time. The BJP’s rampant corruption has significantly damaged its social reputation. The responsibility for bringing the issues of inflation and corruption to the forefront of public consciousness lies with a combined effort involving social campaigns, budding new trend media initiatives and the campaigning endeavours of the Congress party. The combination of the heat of every day issues which touched the base and the political campaign which touched the minds set the voters mood, especially women voters.
  • Simultaneously, the guarantees offered by the Congress are akin to providing water to those in distress. If debates on the usefulness and potential risks of these schemes persisted on the one hand, the common people found solace in the assurance that they would receive relief support during these challenging times. This instilled a sense of hope and optimism in the projections on Congress.
  • Additionally, the BJP government’s introduction of the contentious anti-farmer laws and the resulting conflicts, anti-labour policies, increasing job insecurity, numerous struggles faced by various working sections, the struggle of the downtrodden sections for land, housing and  NREGA schemes,  the resistance from government employees against the New Pension Scheme, have all as a whole, played a significant role in distancing people from the BJP. Furthermore, the conscious efforts by these movements to mould people’s political opinions have also contributed to the overall dynamics.
  • In sum, the collective awareness and unity among minority communities against the politics of hatred, the increasing dissatisfaction among oppressed communities, the impact of price rise and the burden of corruption, and the resistance generated within various communities due to the anti-people policies were all nurtured through the hard efforts of various social organizations and peoples media set the tone. .Together with this the efforts made by Congress by rising its voice against price rise and corruption, Bharath Jodo Yathra and the Guarantee promises instilled a feeling among voters that the BJP should be ousted. The Congress party has reaped significant benefits from this whole situation.
In sum, the collective awareness and unity among minority communities against the politics of hatred, the increasing dissatisfaction among oppressed communities, the impact of price rise and the burden of corruption, and the resistance generated within various communities due to the anti-people policies were all nurtured through the hard efforts of various social organizations and peoples media set the tone. .Together with this the efforts made by Congress by rising its voice against price rise and corruption, Bharath Jodo Yathra and the Guarantee promises instilled a feeling among voters that the BJP should be ousted. The Congress party has reaped significant benefits from this whole situation.

Does the BJP’s retained vote share reflect the success of communal politics?

  • The analysis stating that the BJP has maintained its vote share [36%] despite significant defeats, implies that “Congress has won but communalism has not lost,” is partially correct but mostly inaccurate.
  • The statement is partially correct because:  while a majority of people voted against the BJP, it is important to note that not all of these votes can be attributed to a voting against hate politics. Minorities and democratic sections of the people have consciously casted their votes against communal politics. This suggests that some sections of the voters did cast their ballots as a response to the BJP’s hate politics. It is also worth noting that for another big section of voters, other life issues hold greater significance than communal politics. But the biases infused by the politics of hatred or communalism still do persist in the minds of these sections also.
  • In this election, several right-wing individuals have also switched their allegiance from the BJP to the Congress. They have also garnered some right-wing votes. Additionally, communal polarization played a significant role in shaping the outcomes in Udupi, Dakshina Kannada districts, as well as the Shimoga-Belgaum, Dakshina-Hubli, and Vijapur city constituencies. All this points to the importance of the immense work that needs to be done against the politics of hate and the danger of the kind of vicious atmosphere that communal politics can opportunistically create.
  • At the same time it is also to be noted that in most parts of the state, not only has the hate politics card not worked but the increased voter share in majority areas can be attributed to reasons other than communal politics.
BJP has received the highest number of votes in Bangalore city, with a vote share of 5.4 percent, totaling 4,71,079 votes and resulting in an increase of 6 seats. However, it is important to note that these votes were not garnered solely due to communal politics. Instead, there are four primary reasons behind these electoral gains.
  • Operation Kamala: The people who sold themselves and shifted from congress to BJP during Operation Kamala in 2019 (S. T. Somashekar from Yeshwanthpur, K Gopaliah from Mahalakshmi Layout, B. A. Basavaraj from K. R Puram, and Munirathna from RajarajeshwariNagara) have brought almost half the votes that BJP got in this election. One aspect of Operation Kamala is, although many candidates have lost in this election they have contributed to the vote share of BJP. Their cumulative votes share in the entire BJP vote share is 2.86%. In the exceptional case of the Yeshwanthpur constituency, the BJP was able to secure 59,308 in 2018 elections, the congress candidate S.T. Somashekar who had jumped to BJP in 2019 was able to secure 1,69,149 votes in 2023 elections.
  • Collapse of JDS: In Bengaluru this time, there was a significant decline in support for the JDS. Both the Congress and BJP have gained from this shift, but the BJP has emerged as the biggest beneficiary. Traditionally anti-Congress votes that were previously cast for the JDS have now shifted towards the BJP. The influence of Power and Money: Bangalore generally tends to favor individuals with financial resources and influential positions. This can be attributed to the city’s close proximity to the centres of authority and the well-established ruling power networks within the slum areas.
  • Modi road show: The Modi road show campaign during the final phase of the election is also had a slight impact on boosting the BJP party to an extent.In conclusion, it is primarily the aforementioned four factors, rather than communal polarization, that have played a significant role in shaping the political landscape of Bengaluru and resulting in the BJP’s significant gains.
BJP’s second highest gain is in the Mysore region.
  • BJP has directed its utmost attention towards capturing this vokkaliga majority area, which holds singular priority for them. In their pursuit, the BJP has emphasized the involvement of influential leaders, Modi and Shah rallies, creating controversies surrounding Tipu, the fabrication of Urigowda-Nanjegowda fictional characters, and the distribution of substantial funds. They have utilized various tactics to achieve their objectives. Despite these efforts, the BJP did not witness an increase in its number of seats; in fact, it experienced a decrease. It only managed to gain a 3.2 percent increase in the vote share. However, it is important to note that the main reason for this outcome is not the communal politics it aims to promote. The primary factor influencing the election results in this area is the decline of the JDS. Upon closer examination, it becomes evident that the Congress has benefited more from this situation than the BJP. The Congress not only saw an increase in its seat count from 16 to 30 percent but also gained a 5.8 percent vote share. On the other hand, the JDS, with its stronghold crumbling, experienced a decrease in seats from 24 to 13, resulting in a decline of 9 percent in its vote share. While the Congress has benefited the most the BJP has also experienced some gains from this situation. Additionally, factors such as the presence of popular figures like Sumalatha and Darshan, who are closely associated with the BJP, and the party’s strategy of enticing small leaders through substantial financial investments have contributed to their increased vote share. The influence of these factors can also be observed in the voting patterns of Srirangapattana town. There is indeed a role of communal politics that the BJP has emphasized and attempted to cultivate here. However, it is not the sole determining factor. And It would be too simplistic to consider the 4,000-vote increase in Melukote as a significant reference point.
  • The concentration of the entire BJP government machinery towards the Varuna constituency to defeat Siddaramiah has also played a part in the neighbouring constituencies to win more votes. In spite of this, BJP could win only one seat in Mysore and Mandya out of 18 seats, in 5 seats it has secured the 2nd position, and in 12 seats it could only manage to secure 3rd place.
  • Communal politics is not the primary reason for the BJP’s increased vote share even in some other constituencies. While caste politics played a role in Bhadravati, personal image politics influenced the outcomes in Belagavi and Bagalkot. Additionally, the voter turnout for Yatnal in Vijayapur was also marred by fraud, as over 17,000 voters from other constituencies were discovered to have cast their votes using forged ballot papers.
  • In sum, communal polarization played a significant role in the BJP’s victory in two districts and four constituencies. And the influence of communal prejudice is deeply entrenched in general. However, while the BJP has seen an increase in certain areas and maintained an overall vote share of 36 percent, it is important to note that this cannot be exclusively attributed to communal politics.
  • BJP played the cards of Communalism, Caste politics, Operation Kamala and Huge Money to woo voters. In this the Communal card could not save them much, though communal prejudices continue to prevail, Caste politics boomeranged to an extent. Operation Kamala and Money power helped them to retain their vote share though it could not be materialised in seat share.

Is there any reason to celebrate or not?

There are several reasons to find some level of solace in this election result. Karnataka has effectively curbed the politics of hatred through strategic and concerted efforts, resulting in the removal of communal forces from state power. Significant credit goes to the social forces that have actively shaped a narrative that diminished the influence of communal politics, while simultaneously highlighting the genuine concerns of the people. People’s movements have played a vital role in exposing the BJP’s anti-people legislations, thereby unifying the secular votes and preventing divisions within the electorate. Even though the Congress made several mistakes this time, they have also shown prudence in their actions after a long period. As a result of these collective efforts, authoritarian forces have been defeated. The masses, forces working on the ground, and the democratic intelligentsia are experiencing a profound sense of relief. As a friend aptly put it, “Now, it feels like the air is oxygen-rich.” This outcome is the culmination of years of conscious action by multiple forces working towards a common goal. This should bring certain happiness and satisfaction. However, it is important not to forget that although the communal forces have suffered a setback in this election, the influence of communalism still persists, and its potential danger cannot be underestimated. There is every possibility that it may resurface in a more aggressive and violent form. Various forces are actively working towards this agenda. Moreover, there are real concerns about the Congress party potentially enabling or allowing the resurgence of communalism through its mistaken moves. We need to be glad about what could be achieved, draw the positive lessons from the same and constantly remain cautious not to fall a prey to any illusions and temptations. At the same time we should determinedly raise our voice against the probable mistakes by the Congress party and thwart the conspiracies of the BJP and its allies. On these lines, social forces must embark on a new phase of work to prepare the people for necessary actions.

MP:Fresh Attack on Adivasis Asserting their rights and opposing Atrocities against them

In the most recent attack on Adivasis demanding their legal and constitutional rights in Madhya Pradesh Jagrit Adivasi Dalit Sangathan activist Madhuri has been externed from Burhanpur district for a period of one year. Madhuri spearheaded the legal awareness campaign and was also active in the recent campaign against massive illegal forest felling in the area. Adivasi activists of Jagrit Adivasi Dalit Sangathan responded to the move by issuing a statement asking, “Why does CM Shivraj Singh Chouhan fear Adivasis asserting their rights?” They also declared that they would not be suppressed by this attack on the Adivasi movement, nor will the movement stop raising its voice against the atrocities enabled by MP government and its’ administration. Further, the order will not only be appealed against in the High Court, but that the organization would also lead an extensive campaign to reveal the conspiracy to repress dissenting voices opposing the destruction of Jal-Jangal-Zameen. For the past 5 years, JADS activists and members have not only been unitedly campaigning for their rights but have also been consistently opposing illegal forest felling made possible by the connivance of Forest Department. In the widespread forest felling that started in October 2022 resulting in the loss of trees over roughly 15,000 acres of forest land and the illegal smuggling of crores of timber – undoubtedly aided and abetted by the administration and the state government. This obscene collusion was fiercely resisted by the organization as over a thousand Adivasi women and men led a 3-day long protest against the tacit support given to the widespread illegal forest felling by MP Government, emphasizing that felling at such a scale is impossible without the implicit support of the State government itself. It is pertinent to note that the Forest Minister of MP, hails from the adjoining district of Khandwa, not far from the site of mass felling. 35 Adivasis Arrested After Run-ins with the Forest Department Troubled by the challenge posed by the movement, the state unleashed a wave of repression since April 2023, arresting Adivasi activists leading the movement, maligning their image by making baseless accusations against them, even going as far to try and illegally evict eligible claimants under the Forest Rights Act, because they highlighted and complained against the administrations’ role in the widespread illegal tree felling over the past 6 months! Now, they have externed Sangathan activist Madhuri for a period one year from Burhanpur district. Forest department in Burhanpur has been attempting to illegally evict Forest Rights Claimants for years, while turning a blind eye to illegal felling that was being carried out right under their noses – while the brazen disregard the department has for the Forest Rights Act and protection by the State allowed its personnel to threaten, harass and torture rightful claimants with no repercussions at all. However, the Forest Department began facing unprecedented resistance against its’ illegal activity as Adivasis began asserting their rights over the past few years and refused to be extorted or exploited by forest staff as they had been for generations – this has resulted in widespread resentment amongst personnel who revelled in exploiting and harassing Adivasis. Thanks to the department and an enabling and apathetic administration about 10,000 forest rights claims remain pending in the district, and Adivasis continue to be criminalized for simply farming on lands they have been living on for generations. JADS activists remain committed to ensuring the right to a dignified life to every citizen, to make the dream of our Constitution a reality and to resolutely resist the loot and exploitation of their Jal Jangal Zameen. Harsing Jamre – 9893104698 ; Asha Bai – 9343462579; Madhuri – 9179753640

Karnataka Assembly Speaker U.T Khader’s love for a die-hard Hindutva Guru Sri Sri Ravishankar

The 2023 Karnataka Assembly elections was a mile-stone in the fight for saving Indian democracy from the Hindutva onslaught. Congress defeated RSS-BJP convincingly. Though it was a State election but the results had national ramifications. Karnataka had become the newest Hindutva laboratory; the RSS-BJP campaigners used every dirty trick in the Hindutva armoury of communal polarization to put a stamp of approval to the rule of Basavaraj Bommai. Under him Karnataka had turned into a land out of bound for Muslims, their beliefs and customs; lynching becoming a new normal. What was at stake for PM Modi in this election can be known by the fact that he asked for votes in the name of Bajrang Bali (Hanuman). Congress could win because it boldly challenged the Hindutva bigotry during election promising that it would ban organizations like Bajrang Dal (RSS storm-troopers) and discard anti-minority laws passed by the Bommai government including pro-Hindutva changes in the school text books. Congress victory was ensured due to unwavering stand against Hindutva communal polarizing campaign by the Congress top campaigners, including Mallikarjun Kharge, Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi, Siddarmaiah and DK Shivakumar. Sadly, UT Khader Fareed, Speaker of Karnataka Assembly, who won on Congress ticket, is showing no inclination to defend this gain, on the contrary using his office to legitimize the Hindutva ideology. He has invited a die-hard Hindutva Guru, Art of Living’s founder Sri Sri Ravi Shankar, as a prominent resource person to train the first time MLAs, numbering 70, in meditation and yoga therapy apart from classes on the technicalities of law making. Who advised him to invite this Hindutva Baba who is not content with having one SRI with his name but two? Egoism at galore! It is shocking that a senior Congress leader from Karnataka is not familiar with anti-national and anti-humanity background of this Baba. He has been a prominent speaker at almost all RSS events. He is a die-hard believer in Casteism. If Speaker had even asked a clerk in his office to search the Hindutva credentials of double SRI, the former would have been provided with the following troubling facts. Double SRI is an old patron of Hindutva organizations like Hindu Janajagruti Samiti (HJS) an affiliate of Sanatan Sanstha. These organizations are being investigated for assassinations of MM Kalburgi (a renowned thinker and critic of Brahmanism, assassinated on August 30, 2017), Gauri Lankesh (a renowned Lingayat author, journalist and activist, assassinated on September 5, 2017), Govind Pansare (a noted Communist leader, historian, assassinated on February 20, 2015) and Narender Dabholkar (Great Rationalist and thinker, assassinated on August 20, 2013). The first two belonged to Speaker’s own State. How close and old is the relationship of this double SRI with these organizations which are being investigated for Hindutva terrorism can be known by the following statement of Mumbai region Convener of HJS Shivaji Vatkar and Ramesh Shinde, spokesperson of HJS for Maharashtra stated after meeting double Sri on the 20th November (2006) in Mumbai: “The founder of the ‘Art of Living’ Pujya Sri Sri Ravi Shankar (Swamiji) has given his blessings to the activities of the Hindu Janajagruti Samiti (HJS)…He conveyed His blessings. Swamiji further said that he knew about the HJS’ activities and appreciated the same. He also said that, the HJS should continue to create awareness among the masses…Shri. Shinde also informed Swamiji about the campaigns undertaken by the HJS against the ‘Anti-Superstition Act’ and the ‘Temple Takeover Act’ with a view to make the society aware of anti-Hindu activities being undertaken by the Maharashtra Government. On this occasion, Swamiji was also shown sattvik pictures of deities drawn by seekers of the Sanatan Sanstha.” ‘Pujya Sri Sri Ravishankar blesses the HJS’, November 22, 2006. It is to be noted that apart from, as per police investigations, being involved in assassinations of ‘anti-Hindu’ intellectuals HJS and Sanatan Sanstha have been involved in aggressive campaigns for converting democratic-secular India into Hindu rashtra. The theme of the yearly conferences is fixed; ‘All India Hindu Convention for Establishment of Hindu Nation’. In 2013, the 2nd such conference began with a felicitation message from Modi as CM of Gujarat. Double Sri could not come to grace the conference but bestowed his blessings by offering a yellow shawl to Shivaji Vatkar to be presented in the said conference. It was at this conference that a senior RSS cadre, K.V. Sitaramiah, in his address declared that Gandhi was ‘terrible, wicked and most sinful’. Rejoicing the killing of M.K. Gandhi, he went on to declare: “As Bhagwan Shri Krishna said in the Gita, Paritranaya Sadhunam Vinashaya Cha Dushkritam/ Dharamasansthapnaya Sambhavami Yuge-Yuge (For the protection of the good, for the destruction of the wicked and for the establishment of righteousness, I am born in every age) On 30th January 1948 evening, Shriram came in the form of Nathuram Godse and ended the life of Gandhi.” Double Sri’s modus operandi, operations, gimmicks and close connections with RSS have been recorded by a renowned South Asia expert and journalist, Edward Luce, in his amazing book, In Spite of the Gods: The Strange Rise of Modern India, Doubleday, New York, 2007. Narrating details of a meeting with him at his palatial ashram at Bengaluru Luce stated: “I had come to visit Sri Sri Ravi Shankar (not to be confused with Ravi Shankar, the classical sitar player), who is perhaps the most prominent of a new breed of highly successful Hindu evangelists, at his Art of Living Foundation near Bangalore in south India. It was evening and hundreds of devotees had already congregated for evening prayers. From close up, the meditation hall was even more striking. Rising to five stories, it had been built entirely from marble. The hall was shaped like a lotus. There were 1,008 marble petals covering the exterior of the building symbolizing the diversity of human consciousness. It was only a few years old. The funding for this extravagant construction had come from corporate donations-much of it from the software companies in nearby Bangalore-and revenues the foundation earns from its hugely popular course in breathing techniques and meditation. ‘Come inside,’ said the polite young lady assigned to show me around. ‘You are just in time to watch the guruji take his evening questions.’” “The interior was even more striking, fashioned like a Roman amphitheatre. We sat on polished white marble steps looking down at the stage in the centre. I felt like I had stepped inside a large wedding cake…Alone on the stage, on what looked to be a large throne, sat a man in flowing white robes with an equally flowing white robes with an equally flowing beard and silky locks of hair falling luxuriantly around his shoulders. It looked as if Jesus were shooting a shampoo advertisement. This was Sri Sri Ravi Shankar.” Referring to Question-Answer session Luce wrote: “There was some chanting and clashing of cymbals. Then the prayers ended and a hush descended over the hall. It was time for guruji to take questions. I, expecting people to ask about higher consciousness or metaphysics. But the questions consisted mostly of mundane queries about how to deal with recalcitrant teenagers, whether staying late in the office was a good thing, and how to choose a marriage partner. The guruji spoke in a quiet but sonorous voice. But his answers were more like those of an advice columnist than a prophet…Someone asked about whether it was always wrong to pay bribes. ‘You shouldn’t be too idealistic all the time,’ said the guruji. ‘Sometimes you have to make little, little compromises.’ Again the audience erupted in laughter. I was beginning to wonder about the Art of Living’s breathing techniques. According to Luce double SRI was a fervent supporter of building of a Ram Temple after demolishing Babri Mosque at Ayodhya: “What is less widely known is the guruji’s close attachment to the RSS. He has shared platforms with VHP leaders at public meetings. I asked him whether the Ram Temple should be built in Ayodhya. ‘Suppose,’ he said, ‘that it was the birthplace of Jesus or Mohammed. What would you have done? Would you have tolerated another structure on that site? Let us build a temple to Ram and let the Muslims make this gesture as an act of goodwill and then the temple will also belong to Allah and to all Muslims.’ To Allah? I asked. ‘Yes, as you must have seen, we accept all paths to God. Sometimes we wish other religions would do the same.’ The guruji’s words reminded me of Advani’s desire to see more ‘Hindu Muslims and more ‘Hindu Christians’.” Luce underlining the deep partnership between double SRI and RSS shared an anecdote: “A few weeks later received a telephone call from Ram Madhav, the national spokesman of the RSS. ‘I am calling about Sri Sri Ravi Shankar,’ said Madhav. ‘I was talking to him the other day and he said he was disappointed with your article in the Financial Times. You only quoted his views on politics and the Shankaracharya. He said he was hoping you would quote his views on tolerance and spiritualism.’ It is true my article had lacked space to quote the guruji’s opinions on other matters. But I was surprised the guruji should have chosen the RSS—of all organizations—to convey his complaint.” It is high time Congress leaders like Karnataka Speaker Khader Fareed who are part of Hindutva sleeping cells in Congress are divested of all responsibilities. The democratic-secular India is indebted to Karnataka for being a barricade against the free run of the Hindutva bandwagon, let no Fifth Columnist be allowed to demolish it. Author taught Political Science at the University of Delhi. Views are personal. He can be reached at [email protected] and @shamsforjustice on Twitter.  Link for some of S. Islam’s writings in English, Hindi, Urdu, Marathi, Malayalam, Kannada, Bengali, Punjabi, Gujarati and video interviews/debates: http://du-in.academia.edu/ShamsulIslam

The Cost of ignoring refugees, the Messenia boat disaster

0
On 14 June 2023, a fishing boat, called the Andrianna, carrying over 750 refugees sank in the Ionian Sea off the coast of Pylos, Messenia, Greece. Greek authorities have recovered just over 100 people and just over 80 bodies from the sinking. The Greek coast guard reported that the ship was heavily crowded with migrants. Distress calls indicated that the captain had already abandoned the ship, leaving the onboard migrants in a desperate situation. In Greece, Opposition leader Alexis Tsipras voiced his concerns, criticizing the absence of proper rescue measures and condemning European migration policies, which he blamed for turning the Mediterranean into watery graves. The business of trafficking poor migrants is a direct result of the ongoing conflicts occurring in North Africa, particularly Libya that emerged following the assassination of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011. The political instability that ensued led to the development of migrant smuggling businesses that would repatriate fleeing families to Europe. The migrants from this particular tragedy were en route to Italy.

How the Libyan crisis emerged

The roots of the crisis can be traced back to the Second Libyan Civil War and the subsequent peace process. The conflict came to a ceasefire on 23 October 2020, marking the end of the Second Libyan Civil War. In an effort to establish stability, the Government of National Unity (GNU) was formed on 10 March 2021, with Abdul Hamid Dbeibeh assuming the position of prime minister. However, this unity government faced significant challenges. On 21 September 2021, the House of Representatives expressed a vote of no confidence against the unity government, further exacerbating the political tensions. This led to a divide within the government, with different factions supporting different prime ministers. Notably, on February 10, 2022, the House of Representatives appointed Fathi Bashagha as prime minister, a decision rejected by Dbeibeh and the GNU. This led to the Tripoli clashes of 2022. On 17 May, the parliamentary-appointed government, led by Bashagha, arrived in Tripoli, triggering hours of intense fighting between armed groups. Eventually, the government team was compelled to withdraw from the city. Tensions escalated further on 27 August, as clashes intensified between factions aligned with Bashagha and those affiliated with Dbeibeh. During this period, fighters supporting Bashagha fired upon a convoy, while Dbeibeh-affiliated groups stormed a military base. The clashes resulted in the loss of numerous lives, with 32 people killed and 159 others injured. Subsequent clashes erupted in September on the western outskirts of Tripoli. This series of confrontations witnessed forces aligned with the GNU, under Dbeibeh’s leadership, consolidating control in the area. The connection between the Libyan crisis and the Mediterranean migrant smuggling ring is undeniable. The ongoing political turmoil, violence, and instability in Libya have created a volatile environment conducive to the thriving smuggling operations for refugees. Forced to flee the dire circumstances within the country, many individuals and families have been compelled to embark on the perilous journey across the Mediterranean, further exacerbating the already dire situation.

How deadly is migrant smuggling?

Estimates state that nearly 21,000 people have died trying to travel through the Mediterranean since 2014. People can be forced to lock up for days while at sea, and the ships used to transport them are very unsafe. Every year, thousands of people die in the journey. While the network was developed in response to the Libyan crisis, refugees and migrants from many nationalities have travelled this way.

Greece Employs Border Wall Extensions to Prevent Afghan Refugees From Entering Europe

How did the Greek government react?

Greek authorities have already arrested nine men who they believe to be connected with the smuggling ring. They are all of Egyptian descent and will be charged with a variety of crimes, including mass murder. In Greece, three days of national mourning were declared in response to the deaths of their shored. Greek President Katerina Sakellaropoulou visited survivors, offering condolences and solidarity. Many people in Greece, including politicians realized that the tragedy was partly a result of the previous conservative government’s strict migration policies, characterized by tightened border controls and a propensity to turn away boats carrying migrants and refugees.

How did the Greek people react?

Public outrage and protests against these migration policies quickly spread across Greece. Left-wing organizations, trade unions, and political parties organized demonstrations to express their support for refugees and their dissatisfaction with EU migration policies. Some of these protests turned violent, with clashes between protesters and police occurring in Athens. Tear gas filled the air as a small group resorted to throwing petrol bombs. In Kalamata, protesters gathered near migrant facilities, highlighting their opposition to the EU’s migration pact and denouncing what they perceived as insincere responses to the incident.

How should we understand this crisis?

It is important to stress how the growing xenophobia and anti-immigrant policies in Europe, along with the callous international war machine, directly contributed to the disaster. The illegal and unregulated sea routes were developed in response to the ongoing conflicts in Northern Africa and the Middle East. These conflicts are a direct result of policies pursued by foreign countries, particularly Western powers, to destabilize the region and keep them in a perpetual state of war. The Libyan Civil War was a direct outcome of the War on Terror led by the United States, leading to a seemingly unending conflict which is only getting fueled. Rather than recognizing the crisis and giving victims of intense conflict safe passage, xenophobic policies have driven the migration underground so they can be exploited in Europe as cheap labour. Years of demonizing international migrants led to a situation where disasters like this are actually very regular, leading to thousands of seats annually. Western powers have already profited from decades of cheap labour in the informal economy and have a responsibility to at least ensure the safety of the waves that are resulting from the conflict. Even without this history, humane policies should ensure that people fleeing conflict should be ensured some sort of safety.

Burning down Bank in Beirut: Frustrations in Lebanon run high

0
After years of economic crisis, Lebanon has again seen protesters take to the streets, this time in a violent fashion. In a suburb outside Beirut, demonstrators targeted banks, sometimes burning them down, venting their anger towards the financial controls that have left their life savings in tatters. Protesters have been demanding that banks need to be accountable to them and protect their savings with some form of democratic accountability. The crisis has been ongoing in Lebanon since 2019. The Lebanese pound has lost an astonishing 98% of its value against the US dollar, leaving many people’s life savings virtually worthless. Financial controls imposed by the authorities have only worsened the situation, intensifying the anger of those who have been financially ruined.

Origins of the crisis:

Lebanon’s strategic location made it a focal point for Western powers and their allies in the Middle East, leading to international involvement in the Lebanese civil war. The conflict also had an ideological dimension, with various factions calling for reunification with Syria, the democratization of the government, or neo-liberal reforms. In 1990, a new constitution was adopted to end the civil war, aiming to protect market interests and implement neo-liberal economic policies. Rafic Hariri, a prominent business tycoon, played a significant role in Lebanon’s post-war era. As Prime Minister from 1992 to 1998 and again from 2000 to 2004, Hariri implemented many of the neo-liberal reforms that contributed to Lebanon’s current crisis. However, his tenure was also marred by corruption and personal enrichment, as evidenced by his substantial increase in personal assets during his time in power. Hariri used the military to suppress dissent and allocated reconstruction contracts to other wealthy business moguls, further exacerbating inequality and corruption. The years that followed were marked by political instability and external influences. The assassination of Rafic Hariri in 2005, attributed by Western powers to pro-Syrian forces in Lebanon, triggered mass protests known as the Independence-05 movement. These protests, supported by America and France, aimed to establish democratic governance and were condemned by Syria and Iran. Nevertheless, Hariri’s party continued to hold a prominent role in parliamentary politics. “We don’t need your teargas to cry” – the dissenting pangs of Lebanon The invasion of Iraq and Syria by the United States further destabilized the region, and Lebanon experienced spillover effects. The influx of approximately 1.5 million Syrian refugees into a country with a population of around 6.9 million strained Lebanon’s resources and security, aggravating sectarian tensions and heightening insecurity among the population. The combination of political instability and a highly neoliberal constitution has kept Lebanon in a state of economic disaray. Many businesses try to hoard foreign currency, leading to inflation. The government responded by tightening banks, making it difficult for the common people to use their local currency. As the banks have made withdrawal harder, many of them had to watch helplessly as their savings became worthless. At the same time, the wealthy elite in Lebanon have become more ostentatious with their wealth.

No prima facie case, none of the sections are applicable to Setalvad: HRD’s counsel submits in Guj HC

0
Rights Defender and journalist, Teesta Setalvad was arrested on June 25, 2022, a day after the Supreme Court judgement disposing the appeal of ZakiaJafri seeking re-investigation into Jafri’s claims of larger conspiracy behind 2002 Gujarat pogrom. The bail hearing of human rights activist Teesta Setalvad in Gujarat High Court has been in progress as she seeks permanent bail in the case alleging she submitted false evidence. She currently has interim protection from the Supreme Court (September 2, 2023) after spending 70 days in prison in Gujarat. While the applicant has already made her submissions on June 12 and 13, the state is in process of making submissions. The applicant’s counsel Senior Advocate Mihir Thakore made elaborate submissions before the bench of Justice Nirzar Desai on June 12 and June 13.

Background

It was only about a year ago that Ms Setalvad was arrested from her Mumbai home by Gujarat ATS in a rather hurried fashion soon after the Supreme Court’s judgement in the Zakia Jafri case. She was booked under sections 468 (forgery), 471 (using as genuine a forged document or electronic record), 194 (giving or fabricating false evidence with intent to procure conviction of capital offence, 211 (false charge of offence made with intent to injure), 218 (public servant framing incorrect record or writing with intent to save person from punishment or property from forfeiture) and 120 B (criminal conspiracy) of the IPC. Zakia Jafri, along with Ms Setalvad (through Citizens for Justice and Peace) as second appellant, had filed this appeal against the Gujarat High Court judgment confirming the trial court order dismissing the protest petition filed by Ms Jafri. Ms Jafri had filed the protest petition against the closure report of the SIT which was given the task of looking into Ms Jafri’s 2006 complaint alleging a larger conspiracy behind the 2002 Gujarat pogrom in which Ms’ Jafri husband Mr Ehsan Jafri was mercilessly slain, along with a genocide of a large Muslim population. The Supreme Court while disposing the appeal, made some adverse remarks against “those who had kept the pot boiling” with an “ulterior motive” for the past 16 years should be in the dock and be “proceeded with in accordance with the law”. The counsel articulated each charge invoked against Setalvad in the FIR and took the bench through the definition of each offence invoked against her under the IPC to emphasize how none of the charges were made out against her. The counsel stressed emphatically before the bench that the affidavits that the Gujarat police are claiming to be forged or false were in fact filed before the Supreme Court and not the police. These affidavits were filed in a transfer petition where CJP had intervened. The case had been originally filed by the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) three years before the complaint filed by Ms Jafri in 2006. Therefore, under section 195 of CrPC, “except on the complaint in writing of that Court or by such officer of the Court as that Court may authorise in writing in this behalf, or of some other Court to which that Court is subordinate”, no proceedings can be initiated against her. More pertinently, none of the statements recorded by the SIT or the affidavits filed before SIT were referred to in Ms. Jafri’s complaint (2006) or the protest petition. The affidavits were not used in Ms Jafri’s special leave petition before the apex court and were only filed to support NHRC’s claim in its transfer petition, which was way before Ms Jafri’s 2006 complaint. Besides, counsel cited Iqbal Singh Marwah and anrvs Meenakshi Marwah (2005) 4 SCC 370, in which the Supreme Court had held that that a complaint is maintainable before the document is in the custody of the law and has been filed in court, but after it is filed in court the procedure specified in 195- 340 CR.P.C has to be followed will not apply to cases which fall into 195(1)(b)(i). What this necessarily means that whether the false evidence has been given or fabricated before or after it is produced in court, or in judicial proceedings, the only way to initiate proceedings is by the competent court filing a complaint as stipulated by section 195 and section 340 of the CR.P.C. However, instead of following this laid down procedure, the Gujarat ATS had simply arrived at Setalvad’s home without warrant and forcibly taken her to Ahmedabad where she was thereafter remanded to police custody on June 26. Thereafter on July 2, 2022 she was sent to judicial custody in the Sabarmati Mahila Jail, Ahmedabad. Setalvad has also made serious allegations of violence by the ATS when they forcibly entered her home that day.

No prima facie case made out

The counsel then went through an elaborate reading of sections 467,469 and 194 of IPC and said, “these offences would be applicable if it had been alleged that Setalvad had persuaded Zakia to file the complaint in 2006. But that complaint was filed by Zakia and not me.” Senior counsel Mihir Thakore then pointed out that sections 467, 469, 471 were invoked against her only to keep the case out of the purview of section 195 CrPC because not a single document except the petition in Supreme Court has been signed by Setalvad. The counsel stated that to invoke sections 194 and 211 of the IPC it would be necessary that a complaint from the Supreme Court is forthcoming which is not the case and thus no prima facie case is made out against Ms Setalvad. The counsel then went on to discuss the provisions of section 437 [4When bail may be taken in case of non-bailableoffence] and 439 [Special powers of High Court or Court of Session regarding bail] of CrPC to assert why bail need be granted in this case.

Cases cited pressing for bail

Thakore then cited Kalyan Chandra Sarkar vs Rajesh Ranjan Alias Pappu Yadav (Appeal (crl.) 324 of 2004; decided on March 12, 2004) whereby the Supreme Court had held, “The law in regard to grant or refusal of bail is very well settled. The Court granting bail should exercise its discretion in a judicious manner and not as a matter of course…It is also necessary for the court granting bail to consider among other circumstances, the following factors also before granting bail; they are, (a) The nature of accusation and the severity of punishment in case of conviction and the nature of supporting evidence; (b) Reasonable apprehension of tampering of the witness or apprehension of threat to the complainant; (c) Prima facie satisfaction of the Court in support of the charge Appealing to the court to take a humanitarian approach towards the bail of Ms Setalvad, the counsel cited Satender Kumar Antil vs Central Bureau Of Investigation (Miscellaneous Application No.1849 of 2021; decided on July 11, 2022) whereby the Supreme Court held, “It is high time that our Parliament realises that risk of monetary loss is not the only deterrent against fleeing from justice, but there are also other factors which act as equal deterrents against fleeing… other relevant considerations such as family ties, roots in the community, job security, membership of stable organisations etc., should be the determinative factors in grant of bail and the accused should in appropriate cases be released on his personal bond without monetary obligation…If the Court is satisfied, after taking into account, on the basis of information placed before it, that the accused has his roots in the community and is not likely to abscond, it can safely release the accused on his personal bond.” It further held that under section 437 CrPC, “in a case pertaining to women, the court is expected to show some sensitivity.” The counsel also stressed that in the cases filed against her till date, she has never misused the liberty granted to her by courts by way of bail, and many of these have even been quashed.

Earlier allegations have fallen flat

It must be noted that this is not the first time that an elaborate attempt is being made to harass Ms Setalvad. Here’s a chronological list showcasing how Setalvad has been hounded by the regime, as well as a point by point rebuttal of all baseless allegations levelled against her. In fact, many international publications such as the New YorkTimes and the BBC and organisations like Frontline Defenders have also reported on her constant persecution by a vengeful regime. In fact, in the past, the courts themselves have thrown out baseless charges of ‘tutoring’ witnesses amongst other allegations. In the Sardarpura Special Sessions Court judgement (during which proceedings in the trial a former employee of CJP, Raees Khan had made allegations of tutoring, the Court held, “The witnesses have specifically denied that, Teesta Setalvadhas told them as to what evidence was to be given in a case. Considering the evidence and fact in this regard when we consider this fact mere discussion about the case would not necessarily indicate tutoring.” The court elaborated, “It is not an accepted proposition that the witnesses are never to be contacted by any one or spoken to about the matter regarding which they are to depose. A number of things can be told to the witnesses such as not to be nervous, carefully listen to the question put to them, state the facts before the Court without fear, therefore it does not appear any objectionable morally or legally.” Most importantly, the court clarified, “Tutoring a witness is quite different from guiding him as to his behaviour. In the present case, the injured witnesses were in such a state of mind that without the active support of someone they might not have come before the court to give evidence at all. The encouragement and the advice if provided by Citizen for Peace and Justice that cannot be considered as tutoring and simply because of that, we cannot infer that the witnesses are tutored.”

Gujarat 2002

Citizens for Justice and Peace (CJP) that Setalvad is Secretary of has assisted survivors of the carnage of 2002 to battle as many as 68 cases in courts, from the trial courts right up to the Supreme Court. In an unprecedented record in terms of communal violence, as many as 174 perpetrators were accorded punishment and 124 of these to life imprisonment.

Previous Vendetta

Setalvad has over the past 21 years, faced faced eight previous FIRs and has had to take Anticipatory Bail on all occasions first from a Mumbai Court where she resides and thereafter from Gujarat. In all except one she has been granted bail by the Gujarat’s courts. The very first one was after the famed Best Bakery case was transferred to Maharashtra and the prime witness, ZahiraShaikh turned hostile and made allegations of kidnapping etcon Setalvad. At the time, Setalvad had herself then approached the Supreme Court of India to order a high level inquiry into the truth and falsity of the claims. A high level Registrar General of SC Inquiry conducted (BM Gupta) submitted in August 2004 exonerated Setalvad, held CJP’s accounts to be in order and in fact held both Zahira Shaikh guilty of perjury and Madhu Srivastava, MLA of the BJP of inducing a star victim witness with Rs 18 lakhs, Zahira Shaikh was thereafter convicted to one year’s simple imprisonment for perjury. In the case of the Gulberg Memorial FIR (filed in January 2014) after the Sessions Court refused anticipatory bail and thereafter even the Gujarat High Court rejected bail for Setalvad and her husband Javed Anand, the Supreme Court has accorded them both protection. For nine years since, despite their having submitted over 20,000 pages in evidence (entire accounts, vouchers etc) their personal bank accounts and the organisations (Citizens for Justice and Peace) remain frozen! No charge sheet has been filed in the nine years in this or any other case. When this matter came up in April 2023, the Gujarat counsel told the court requesting time that the couple has cooperated in the investigation.