Delhi Police imposes Section 144 in Shaheen Bagh

Delhi Police has imposed Section 144 at Shaheen Bagh, the site of anti-Citizenship Amendment Act protests, mainly by women, in Delhi. The police deployment has come after the right-wing group, Hindu Sena, gave a call to clear the Shaheen Bagh road on March 1. However on Saturday, with the reported intervention of the police, they called off their proposed protest against the anti-CAA agitation. Joint Commissioner DC Srivastava at Delhi’s Shaheen Bagh told ANI, “As a precautionary measure, there is heavy police deployment. Our aim is to maintain law and order and prevent any untoward incident from occurring.” Section 144 (which prohibits assembly of five or more people) has been imposed in Shaheen Bagh on Sunday, 1 March, a day after right-wing group Hindu Sena took back their call to “clear the protest site”. In a statement on Saturday, the Hindu Sena said that police pressured them to call off their peaceful protest on Sunday. It also claimed that their national president Vishnu Gupta had been “illegally detained” by the police. Twelve companies, including two of female forces, have been deployed in Shaheen Bagh, 100 men each from four police districts have also been deployed along with the local police, the official said. “People are informed that Section 144 of CRCP has been imposed at Shaheen Bagh and it is requested that permission for any gathering is not allowed. Violation of this may invite legal proceedings,” said the Delhi Police directive. A large number of people, mainly women, have been holding a sit-in protest in Shaheen Bagh, near Jamia Millia Islamia since mid-December last year in protest against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), National Population Register (NPR) and the National Register of Citizens (NRC). Many areas in North East Delhi are still tense over the riots that started last Sunday. At least 42 people have been killed and over 200 injured in the violence that gripped the city.

Neither Kapil Mishra nor Anurag Thakur! In Tahir Hussain media has found the convenient scapegoat

0
The fires that BJP leader Kapil Mishra stoked on 23rd February has burned down several neighbourhoods in Northeast Delhi. The violence that ensued has taken 42 lives so far and has left hundreds injured. The houses, shops, and properties of Muslims have been burnt down to ashes.  Out of those 42 deaths, the one death that has gotten all the media attention is the murder of an IB staffer Ankit Sharma. The family of the Ankit has blamed AAP member Tahir Hussain. He has been booked under kidnapping and murder, a FIR is lodged against him, and he has been suspended from the Aam Aadmi Party.

Tahir Hussain

Tahir Hussain has denied all the charges and says he was not at the property on the day of Ankit Sharma’s murder. But mainstream media has already declared him the mastermind of Delhi violence in its media trials. There are videos being circulated on social media and TV channels where Tahir Hussain is seen holding a stick in the same building where a big mob has gathered and is throwing stones and petrol bombs. According to Tahir Hussain “, People forced themselves into the compound of my house and I was trying to remove them from the premises. I kept calling 100 but the phone would not connect. At 7.00 in the evening was when the Police came and helped me get out”. Hussain said post 11.30 PM he did not go to his house. Hussain said he had no access to his house on the 25th of February as it was cordoned off by the Police. According to forensic reports, Ankit Sharma died on the 25th of February. Yunus Salim, the President of the Aman Ekta Committee, confirmed that Tahir was in the house on the 24th but he was trapped and had to be evacuated from the house by the police.  Kapil Mishra Vs Tahir Hussain Kapil Mishra, a BJP member, was the instigator of the 23rd February violence used to be in AAP until 2017. At that time, it was Tahir Hussain who helped him win the MLA seat from the area when he was in AAP. Kapil Mishra is now calling for Hussain’s arrest, sharing videos of Hussain’s roof being used to throw stones as proof that Tahir is behind the murder of the IB staffer. The same videos are taken up as credible evidence by news outlets to frame Tahir Hussain.  The media has been biased in the reporting of both Tahir Hussain and Kapil Mishra’s role in the riots. Popular media channels have been quick to label Tahir Hussain as a terrorist. Hashtags like #Tahir_Hussain_Terrorist, #TahirOnTheRun, #TruthAboutDelhiRiots, #HinduonKoMarnaBandKaro are being used by channels like Republic TV and Times Now. Zee News has also called him the mastermind of the Delhi riots and running a riot factory. Arnab Goswami claims that Hussain led the riots and was involved in the mass butchering of people. He also claims that no one should believe that Kapil Mishra’s statement provoked people to violence instead it was Tahir Hussain’s “bloodthirsty” mob that is responsible.   Hussain fits all the checkboxes for popular media to shift blame away from Kapil Mishra. He is Muslim and an AAP member. On the other hand, Kapil Mishra has gotten away with a slap on the wrist by media outlets. Most of these channels have started to now cover the peace rally that Kapil Mishra aims to hold. He is being painted as a peace-loving political figurehead who could not instigate violence through mere words. The media has covered up the blood that BJP has on its hand by blaming a Muslim as the mastermind of the riots. The argument that is being used is that the riots have not been anti-muslim as the leader of the riots is Hussain and they have harmed both Hindus and Muslims. This has given relief to both BJP and new channels. They can now continue to undermine the Anti-CAA movement and have more ammunition by blaming the riots on Muslims.  The BJP government too has been quick to lay blame on Hussain and has refused to acknowledge the role that Kapil Mishra, a BJP member, played in the riots. In multiple videos, Kapil Mishra is seen inciting violence against Muslim anti-CAA protestors. The main question that needs to be asked and many Muslims have been asking is where was the police when people were calling for help? Why were the police not stopping the violence, instead why was it aiding it? Multiple videos have come out which show that the Delhi police was involved in assisting and being actively involved in the riots and supporting right-wing goons. None of these allegations have been answered by the BJP or the Delhi Police. The allegations on Tahir Hussain instead have taken central precedence. Tahir Hussain has become a convenient scapegoat for all parties to hide behind, including AAP. AAP has been equally culpable in the violence that was undertaken in Muslim areas and have not spoken out against the BJP or demanded answers from it.   The riots, even though clearly organized by the Hindu right-wing have not been linked to any organization. Kapil Mishra is still part of the BJP and no action has been taken against him. This seems to be a clear move to divert attention from the loss of multiple Muslim lives and the number of Muslims who have been injured. Reports have come in that the police had allowed full access to reporters to Tahir Hussain’s house. The forensic team arrived at Hussain’s house only a day later, which raises the question of why there was a delay in collecting evidence, especially since the media could have tampered with the evidence.  AAP has suspended Hussain, to distance themselves from their involvement in the violence.    

How Delhi fires engulfed the “apolitical” morality of Kejriwal?

A Wednesday

It was a rare sight in Delhi Assembly on Wednesday when Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal read out names of the deceased in recent riots along with their religion alternatively as if he was trying to strike a balance of violence and console both communities one by one. He was being criticised for not intervening in the days since the violence began. Finally, on Wednesday, he visited some of the stricken areas for the first time and read out a sadist and un-impressive speech in Assembly accusing “outsiders” and “political and anti-social elements” for the riots that rocked Delhi over past three days. He said, “I want to show who faced losses from the riots. Everyone lost. More than 20 people have died. Veer Bhan died, he was a Hindu. Mohammad Mubarak died, he was a Muslim. Parvesh died, he was a Hindu. Zakir was a Muslim. Rahul Solanki was a Hindu, Mohammad Furqaan a Muslim and Rahul Thakur was a Hindu. Maut toh dono ki ho gayi – Hindu’o ki bhi ho gayi, Musalmano ki bhi ho gayi, aur policewalon ki bhi ho gayi (Hindus, Muslims, and policemen – all have died).”
This new avatar of AK is realpolitik sans culture, as can be seen in his statement given during PC: “National security should not be compromised with.”
The stark contrast did not go unnoticed as he opened his speech with the news of Melania Trump (introducing her as the wife of world’s “strongest” man Donald Trump) visiting Happiness classes in Delhi government-run schools and then he moved on to riots posing a final question to the house: “Which type of Delhi you want?” The house, filled with a majority of AAP MLA’s clapped in response. Outside, the scene was entirely different. Kejriwal visited AAP stronghold Burari the same evening to pay homage to deceased Delhi Police official Ratan Lal. He was hounded by the locals and forced to leave the area amidst slogans like, “Kejriwal Go Back”, “Kejriwal Pakistan Jaao”! People who voted for AAP just three weeks back for a “happy” Delhi had now vehemently opposing and rejecting AAP’s politics and Kejriwal’s stance on the riots that took place amidst anti-CAA protests in North-East Delhi. The question Kejriwal had posed inside the house was answered specifically on the same streets where he was used to sit-in a few years ago on the question of governance. Early morning before he went to Assembly, a crowd gathered outside his residence on Civil Lines to protest his inaction. The call was given by students of Jamia and JNU who were active in anti-CAA protests across the capital city. This was the first instance in the last six years and three terms of AAP when protestors were tackled with water canons and dispersed. It was never expected of Arvind Kejriwal, at least! His politics had come full circle! The rabble-rouser of Delhi had become a politician in the true sense but Alas! He has lost his clothes!

Press Conference and over

On Thursday evening when Kejriwal addressed media in a press conference for the first time since riots, he was categorical in saying that nobody involved in riots should be spared, be it from AAP. He was referring to Tahir Hussain on a question from media persons, an AAP leader accused of rioting and trending on twitter at the same time. Saying this he did not miss the usual rant, “Police humare paas nahin hai”. for which he used to criticise Sheila Dixit when Congress was in power. This was the single excuse that has bailed out each and every member of the Aam Admi Party, be it a minister or an MLA, when approached by the toiling people during riots. Aatishi Marlena, Gopal Rai, Somnath Bharti, and others have been accused of not responding to phone calls during riots on Monday night. It was on Tuesday evening that I called up Gopal Rai twice but he did not pick up the phone, neither called back. One lawyer who was active in anti-CAA protests called up MLA Aatishi Marlena on Monday night. She says, “she picked up the phone and said- this is a law and order problem aur Delhi police humare under mein nahin hai.” The same sundry logic for which Kejriwal was hounded on the streets Wednesday evening was hailed as a “political tactics” by his supporters a month back when he had refused to join Shaheen Bagh anti-CAA protests and placed the onus on Union Home Minister Amit Shah to clear the roadblock. At that time too, Kejriwal could not sense the irony of his statement that could be read out of the text as follows: I would have cleared the roadblock if Delhi Police reported to me!

The missed call

If a riot is purely a question of law and order and if law and order rest on the police, then it should be asked from the Leader why he used to chant a filmy song in his rallies that read out as: “Insaan ka insaan se ho bhaichaara, yahi paigaam humaara!” Still on AK’s twitter account, we can find the same cultural message as the intro. It is not long ago when Arvind Kejriwal sat on a dharna with his party men defying Section 144 in front of Rail Bhawan in Lutyen’s Delhi complaining non-cooperation by Delhi Police to his MLA Somnath Bharti in Khirki Extension raid case. It was amply clear that Delhi Police was facilitating rioters earlier this week and not acting against them, as stated in dozens of testimonies plus a letter by Rajya Sabha MP Naresh Gujral, who has exposed the failure of the Delhi police to assist riot victims. Gujral has written a letter to Delhi Commissioner of Police with his personal experience on trying to get assistance for those being targeted. If this was indeed the case, the root cause of governance glitch in Delhi remained the same as in 2014 but the response and effect were entirely opposite. Kejriwal did not utter a word against Delhi Police, let alone sitting on a dharna as he used to perform regularly in his initial days. This new avatar of AK is realpolitik sans culture, as can be seen in his statement given during PC: “National security should not be compromised with.” This is the same language that former PM Manmohan Singh spoke of in DGP’s conference of LWE (left-wing extremism) affected states. This is the same rhetoric that we are used to hearing from PM Narendra Modi on each and every issue.
Are communal riots an issue of national security? Is it not a cultural and social issue that needs to be addressed socially and culturally? What Mahatma Gandhi did in Noakhali and elsewhere is a historical example of dealing with riots and reaching out to the affected. AK need not follow Gandhi necessarily but was at least expected to go into crisis areas and lend a helping hand to victims. He could not do that because he had nothing to do with this sort of “politics”.
That is why he aptly said in his press conference, “dange ke saath rajneeti nahi honi chahiye”.

Politics of distancing?

First, he avoided Shaheen Bagh as he feared being branded as tukde tukde gang (Maneesh Sisodia said this in an interview). He distanced himself from an iconic protest to show his Hindu voters that he has nothing to do with the anti-CAA protests. Then he distanced himself from the communal fire that engulfed around 50 lives, destroyed homes, shops and left his “aam admi” in a lurch: all this in a matter of just 48 hours! Now he is up to relief measures announcing compensation etc for riot-affected people. The vacuum that the elected government of Delhi left during 48 hours on Monday and Tuesday was filled by none other than the Ajit Doval. Irony cannot be starker than this: A National Security Advisor taking on the job of a political communicator in an electoral democracy, assuring people on the streets: “Mashallah! Sab Theek Ho jayega!”
Historian Amaresh Mishra, who stood against Narendra Modi in 2019 Loksabha Elections from Varanasi independently and almost unnoticed, terms this phenomenon as “deep state hand in Delhi genocide 2020”!
A Wikipedia entry on “deep state” says, ” A deep state (from Turkish: derin devlet), also known as a state within a state, is a form of clandestine government made up of hidden or covert networks of power operating independently of a state’s political leadership, in pursuit of their own agenda and goals.” The vacuum created in an electoral democracy by the elected government of Delhi and filled instantly by NSA Doval is a familiar scenario resembling Kashmir dated August 2019, when all the elected peoples’ representatives were jailed after the abrogation of Article  370. Doval was on the streets of Srinagar twice last year performing the job of a political communicator. That was a state within a state phenomenon unfolding in the newly formed Union Territory. Jammu and Kashmir was a full-fledged state bound to New Delhi by Article 370 thus making space for deep state actors. Delhi is still not a full-fledged state. This character itself creates a space for the deep state to operate here and co-opt those who have a political interest in the territory. The Aam Aadmi Party has faced the heat in its initial couple of years ruling over Delhi but gradually things got settled and it distanced itself from those issues that involved contentious things like Delhi Police, law and order, etc.
This overt distancing strategy was basically coming close to the covert and clandestine power networks, that facilitated its third win in Delhi.
What seemed to us as a politics of distancing proved out to be a politics of convenience. This political convenience was basically getting threatened by an eruption of sudden violence and riot last Monday. Arvind Kejriwal maintained a status quo by not responding or reacting to reality but this time the reality was so loud that he got exposed in the process.

What next?

The game is not yet over. Shaheen Bagh is still in place. Hauz Rani and many such protest sites are alive and kicking. This “distancing policy” will haunt AAP and Kejriwal persuading him to flip-flop his stance on CAA. If riots break again and expand to the whole of Delhi, then the elected government of Delhi will be obliged to speak up. Speaking up would effect a disconnect from the clandestine networks of power. Silence may ultimately lead Delhi to a situation like Kashmir. It would be no exaggeration that it is quite possible that the central government recommends the President’s rule in the capital on the excuse of law and order. To sum up, the “apolitical” AK is now caught between the Devil and the Deep Sea! His social base is fast eroding. His political investment is caught up in the law of diminishing returns. He had lost his cultural ground way back. AAP’s politics of desertion is now in direct conflict with the politics of assertion. Be it Hindu assertion or that of Muslim, Kejriwal is the one to lose both ways. This will not be a political loss. This is more of a moral loss. A moral loss for an “apolitical” party.

Abhishek Srivastava is the Executive Editor of Mediavigil.com. Views are personal. 

Neither coincidence, nor experiment! This is the RSS-BJP´s Project Delhi!

0
Since the last few years, Delhi, the capital city of India, has been on target, first, the universities were targeted and now the slums are burning.  Since the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, this is the biggest communal violence that the city has seen. This time also, without any prevention, the dance of death continued for 3-4 days leading to the 39 deaths, more than 300 injured and heavy damage to the property. Many videos from the Delhi violence show not just police inaction but violence taking place with police complicity and protection. The Central government based in Delhi woke up after two days and sent National Security Advisor, Ajit Doval for a tour to the riot-hit area instead of an elected representative. Prime Minister Narendra Modi appealed for peace through twitter. Meanwhile, Justice Muralidhar who was hearing the court cases for the Delhi riots was given transfer orders. The Supreme Court Collegium had recommended his transfer on 12 February along with three other judges. But only Justice Muralidhar was given transfer orders. Transfer of Justice Muralidhar is being linked to the court hearing where he came down heavily on the Central government and Delhi Police for their inaction and ordered FIR against BJP leaders for their hate speeches.
What happened in Delhi is neither a coincidence nor an experiment. The project to divide India into “Us Vs Them”, that has been tried for many decades is now put in acceleration mode. The divide created in minds is now visible on the ground as well, due to which India is falling into a dark abyss of hate, fear, and despair. The dreams of freedom, equality, and fraternity that were envisioned forgetting the pain of partition are rapidly being destroyed. 
Justice Muralidhar had convicted Sajjan Kumar for his role in 1984 anti -Sikh riots and said in High court in the present Delhi riots that “ Will not let another 1984 happen in Delhi”. With the transfer of Muralidhar, the court hearing has been postponed to 13th April. The background of violence in Delhi is the citizenship amendment bill and the movement against it, for which Shaheen Bagh has become an epicenter. As it was clear from the beginning, the aim of the citizenship amendment bill has less to do with giving citizenship to non-muslim refugees from the neighbouring countries and more to do with linking citizenship to religion. Since the passage of the bill, the whole country has erupted into protests. But instead of listening to the people who are sitting in protests for now 3 months, and clarifying their doubts, the central government is declaring them as terrorists and anti-nationals. The Prime Minister himself in one of the election rallies in Jharkhand said things like identifying protesters with their clothes. Since then, there has been a flood of hateful and threatening statements from people in responsible positions. Karnataka BJP minister C.T. Ravi last year had made a statement like- “If the majority lost its patience then Godhara like things can happen again”. In the Delhi Assembly election campaign, all limits were crossed. Home Minister Amit Shah and State revenue minister Anurag Thakur gave statements like sending “current to Shaheen Bagh” and “Shoot the traitors”. BJP MP Pravesh Verma and Kapil Mishra are openly playing the role of riot mongers. During this time, there were two instances where youth were found to be waving pistols in the air at anti CAA protesters at Jamia and Shaheen Bagh and now the same violence has come in an explosive way. In Delhi 2020 violence, there was no “action-reaction”, nor “a big tree fell that shook the earth”. This is a result of a continuous process that has changed the minds of many. Delhi is the capital of India and maybe the last endpoint of this project. Of Course whatever happens here will have an impact on the psyche of the whole country. 18 years ago, when “action-reaction” happened in Gujarat, Delhi was criticizing it, but now that the Gujarat model is being repeated in Delhi, Delhi is not even in a position to sigh. What is happening in Delhi is horrific and worrisome, but what is scarier, is the lack of a political alternative. Today there is no political force in sight to counter the aggressive majoritarian politics. We only see people’s resistance but a mass of the population is prepared with hate to counter these peaceful resistance movements. There is no project to counter the BJP-RSS project, but the even bigger worry is the lack of a feeling for this vacuum. Not too long ago, the anti-BJP-RSS camp was jumping with joy over the victory of AAP in Delhi elections and was calling it a mandate against BJP´s “project”. RSS and its electoral front BJP have their own agenda for which they have been planning for a long time. Their goal is not limited to winning elections. After BJPs defeat in Delhi Elections, Amit Shah had said- BJP is an ideology based party and it does not fight elections to win but elections are also a medium to further its ideology. It is the result of this planning that today the basis of electoral politics has changed in the country. Today RSS proposed Hindutva politics has become mainstream politics. This is a big victory for any ideology that all electoral parties in the country wittingly or out of helplessness are competing on the pitch laid out by them. However, the violence in Delhi is not a reaction to any recent incident. The chasm has become much deeper and now it is showing its deadly dance in the capital. This chasm can only be filled with a long term project. It seems that after 2014 the political parties in the country have also gone for a hiatus at a time when they are needed the most. In such an adverse situation, both in politics as well as society, there is an absolute absence of judiciousness and there is not even a single person in the country to whom the whole country is willing to listen. Views are personal. Javed Anees is a writer based in Delhi.  The article has been translated from the original article at the media vigil.

BJP’s Serial offender Basangouda Patil Yatnal insults Centenarian Freedom fighter H.S. Doreswamy

0
BJP Basagouda Patil Yatnal’s insulting statements against Centenarian Freedom Fighter H.S. Doreswamy has not been taken kindly by the people of Karnataka. Protests and demonstrations are taking place all over Karnataka. Two days ago on 25th February, the controversy started when Siddharamaiah had said- BJP has not participated in the freedom struggle and they are talking about nationalism. Responding to it, BJP’s leader Basangouda Patil Yatnal said- Did Siddharamaiah participate in the freedom struggle? Did Sonia Gandhi participate in freedom struggle? Everone had participated. Vajpayee has also participated.” “Now there are these fake Freedom fighters. One person called Doreswamy in Bangalore, who is that guy? who is that old fellow? He speaks like a pakistani agent..He continued insulting him saying he is the mouth piece of Congress and JDS”. As if that is not enough he added-  “Days of feeding biriyani to traitors is over, it is time to shoot at sight”. He also has proudly justified the state sponsored violence in Delhi. Basangouda Patil is himself facing serious criminal charges (23 Charges) against him and is notorious formaking hateful and communal speeches. He is recieving severe criticism for his statements from all sections of the society, despite that Vijayapura BJP Minister Basavanagauda Patil Yatnal yesterday refused to apologise.
yatnal
Centenarian Freedom Fighter H.S Doreswamy
H.S. Doreswamy is 102 year freedom fighter. He is a celebrated person in Karnataka and has been part of several people’s movements for the welfare of people. Recently he has been part of the Movement for land and shelter for the landless people ( Bhoomi matu vasati vanchita horata) in karnataka. Congress, JDS and Karnataka Rajya Raitha Sangha ( KRRS) and many progressive forces of Karnataka have condemned the statement urging the state government to intervene and apologise for Yatnal remarks and asked for his removal.   Protests happened yesterday the Land and Shelter movement activists in Raichur, Sindhanur, chikmagalur and Sagar district. Yesterday Congress also staged a big protest in Vidhan Soudha demanding Yatnal’s removal from the party.     Today several concerned civil society members staged a protest meet at Gandhi Bhawan codnemning Yatnal statements and asked for his apology and removal from the party. They also gave a memorandum to the chief Minister asking that Yatnal should be punished for his statements according to the law. Minister V. Somanna,housing minister BJp leader has supported Yatnal statement further adding that Dareswamy shpould control his tongue and shpuld not speak against Modi and should not talk about secularism. BJP with the help of its IT cell has started a dirty campaign against H.S. Doreswamy and planning to ruin his reputation and thereby affect the people’s movement in this way. This will be a big attack on the democratic and plural atmosphere of karnataka. BJP only agenda is in spreading hate and poison. We need to stand united and not fall for this defamation and negativity on the celebrated figures of the country.    

Midnight transfer of Justice Muralidhar, had ordered FIRs against hate speeches

0
On the day, Justice Muralidhar of Delhi HC grilled Centre and Delhi Police over violence in NCR and inaction in filing FIRs against BJP leaders for their hate speeches, he is transferred to the Punjab and Haryana High court. The Ministry of Law and Justice on Wednesday, 26 February notified the transfer of Justice S Muralidhar from the Delhi High Court to the Punjab & Haryana High Court. A notification from the Department of Justice in the Ministry of Law and Justice said: “In exercise of the power conferred by clause (1) of Article 222 of the Constitution of India, the President, after consultation with the Chief Justice of India, is pleased to transfer Shri Justice S Muralidhar, Judge of the Delhi High Court, as a Judge of the Punjab and Haryana High Court and to direct him to assume charge of office in the Punjab and Haryana High Court.” The notification follows the recommendation passed by the Collegium headed by Chief Justice of Indian S A Bobde. The Supreme Court Collegium had recommended his transfer on 12 February. When the decision became public on 19 February, it was widely condemned, including by the Delhi High Court Bar Association, whose members abstained from work on 20 February in protest. Protesting Justice Muralidhar’s transfer, the Delhi High Court Bar Association had urged the Collegium to “revisit” and recall its recommendation, saying such transfers “tend to erode and dislodge the faith of the common litigant in the justice dispensation system”. Justice Muralidhar in an urgent midnight hearing on the night of 25-26 February ordered the Delhi police to allow the prompt passage of ambulances and emergency services in the riot-hit areas. Justice Muralidhar is known for his strong judgements on communal violence and human rights of poor and marginalised. He has delivered the Hashimpura verdict convicting personnel of the Uttar Pradesh PAC for the 1987 mass killings. He had also convicted Sajjan Kumar for his role in 1984 anti -sikh riots. He was part of the two-judge bench along with then Chief Justice A P Shah that delivered the landmark verdict decriminalising homosexuality.      

Modi finally frees himself from hospitality to speak on Delhi violence

0
After three days of silence, today afternoon, Prime Minister Narendra Modi took to twitter and appealed for calm and peace in Delhi. The death toll has reached 20 in the violence that started on Sunday evening after BJP leader Kapil Mishra made inflammatory statements to Police and Pro-CAA supporters. In two tweets on Wednesday afternoon, PM Modi said he held an extensive review meeting to look at the current situation in the national capital. Prime Minister Narendra Modi Wednesday appealed to his “brothers and sisters of Delhi” to maintain “peace and brotherhood” at all times. He said it was important to restore “calm and normalcy” at the earliest. PM Modi added, “Peace and harmony are central to our ethos. I appeal to my sisters and brothers of Delhi to maintain peace and brotherhood at all times. It is important that there is calm and normalcy is restored at the earliest.” Until yesterday Prime Minister Modi was busy entertaining state guest USA president Donald Trump. Trump was on a two-day India visit during which PM Modi hosted him to Gujarat Sabarmati Ashram and a visit to Tajmahal in Uttar Pradesh.
The two-day trip ended after meeting with Indian business leaders and a state banquet at the Rashtrapati Bhavan. 15 Kms away in Jafarabad and Maujpur, Delhi was on fire.
At least 20 people have died in northeast Delhi in the riots that started on Sunday and continued till Tuesday night. Incidences of shooting, arson, and vandalism are being reported even on Wednesday. This delayed response to any crisis and calamity is a trademark strategy of PM Modi right from the days of Gujarat riots, where for days mob was allowed to carry out the violence. The army was called after 3 days in riot-affected areas. In a press conference on Wednesday, Congress chief Sonia Gandhi held Home Minister Amit Shah responsible for the violence in Delhi and sought his resignation. “The Centre and the Union Home Minister is responsible for the present situation in Delhi. The Union Home Minister should resign,” said Sonia Gandhi.

Where is AAP ka beta Arvind Kejriwal, when Delhi is burning?

1
The pre-planned rioting that started in Northeast Delhi on Sunday night has claimed 20 lives so far, with unofficial sources claim the figure could be as high as 50. At least 189 people have been injured. Meanwhile, the horrific images and videos of the pogrom on social media have left people numb. Muslims are being killed, beaten with rods, sticks, and stones. Muslim houses and property are being burnt and vandalised in a targetted manner. The videos of Hindutva mob with police support police creating mayhem in Muslim neighbourhood may one day prove them guilty but as of now, it has taken away whatever little faith people had in the government machinery. As Delhi burns, Modiji is busy entertaining his twin American brother, Donald Trump while the Chanakya home minister Amit shah is nowhere to be seen, probably because there are no upcoming elections.
While many praised his “not falling for BJP trap” a success story and something to be replicated in other states, it is ironic to see Kejriwal Exposed Within a fortnight of HIS victory. So much for fighting fascism!
The behaviour of BJP, RSS and the Hindutva mob has been known and clear as day to people. Hatemongering, mob lynching, and rioting is their expertise but the behavior of AAP and its head Arvind Kejriwal is what has come as surprise to many especially, people who were giving Kejriwal the medal of honor last week for defeating fascism in Delhi. Well, they have got their rude awakening!!! AAP ka beta, Dilli ka Beta Arvind Kejriwal an astute politician, very cleverly stayed away from the hate campaign of BJP and focused on education, water, and electricity. Many praised him for it. He tactically also stayed away from Shaheen bagh and called for the place being vacated. Playing to both sides, Mr. Kejriwal won the Delhi elections with a huge mandate. While many praised his “not falling for BJP trap” a success story and something to be replicated in other states, it is ironic to see Kejriwal exposed within a fortnight of his victory. So much for fighting fascism! Let’s take a look at what Mr. Kejriwal did while Delhi burnt- Kejriwal made three tweets about how sad he is that the situation is tense in Delhi and people should maintain peace. He retweeted other AAP leaders tweets for calls for peace. He also expressed grief in his tweet over the death of a head constable in the riots, by this time the death toll was 4. The next day on Tuesday, when social media is full of horrific images and evidence of mobs led by BJP leaders burning Muslim neighborhoods, Mr. Kejriwal did a press conference and went to Rajghat to “pray” for peace. AAP won overwhelmingly in Muslim dominated areas, so much so that AAP´s candidate Amanatullah won with the second-highest margin in the Delhi Elections from the Okhla constituency where Shaheen Bagh is situated. So it is natural that people will have expectations from the MLAs at such times. What is Arvind Kejriwal afraid of now, when there are no elections or Hindu votes to lose? Mr. Kejriwal did go to see the victims of the violence in the hospital on Tuesday night, 3 days after the violence. A delegation of students went to meet him with a charter of demands that he should do something to contain the situation in Delhi. Instead of meeting them, the students were water cannoned, 42 of them were beaten up, detained and slapped with police cases. Delhi CM Kejriwal has expressed his helplessness and not being in control of police as reasons for his inability in handling the situation. But that is not true. According to an article by Indian Express, there is a list of things that a union territory can do, for example- call the central government to send the army. Mr. Kejriwal did that, on Wednesday. By this time, the death toll reached in the 30s, fear instilled in people, anti-CAA protesters vacated from the neighbourhood, and crores of damage to the property had already happened. What stopped Kejriwal from acting as a responsible Chief Minister? Kejriwal’s response leaves much to be desired and social media didn’t leave any punches in telling him just that.   Mr. Kejriwal when will you stand up for your Dilli?  

Indian Journalist Rana Ayyub awarded with McGill Medal for journalistic courage

0
Indian journalist Rana Ayyub was awarded the McGill Medal for Journalistic Courage for the year 2020 on Monday, 24 February. Ayyub is presently associated with The Washington Post as Global Opinions Writer and will collect the award at The Grady College Of Journalism and Mass Communication, the University of Georgia on 22 April. Rana Ayub has reported on religious violence and extrajudicial killings by the state in India will receive the 2020 McGill Medal for journalistic courage.
“I accept this award on behalf of all journalists who are fighting an unpopular battle to speak the truth,” tweeted Ayyub after winning the award.
In a career spanning fourteen years, Ayyub has been awarded the Sanskriti Award for integrity and excellence in journalism from the President of India. She was the recipient of the Global Shining Light award for Investigative journalism in the year 2017 and the Most Resilient Global Journalist of 2018 at the Peace Palace in Hague. Ayyub authored an international bestseller titled “Gujarat Files: Anatomy of a Cover-Up,” an undercover investigation that exposes the complicity of the Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in state-sponsored genocide. She has also been named by Time magazine among ten global journalists who face maximum threats to their lives and has been profiled by New Yorker. Ayyub is based in Mumbai, India. Nominations for the medal came from journalists and journalism educators from across the country. The 2019 class of McGill Fellows, 12 students chosen for academic achievement, practical experience and leadership, researched the nominees and made the selection. “Ayyub is committed to telling the stories of people who can’t do it on her own, making her an ideal McGill medal recipient,” said Sofia Gratas, the McGill Fellow responsible for researching the nomination. The McGill Medal, now in its twelfth year, is part of the McGill Program for Journalistic Courage at UGA’s Grady College. For more than 40 years, the McGill Lecture has brought significant figures in journalism to UGA to help the university honor McGill’s courage as an editor. In 2007, UGA added the McGill Symposium, bringing together students, faculty and leading journalists to consider what journalistic courage means and how reporters and editors exemplify it. The medal was added in 2009. “All of this is for a single purpose: to advance journalistic courage,” said Diane H. Murray, the Grady College’s director of alumni relations and outreach and director of the McGill program. The McGill program is named for Ralph McGill, the late editor, and publisher of the Atlanta Constitution. McGill was regarded by many as “the conscience of the South” for his editorials challenging racial segregation in the 1950s and 1960s.
 

“We don’t need your teargas to cry” – the dissenting pangs of Lebanon

1
In 2019, a series of austerity measures were introduced in Lebanon. Noticeably was the increase in taxes on gasoline and online phone calls. This so-called WhatsApp tax led to a national wave of protests. The protests began on 17 October 2019, when hundreds of protesters occupied downtown Beirut, the nation’s capital., and grew from there. As the protests spread, so did the issues spread, to corruption, sectarianism, unemployment, lack of state accountability, and need for basic services. Protesters have complained that since 1990, electricity has been provided at 80% of demand. The protests are leaderless and have led to the resignation of Prime Minister Saad Hariri, son of former Prime Minister Rafic Hariri, in December 2019. They continue. Unlike previous struggles in Lebanon, these protests have resisted any sectarian, political or international patronage, and continue as an expression of dissent. The resignation of Saad Hariri left a political vacuum, which has caused the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank to put pressure on the state to put up a government that can manage the situation better. On 21 January, Hasan Diab became the newest Prime Minister. Diab attempted to balance American and Iranian interests, owing to his good relations with Hezbollah and a cabinet packed with American nationals. His government is likely to continue with the policies that the protesters are agitating against.

Making of Lebanon

Lebanon was a country designed to be unstable. With the defeat of the Ottoman Empire in World War I, Syria and Lebanon came under the control of France. The colonial powers defeated the Ottoman’s in an alliance of a growing Arab solidarity movement but betrayed them when they created the new countries from the Ottoman Empire. Religion was the basis of a divide and rule strategy. At Lebanon’s independence in 1943, about half of the country was Christian. The most prominent Christian sect, the Maronites, a third of the population. Nearly a third of the population was Muslim, and the remaining population was composed of local religions. So the French Mandate of Syria was partitioned on communal lines to give a country to the region’s Christian population, the Maronites. This country became Lebanon. After the partition of Syria, Lebanon was a free market bastion in a region of the world that had more state control. Syria, Egypt, and Iraq began to adopt Secular Socialist states based on Arab Nationalism. The communal nature of the divide haunted Lebanon. The Christian-Muslim split had regional and urban-rural dimensions. In the 1970s, many people migrated from rural areas to urban areas. Communal tensions flared up. Some groups, mostly Sunni, advocated for reunification with Syria.

Hezbollah

The tensions led to a 15 year Civil War in Lebanon from 1975 to 1990. In this period, Hezbollah arose as a powerful political force in Lebanon. It worked with local Shia leaders and drew international support from Iran. It continued its presence even into the current day with a militant stand against the United States and Israel. Hezbollah’s organizational structure runs between that of an organized state and a religious community. As a well-organized group without a traditional state structure, it has become a threat to American and Israeli presence in the Middle East, often being compared with Iran and Russia in terms of its adversarial relationship with the United States.

Lebanon as a Neo-liberal station

Lebanon occupied a strategic place, culturally, economically and militarily for Western powers and their allies in the Middle East. There was a fear from the Western powers that Lebanon would reunite with Syria. The Lebanese Civil war had an international dimension. The different factions of the war called for reunification with Syria, the democratization of the Lebanese government, neo-liberal reforms, state control over the economy, etc. In 1990, to accommodate the changing demographics of the country and to end the Civil War, Lebanon adopted a new constitution that protected market interests. It also made concessions to the Shia and Sunni communities by way of communal representation in the government. Christians would keep influence over the military, and Muslims would have more presentation in Parliament. The Prime Minister would be a Sunni Muslim. The government design made sure that trade would be unhampered. Lebanon was an example of the weak state that would facilitate neo-liberal interests. The first Prime Minister after the Civil War was Omar Karimi from the Arab Liberation party, an offshoot of the Dignity movement, which supported pan-Arab solidarity. His regime lasted just over a year. The next major Prime Minister was Rafic Hariri, a business tycoon, and father to the recently deposed Saad Hariri, who implemented many of the neo-liberal reforms, which contributed to today’s crisis. He was President of Lebanon in 1992-1998 and again from 2000-2004. He was known for his corruption, where his personal assets jumped 16-fold from 1992 to 2005 when he died. In 1994, he began to use the military to crush public dissent. He was also known to use the reconstruction of Beirut to give contracts to other rich business moguls. Inequality in Lebanon become the highest in Asia. Corruption in government services increased. The public deficit rose through the 1990s. In the 2000s, Lebanon borrowed heavily internationally. By 2019, the public debt was one and a half the total GDP of the country.

Tension in the country

In the 1990s and 2000s, dissent was kept suppressed. Hariri lost the election to Karimi in 2004, leading to a pro-Syrian tilt in the state. In February 2005, Rafic Hariri was assassinated. Western powers blamed pro-Syrian forces in the country. In the aftermath, the Independence-05 movement, where nearly 10 lakh people came to the street in protest. This was called the Independence Intifada by the Arab world. In the western world, it was called the Cedar Revolution, a reference to the tree on the Lebanese flag. The protests were supported by America and France, calling it a democratic struggle. It was condemned by Syria and Iran. The result of the protests was an end to the Karimi government. Hariri’s party continued to keep a prominent role in parliamentary politics over the next fifteen years. The invasion of Syria and Iraq by America also led to instability. The Syrian refugee crisis and the spillover of the conflict into Lebanon made the next decade violent and unstable. Lebanon had a population of nearly 70 lakhs and hosted 15 lakh, Syrian refugees. As the Lebanon nation was based on a truce based on sectarian balance, the influx of refugees caused insecurity to the population. In 2019, the current wave of protests began. These protests are different from the Independence-05 movement, in that they do not have any international patronage and are critical of all sides, including the reunification movements, Hezbollah, Iran and the United States. The movement has come as an undying expression of frustration by the people of Lebanon against the current state of things. Underlying the protests is a frustration with a state that is both indebted to foreign powers and usurious against its own people. The protesters have been chanting, “All of them means all of them,” indicating that they are done with the rearrangement of power, as was done in the past. What the future holds, remains to be seen.