
Karnataka: Adivasi huts destroyed in Kodagu district, police beat up activist who questioned!

Delhi Elections 2020: History repeating itself as “farce” in Delhi
- After the poll campaign ended for elections to 70 seated Delhi Assembly on Thursday, voters are left to choose between two sundry offerings- to embrace BJP regime that is contesting voters’ citizenship (through impending NPR/NRC/CAA) or denounce it by reducing one’s own citizenship status to being a mere state beneficiary in AAP regime.
Loss of a national narrative
Let us put it straight- Whoever wins this assembly election will do so at the cost of the Shaheen Bagh Movement. Shaheen Bagh will lose in any case. And why Shaheen Bagh is so central to Delhi polls? Not because BJP has brought in its highest leadership to instigate communal polarization, but because it is a focal point in our contemporary national discourse that will set the narrative for the upcoming state polls, most importantly for West Bengal. This narrative will go a long way in shaping the political climate of this nation-state. Alas! the stage has been set in the national capital for a loss of narrative in a double-edged sword game and we will see to it on February 11th when the verdict comes. Meanwhile, let us have a swift look at the chronology of political developments. It was the Aam Aadmi Party that responded much later to Shaheen Bagh, almost more than a month later after it kicked off. The reason stated on the record by Manish Sisodia was that the party did not want itself to get branded as Tukde Tukde Gang. And he was not incorrect in saying this. The moment Sisodia came out in support of Shaheen Bagh, BJP branded AAP as the conspirator of anti-CAA protests. Delhi CM Kejriwal sensed the urgency and immediately distanced itself from Shaheen Bagh by placing the onus on the Union Home Minister Amit Shah. He asked Shah why he is not clearing the roadblock if Delhi Police is under him! At the same time, Kejriwal could not sense the irony of his statement that could be read out of the text as follows: I would have cleared the roadblock if Delhi Police reported to me! AAP Muslim voters also sensed it and they are in a lurch. A resident of Shaheen Bagh and AAP sympathizer Sultan Bharti says, “I am afraid if Muslim voters decide their vote on CAA/NRC. Then they would certainly go for Congress that is vehemently opposing CAA/NRC. Otherwise, it is true that AAP has worked on the basics in the last five years but distancing itself from anti-CAA protests will cost it Delhi’s fortunes”. Satyam Shrivastava, a civil society member who works on tribal issues articulates this expression as follows: “AAP has NGOised Delhi politics. This election seems to be a renewal of grant for ‘NGO’ AAP. Asking votes in the name of bijli-pani is like completing the checklist of project requirements, ignoring the very basic question of citizenship for which a section of the electorate is protesting. This shows AAP is basically reducing citizens into a mere state beneficiary”. On the other hand, BJP is in full swing, doing its own brand of politics from parliament to road. On Thursday, in his thanksgiving speech to President during the budget session in Loksabha, PM Narendra Modi spoke for around an hour and forty minutes. He did not utter a single word on development or basic services rather invoked Ram Mandir, Article 370, triple talaq, etc claiming credit to all these recent decisions given by the honorable Supreme Court. Does that mean that the SC’s decisions on Ram Mandir, triple talaq, Article 370, etc. were in fact dictated by Centre? If what PM says is true, then, then Justice Kurien Joseph, Justice Chelameswar, Justice Ranjan Gogoi and Justice Madan B Lokur also spoke the truth in the unprecedented and historic press conference exactly a couple of years back that “Democracy is at stake in India?”The Populism trap
No one will doubt the victory of AAP. Margins may reduce. In his weekly column at Dawn Jawed Naqvi termed AAP and kejriwal sucess as anomalous. But this “anomalous” in AAP has a perverse logic: When Kejriwal wins, he loses! This is where I see a change of the game in Delhi. On the question of CAA, Kejriwal has remained cautious. But the perception that AAP tried to build among its Hindu voters by distancing itself from Shaheen Bagh has been shattered by sustained propaganda of BJP. Be it the paid media channels defamed AAP as Urban Naxal, TTG, terrorist or the hate speeches of Yogi Adityanath, Anurag Thakur and Pravesh Verma. Likewise, Muslims are also not in a condition to pose full faith in AAP as they could see Congress taking a firm stand on the question of citizenship. For AAP this is a Catch-22 situation. BJP is much comfortable with Hindu votes alone. As far as INC is concerned it seeks to grab a piece of pie from Kejriwal, especially in Muslim dominated areas. It has tried to mobilise some of its finest faces in civil society last week at protest sites. This may work in its favor garnering a couple of seats. In CPI (ML) and other left factions, Kejriwal has got some blessing in disguise free of cost. Students and activists affiliated to Left groups are asking votes for AAP at anti-CAA protest sites. Not so openly, but Yes! Polit Bureau member of CPI (ML) Kavita Krishnan affirms this when she speaks to Rohin Kumar of Mediavigil, “AAP is not clear on many issues, say CAA/NRC but the situation demands that whoever has the potential to defeat the communal politics of BJP/RSS is to be supported. This is our strategy in Delhi, although we will fight with a different strategy in Bihar”. So here is some Oxygen for AAP coming from the left-outs! Sultan Bharti openly accepts the role of left parties in building anti-CAA protests in Muslim areas of Delhi but he sums up this role in an interesting phrase. “Vaam ka kaam har murde ko kandha dena hota hai, use murda zinda to nahin ho jata!” (Left is there to lend its shoulder to every corpse but that does not instill life in a corpse!) AAP is still alive and kicking- in the sense of a regular electoral party. But it was dead way back as a movement, hollowed with ethics and redundant with values. Left has lent its shoulder to AAP for fighting communal politics of BJP in Delhi but unfortunately, it has forgotten the basic lesson that from 2011-2014, AAP was the single Oxygen cylinder that filled air into nationalist aspirations of BJP. So for left politics, Delhi is again a populist trap. Nothing new! Whoever will win or lose will be a mirror image of the other. The eventual losers are the Mothers and Daughters of Shaheen Bagh! We may just hope that this does not get reflected within 48 hours of the announcement of mandate in the form of a brutal crackdown. (Abhishek Srivastava is the Executive Editor of Mediavigil.com, he has written a book for Juggernaut Publishers on the journey of anti-corruption movement from IAC to AAP that is yet to be published) Views are personalDelhi Elections 2020: AAP and BJP Game of Thrones
Office of Profit case
The Delhi HC in a petition hearing by Rashtriya Mukti Morcha that sought scrapping of appointments for being “unconstitutional, illegal and without jurisdiction” said in September 2016: “The specific plea of the petitioner [NGO] that the impugned order dated March 13, 2015, was passed without communicating the decision to the Lieutenant Governor for his views/concurrence has not been disputed by the Respondents (Delhi government). Therefore, we find force in the submission of the petitioner that the issue is squarely covered by the decision [of the HC passed on August 4]…Accordingly, without going into the other contentions raised in the writ petition, the impugned order dated March 13, 2015 is hereby set aside.” Things went very far in a matter of 15 months. On the recommendation of EC, the President approved the disqualification of AAP MLAs. Delhi government again challenged this in HC. Public opinion was sharply divided on this issue but no one asked a crucial question related to the original petition by Rashtriya Mukti Morcha (RMM) and the decision of AAP/Delhi government in this respect to challenging it on the very face of it. This becomes important considering that RMM, the NGO was founded by the same Ram Jethmalani who was hired by Kejriwal to represent him against Arun Jaitley in the defamation case. It is an entirely different fact that Jethmalani had parted from this NGO as its founder president way back in 1989 but a look at the history of cases fought by this NGO reveals its political character and affiliations. Without going into details, just a cursory look at an interview of advocate Ravinder Kumar, the National President of RMM published in Livemint on April 30, 2007, is very insightful in understanding the ideological connections of AAP and RMM. Apart from Sonia Gandhi’s foreign origin case and the Prime Minister of India P.V Narasimha Rao (in Jharkhand Mukti Morcha bribing case in which RMM was responsible for his first conviction) the cases taken up by RMM clearly shows who was getting benefitted politically. Although Kumar openly pronounced his equal disgust for Congress and BJP, in the interview he says, “All of them are equally hypocritical and live off each other. Both the Congress and the BJP get a chance to rule by turns because of negative voting against the party in power. This indicates how the disgusted and frustrated voters are always seeking a change”. This was the basic premise upon which the AAP party had started its political journey and held itself as an alternative to the BJP-Congress diarchy. There may be a dozen questions on Arvind Kejriwal in this regard. Let us keep “Operation Lotusbloom” aside for a moment. How come a like-minded and anti-Congress anti-BJP outfit petition against his MLA’s? Why did he choose the founder President of RMM as his lawyer? Why he did not dispute the “specific plea of the petitioner (NGO)”, as mentioned in the HC order? Kejriwal repeatedly alleged the central government and LG of Delhi for not letting his mandated government work smoothly. Why did he not take the name of RMM, the original petitioner in the office of profit case even once? Was this some sort of marriage of convenience? What about his colleagues?Mandate “fixed” again?
Getting a huge mandate is second to holding it. Once you get a mandate to rule, you need to create and stick on to a perceptional vote. AAP has lost this perception war against its rivals, be it BJP or Congress. The main reason behind this is the centrality of the internal power structure that lies with Arvind Kejriwal much like PM Modi who has unleased the Gujarat model of governance in Centre where the cabinet and ranks become redundant. In Kejriwal’s case, one can call it the Delhi model of governance. This analogy would have been apter had AAP consolidated its organisational capacity and structure in the last couple of years. But it failed to do as seen by the results of Punjab and Goa. I am reminded of two insightful articles- one by Yogendra Yadav and the other by Jawed Naqvi. In April 2017, Yadav had written a piece in a national daily where he said, “BJP is out to murder the Aam Aadmi Party but the Arvind Kejriwal-led party will suicide before it gets murdered”. Around the same time Naqvi in his Dawn column titled “The anomalous rise of Mr. Kejriwal” had concluded, “…in Kejriwal’s case when he loses, he wins”. Formulating the “anomalous”, he wrote, “The anomalous rise of Kejriwal persists with its perverse logic”. This is where questions are raised upon the 2015 Delhi mandate being “fixed” and another upcoming “fixture” on February 11, 2020. In a nation of short term memory loss, it would be useful to remind of a slogan that appeared mysteriously on the website of Aam Aadmi Party in November 2014: ‘Delhi Speaks: Modi for PM, Arvind for CM‘. The party later removed the image from the homepage of its website, but hundreds of messages on Twitter and Facebook ridiculing the party for its clear endorsement of Prime Minister showed that the damage was done. India Today had reported: “AAP shamelessly using Namo’s picture on its website as a crutch to sell itself. Sad really,” said a tweet. “Aaj ‘Hail Modi’ & before Gen Elections it was ‘Jail Modi'”, said another. “I’m willing to bet almost anything that #AAP will claim its website was hacked,” a third tweet said. There was no reaction from the party on Twitter, where chief Arvind Kejriwal is pretty active. The AAP even had a statement on the site, which was also removed along with the image. The statement said, “The voters in Delhi have decided. They want a strong Prime Minister which is why they elected Narendra Modi. They now want a strong Chief Minister so that issues like corruption, inflation, better schools, transport, and hospitals could be resolved. They want Arvind Kejriwal again.” Even a video showing Kejriwal taking oath as Delhi’s chief minister in December last year was removed by the party from its website. Around February 2015 just before Delhi Assembly elections in last-leg, this slogan became the unofficial campaigning line of AAP when Modi was scheduled to address BJP rallies. The Telegraph had reported then: The plan has been prompted by fears that Narendra Modi could halt the momentum AAP leaders believe Kejriwal has been able to generate so far and turn the tide in favour of the BJP. To counter such a possibility, AAP poll managers feel the “Modi for PM and Kejriwal for CM” tactic would be the best bet. Later when the results were announced on February 10, 2015, many commentators termed AAP sweeping Delhi as a return gift for a huge BJP mandate in 2014. Whatever be the case, one must not forget that the original anti-corruption movement was kicked off by none other than Baba Ramdev and the entry of Anna Hazare in the IAC movement was via Shri Shri Ravishankar, the self- styled Godman working for BJP. And the last thing that needs to be remembered is the involvement of RSS think-tank Vivekanand Foundation in IAC movement, headed by notorious Ajit Doval, the National Security Advisor! (Abhishek Srivastava is the Executive Editor of Mediavigil.com, he has written a book for Juggernaut Publishers on the journey of anti-corruption movement from IAC to AAP that is yet to be published)Indigo passengers protest in solidarity with Kunal Kamra
After they stood for a while, IndiGo’s security ground staff went in and asked them to take their seats, which they did. IndiGo sources described the protest as “peaceful”. One of the women, Medha Kapoor shared the photos on Twitter and mentioned that, “No, nobody said a word to us. When security personnel asked us to sit down, we complied. It was very peaceful.” On being asked why they just didn’t boycott the airlines, Kapoor added that: “Our tickets were booked way before the incident happened so we decided to travel one last time and make that count”. After the controversial run-in between Kunal Kamra and Arnab Goswami, and Indigo banning Kunal Kamra, last Tuesday, aviation minister Hardeep Puri advised other airlines to impose a similar ban on the comedian. “Offensive behaviour designed to provoke & create disturbance inside an aircraft is absolutely unacceptable & endangers the safety of air travellers. We are left with no option but to advise other airlines to impose similar restrictions on the person concerned,” the minister tweeted last night. GoAir, SpiceJet, Air India followed suit soon after. An AirAsia India official told PTI that the airline is waiting for the aviation regulator DGCA to issue a formal notice, and after then it will take action against Kamra. Taking a dig at the airlines, the comedian tweeted this evening that Vijay Mallya, Lalit Modi, Nirav Modi and Mehul Choksi — all absconding and wanted in mega frauds — were able to take a flight when they shouldn’t have.In solidarity with @kunalkamra88 on an IndiGo flight while being compliant with all DGCA passenger guidelines! pic.twitter.com/QEnyoMLcYQ
— Medha Kapoor (@MedhaKapoor4) February 6, 2020
Madhya Pradesh: Another case of Mob lynching over rumours of child lifting
Farmers were dragged out of vehicles and attacked
“All six men were dragged out of their vehicles and attacked brutally. Our cops meanwhile got to know that some men were being attacked on suspicion of child theft. Cops rushed to the spot and managed to bring them to Manawar hospital. One of the critically injured men was rushed to Indore, but died midway,” the SP Dhar said. According to Singh a case of murder, an attempt to murder and rioting has been lodged against the three labour contractors and 10-15 of their aides. No arrests, however, have been made till now. Incidents of mob lynching have become increasingly common in India. Some of the states have also passed laws against lynching but it seems to be ineffective when the mob is instigated on emotional issues like religion, cow and nowadays child lifting. Madhya Pradesh’s government passed a law to prevent cow-related vigilantism in June 2019. The Madhya Pradesh government announced a compensation of Rs 2 lakh to the relatives of Ganesh Khasi, the farmer who was lynched on Wednesday.Court pulls Delhi police for inaction on hate speech by Anurag Thakur and Pravesh Verma
Kanhaiya Kumar convoy attacked after public meeting on CAA in Bihar
Kanhaiya Kumar was addressing the people on the Citizenship Amendment Act along with other anti-CAA protesters as part of the All India Hum Bharat ke campaign. Police say nobody was hurt in the attack. But Kanhaiya Kumar on his twitter handle mentioned that one of the friends who was driving was hurt. He also said, tomorrow in Saharsa and Madhepura rallies,”Hum bharat ke log” will respond to such violent attacks by slogans of “freedom in the free country”Bihar: Former JNU Students Union leader Kanhaiya Kumar injured after stones were pelted at his convoy in Supaul, today. Kanhaiya was heading towards Saharsa, after addressing a rally in Supaul at the time of incident. More details awaited. pic.twitter.com/IzJhtWzxiB
— ANI (@ANI) February 5, 2020
This was the second time in four days that Kanhaiya Kumar’s convoy was attacked. Stones were thrown at his vehicle on Saturday as his convoy passed through Saran district. Two of the vehicles were damaged at the time. The attacked happened around 5.30 in the evening after the end of the meeting. The incident happened near a police station where some 25-30 youth were sloganeering in favour of CAA. They threw black ink at Kanhaiya’s vehicle and then stones. Kanhaiya Kumar along with Chandrashekhar Azad, the two youth icons have been the sharpest critics of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his policies. Chandra Shekhar Azad was arrested/detained several times in the last month and was not allowed to even reach protest sites.आज जन-गण-मन यात्रा के सातवे दिन झंझारपुर और सुपौल में सभाओं का आयोजन हुआ। यात्रा को मिल रहे अपार जनसमर्थन से हताश होकर गोडसेवादियो ने सुपौल बाजार में यात्रा के क़ाफ़िले पर हमला किया, लेकिन नफरतों के साये में मोहब्बत का कारवाँ रूकने वाला नही है। 😊 pic.twitter.com/iNyDY1nO7i
— Kanhaiya Kumar (@kanhaiyakumar) February 5, 2020
Uttar Pradesh: UP police early morning crackdown on Anti-CAA protesters
AAP election manifesto promises clean water, electricity with Jan Lokpal Bill
Kashmiri Journalist Yusuf Jameel chosen for 2019-20 PEN-Gauri Lankesh Award
“The 2019-2020 PEN-Gauri Lankesh Award for Democratic Idealism is awarded to Yusuf Jameel. His work in journalism shows an exemplary commitment to professional integrity and the ideals of democracy. Starting his career as a journalist with Aftab, the Srinagar-based Urdu daily, in the early 1980s, he has worked for various newspapers and media agencies since, including The Telegraph, BBC, Reuters, Time, Voice of America and The Asian Age. In the context of rising insurgency in the Kashmir valley in the late eighties and the nineties and the very complex conflict scenario that has evolved since, his work as a reporter pioneered fearless and candid journalism in Jammu and Kashmir. As a print and radio journalist working in both Urdu and English languages for over three and a half decades, his work shows a deep level of social engagement and concern and has contributed immensely to the traditions of fair and courageous reportage.”In 2018, the award was given to cartoonist P. Mahamud. P Mahamud has always been very vocal about the advancement of social and economic justice through his work. His works have always offered a non-partisan critique of political corruption, communalism and caste prejudice, in the country in general, and in Karnataka in particular. PEN was founded in 1921 to promote friendship and intellectual co-operation among writers. PEN defends the rights of writers internationally. PEN has three centres in India – Delhi, Bombay and South India. PEN South India was founded in 2017 and is based out of a different city each year.


