Hindutva & Zionism As Natural Allies Pose Great Danger to Multicultural World

0
Those who believe in a world free of hegemonic ethno-nationalism, Racism, religious bigotry and hatred have rightly taken note of Zionism and its ally Christian Zionism, major perpetrators of ethnic cleansing of ‘Others’.  However, the civilized world with its core belief in multi-culturalism and peaceful co-existence is oblivious to a no less dangerous threat to the present human civilization; the Hindutva Zionism. As the term reads it is part of the Hindutva world-view which stands for an exclusive Hindu India minus Muslims and Christians. The other religions like Sikhism, Buddhism, and Jainism will have no independent status but treated as part of Hinduism. The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS; National Volunteer Organization) is the most prominent flag-bearer of the Hindutva politics whose cadres presently rule India, the largest democracy in the world. RSS was founded by Keshav Baliram Hedgewar (1889-1940) in 1925 who was disillusioned with the Indian freedom struggle led by Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi (1869-1948) against the British rule for believing that Indian nation was a composite entity consisting of Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Christians and followers of other religions living in India. Hedgewar and his associates aggressively claimed that India was an exclusive nation of Hindus. For RSS the real enemies were not the British rulers but Muslims and Christians as they belonged to foreign religions. Thus RSS represented the militant Hindu nationalism, termed as Hindutva opposed to Gandhi’s all-inclusive Indian nationalism. According to the most prominent ideologues of Hindutva, Vinayak Damodar Savarkar (1883-1966) and Madhav Sadashiv Golwalkar (1906-73), the Hindutva is true ‘Hinduness’ which should not be reduced to what is understood as Hinduism. Hindutva is aggressive commitment to the belief that India is the Father-land and Holy Land of Hindus who are Aryans, speak Sanskrit language and believe in Casteism. All others are foreign races who, “must either adopt the Hindu culture and language, must learn to respect and hold in reverence Hindu religion, must entertain no idea but those of the glorification of the Hindu race and culture…must lose their separate existence to merge in the Hindu race, or may stay in the country, wholly subordinated to the Hindu Nation, claiming nothing, deserving no privileges, far less any preferential treatment not even citizen’s rights.”  Golwalkar’s another ‘Holy’ book for the RSS cadres Bunch of Thoughts, has a long chapter titled as ‘Internal Threats’ in which Muslims and Christians have been described as threat number 1 and 2, respectively. Importantly, RSS and its leading cadres presently ruling India are the most vocal supporters of Zionism and the Zionist Israel after the West. The renowned Indian author, Khushwant Singh noted that RSS “supported Zionism and the Jewish state of Israel for no other reason but that it was forever waging wars against its Arab neighbours who were Muslims”.  The current RSS chief, Mohan Bhagwat like his predecessors has been calling upon the RSS cadres to emulate Israel to tread “the path of Israel while serving the cause of nationalism.”  A leading English daily of Israel, the Jerusalem Post too underlined the fact that “whenever a BJP (Bhartiya Janata Party; a political appendage of the RSS) government comes to power, the vibrancy in India-Israel relations reaches new heights.
PC:middleeasteye.net
At the government level Narendra Modi [Prime Minister of India since 2014] who is also a leading ideologue of the RSS was the first Prime Minister of India to visit Israel in mid-2017 [almost 70 years after founding of the Indian Republic] with the then Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visiting India in early 2018. Both continue to enjoy close friendship despite Netanyahu no more being the prime minister of Israel. India is one of the largest importers of Israeli arms but the largest consumer of the surveillance and intelligence-related equipment. The latest disclosures about the Israel made Pegasus spyware make it clear how India made large purchases of it for use against lawyers, journalists, politicians and activists who were suspected to be opposed to the Hindutva politics. On the surveillance front the ganging up of Zionist Israel and India is proved by the fact that India remains the only democracy not to share any information about the purchase of Pegasus spyware which has been described as the ‘world’s most powerful cyber weapon’. Concerned by the abstruseness of Modi government Supreme Court, the highest court of justice of India had to constitute a committee to find out the truth in October 2021. The report was submitted in a sealed cover on August 25, 2022. The Bench comprising Chief Justice of India N V Ramana and Justices Surya Kant and Hima Kohli while accepting the report informed that the Government of India did not cooperate with the committee. It was a sad scenario for Indian democracy that rulers of India even refused to respond to a committee appointed by the highest court of justice whose deliberations were confidential. For reasons known to the Court only it did not pass any judgment.

Pegasus Snooping Might be behind Fall of 2019 Karnataka Government

In the meantime, two renowned investigate journalists; Ronen Bergman and Mark Mazetti relying on official papers of Israel confirmed that India did buy the Pegasus courtesy Netanyahu. According to the report, “In July 2017, Narendra Modi, who won office on a platform of Hindu nationalism, became the first Indian prime minister to visit Israel. For decades, India had maintained a policy of what it called ‘commitment to the Palestinian cause,’ and relations with Israel were frosty. The Modi visit, however, was notably cordial, complete with a carefully staged moment of him and Prime Minister Netanyahu walking together barefoot on a local beach. They had reason for the warm feelings. Their countries had agreed on the sale of a package of sophisticated weapons and intelligence gear worth roughly $2 billion — with Pegasus and a missile system as the centerpieces. Months later, Netanyahu made a rare state visit to India. And in June 2019, India voted in support of Israel at the U.N.’s Economic and Social Council to deny observer status to a Palestinian human rights organization, a first for the nation.”
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu seen strolling on beach in Israel.  PC:timesofisrael.com

India Under Hindutva Rule Follows Israel in dealing with Muslim Kashmiris

With the beginning of the 2nd term of Modi [2019] India witnessed brazen execution of the old anti-Muslim agenda of the RSS. Article 370 which provided special provisions to guarantee its distinct character to Jammu & Kashmir State [the only Muslim majority State in India] was abrogated [August 5, 2019]. A day later, renowned political thinker, Pratap Bhanu Mehta could not help writing: “There are times in the history of a republic when it reduces itself to jackboot. Nothing more and nothing less. We are witnessing that moment in Kashmir. But this moment is also a dry run for the political desecration that may follow in the rest of India. The manner in which the BJP government has changed the status of Jammu and Kashmir by rendering Article 370 ineffective and bifurcating the state is revealing its true character. This is a state for whom the only currency that matters is raw power. This is a state that recognises no constraints of law, liberty and morality. This is a state that will make a mockery of democracy and deliberation. This is a state whose psychological principle is fear. This is a state that will make ordinary citizens cannon fodder for its warped nationalist pretensions. “For, fundamentally, what this change signals is that Indian democracy is failing. It is descending into majoritarianism, the brute power of the vote; it will no longer have the safety valves that allowed inclusion…Not a single one of us can take any constitutional protections for granted. Parliament is a notice board, not a debating forum.” The Indian State under Modi has been religiously following the Zionist Israel in persecuting Muslims and human rights’ defenders of the region. According to Fernand de Varennes, Special Rapporteur on minority issues, and Ahmed Shaheed, Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief, in a statement said: ‘“The loss of autonomy and the imposition of direct rule by the Government in New Delhi suggests the people of Jammu and Kashmir no longer have their own government and have lost power to legislate or amend laws in the region to ensure the protection of their rights as minorities”  The following report carried by UNO new site proved once again that Kashmir looked like Palestine under Zionism: “Since the Indian Government’s 5 August announcement revoking Kashmir’s special status, tighter central Government control has resulted with access to information and peaceful protests quashed. Reports have described a near total communications blackout in Jammu and Kashmir since the evening of 4 August, with internet access, mobile phone networks, and cable and Kashmiri television channels cut off.
kashmir
Photo Courtesy: Livelaw
The experts expressed concern that the measures, imposed after the Indian Parliament revoked the Constitutionally-mandated status of the state of Jammu and Kashmir, would exacerbate tensions in the region. ‘The shutdown of the internet and telecommunication networks, without justification from the Government, are inconsistent with the fundamental norms of necessity and proportionality,’ the experts said in a statement. ‘The blackout is a form of collective punishment of the people of Jammu and Kashmir, without even a pretext of a precipitating offence.’ The Government has also imposed a curfew across Jammu and Kashmir, with massive numbers of troops brought in to enforce movement and peaceful assembly restrictions, particularly in the Kashmir Valley. ‘We remind the Indian authorities that the restrictions imposed by the Indian Government are intrinsically disproportionate, because they preclude considerations of the specific circumstances of each proposed assembly,’ the experts stated. At the same time, information received suggests an increase in the arrest of political figures, journalists, human rights defenders, protesters and others. The experts expressed deep concern over reports that security forces were conducting night raids on private homes leading to the arrests of young people.” Amnesty International released many reports of the impunity with which Indian State was following the Zionists in persecuting Kashmiris. In one of these released in July 2015 titled, ‘“DENIED: Failures in accountability for human rights violations by security force personnel in Jammu and Kashmir’ described in details how Kashmir had turned into killing fields.

Affinities Between Zionism and Hindutva

God’s ‘Chosen People’: According to Zionism the Jewish people were chosen by God as His true worshippers and to fulfill the mission of proclaiming his truth among all the nations of the world. The Hindutva flag-bearers proclaim the same status. According to them Hindu Race, “professes its illustrious Hindu Religion, the only Religion in the world worthy of being so denominated, which in its variety is still an organic whole, capable of feeding the noble aspirations of all men…enriched by the noblest philosophy of life in all its functions, and hallowed by an unbroken, interminable succession of divine spiritual geniuses, a religion of which any sane man may be justly proud. Guided by this Religion…the [Hindu] Race evolved a culture, which despite the degenerating contact with the debased ‘civilizations’ of the Mussalman and the Europeans, for the last ten centuries, is still the noblest in the world.”Speaking a language similar to the Zionists, Golwalkar went on to declare that the world soon will “tremble with fear” before the ‘Chosen People’; upholders of the Hindutva.  It is to be noted that MK Gandhi described as Father of Indian nation without mincing word stated as early as 1938:
  1. “Palestine belongs to the Arabs in the same sense that England belongs to the English or France to the French. It is wrong and inhuman to impose the Jews on the Arabs… Surely it would be a crime against humanity to reduce the proud Arabs so that Palestine can be restored to the Jews partly or wholly as their national home”
  2. Religion as basis of nationality: Both believe that religion is the determining factor for nationality. Both are against inclusive nationalities.
  3. Religious scriptures as authentic history: For Zionists and Hindutva protagonists, religious scriptures narrate actual history and any other narrative is unacceptable. Myths are truths.
  4. Genocidal: Zionist organizations and Zionist Israel have been widely condemned for the genocide of Palestinians and other opponents. Israel is the only state which has been condemned both by the General Assembly and the Security Council of the United Nations through more than 200 resolutions since its founding in 1948.
In India we have witnessed a major genocide of minorities almost every decade in which Hindutva cadres have been found involved. In these genocides victims have not been only minorities but lower Castes of Hindus also. It is important to know that RSS which claims to be a cultural organization is fond of worshipping arms. It celebrates its foundation day as ”shastr pooja” (worship of the arms) in which RSS leaders/cadres participate in large numbers. Recently following into the foot-steps of Zionist Israel RSS-BJP rulers have made bulldozers as a symbol of punishing Muslims. 5. Demonization of opponents: An important commonality between the two is the demonization and persecution of anti-Zionists as Anti-Semitic and anti-Hindutva as anti-Hindu. The renowned researcher of Zionism, Yoav Litvin wrote: “In fact, anti-Zionists were targeted from before the foundation of the state of Israel. Today, Jewish pro-Palestinian activists who support the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement are detained, punished and even deported.” In India MK Gandhi (Father of the Nation), anti-Hindutva intellectuals/journalists namely Govind Pansare, MM Kalburgi, Narender Dabholkar and Gouri Lankesh were assassinated by the Hindutva zealots for being anti-Hindu. Arrest of anti-Hindutva intellectuals like Anand Teltumbde, Fr. Stany (who died during incarceration), Gautam Navlakha, Varavara Rao, lawyer Sudha Bharadwaj, activists Arun Ferreira, Vernon Gonsalves, Hany Babu, Umar Khalid and hundreds others under terror laws. Blatantly Racist: Zionists ruling Israel may harp on the divine unity of the Jews of the world but in reality Israel is ruled by and for superior Ashkenazi [European] Jews.  In Israel hatred for dark-skinned African Jews and Sephardi [Spanish speaking Jews] and Mizrahi Jews [Jews from Central and West Asian countries, many of them Arabic-speaking] is too glaring to be missed. In India RSS demands abrogation of the democratic-secular-egalitarian Constitution and promulgation of Manu Code [Manusmriti] as law of the land. Manusmriti is declared to be most worship-able after Vedas. It decrees sub-human status to women and Sudras [lowest Caste in the Brahmanical Caste system].

RSS linkages with International Neo-fascist Organisations

RSS building a deadly alliance against Muslims & Christians in South Asia: Editorial in the New York Times The world has not bothered to take any notice of a terrorist network developing fast in India and its neighbourhood between RSS and the two terrorist ultra nationalist Buddhist groups of Myanmar and Sri Lanka against minorities; specially Muslims in the region. According to an editorial in The International New York Times [‘Deadly alliances against Muslims’, October 16, 2014] it was announced by Galagodaththe Gnanasara, the leader of the radical Sri Lankan Buddhist group Bodu Bala Sena [Buddhist Power Force] at an international convention in Colombo in September 2014.  The editorial disclosed that at the convention: “The guest of honor was Ashin Wirathu, a Buddhist radical whose picture Time magazine put on its July 1 [2013] covers as ‘The Face of Buddhist Terror’…Mr. Gnanasara claimed he was in discussions ‘at a high level’ with the right-wing Indian Hindu group Rashtriya Swayam Sevak to form what he called a ‘Hindu-Buddhist peace zone’ in South Asia.” The NYT editorial also carried Facebook and Twitter congratulatory messages of Ram Madhav (who kept on shuffling as spokes-person of RSS and general secretary of BJP) to Bodu Bala Sena. These must be read to know the depth of linkages between Buddhist terrorist organizations and RSS.

Neo-Nazi mass murderer of Norway, Anders Behring Breivik’s linkages with the RSS

On 22 JULY 2011 Breivik massacred 77 youth belonging to the Norway’s ruling Labour Party at a youth training camp on the island of Utøya. It was no sudden carnage by some mad person. Breivik had planned it for years. Just before the attack he had released on line ‘A European Declaration of Independence’ which declared war against the devils; cultural Marxism, Multi-culturalism, feminism, emotionalism, humanism, and egalitarianism.
Anders Breivik, is a Norwegian far-right domestic terrorist known for committing the 2011 Norway attacks on 22 July 2011.
In this case, too, the world took almost no notice of the critical fact that Breivik’s manifesto laid down a plan of co-operation between Neo-Nazi movements of Europe and “Hindu Nationalist” organizations of India. Out of 1515 pages of Breivik’s manifesto 102 pages dealt with the glorification of Hindutva movement of India. It emphasized that it was essential that these two “learn from each other and cooperate as much as possible” as “Our goals are more or less identical.” This manifesto specially mentioned the name of the fountain head of the Hindutva politics, RSS and its appendages like BJP, ABVP (Akhil Bhartiya Vidyarthi Parishad; student appendage of the RSS) and VHP (Vishwa Hindu Parishad; RSS appendage to bring the world under Hindutva hegemony) as partners. Importantly, the manifesto pledged military support “to the nationalists in the Indian civil war and in the deportation of all Muslims from India” as part of a larger campaign to “overthrow of all western European multi-culturalist governments”. How critical is the danger of RSS becoming a rallying point of all the neo-Fascists of the world can be gauged by the fact that the former according to its own admission was active in 39 countries with the nomenclature, Hindu Seva Sangh. The RSS has not uploaded data after 2015 in this regard. There must be many more countries where it could be functioning covertly. The civilized world can risk overlooking this most lethal danger on its own peril.

For in-depth study of RSS, please, look at the following link:

https://www.academia.edu/44213326/RASHTRIYA_SWAYAMSEVAK_SANGH_AS_A_TERROR_OUTFIT_EVIDENCE_FROM_ITS_ARCHIVES_E_book_updated_on_October_14_2020 Link for some of S. Islam’s writings in English, Hindi, Urdu, Marathi, Malayalam, Kannada, Bengali, Punjabi, Gujarati and video interviews/debates: http://du-in.academia.edu/ShamsulIslam Facebook: https://facebook.com/shamsul.islam.332 Twitter: @shamsforjustice http://shamsforpeace.blogspot.com/  

The Rise of Far-Right Swedish Parliament

2
On 11 September 2022, the Swedish General Elections were held. While no party has won a majority, it appears that the new government will be formed by a four-party collation of right-wing parties, provided that the second largest winner, the Sweden Democrats, can join forces with the third largest winner, the right-wing “Moderate” party. This year has been a rocky political year in Sweden, as Sweden had just agreed to join the NATO alliance during the Ukrainian war. This election saw a polarization of the election. The largest left party, the Social Democrats, won the most votes, gaining primarily in large cities, notably in Stockholm county. The largest right-wing party, the Swedish Democrats, won many more votes, passing the Moderate Party to become the second largest party in Sweden. The rise of the Sweden Democrats is troubling for many reasons. The party has early links with the neo-Nazi, though its leadership denied it. They also have campaigned on a platform of anti-immigration and anti-environmentalism.

Social Democrats, the largest party in Parliament

To date, the Swedish Social Democratic Party has been the most popular political party in Sweden. Since 1932, the party has always gotten more than 100 of the 349 seats and remains the largest political party in Sweden, both in terms of seats and votes. The Social Democratic Party has its roots in the Second International where many Marxist parties, then known as Social Democrats, from across the world established political parties in different countries in Europe. The party enjoys support from all over the country but has been very strong with the organized labour force. However, since the mid-2000s, support from their core support base has been beginning to fade. Though the party is very active in its Trade Unions, the strength of trade unions has faded.
Jimmie Åkesson, the leader of Sweden Democrats

Key to crisis for the Swedish left

In the mid-1990s, Sweden was hit by the global economic crisis. To combat the crisis, the Social Democrats, who were in power at the time, began reducing government spending on welfare programs, leading to a weakening of the working class’s strength. Sweden was not nearly as drastic as many other countries, but the effects have taken a slow but decisive hit to their support base. Since 2006, the left parties have been losing votes from two major blocks: pensioners and trade unions. Pensioners, who have left the working class, have been susceptible to alt-right media which has pushed a right-wing agenda. The alt-right media in Sweden is xenophobic and creates a sense of crisis and urgency. It blames the left and immigration for crime in Sweden.

Origins of the Swedish Democrats

After World War II, Nazism manifested itself in the form of the Swedish Opposition. The Opposition distanced itself from Nazism after the war but played a key role in protecting Nazi collaborators after the war. To protect itself, the Opposition was renamed the New Swedish Movement and continued its work. The Neo-Nazi networks survived through the 1980s. Most of their support came from racist Swedes who wanted to defend the white race. They spread across Sweden, though they had their strongest presence in the region of Scania, a district with strong regional pride. The Neo-Nazi movement infiltrated a variety of right and centre-right political movements. These movements were politically active, campaigning on anti-feminism and xenophobia. Many of them came together in 1979 to form the Swedish Progress Party.
Map of Scania region, South of Sweden

Swedish Democrats and the Rise of the Right:

The party was founded in 1988 as a merger of the Progress Party with even more extreme right-wing parties in Sweden. For a long time, the party remained a fringe movement with very little popular support. In the early 2000s, this changed as the party began distancing itself from its Nazi and Fascist past, and adopted more mainstream positions. The top leadership began ousting the more extreme members of the party. As a result, the Swedish Democrats began winning seats for the first time in 2010.

Syrian Refugee Crisis:

During the Syrian Civil War in 2015, many alternative news outlets took the fear-mongering. After years of blatant Islamophobia, the prospect of taking in refugees from a Muslim majority country led to greater support for right-wing policies on immigration. Support for the Swedish Democrats rose from under 10% to nearly 25% throughout the crisis. The Swedish democrats went from being a fringe right-wing party to a mainstream party.

Polarizing Elections:

Both the Social Democrats and the Sweden Democrats gain in the 2022 election, securing marginally more votes and substantially more seats. Alternative parties from across the political spectrum have lost seats and votes owing to the critical decision in front of the voters. Either support the winning party or forfeit the vote. The Swedish Democrats have risen in the polls owing to the narrative of Swedish nationalism and Islamophobia and continue to rise in collaboration with their robust network of alt-right news sources. They insist that Sweden has been historically open to immigrants and refugees from the time of World War II, but recent changes are a bridge too far. To protect Swedish culture, it is important to drive out these new immigrants and refugees who will corrupt the culture and put Swedes at risk. Many of the elections were won by slim margins, but as the Indian experience shows, those slim margins can mark the beginning of a right-wing turn in politics. Traditional left parties have not protected the social democratic nature of Swedish society and now, the Swedish people have begun showing support for the right, even though the support for the right is still fragmented.

The first 9/11: How the Parliamentary Path to Socialism in Chile was Crushed

Hijab Ban: Muslim Girls Deprived of Right to Education, says PUCL Report

0

For last eight months, Karnataka and the rest of the country is witnessing the spectacle of Hijab ban in schools in Karnataka. Not just the schools, colleges but police, administration, high court, state government but even Supreme Court either added fire or were mute spectators for the harassment and apathy that the Muslim girls had to go through.

High Courts’s orders and Karnataka govt. notification gave a free hand to vigilante elements to vilify and harass and prevent muslim girls from accessing education.

PUCL (People’s Union for Civil Liberties) Karnataka has come with a report on the impact of the HC verdict on the affected students– educational, social, and psychological and the violation of constitutional rights.

According to the report, the decision of the state government of Karnataka to impose a ban on Muslim women students wearing the hijab while attending classes has deprived, at one stroke, the right to education, the right to expression and other associated rights, and has even imperiled their security.

The report is based on the visits by members of the team as they travelled to different districts of Karnataka, understanding the testimonies of women who have been denied their right to Education and other rights associated with the right to education.

The report provides critiques of the judgment of the case of Resham v State of Karnataka heard in the High Court of Karnataka. The critique looks at critical rights and freedoms related to the case and highlights the incorrect focus on the Hijab as Essential Religious Practices. The sections point out the folly in the judgment in prioritizing the sanctity of maintaining a “uniform” as an essential feature of a school at the cost of ensuring education with reasonable accommodation for people of minority communities and freedom from discrimination, which arise from constitutional principles in educational spaces. The report points to the various ways in which the parties affected by the judgment were excluded. students The PUCL team also studied the role of media, the role of the bureaucracy and how the whole situation led to the violation of rights.
The analysis of the media shows how local media coverage of the event fanned the flames of hatred against women seen wearing headscarves, and in certain cases harassed women on their campus. One major feature is the lack of democratic structure in the case of College Development Committee (CDC). CDCs often acted as authoritarian bodies without any concrete systems of accountability or representation of local stakeholders.

How Police Administration played out?

Often local police would add to the stifling of the community. The report documents how police presence on college campuses would instill a culture of fear among students found wearing hijabs and would often prevent any expression of dissent by the local community. Police deployment was focused more on ensuring enforcement of the order than ensuring the security of the students. The section points to two broad trends, one starting before the passing of the Interim Order where a vilification campaign against the students developed without hindrance, and a second phase beginning with the passing of the Interim Order where the government machinery took part in the campaigns for the exclusion of Muslim women.

Concerns Among Muslim Girls 

Many women documented their struggles and worries regarding their educational future, covering issues of access to educational certificates, harassment and safety within the college campuses.Concerns regarding the wider society isolating Muslim women from public spaces enforced by threats of assault reversing the earlier trends of empowerment of Muslim Women was also highlighted in the testimonies. The psychological concerns focused on the feelings of fear and panic engineered by the ban. The report also focuses on the Rights associated with education and looks at how associated rights, i.e.: Rights that are essential to fulfill the right to education and to partake in educational spaces as full human beings, have been attacked. These include the Right to Education without discrimination, Right to Dignity, Right to Privacy, Right to Expression, Right to Non-Discrimination, and Freedom from arbitrary state action. The report also highlights on how the ban has threatened the very constitutional ideals. In this situation of a complete failure of the state government to fulfill its obligation to protect constitutional morality, it falls on citizens to then do so. Nobody has done so with more grace, dignity and courage than young Muslim women who have asserted their right to education. All the testimonies by students across the state echoed the same sentiment that the solution to these problems is the enforcement of the promises of the Indian Constitution to protect their rights to a dignified life within an educational space. students The report ends with a list of recommendations by the team that would take the state in the direction of addressing the loss of rights.
Recommendations
  1. First and foremost being the immediate cancellation of the Government Notification dated 05.02.2022.
  2. It also recommends that the court must issue a directive to the government to conduct a comprehensive inquiry into lost years and expenses incurred as a result of this order and ensure that compensation to the women and their families is paid.
  3. The government must allow the students to enter the classrooms immediately, and in consultation with students, arrange special classes for them. The State Human Rights Commission and Minority Commission should register suo-moto complaints against the principals and CDCs of colleges for violating the fundamental rights of the concerned students and initiate actions at the earliest.
  4. The Karnataka government must take adequate measures to strengthen a secular and non-discriminatory learning environment within colleges, allowing the students to express their faith and identity fully and ensuring that such shocking violations do not recur.
The court must issue a directive to hold CDCs accountable, by both:
  1. Making the CDCs truly representative, to be accountable to all of the different stakeholders, including members of all communities, students, non-teaching staff, teaching staff, members of civil society, and women.
  2. Conducting an inquiry into cases where the CDC had overstepped its mandate and not provided appropriate forms of redress, in writing, to students and parents who have raised concerns and initiate actions against them.
The full report can be downloaded here.

Gyanvapi Mosque: Varanasi Court Accepts to hear Hindu Parties seeking worship rights

0
A Varanasi Court on Monday held that a suit filed by Hindu parties seeking worship rights inside the Gyanvapi Mosque is maintainable. The Anjuman Intezamia Masjid Committee has said the Gyanvapi mosque is a Waqf property and had questioned the maintainability of the plea. District Judge Dr AK Vishvesha dismissed the plea filed by the Muslim party, Committee of Management of Anjuman Intezamia Masjid, contesting the maintainability of the suit through an application filed under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The case arose after Hindu devotees approached the civil court claiming the right to worship inside the premises of the Gyanvapi Mosque, on the ground that it was a Hindu temple and still houses Hindu deities. The Varanasi District Court on Monday rejected the petition of the Muslim side. The court said that the suit by Hindu parties is maintainable in the court. The court has posted the matter for hearing on September 22 and it will now hear the arguments based on merits. A single bench of district Judge AK Vishvesh delivered the verdict in the Gyanvapi Shrinagar Gauri dispute case today. “The court rejected the Muslim side’s petition and said the suit is maintainable. The next hearing of the case is on Sep 22,” advocate Vishnu Shankar Jain, representing the Hindu side, said.

‘Kashi-Mathura Baaqi Hain’: Why the Ayodhya Verdict Won’t Offer Any Respite From Saffron Hatred

The civil court ordered a survey of the Mosque by an advocate commissioner. The advocate commissioner then conducted the videographed survey and submitted a report to the civil court. The Muslim parties meanwhile filed an application challenging the maintainability of the suit on ground that the Places of Worship Act of 1991, which was introduced at the height of the Ram Janmabhoomi movement, seeks to protect the status of all religious structures as it stood on August 15, 1947. Section 4 of the Act states that the religious character of a place of worship existing on August 15, 1947 shall continue to be the same as it existed on that day. It bars courts from entertaining cases regarding such places of worship. The provision further states that such cases already pending in courts would stand abated. The suit before the civil court was, however, transferred to the District Judge by the Supreme Court on May 20 in view of the sensitivity of the issue involved. Source: Bar&bench

The first 9/11: How the Parliamentary Path to Socialism in Chile was Crushed

1

“We (Chile) are moving towards socialism, not from an academic love for a doctrinaire system, but encouraged by the strength of our people, who know that it is an inescapable demand if we are to overcome backwardness and who feel that a socialist regime is the only way available to modern nations who want to build rationally in freedom, independence, and dignity.

We are moving towards socialism because the people, through their vote, have freely rejected capitalism as a system which has resulted in a crudely unequal society, a society deformed by social injustice and degraded by the deterioration of the very foundations of human solidarity.” – Salvador Allende

On 11 September 1970, General Augusto Pinochet led a military coup leading to nearly a decade of military rule in Chile. This date marks the beginning of the global neo-liberal era, where governments across the world began to move to establish strong authoritarian governments adopting market-led policies against the interests of the people.

Salavador Allende

On that day, Salvador Guillermo Allende Gossens, then President of Chile, died. His death was caused by suicide, a gunshot to the head. This was followed by a month of largescale murder and imprisonments of supporters of Allende and other leftists. The new military government held power for nearly a decade, destroying movements that evolved over decades before. On leaving power, Pinochet established a constitution that would enforce the neo-liberal governing structure he built for decades to come.

Allende’s government was the first in the world to chart a path to socialism using parliamentary means. In the few years it held power, despite horrible economic challenges, it remained popular. The military coup that followed became a symbol to all countries of how they would be punished if they decided to consider socialism in the future.

Rise of Anti-Capitalism in Chile

In 1929, a global financial crisis, known as the Great Depression, sent shockwaves through Latin American. The depression led to a near-collapse of the mining sector in Chile, which affected all parts of the economy. At the same time, a growing consciousness in the workers let to anti-capitalist movements taking off, including Marxist, Leninists, anarchists, Mapuche (indigenous), and feminist movements. While the economy suffered, this was also a time where Chile began to stabilize its civilian government, which up until then had been teetering on military rule.

In 1933, Salvador Guillermo Allende Gossens, a physician who had been influenced by leftist thought, co-founded the Socialist Party of Chile. The movements of the time led to the nationalisation of major industries and the establishment of critical labour reforms.

Starting from the 1950s, Chile saw a right-wing swing in its politics. The extreme right-wing fell out of the political landscape after World War II, but conservative Christian factions began to gain strength. The American government played a role in this swing, financially supporting the right-wing parties and promoting propaganda campaigns in Chile. American involvement intensified after the Cuban revolution in 1959.

In this period, Allende grew as a Presidential Candidate for the Left-Wing Coalition. Though he barely received 5% of the popular vote in his first bid, subsequent bids made impressive gains, getting nearly 30% of the popular vote in subsequent elections. He finally won in 1970 with support from the Christian Democratic Party giving his coalition enough to win.

Allende kept close ties with the Communist Party of Chile. The CPC’s presidential candidate, famed poet Pablo Neruda, supported Allende’s bid and served as a diplomat under Allende’s government.

“The nationalisation of our copper is not an act of vengeance or hatred directed towards any group, government or nation. We are, on the contrary, positively exercising an inalienable right on behalf of a sovereign people – that of the full enjoyment of our national resources exploited by our national labour and effort.”– Allende

Allende’s rise was seen as a threat to America’s hegemony in Latin America. Though technically not part of the Communist Party of Chile, Allende’s was the first socialist government that could take power in the American continents through parliamentary means. Even more threatening, Allende advocated policies that went against American business interests.

A threat to American Business Interests

When he first took office, Allende gave a famous speech, now called, “The Chilean Path to Socialism” speech. In his speech, Allende described how Chile could use parliamentary methods to move towards a Marxist humanism, and build on pro-people policies. One of the proposals in the speech was the nationalisation of the copper mines, which were used by American businesses until then.

The result was an economic backlash from America. The United States also engaged in a series of economic tactics to increase inflation in Chile, reducing the average wages despite raising the minimum wage when Allende was in power. This was in line with American policies regarding Latin America.

From 1966 to 1973, Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Peru, and Uruguay had military coups. This was accomplished by American propaganda. Latin American military leaders would attend the US Army School of the Americas, where they were tutored in anti-communist/pro-American propaganda and “national security” techniques. Graduates of the school maintained good relations with the US, even after the military took over.

Regarding Chile, American President, Richard Nixon, was reported saying that he wanted to “make the economy scream.” America stopped trade with Chile. This hurt the transport and machinery sectors in Chile. As a result, Chile’s transport and mining sector suffered deeply. Vehicles and machines could not be repaired because of a lack of spare parts or tires.

The stagnation of the economy led to a dramatic fall in real wages. By the time of Allende’s death, real wages fell to nearly a third of what it was when he took power.

From 1972, social unrest began to rise, mostly from the Chilean middle-class. Despite the social unrest and a struggling economy, in the 1973 Senate elections, Allende’s allies got more votes and more seats.

US-Backed Military Coup

After the 1973 election, the Chilean military, along with various right-wing paramilitary groups began to organize the overthrow of the Allende government. Every violent act by the paramilitary groups led to calls by the opposition parties for greater powers for the military. In August 1973, the opposition party demanded that the Chilean military protect the law and order of the land.

General Augusto Pinochet during his military rule

The military chose the date to match the takeover by the military on 12 September 1924. To them, the movements which began in the 1930s were symbolic of a loss of authority and prestige.

The aftermath of the takeover was brutal. Most notably, to break any resistance, the military converted the Estadio Nacional (National Stadium) in Santiago, Chile’s capital, to a prison camp where thousands were detained, tortured, and executed for supporting Allende.

While Chile has since transitioned back to a democracy, Pinochet established a very regressive constitution, which plagues movements in Chile to this day.

From 2006 onwards, when students began taking to the street, Chile finally saw the rebirth of resistance against the neo-liberal policies of Pinochet.

2019 saw the largest protests seen in the country since the coming of Pinochet. These protests shook the world, but owing to the COVID-19 pandemic, the state instituted lockdowns in several key areas. Resentment continues, but owing to the lockdown, the state has established control over key areas of protest.

11 September stays in the memory of the Chilean people as the day their parliamentary path to socialism was brutally taken from them.

The legacy of Mikhail Gorbachev

0
On 30 August 2022, Mikhail Gorbachev, the last leader of the USSR died at age 91 after a prolonged illness. Much has been said about Gorbachev’s role in the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Sometimes he is shown as the last leader of a failing empire, though this seems inaccurate. While the Soviet block had had periods of economic stagnation in the 1970s, they were nowhere near the point of collapse when Gorbachev came to power. The Soviet Union still was the second largest economy in the world. Many factors of the collapse occurred as a direct result of Gorbachev’s reforms and concessions.

The Legacy of Gorbachev

Sometimes Gorbachev has been portrayed as a traitor to the Soviet cause, or, by critics of the Soviet Union, he is portrayed as a visionary who saw the faults of the Soviet Union and pushed the country to a transition to democracy. This also seems inaccurate. As the leader of one of the most powerful countries in the world, he gained nothing from the dissolution of the Soviet Union. He maintained opposition to the major leaders of Russia afterwards. While his political positions were less committed to Marxist-Leninism than his predecessors, he was not substantially right of his contemporaries in the Polit Bureau. His positions did reflect a shift in the Soviet leadership at the time, which was much larger than Gorbachev. The crisis that Gorbachev was wrestling with was a crisis of leadership. By his time, the Soviet Union was no longer the face of revolution and was facing discontent within the country. There was frustration with the elite members of the Soviet Union, who had lost touch with the people. Within this crisis, a new political elite worked with the developing economic elite to overthrow the Soviet Union and create the situation we see today.

What propped up a man like Gorbachev?

While the Russian Revolution was able to overthrow the Tsar and the rich elite of Russia, the country was still run by an administrative structure left behind by the Tsar. The Communist Party ran the country through the same basic bureaucracy of the previous regime. Many measures were taken by Lenin and then Stalin to prevent counter-revolutionary elements in the bureaucracy from taking over. This included centralization of authority, close scrutiny and surveillance and indoctrination. Over time, they replaced the old bureaucrats with their own people and implemented reforms to allow for better local accountability, but government positions were still highly sought after, and the basic structure of the bureaucracy still remained intact. With the death of Stalin, there was competition for the top spot of leadership. This propped Nikita Kruschev up as the next major leader of the Soviet Union. Kruschev was high ranking member of the Polit Bureau and had the support of many high-ranking leaders and officials in the government. His rise marked a shift in the system of leadership in the Soviet Union coming from the bureaucracy. While all of the leaders of the Soviet Union were firm believers in Marxist-Leninism, their interpretations varied, and from Kruschev onward, the Soviet Union developed a culture of bureaucracy that stood further and further apart from the working people. Leaders would start taking power at older ages, and after establishing themselves within the apparatus of the state. Leadership also became more Russian and lacked representation of non-Russians from the other Soviet Republics. Ideologically, the Soviet Union entered into a crisis. Kruschev’s so-called de-Stalinization measures put the Soviet Union at odds with Maoist China. Mao had become a new icon for radical left movements across the world following the takeover of China. As a result, the international support base of the Soviet Union became split. While some supporters of the Soviet Union insisted that the USSR represented what real or developed socialism would look like, dismissing supporters of Mao as immature, this split created a crack in the image of the Soviet Union as being the face of Communism. By Gorbachev’s time, the Soviet administrative apparatus was completely run by bureaucrats, and ripe for the so-called revolution from above. Leaders could now implement sweeping changes with little feedback from the people. They would be motivated more by the administration.

Sinking the ship

Gorbachev became the leader of the new Soviet Union after two of his predecessors died in quick succession. Concerned about the next leader dying of old age, Gorbachev was the only leader to have been born after the Russian revolution. He was charismatic and implemented his policies of perestroika and glasnost (reform and openness). While he believed in the communist cause, his position drifted to a more liberal stance. He believed in deregulating markets and keeping the state more as a provider of public welfare. Under Gorbachev, the Soviet Union ceded a lot of its international influence. Outside of the Soviet Union, Gorbachev withdrew its military presence, leading to the dissolution of the Warsaw Pact. Within the Soviet Union, Gorbachev made it easier for non-communists to run for office and for dissent against the USSR. The Soviet Union did not show any support for countries that tried to implement Soviet-like governments, like Libya or Syria during Gorbachev’s term. Rather, the USSR tried to work with former enemies, like the USA and the UK. Both American President Ronald Reagan and UK Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher found Gorbachev very easy to work with. Gorbachev may have been hoping for peace, as he consistently tried to mend fences with rivals of the Soviet Union, particularly China. However, his concession allowed for the unfettered growth of NATO and the unchallenged hegemony of the USA for decades. At this time, an alliance between disaffected bureaucrats and the capitalist class from the USSR came together to take advantage of the situation. All reforms made by Gorbachev worked against him and the USSR, eventually leading to an attempted coup against Gorbachev. In the chaos, the various republics of the USSR began leaving, eventually leading to the formal dissolution of the Soviet Union and the resignation of Gorbachev from power. The Russian Federation was declared a new state and would elect Boris Yelstin, a former Soviet bureaucrat who was a major voice campaigning against Gorbachev and demanding that Gorbachev’s reforms were too slow and too little. To learn from Gorbachev’s legacy, we should learn about the circumstances that threw up a man like him and vested in him the power to decide the fates of millions, as well as the mistakes he made while in power. The enemies of the Soviet Union almost lionize Gorbachev, giving him a Nobel Peace Prize and accolades as the one who ended the Cold War. Those nostalgic of the Soviet Unions fault him on many grounds, but these are not the real lessons of history. Gorbachev will forever be remembered as the one who heralded the end of the largest socialist experiment in history and the real lesson is the one that teaches us how it ended.

Saving Bengaluru from its absurdities

0
As we commemorate Teachers Day in memory of the erudite Dr. S. Radhakrishnan, it’s worth asking: how does one pass on knowledge to someone who claims to know already, or quite simply is immune to learning.  This is the feeling one gets every time you hear of Bengaluru flooding, or worse, one suffers its terrible consequences. For a sprawling metropolis sitting 1000 metres above sea level, drained really well by three richly featured valley systems, within which hundreds of generations have nurtured every stream and gully, and protected kaluves (canals) to carefully and intelligently guide rain, spring and surface water flows into  irrigation tanks (which we now call lakes) which they built. These structures were designed to hold water for a few months longer, temporarily, turn dry during summer and be ready to receive fresh water next monsoon.  In this manner, a semi arid zone was turned into an highly livable region that also supported excellent diversities of crops, horticulture and pastoralism.  Take a toposheet of the region and you will notice that the landscape is littered with water bodies big, medium and small, and rarely, if ever, will you be able to find a spot for constructing a new lake or pond.  It is this landscape rich with traditions of water harvesting that transformed into a sprawling metropolis which floods every time it rains.  This is the outcome of stupidity, hubris and corruption that has become systemic to administration and planning in the region.  And we shouldn’t accept any explanation that claims this is because of unprecedented rains. Here’s why.

As massive finance flowed in from across India and the world, ambitions soared of turning Bengaluru into an aerospace hub, and also as a second home for millions of NRIs in fancily named gated communities.

If engineers and bureaucrats of Bengaluru Development Authority (BDA) and Bruhat Bengaluru Mahangara Palike (BBMP), and Corporators and MLAs over the decades, had it in them to respect traditional knowledge and wisdom, to follow ecologically wise planning from the ground up, willingness to learn from civil society and academia who working with local communities gained deep understanding of the landscape, or had the humility of complying with judicial directives repeatedly stressing the critical importance of protecting wetlands and water ways from encroachment and polluting, perhaps then this calamity that we are now witnessing and suffering, would not have occurred.  But we have a metropolis now where blessings from the sky instantly turn into curses resulting in multiple miseries: loss of time, loss of health, loss of homes, loss of property, loss of infrastructure, loss of opportunity, even loss of life.  And as always, the poor are worst affected.  But the damage now extends to neighbourhoods of middle classes and the rich as well.
Hebbal Lake
In simple terms if this situation has to be explained, it is this: careless disregard for the role wetlands play in supporting and sustaining human settlements. This phenomenon has been markedly true for Bengaluru from the early 1970s when the draining of lakes became epidemic as a method of containing the spread of malaria and also to create a variety of public infrastructure, and industrial and residential layouts.  For decades, sewage and industrial effluents were let into kaluves polluting them, and these polluted waters ended up in lakes.  In the process not only was the ecology of these surface water bodies contaminated and destroyed, soon the pollution reached ground water aquifers adversely affecting public health. The intensity of this cycle of contamination and destruction of wetlands and water worsened when the IT sector expanded in Bengaluru.  Massive infusions of capital into the sector phenomenally transformed land into highly valued real estate.  With return on investment being the major guiding factor, and without a second thought to sustainability and functionality of the metropolis, massive tracts of land was urbanized frantically. Under directions from successive Chief Ministers who commandeered the parastatal BDA, and without any public oversight as a result, massive corporate complexes and neighbourhoods were approved just about everywhere.  In the process, thickly wooded horticulture farms and wetlands (which mostly were paddy fields) were transformed into densely built real estate.  An approach uncaring of raja kaluves, even lakes, became the feature of the day as natural drainage features of the region were bulldozed away.  Planned development fell by the wayside and kaluves, which act as sponges to absorb flood waters, were constricted and turned into narrow concretised channels carrying sewage, filth, debris and solid waste and depositing them on lake beds.  As a consequence of such urbanization, when it rains, it floods. There is no place for water either in the kaluves or in the lakes which are brimming with sewage. The State Government appointed Lakshman Rao Committee report (1988) forestaged protection of wetlands as crucial to the success of Bengaluru’s urbanisation project.  Its recommendations the Government accepted in toto. but it did act on them.  Meanwhile, BDA in its Master Plans ignored the critical role of wetlands in providing water security and buffering the city from flooding.  As a parastatal unaccountable to the people, only to the CM, the agency turned Bengaluru’s peri-urban region – filled as it was with lakes, kaluves and wetlands – into commercially lucrative real estate.  Brokers and builders managed conversions of projects big and small with such ease, that those who followed the lawful path were left bewildered and frustrated.  Deputy Commissioners as revenue officers played a supportive role, especially in rural areas. Corruption ruled.  Against all urban planning norms, disregarding environmental limits and ecological principles, without in any manner considering social losses of farming and pastoral communities, of the urban poor, BDA officials and Tahsildhars (Revenue Officers) turned the power they wielded of converting land use into a  powerful instrument: those who were willing to pay could convert farmland and wetlands into ‘developed’ urban areas.  This was a difficult choice for stuggling farmers to reject as the value of land appreciated geometrically.  And its impact is evident in a historical review of the peri-urban region of Bengaluru, say by Google Earth, and the rapidity with which the city is literally choked by its own reckless and unplanned expansion is clearly evident. This cannot all be the bureaucracy’s making; they merely executed diktats coming from real estate brokers (several of who were erstwhile feudal landowners) for a hefty commission.  These brokers and land developers over time amassed sufficient wealth to finance their political ambitions: check the background of most corporators, MLAs, even MPs.  The heft of political power they now wielded was employed in modulating and modifying land use planning and governance laws in ways that would support their highly successful business interests – corrupt as it was. Over time, such ill-gotten real estate gains transformed the nature of politics.  This was tapped by mega facility managers who supplied ‘world class’ inventories to the IT/BT sector.  As massive finance flowed in from across India and the world, ambitions soared of turning Bengaluru into an aerospace hub, and also as a second home for millions of NRIs in fancily named gated communities.  The supply of land for such projects always came without a care about environmental and social impacts, and functionality. This juggernaut of ‘development’ promoted by this nexus of bureaucracy-political-builder-investor class mocked warnings, of which there were plenty.  Traditional wisdom was discarded and massive real estate projects that effectively concretised all wetlands in the Bommanahalli-Koramangala-Bellandur-Varthur-Whitefield-Sarjapur region, for instance, were allowed without a thought to their environmental sustainability.  After all, v
floods
white topping of roads also contribute to flooding
Such was the frenzy with which the demands of the IT/BT sector was being met, that planning norms were bent out of shape and land use regulations willfully modified to suit fancies of developers and their financiers such as global investment and real estate firms Black Rock, We Work, etc., on the one hand, and mega Indian developers such as Prestige, Sobha, Purvankara, Salarpuria, Brigade, Mantri, etc. on the other.  Very soon, the peri-urban region of the city which was replete with horticulture farms, lakes and paddies, was transformed into this heavily built metropolis.  There was simply no effort invested in developing appropriate supportive infrastructure for transport, housing, health care, education, and most certainly not for water and environmental management.   The traffic snarls in the region is one indication of this terrible lapse. What matters now is how we get out of this conundrum.  For thousands of families who are losing all they have – and this is the poor and working classes, and for those employed in and gaining form the IT/BT sector whose loss is in time, health, opportunity and resources, Chief Minister Bommai’s promise that he will resolve this situation by removing encroachments of the kaluves and lakes and then concretising kaluves, may seem as an helpful way forward.  After all, Rs. 1500 crores has been allocated to this project.  But I argue this project will make matters worse. Here’s why. Given the loss of paddies and other wetlands, kaluves are the only buffers left with potential to serve as a sponge, especially during heavy downpours. This is most critical given the nature of rain as we are now witneesing, which is likely a consequence of climate change when extreme weather events, such as the rains we are receiving since May  this year, become frequent.  In this situation, concretising kaluves will drastically reduce their water holding capacity, and will force water to rush on these concretised surfaces into lakes. But lakes, which went through cycles of drying up and receiving fresh waters, are always full now, and with sewage.  This causes lakes to overflow, flooding low lying areas which not too long ago were downstream paddies known as atchkats.  As the lakes are not well maintained, they can easily breach.   Thus the concretising and building of walls along kaluves will only intensify flooding, as is now the case with the Outer Ring Road region.  People suffering here been forced to take a boat or tractor out of these flooded zones, and have begun to call it Outer River Road. Matters could turn worse as sumps storing drinking water are contaminated with flood waters and this could result in a choleric epidemic.  The Mandya water pumping station from where Bengaluru draws water from Cauvery is also flooded and it is highly like that normal water supplies will take days to be restored.  As a major public health intervention, emergency supplies of clean water would be essential in all flood affected areas for several days. Getting out of this mess demands a politics of accountability where carefully constructed interventions evolved ground up find a place.  And several highly viable solutions have already been written out and has received judicial approval: the 2012 Justice N K Patil Committee report that is the outcome of a PIL filed by ESG in 2008 is the most comprehensive.  But even a decade after this report was accepted by nine government agencies, which were party to its crafting, and a judicial directive to follow the recommendations from the Principal Bench of the Court, they are ignored by State and civic agencies. This is evident in how kaluves are constricted and concretised preventing them to act as sponges during floods and as free water cleansing zones otherwise.  It is evident in how lakes are padded all around with wide walking paths which also restrict water flows into the water bodies and contribute to devastating bund breaches.  It can be perceived  from the absolute lack of interest in the administration in ensuring protection of lakes, kaluves and other wetlands is undertaken with community involvement.  Instead, floods are being turned into an opportunity to finance mega projects, such as the concretization of kaluves, in further expansion of ‘white topping’ of roads even as it is abundantly evident. They contributed to the flooding.  Rather than waste precious resources on such projects that will worsen flooding in years to come,  ensuring public involvement through deeper local democracy  and encouraging every ward and sub-ward to develop a plan not only to avoid such catastrophic flooding, but to also ensure urban transformations do not end up in an irrevocable disaster. As we commemorate Teachers Day, a day when we also painfully reminisce the assassination of Gauri Lankesh, can we expect such simple wisdoms to become systemic to Bengaluru’s governance? Leo Saldanha works with Environment Support Group, a voluntary policy analysis, education, research and campaign initiative responding to social and environmental justice causes.  More information: www.esgindia.org Email: [email protected] 

Taiwan: An unstated understanding between countries 

0
On 2 August 2022, American Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi, landed in Taiwan. The Speaker of the House is the highest official in the American legislature and is the closest approximation to the Prime Minister within the House of Representatives. This visit marks the highest level visit by an American official since 1997 when Speaker Newt Gingrich visited Taiwan. Pelosi’s visit was condemned by the People’s Republic of China (PRC). Following the visit, China announced that it would conduct military drills and missile tests around Taiwan. These military exercises are an unprecedented display of force in the region and experts are concerned that the visit and the reaction mark a deterioration in the relations between two of the most powerful countries in the world.

Isn’t Taiwan an independent country?

Since its de facto separation from China, Taiwan has had an ambiguous legal status. It is not officially recognized by most countries across the world, including the United States, though most countries have certain arrangements with the government of Taiwan. Since the Chinese Revolution, Taiwan has held a strategic position for Western Powers against China. America has been ambiguous regarding its position on the matter of Taiwan. It neither overtly supports the PRC’s One-China policy nor does it support Taiwanese independence. Historically, the island of Formosa (Taiwan) was the envy of many colonial powers, for its strategic place off the coast of China. Chinese empires had to fight off colonial invaders, like the Dutch the British and the French from the island for centuries. In 1894, Japan invaded the island. Japanese rule  lasted until World War II when Japan had to cede control of Taiwan to China, who fought on the side of the victorious Allied forces. This coincided with the Chinese Civil War, which lasted from 1927 to 1949. The war was fought between the Nationalists, who succeeded the Qing dynasty, and the insurrectionary Communists. The Nationalists were in power when control of Taiwan shifted to China. The Nationalists were defeated by the Communists in the Civil War. In 1949, the Chinese Communist Party declared itself as the rightful ruler of China and consolidated its rule over all of mainland China by 1951. The Nationalist Government fled to Taiwan and established a new capital in Taipei, claiming to be the rightful ruler of China. They carried the name Republic of China (ROC) and represented the Chinese country as a whole internationally.

Two Chinas

In 1954, the US signed a defence treaty promising to protect ROC (Taiwan) if the PRC were to claim the island. This discouraged the PRC from consolidating Taiwan into the PRC. America maintained a strong military presence in East Asia, with wars in Korea, Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos. If the PRC made claims on Taiwan, it would have ignited another conflict, which the PRC was not ready for. In 1964, the PRC began testing and developing nuclear weapons, which may have been the main reason it was able to keep the United States from invading. America officially recognized the PRC as the sole legal government in 1979 after the PRC and the Soviet Union split. It ended the official recognition of the government of Taiwan. The American position has since been that it recognizes the Chinese position that there is one China and that Taiwan is part of China. However, the position has been left deliberately vague. The US does not accept or recognize that there is one China, as defined by the Chinese government, nor that Taiwan is part of China, but there is enough room for interpretation that it does. Neither PRC nor USA has tried to clarify, as it satisfied the interests of both states.

What is the situation right now?

Since the 1990s, China’s position in the world has grown. While in the 1980s, it seemed like the country was falling apart at the seams, in the 1990s and 2000s, China made great advancements in the Manufacturing, Finance and Tech sectors. These developments have levelled China’s position concerning western countries. The 2008 financial crisis saw a huge shift in China’s financial position. Western powers have feared that many of its last enclaves around China are quickly disappearing. China has been slowly integrating Hong Kong into the broader Chinese political system. China has also developed its economic influence across the world. Western powers fear that China will substantiate its claim on Taiwan.

Convenient Murkiness

Taiwan’s status as a sovereign nation is ambiguous. Western Powers, the PRC and the Taiwan government have allowed this ambiguity to persist for convenience. Piercing through the vagueness can create conditions for conflict. Pelosi’s visit is an example of this. Overt support for Taiwanese independence has not been supported by any major power. China’s claim on Taiwan is still nominal, and Taiwan has retained good trade relations with China. Polls among the Taiwanese people show that most people in Taiwan support the current status quo. The Chinese National identity is very intertwined with its specific experience of colonialism. Western powers invaded the country, spread Opium, subjugated it economically, and promoted social and political strife for over a century. Since the Chinese Revolution, and especially now, the Chinese see Taiwan as part of their country and would see western powers protecting it as a threat to the Chinese nation. Most people in China read the ambiguity over America’s stance on Taiwan as an acceptance of China’s One-China policy. Western powers have conflated issues of China’s human rights record and its history of claiming Tibet and Hong Kong with the issue of Taiwan. These are important but different issues. In the end, no party wants to clear up the ambiguity and it has worked well for them. Tensions between China and the US are a global concern. Like with Russia, American influence around China is being seen as a threat to the very existence of China and can be an incentive for China to act rashly. China is a nuclear power, which makes the prospect of war a threat to the Earth. Even if the conflict does not escalate into a nuclear conflict, both China and US are key players in the global economy, and antagonism between these two countries can easily have consequences on many aspects of life for everyone.

Farmers org to hold Jai Jawan Jai Kisan Sammelans across India against Agnipath Scheme

Farmers, ex-servicemen and youth of the country have joined hands to begin a sustained campaign against the disastrous ‘Agnipath scheme’ announced by the government of India The inaugural Jai Jawan Jai Kisan Sammelan was held at Narwana, Haryana on 7th March 2022. The sammelan was against the Agnipath Scheme, and was jointly addressed by leaders of Samyukta Kisan Morcha and United Front of Ex-Servicemen, Hannan Mollah, Major Satbir Singh, Yogendra Yadav, Col DK Bhardwaj, Joginder Nain, Phool Singh Sheokand, Sudesh Goyath, Deepak Lamba. Farmers, ex-servicemen and youths came together for a nationwide campaign against the Agnipath scheme. The sammelan demanded immediate withdrawal of the Agnipath Scheme. The leaders also called for filling of all pending vacancies in the armed forces, completion of already initiated recruitment process, and immediate release and withdrawal of cases against the youths protesting against the scheme. Over 500 people attended the sammelan and pledged to take this campaign to every village across the nation. On this occasion the leaders also visited a hundred-day long dharna by SKM for crop loss compensation and other demands of the farmers. The leaders complimented the farmers for their long struggle. The meeting resolved to continue the struggle against Agnipath Scheme as well. SKM rejects the committee formed by the Government on MSP A Jai Jawan Jai Kisan Rally was also held at Kolkata, West Bengal, which started from Ram Leela Park at Moulali and marched till Lenin Statue in Dharmatala. This campaign aims to educate the public about the disastrous consequences of the controversial Agnipath scheme and compel the central government, by using democratic, peaceful and constitutional means, to roll back the scheme. If the farm laws were dire, the Agnipath scheme is disastrous. With our kisans and jawans in distress, the very backbone of our nation is in the danger of breaking. Our silence cannot be the reason for the government to bulldoze and destroy the protectors and feeders of the nation. We have stopped them once, we can stop them again. On the call of Samyukta Kisan Morcha and United Front of Ex-Servicemen, Jai Jawan Jai Kisan Sammelans will be held across the nation from August 7 to August 14. The nationwide campaign will educate the public about the disastrous consequences of the controversial Agnipath scheme, and will continue until the scheme is withdrawn.

 Grassroots Resistance in Ecuador: CONAIE and the organization of Indigenous Activists

Since 13 June 2022, Ecuador has been rocked by massive protests. The protests have been primarily sustained by indigenous activists, mostly associated with the Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador (CONAIE). It also has strong support from workers and student groups. The protests have been against the destructive economic policies of the government that resulted in rising food and fuel process in the country. In response to the protest, the President of Ecuador, Guillermo Lasso, has declared a state of Emergency. Lasso has claimed that the protesters are planning a coup d’etat. The protests began on 13 June with a march on the nation’s capital, Quito. The march was organized by CONAIE. CONAIE also called for an indefinite strike. They demanded that fuel prices be controlled, and there should be increased spending on education and other social services. Along the march, there were sporadic outbreaks of violence. The next day, CONAI president Leonidas Iza, was arrested, leading to escalation. Though the court deemed the arrest legal, protesters saw it as illegitimate and responded by blocking roads. Students and workers joined the protests on 15th June. By 17th June, violence between police and protesters broke out. Police put up barricades to prevent the movements of the protesters. Protesters broke through the police barricade. Nearly a dozen protests were critically injured. The same day, the government tried to cancel offline classes and demand students take classes from home online, and declared a state of national emergency. The escalation continued over the next week. On 22 June, CONAIE brought out a list of demands to the state. The demands were:
  1. Controlling fuel prices
  2. Economic relief for four million families.
  3. Food prices that are fair for farmers and consumers
  4. Effective policies to prevent job insecurity and indebtedness
  5. Moratorium on oil and mining industries
  6. Respect for the rights of self-determination of indigenous people as enshrined in the Constitution
  7. Stopping the Privatization of industry
  8. Regulation of prices of basic necessities
  9. Support understaffed hospitals, and guarantee access of youth to higher education
  10. Effective Public policies to curb crime
  CONAIE was founded in 1986 and is currently the largest indigenous rights organization in Ecuador. It is composed of three regional federations representing the people of the Amazon, Coast and Quichua (highlands). CONAIE rejects electoral democracy as a political strategy and calls for a multi-nation state of Ecuador based on principles of participatory democracy and the self-determination of indigenous people. Traditionally CONAIE has used road blocking and systems of cultural resistance to protest against the state and policies imposed by the IMF. While they have stayed away from electoral politics, in 2002 they supported the Presidential campaign of Lucio Gutierrez. However, after his victory, CONAIE went against him saying that they went back on his promises to CONAIE by deepening ties with the IMF. Their campaign led to the recognition of the rights of nature in the Ecuadorian constitutions in 2008. Since then, CONAIE has begun to shift away from protests and move towards policy recommendations and awareness building. The indigenous populations of Ecuador have been a strong driver in politics. Nearly a quarter of the population identifies as indigenous. The people come from different ecological contexts, but their concern for the environment unites them. Deforestation, Oil & Mining companies and other industries have been ruining the ecological heritage of the country.   These popular movements have been at odds with the demands of the Global Economy. In the 1990s, American influence, through the IMF, hollowed out the finances of the state, leading to dependence on trade. Ecuador tried to move towards other poles for support, such as China, Russia or Iran, but this had no effect on the ability of the country to protect its environment or its people. As oil prices change, every country that Ecuador has worked with has changed the nature of support. This has often led to further exploitation of resources. While the state officially recognised the rights of Nature, it has been helpless in protecting those rights. Former President Raphael Correa had declared that while Ecuador was committed to protecting the Earth, the rest of the world keeps betraying them. Latin America has had pro-people and pro-nature politics at different points, but they have waxed and waned in different parts at different points of time. This has kept Ecuador in a precarious position, as throwing in with a sympathetic country today, could mean being ostracised tomorrow.
Courtesy-Bloomberg news
An indigenous women in the midst of protests in Quito, Ecuador, 2019
The only form of resistance comes in the form of para-parliamentary organizations such as CONAIE which speak to the exploitative nature of capitalism against the country. The country means both the people of the country and its rich cultural and natural heritage. This resistance knows that the state will only serve the interests of Global trade unless it meets with resistance outside the state. CONAIE keeps a philosophy of grassroots democracy, which they insist is the only path to democracy. Relying on the parliament only keeps power away from the people and in the hands of the international traders and national elites. Across the world, there has been a growing movement in indigenous politics. Since the 1970s, efforts have been made across many continents to establish the rights of indigenous people. These movements have grounded themselves in demands for local level democratic autonomy, respect for the varied cultures that have existed before the current nation-states, principles of self-determination, recognition of the historic relationship between the people and their land, and a desire for harmony with the broader globe. They have been under attack for centuries and would like to move on to a place of peace and liberation. Since the 1970s, there has been increased pressure from indigenous groups to recognize the fights of the first peoples. At the same time, corporations and the state have been even more vicious in looting the resources that rightfully belong to the original inhabitants. Even in India, where in recent times, many of the historic gains by indigenous groups have been under attack, the tug-of-war between the state and the demands of local indigenous people has required more coordination across various communities. In Ecuador, CONAIE shows a way to resist.