Kuvempu birthday celebrated with sahasra sahabhojana all over karnataka

0
Kannadigas celebrated the birthday of beloved “Rashtra Kavi” Kuvempu by embracing his writings and principle of universal togetherness. Many citizen groups gave a call for “Sahasra Sahabhojana” all over karnataka on Kuvempu´s birthday. Sahasra Sahabhojana or Thousand gatherings with sharing of food together was celebrated with music, poetry and spoken words of famous Indian poets and writers. People also read the Preamble of the Indian constitution to remind ourselves of the democratic, secural and pruralistic foundation of our country. The tagline of the event was- “Peaceful garden of universal togetherness” because this is how Kuvempu eulogized Karnataka in the state anthem- as a peaceful garden of all humankind , irrespective of caste, creed and religion. The organisers of the event in speaking with Gauri Lankesh news said- The event is to promote peaceful coexistence and social harmony in the country. It is to send a message of love and togetherness as a response to attempts made by certain forces to divide the country into religious lines. The event recieved tremendous response with people gathering from different walks of life to be part of a gathering of like minded individuals promoting communal harmony. People brought food, music and poems. They collectively read the preamble of the constitution and vowed to maintain peace. Many across the state have organized, participated and celebrated the event with great gusto emphasizing the unity of India lies with its diversity on the birth anniversary of Kannada poet Kuvempu. People celebrated the idea of united India against all odds with much joy and gusto. At the event, citizens of all caste, class, gender, and religion pledged allegiance to the constitution of India by reading the preamble of the constitution.
Cubbon Park, Bangalore
Kuvempu Birthday celebration at Raichur
          The event took at many places in Bangalore. The event at Cubbon park was attended by 200 citizens including Ramachandra Guha who was arrested in the recent Anti-NRC-CAB protests.
Kampli
Madikeri
Events across the districts, towns, villages, and homes from Chikkaballapur, Mandya, Shivamogga, Kalburgi, Hospete, Bagalkote, Gauribidanur, Pavagada, Chikkanayakanahalli, Udupi, Baindooru, Belgaum etc were also reported. The people gathered together denounced the divisive politics  and pledged their support to the secular and socialistic fabric of the Indian constitution which furthers the bond of brotherhood. Kuvempu, the cultural icon of Karnataka was born on 29th December 1904 in Kuppalli, Shivamogga district, Karnataka. In his poetry and literature, emphasized the shunning of collective social evils such as the caste system, blind beliefs, and religious animosity by encouraging the concept of universal man (Vishwa Manava). He strongly advocated the principles of social justice to achieve peace and harmony in society. India has a long tradition of tolerant and peaceful co-existence with many sharing the same civilizational exchanges and it our duty to continue and strengthen it. Many attendees remarked in their speeches.- “This event is one of a kind with people uniting for love and peace with food in the time of manufactured hate”.  

Data Protection Bill: Protection of the State by the State and For the State

0
Amidst the pan India protests against the controversial CAA and NRC, the central government has buckled up to pass a serpentine Data Protection Bill during the winter session of the Parliament. Notably, the Bill was introduced on the backdrop of the landmark verdict in the Puttaswamy v Union of India Case which recognized privacy as a fundamental right under the gambit of Article 21. Followingly, the government appointed a committee to provide recommendations to establish an impermeable data protection regime and to safeguard the data of the fellow citizens.

Data is the New Oil

Interestingly, the possibilities of personal data and the window of opportunity it opens towards the commercial and political ventures have been evident from the revelations of various whistleblowers. Christopher Wylie and Edward Snowden have astonished the world by unraveling the clandestine activities of various entities using the personal data of people siphoned from popular websites.
As many experts have pointed out, this bill would be the penultimate step towards the establishment of an Orwellian State.
The books ‘Mindf*ck’ and ‘Permanent Records’ would provide a thorough understanding of what could be done with such information. Such data could be used in multifarious sectors, from the manipulation of elections to managing consumer behavior. As a matter of fact, the Economist magazine has entitled four companies (Facebook, Apple, Netflix, Google) as the pillars of the US stock market and all these four companies utilize data to understand consumer behavior and rearrange their selling pattern accordingly. Big data analytics and Artificial Intelligence bolster their efforts to behave more consumer-friendly. Moreover, data analytics have encroached from all walks of life. The spurious involvement of Cambridge Analytica in the US Presidential elections, as well as its association with Indian political parties, manifest the importance of personal information or data in determining the political course of a nation. Unsurprisingly, the richest man in the country and the trailblazer in the Indian internet ecosystem, Mukesh Ambani had made the statement “data is the new oil”.

Pitfalls in Protection

Even Though the nuance bill in data protection has introduced optimistic clauses of consent, purpose limitation, storage limitation, and data minimization as well as lay down obligations on agencies collecting personal data (data fiduciary) along with the establishment of Data Protection Authority of India(DPAI), it has motley wedges in its formation.  Under the new narrative of security interlinked with technology, it is rendering unrestrictive rights for the government to encroach into the private space of an individual. The bill empowers the central government, in Section 35, to allow any government agency to bypass all the private data protection under the circumstances of (a) in the interest of the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of the State, friendly relations with foreign states or public order and (b) for preventing any cognizable offense relating to the above (a). Notably, the bill has also watered down the strict recommendations of the Srikrishna Committee on data localization as well.

Digital Panopticon

Strikingly, the controversies related to the spyware Pegasus which keeps the government at the suspect list should be read in light of this bill.  This bill can be considered as the digital version of the much controversial Post Office Bill which was introduced during the Rajiv Gandhi tenure. Security is the magical word used by autocratic regimes as an excuse which intends to invade the private life of citizens and to exert absolute control over them. The digital clock tower soon to be erected by the government would generate the feeling of the panopticon for the people. Being watched all the time, being observed everywhere would certainly instill unnecessary fear and anxiety and it could distort the normal life and thought process of the people. As many experts have pointed out, this bill would be the penultimate step towards the establishment of an Orwellian State.

The false promise of protection to non-Muslim refugees from Afghanistan

Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) is a tool for terror, masking itself as an amendment. The Hindu right has claimed that it has come out of love for the persecuted religious minorities of Afghanistan, but this claim does not make sense. The amendment does not offer anything to those who have fled, and in numbers, does not help that many people. Even if every Hindus, Sikhs, Parsis, Buddhists and Christians from Afghanistan found their way to India in need of protection, their basic needs would not be met. This “protection” should be seen for what it is. CAA is a tool to harass the Kashmiri population and is the next step after the abrogation of 370. By including Afghanistan in the list of countries in the CAA, India is reasserting its claim on the full undivided Kashmir and maintains the right to religiously profile, giving itself the right to screen people from Afghanistan as well on the basis of religion. Anyone who moved from Afghanistan to Kashmir to escape persecution in Afghanistan will now have to produce documents, which nomadic tribes are not likely to have or pass a religious test. The inclusion of the non-Muslims from Afghanistan into CAA is odd. It will only help those who came from Afghanistan to India from 2009 onward get citizenship. In the last census in Afghanistan in 1973, the combined population of the Hindus, Sikhs, Parsis, Buddhists, and Christians amounted to a few hundred thousand. Almost all of that population fled during the Taliban rule, over 18 years ago. Nobody knows exactly how many are left, but estimates are that there are around a thousand each of Hindus, Sikhs, and Christians. If the state really wanted to help non-Muslims from Afghanistan, amnesty provisions can easily be made for those settled here. For those who are expected to come, the state can create a system of safe passage, a rehabilitation package with programs of integration, and legal protection. Citizenship can be given to those who chose to live in India for the long term, whether it be 11 years or longer. Shortening the time to 6 years might help those who are prone to travel and would need Indian citizenship to travel, but the state is equipped to grant basic rights to non-citizens, whatever their background. If the state were serious, a draft refugee, settlement and rehabilitation scheme would have been appropriate. The policy could give local officials enough space to assess the specific needs of each case.

Criminalizing refugees

Making undocumented people from other countries label criminals is itself criminal. If people who are escaping the persecution of any kind are illegal in this state, then the state itself is criminal. Law cannot work against someone if the person had no choice. If the person came to India to escape persecution, the law should not punish them at all. CAA isn’t here to help those being persecuted. It gives the state a new tool for persecution. Criminalizing undocumented immigrants just gives the state an arbitrary standard to use against the disenfranchised. Redefinition citizenship on religious grounds does not help those persecuted in Afghanistan. While the inclusion of Afghanistan into a list of countries was justified on the grounds that India shares a border with Afghanistan, the religious minorities in question live mostly in urban areas far from India. They are more likely to travel to India by flight than by land. The “border” also only touches Pakistan Occupied Kashmir, and is far from the Line of Control. For practical purposes, India has no physical contact with Afghanistan To add to the confusion, lakhs of people, mostly belonging to nomadic tribes, speak languages similar to Pashtun, and have lived in the country for centuries. Some of them live as far south as Madhya Pradesh and as far east as Assam. Many members live in Kashmir. It seems likely that CAA will regulate citizenship of the tribal population there, and give the state a new tool to harass them. For decades, Afghanistan has been in deep conflict with domestic and international sides. Millions have been persecuted. It is important for India to take an active role in protecting the people in whatever way is feasible. Offering amnesty to refugees is welcome, and has been part of India’s policy for a long time. Screening refugees on the basis of religion and adapting our citizenship laws are not. Afghanistan has not always been an Islamic republic. Things have changed too much that it might not be one tomorrow. The persecuted of any people who have come from that conflict should be survivor driven. India should accommodate their needs without discriminating on why they have been persecuted but focus on that they have been persecuted. The current government is using a crisis suffered by a neighbor to push an agenda of hate and militarization.

Subramanian Swamy’s latest OpEd on Citizenship Act is a smokescreen

0
Dr. Subramanian Swamy’s latest opinion piece entitled “A premature denouncement of the Citizenship Act” intends to assert that the concerns of the critics of the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) are unfounded. As much as Swamy would appreciate, given his Harvard training in economics and statistics many decades ago, an evaluation of his justifications of the Act from within the lens of his own exacting scholarly disciplines is in order. citizenship amendement bill Swamy rightly starts with a response to the need for the CAA, which the critics too have been actively seeking from the leaders of the Union Government. To this, he pushes the ruling party’s argument that the non-Muslim minorities face persecution in Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan, and, must be granted citizenship. India, of course, has a duty, above all, humanitarian, to protect the persecuted minorities of her neighbors, however, there are at least four aspects of the critics’ concerns that Swamy has failed to consider:

Ignoring the realities from Assam 

Swamy depends on a logic of historical analysis in citing the persecution of minorities in relation to 1947. By the same logic, a more recent connection ought to have been highlighted, namely, the need for the ruling party to urgently enact the CAA in the context of the exclusion of 19 lakh people from the Assam NRC – a majority of them poor and Hindu. The Citizenship Amendment Bill was, thus, introduced in this context to avoid an embarrassment for the majoritarian government, that a large number of Hindus being left out from the Assam NRC had caused. The people of Assam, on the other hand, see the provision for citizenship to the non-Muslim migrants as further hindering their fight for protecting their ethnic identity. Thus, by ignoring the causal factors of the debacle in Assam, Swamy shows what can be called selective amnesia of recent events.  

Ignoring the persecution of minority Muslim groups

If the intention regarding protecting minorities from persecution is fundamental to Swamy’s piece, the fact that he ignores the persecution of minority Muslim groups makes his humanity appear half-hearted. Petitions have been filed arguing for the inclusion of Ahmadi and Shia Muslims who are minorities in Pakistan, Hazara Muslims of Afghanistan and Uighurs from China. Furthermore, narrowly defining minorities as non-Muslims leaves out groups such as LGBT, political and linguistic minorities, atheists, censored artists, and journalists, etc. Swamy must clarify his sense of humanity, which perhaps could also explain that of the ruling party’s. Compared to any other country, it is in India that the leaders must explain the basis for their moral positions towards certain minorities at the risk of excluding others, for the nation-state itself is marked by its complex composition of various minority groups. He further makes an unsubstantiated claim: “No Muslims or Jews came to India over the last 70 years on grounds of religious persecution”. This claim is indefensible even by the logic of language if he is aware that India considers all minority Muslim groups (Ahmadis, Shias, Uighurs) as simply Muslims. These groups, facing persecution in their countries, have fled to India in search of safety. Swamy needs to reconsider the consistency of his own statement, which will require an effort perhaps no more than proofreading his article. 

Factual inaccuracy in quoting a decline in non-Muslim minority population

Swamy’s training in economics has not ensured that he relies on clean data. Despite the debunking from various sources – of the Home Minister Amit Shah’s claim that the population of non-Muslim minorities has declined since 1951 – Swamy goes on to restate this inaccuracy. He conveniently ignores the established fact that the Hindu population in Pakistan from the 1951 data and that from the census data for 1998 are in fact comparable. 

Equating Hindutva with the Constitution

Swamy’s contention is primarily with a previously published editorial by the Chief Minister of Kerala and CPI(M) leader Pinarayi Vijayan which the former sees as exaggerating the Hindutva agenda. Swamy on multiple instances mischievously quotes Vijayan’s concerns with the CAA as “the agenda of Hindutva and the ultimate goal of establishing a Hindu Nation”, “[discriminating] against Muslims”, etc. These are almost every critic’s concerns that it violates Article 14 that guarantees people “equality before the law”. Swamy quotes the Supreme Court to state that “equality before the law” does not apply because discriminated minorities (non-Muslims of Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan) are not placed equally to the Muslim counterparts. If that is indeed the case, then Ahmedias, Shias, Rohingyas, Uighurs, etc., also fall within this legal context. So, even by his own analysis of Article 14, the exclusion of other minority groups from the CAA is inconsistent.  One must read between the lines, especially when one deviously conflates various provisions of the constitution. To Vijayan’s assertion that the goal of a “Hindu nation” underlies the CAA, Swamy writes: “Unfortunately, … Indian Constitution cannot be amended beyond the Basic Structure … as defined by the Supreme Court of India” (emphasis added). It takes a bad writer or a bad editor to let the word “unfortunately” slip in that context. Is Swamy insisting that there should be a way to amend the constitution based on majoritarian Hindu ideas? If so, he violates the secular principles of India, if not by law, then by letter.   It is surprising, if not disturbing, to see a man nominated to such a high political position, resorting to arguments based on religious divisions to defend the contentious legislation, which has created unprecedented panic in the country. In what can only be understood as a sly attempt, he muddies the subject with a distracting reference to Brahmins not seeking reservation for education and employment opportunities reserved for “backward” caste people, as if to create confusion on the understanding of Article 14, and thus creating a false equivalence. Surely, one cannot think that he is impervious to the knowledge of the premise for reservation in India. He also makes the disappointing provocation that the neighboring countries have “Muslim theocracy”, but his own writing does not hide his desire for a “Hindu nation”: he argues that the constitution incorporates Hindutva and that there are enough provisions to “usher in a Hindu Nation”. With such dubious casteist and communal rhetoric, one wonders as to who Swamy is addressing the article to, for it fails to make sense to a common person who believes in the secular values enshrined in the Indian constitution. His alma mater Harvard in 2011 dropped his courses following student petitions against his articles that recommended demolishing hundreds of mosques. The lessons have not been learned by the former professor as he continues to write with the same religious fanaticism. With his latest opinion piece, he attempts to obfuscate facts, and more dangerously use it to further the Hindutva rhetoric. The author is a public policy graduate student at the National University of Singapore. Views expressed are personal. 

Also read: Citizenship Amendment Bill: anti-people, anti-poor, anti-constitutional

Break Superstitious practices during eclipse: Citizen groups attempts to raise scientific temper

0
India witnessed the rare celestial spectacle, the annular solar eclipse, the last one for the decade today morning. A solar eclipse occurs when the Moon passes between Earth and the Sun, totally or partly obscuring the Sun for a viewer on Earth. An annular solar eclipse takes place when the moon’s apparent diameter is smaller than that of the Sun’s, blocking most of the Sun’s light. This causes the Sun to look like a ‘ring of fire’.  solar eclipse Eclipse, solar or lunar are natural phenomena, but in a country like India with a majority population still bereft of basic education, there are many blind and superstitious beliefs that surround such natural events. But its not just the uneducated, it’s also the upper class educated who also indulge in such superstitious practices. Among the most common practices are fasting, not taking bath and not stepping out of the house during the eclipse. Traditionally, many of the big temples like Thirupathi Balaji temple and Sabrimala temple also shut down and reopen only after purification rituals. Most of these practices do not have any scientific basis. 

Height of Superstition in Kalaburgi- Special abled children buried in the ground to ‘cure’ them

In kalaburgi district, many accounts have come where parents bury their special abled children in the ground with only their heads outside during the eclipse. The incident took place in Taj Sultanpur. Parents said they would remove the children out of the ground once the eclipse is over. Children don’t seem very happy with this exercise but parents think this practice will cure their disabilities. This is a clear example of a lack of access to health facilities and education, things that make parents believe such superstitions than a qualified doctor.

Anti- Superstition protest at Town Hall, Bengaluru

Concerned with such prevalent superstitions in the society, several citizen groups and concerned individuals took out a unique awareness program at the town hall, Bengaluru during the solar eclipse. These protestors at town hall consumed fruits and proved that there is no harm in consuming food during the eclipse. eclipse Talking to Gauri lankesh news team- Mr. Mallappa, a transgender activist who was part of the team organizing the program said- “Commonly people believe that one is not supposed to come out of the house, should not consume food or water, etc which is applied to Pregnant ladies also, which is harmful,” Mallappa also added that people must function on the basis of science and not superstition; condemning the wrongdoings that has been propagated by priests and others which cannot be proven scientifically. He also said that these practices bring more harm to the lower class people who easily tend to believe the superstitions because of a lack of education and knowledge. “No consumption of food or water, not stepping out of the house, etc during an eclipse is all false beliefs held by superstition and only that one should not see the sun through naked eyes is true scientifically which should be followed,” said Narasimha Murthy, an advocate who was one of the people eating at the protest site to show the myths surrounds the eclipse.

Do’s and Dont’s during the eclipse 

In India, people from Karnataka, Kerala and Tamil Nadu were able to see the annular solar eclipse, while the rest of the country could see a partial solar eclipse. The solar eclipse was initially visible as a partial eclipse and was viewed first from Riyadh in Saudi Arabia. In India, the maximum duration of the annular solar eclipse will be just over 3 minutes. The moon covers the sun in a rare “ring of fire” solar eclipse as seen from Mumbai. Ahead of the solar eclipse, astronomers issued a set of dos and don’ts for safe viewing. PTI report says- Skywatchers are advised to use safe viewing equipment and proper techniques to view the celestial event as the infrared and ultraviolet rays of the Sun can cause severe retinal damage, a senior astronomer was quoted by Press Trust of India as saying.

“One should not look at the Sun directly for even a little period without proper protection. Even when 99 per cent of the surface of the Sun is covered by the moon during partial eclipse, the remaining light is still intense enough to damage the eye,” Debiprosad Duari, the director of MP Birla Planetarium told PTI.

“Proper solar filters with certified appropriate optical density against radiation which are safe to the eyes should be used in front optical devices and the naked eye,” he said.

According to experts, the best way to view the solar eclipse is a pinhole camera or a telescopic projection used on a suitable surface.

The author is a journalism student based in Bangalore    

Jharkhand Elections: Hul Johar! Birsa Land chooses Jal, Jangal Zameen

Raghubar das led BJP government lost assembly elections in Jharkhand, the tribal heartland and also RSS ‘Hindutva´ laboratory. The election results not just mark the exit to the state’s first non-tribal CM but also a dent in BJP’s social engineering project. BJP’s defeat in one of its stronghold states has come as a shock to not just its supporters but for those who believed in the invincibility of Modi wave and Amit Shah’s “Chanakya Niti”. 

Anti-incumbency, non-tribal CM, anti-tribal policies

Jharkhand tribal population is between 26-30%. Election results in ST reserved seats have shown that the Jharkhand Mukti morcha-Rashtriya Janata Dal- congress alliance (JMM-RJD-Congress)  has won 25 out of 28 seats. Contrast this with the 2014 assembly elections when BJP got 11 out of 28 seats.

So what turned the tide?

Local journalists and activists have stated that there is deep anger and resentment against the Raghubar Das government that has pushed for laws to acquire tribal land. His attempts to change the tribal tenancy laws in 2017, which sought to dilute the protection the scheduled tribe had over their land, created a huge trust deficit for BJP in Jharkhand.
Jharkhand, means “the land of forests”  the state in Eastern India was formed out of Bihar for tribal welfare in 2000. The region has been inhabited since the Mesolithic- chalcolithic period. Use of Iron started in this region as early as 1400 BC. The region was ruled by Maurya, Gupta, Pala, and several tribal kingdoms before coming under East India company under British rule. After the Independence of India, the region became part of Bihar state. The state is mineral rich but 40% of its population is below poverty line and 19% of its children malnourished, a typical story of India’s adivasi lands. 
The Das government had brought two bills in 2017 to change the two tenancy acts-the Chotanagpur Tenancy Act (CNTA) and the Santhal Parganas Tenancy Act (SPTA)–to allow commercial use of tribal land. These laws protect tribal rights over their land and put restrictions on the acquisition and sale of tribal land. The move was largely seen as a pro-corporate and anti-tribal. The Congress-JMM led opposition along with the Church opposed the proposed amendments. Sensing the anger and criticism from the tribal community, the BJP had put the decision on hold before the Lok Sabha polls. But the damage was done.  electionsThese fears have led to a spate of protests and one significant movement called the ‘Pathalgarhi movement’ in 2018,  whereby the tribals erected pathar (stones) plaques engraved with provisions of the Fifth Schedule in the constitution as an assertion of autonomy and independence from the Indian union. The Das government in a bid to suppress the movement filed FIRs against at least 10,000 people, many were still languishing in jail. In Khunti district alone, where the activist Dayamani Barla stood for elections on Jharkhand Vikas Morcha ticket, there were 23 FIRs, 19 of which involved sedition, kidnapping, rape, and other heinous charges mainly against tribal leaders. Some villages have also given a boycott call for elections by burying their Aadhar and voter IDs as a protest against police crackdown. 
Mineral-rich states, such as Odisha, Chattisgarh and Jharkhand have been accruing forest land under Land Banks for use by corporates for years, often without the knowledge of any of the local forest-dwelling communities.
One can judge the impact of the tribal anger by the defeat of BJP state president Laxman Giluwa from a ST reserved seat. Giluwa was a vocal supporter of the police action against the people who participated in the Pathalgarhi movement.  Jharkhand is also the state with 20 cases of mob lynchings, highest in the country. CM’s ideological push on conversion and cow-related issues also did not go well with Hindu as well as Christian tribal communities. 

Is the Modi wave waning?

While many are speculating that this is not a reflection on Modi magic but the result of an unpopular CM candidate. Modi is considered a charismatic speaker and Amit shah, a great election strategist. Both did 9 rallies each during the election campaign. These rallies were full of anti congress rhetoric and its “super” achievements of the scrapping of Article 370, Ayodhya and Ram temple. Some of these rallies were during the time when protests against CAA were going on. It was in one of these rallies that Modi spoke of “You can identify the arsonists from their clothes”. The protesters all across India included people of all religions. The statement clearly was aimed to target Muslims and to polarise the voters on religious lines. But the results do not bode well on Modi and Shah’s image. BJP lost in 6 out of 9 seats that Modi campaigned and 7 out of 9 seats that Amit Shah campaigned. Jharkhand election results also come amid popular nationwide protests against CAA and NRC. So it is a double setback to Modi Shah Jodi who were the main men behind this exercise.  Its too early to say that if Modi wave is receding, but definitely BJP arrogance and over-reliance on Kashmir, article 370 and Ram temple seem to have backfired. In this election also, it looks like the national issues did not resonate with the population mired with burning local issues of land rights and unemployment which was largely ignored in election rallies. The results also consolidate the fact that people vote on local issues in Assembly elections as was seen in the case of Maharashtra and Haryana elections. Also Read: Turning back the clock: How the state is reversing gains made by traditional forest-dwelling communities

Sufiyana: A musical evening with noted Sufi singer Mukhtiyar Ali

0
Pothi padh padh jag mua pandit bhaya na koye Dhai aakhar prem ke padhe so pandit hoye Most Indians know this famous Kabir saying- That brings the language of love above all the knowledge of pandits and the scriptures, Kabir does it so beautifully in 2 line couplets. Kabir couplets and Sufi music take one to a world of universal love, equality, and humanity. Mukhtiyar Ali, the renowned Sufi singer born and brought up in nomadic Mirasi Muslim family grew up listening and singing songs of Kabir, tales of Ramayana and Mahabharata.

Mukhtiyar Ali will be performing at the musical evening program called “Sufiyana” today in St. Joseph’s College, Bengaluru at 5 PM.

Ali spent his initial years singing in bhajan Mandali during festivals like Ramanavami, Deepawali. He came to limelight with ‘The Kabir Project’. An academic project which was undertaken to study and find out how Kabir influenced people and places through his mystic couplets and poetry.  The project spoke and recorded singers, Kabir Panthi activists and disciples from both India and Pakistan; their art and traditions celebrated Kabir. As part of the project a documentary was made called ‘Had Anhad – journey with Kabir’.

Sufis and Sufi Music

The Sufis were mystics. The Sufis laid emphasis upon free thought and liberal ideas. They were against formal worship, rigidity and fanaticism in religion. The Sufis turned to meditation in order to achieve religious satisfaction. Sufism is often compared with Bhakti movement. Both evolved in the medieval period of India between the 15th-17th centuries in India. Both movements brought a new form of religious expression amongst Hindus and Muslims. Like the Bhakti saints, the Sufis too interpreted religion as ‘love of God’ and service of humanity. The Sufi mystics and Bhakti saints transformed the rigid religions by breaking the walls of religions and creating a syncretic culture.
For them, caste had no meaning and all human beings were equal. Such content resonated with the common people and it does even today making India a contemporary epicenter for Sufi culture.
Sufi music is the devotional music of the Sufis, inspired by the works of Sufi poets, like Rumi, Hafiz, Bulleh Shah, Amir Khusrow and Khwaja Ghulam Farid. The Sufi saints and fakirs sang on universal love, humanity, world harmony, egalitarianism in a caste-ridden Indian society. The Sufi movement made a valuable contribution to Indian society. Like the Bhakti saints who were engaged in breaking down the barriers within Hinduism, the Sufis too infused a new liberal outlook within Islam. The interaction between early Bhakti and Sufi ideas laid the foundation for more liberal movements of the fifteenth century. The Sufis believed in the concept of ‘Unity of Being’ which says- that all beings are essentially one. Different religions were identical. This doctrine gained popularity in India. A notable contribution of the Sufis was their service to the poorer and downtrodden sections of society. According to the Sufis, the highest form of devotion to God was the service of mankind. The Sufi movement encouraged equality and brotherhood. The Sufi saints tried to bring about social reforms too. Like the Bhakti saints, the Sufi saints contributed greatly to the growth of a rich regional literature. Most of the Sufi saints were poets who chose to write in local languages. They wrote in Punjabi, Hindawi, Deccani, and Bengali. Listening to these bhajans which start with these words makes us feel as if we are witnessing the medieval times and as if Kabir himself is saying these words while immersed in weaving his loom. Bengaluru is fortunate to witness such an artist.

Anti-CAA protests update: Detentions, non-bailable arrests, lathicharge, teargas on Protesters

0
Yesterday the country saw people come to streets in unprecedented numbers defying prohibitory orders in many states to protest the controversial citizenship (Amendment) Act (CAA). Today also protesters are planning demonstrations in several parts of the country. Uttar Pradesh and Karnataka, both BJP ruled states saw instances of police violence whereby one person was killed in Lucknow in police firing.

Karnataka

Bangalore saw protests where police detained people but later when the numbers grew police were on the back foot and protests went peacefully. Students from various colleges are planning to have anti -CAA protests today. Mangalore witnessed large protests yesterday against the Citizenship (Amendment) Act- National Registry of Citizens. However, by evening, the protests turned violent when police fired directly at protestors leaving 2 dead. The victims are identified as Jaleel Kudroli (49) and Nausheen Bengre (23) and were brought to Highland Hospital. As the news of the death spread, people started gathering outside the hospital that led to some confrontation between the police and people. Later in the night, many videos emerged of police entering the hospital in riot gear, firing tear gas and indiscriminately beating patients, their relatives and many of the hospital staff. Parts of Coastal Karnataka has been put under high alert with a curfew in Mangalore. There is internet shutdown till tomorrow in mangalore.

Delhi

Bhim Army leader Chandrashekhar Azad is planning to hold protests at jama Masjid today afternoon. Parts of delhi are facing internet shut down. Some congress leaders were arrested for protesting outside Amit Shah House. Some areas of the city are put under section 144.

Kerala

North Kerala, esp the areas adjoining karnataka is on high alert after yesterday’s protests. One journalist from kerala was arrested in mangalore protests.

Uttar Pradesh

Despite section 144, people came out to protests in Lucknow and Sambhal against CAA. These areas also saw violent protests. In Lucknow, one youth was killed in police firing. Around 200 protesters were arrested in Lucknow. In Varanasi, 69 people were arrested during the peaceful protest against CAA and NRC. Most of these are BHU students and social activists. Police also made arrests a day prior to the 20th Dec protests to prevent the protests. Police have detained them under section 296/19 ,332,353,147,148 of CRC. These sections are against serious crimes and come unbailable offenses. Over all 3,305 were arrested yesterday. In Lucknow and many districts, mobile and internet services are down.

Tamilnadu

Around 600 prople were arrested in the anti -CAA protests including actor Siddharth and musician TM Krishna. Madras University students were also arrested. Actor kamal Hassan came out in support of the students calling the CAA as state terrorism.  

Gujarat

In Ahemdabad, 5 thousand people were booked yesterday for alleged stone pelting at police personnel. These people are booked under grave offences of an attempt to murder and interfering a public officer in his duty. Yesterday congress MLA Shahzad khan and 49 people were arrested. Jignesh Mewani, an independent MLA was also detained yesterday by the police.

Hyderabad

The city police denied permission for protests at 2 places and many students and activists were taken into preventive custody before the planned protests in Hyderabad. later in the day, protesters gathered at necklace road to protest against the CAA-NRC.
kadapa, Andhra Pradesh
 
Adoni, Andhra Pradesh

Bhopal

Despite Section 144 imposed in about 44 districts, peaceful protests were reported at kandhwa and Bhopal.      

Day in Pictures: Indians United against CAA-NRC

Eminent personalities, students, social activists and people from different walks of life took part in a rally here to protest against the new citizenship law and NRC. Despite prohibitory orders and section 144 imposed in several parts of the country, people were undeterred and took it to streets on Thursday in huge numbers in Delhi, Bangalore, Mumbai, Lucknow, Bhopal, Mangalore, Gulbarga, Varanasi to oppose the controversial Citizenship (Amendment) Act and National registry of Citizens (NRC). Karnataka and Uttar Pradesh, both BJP ruled states had section 144 across the state for from today to the next 3 days. People were on streets in large numbers by 10 AM to express their dissent against the Act. Most places, permission was granted and then withdrawn but people from all walks of life, hindu, muslim, sikh, Christian, students, activists, lawyers, rich, poor came to the protest venues defying the prohibitory orders. In Bangalore, noted historian Ramachandra Guha was picked up by police while he was talking to media at Townhall during anti -CAA protests In Gulbarga district, 40,000 people march to protest against the citizenship amendment act. While in Delhi Swaraj Abhiyan leader and social activist Yogendra Yadav, Umar Khalid (social activist) was arrested early on. In Gujarat, social activist Jignesh Mewani was also arrested. All over the country may prominent activists and common people were detained by the police.
Meanwhile , there were instances of internet shut down and closure of metro entry and exit points in Delhi leading to a traffic jam up to 10 Km.
While protests at Delhi, Bangalore, kalaburgi, Trichi were peaceful, there were instances of violence at places like Mangalore, where police shelled tear gas and lathi-charged the protestors.
Anti-CAA protests at Chennai
Police also used force in Lucknow and Hazratganj in UP when some vehicles were burnt. Eminent personalities, students, social activists and people from different walks of life took part in a rally in Kolkata to protest against the new citizenship law and NRC. Protests are continuing at jantar mantar in Delhi. By evening people started gathering in Chandigarh and Mumbai for anti CAA protests.

Gujarat Riots 2002: Blood Stain Washed Away, Modi gets Clean Chit

0
According to the Nanavati Commission report that was tabled in Gujarat Assembly on 11th December 2019, Gujarat riots of 2002, one of the bloodiest episodes of Hindu Muslim rivalry in post-independent India is not pre-planned or conspired. The report points out, that the riots were a result of spontaneous anger and emotions of a group of people… Sounds Familiar? The report gives a clean-chit to the then Gujarat chief minister and the incumbent Prime Minister and the most powerful person of contemporary politics Narendra Modi. Notably, one of the biggest blots in the political life of Narendra Modi is technically erased forever. The report is a mere reiteration of the findings of the SIT which probed the same issue. The apex court was hesitant to accept the findings of amicus curiae Raju Ramachandran which clearly stated the involvement of Modi in the dark episodes of the Gujarat riots. The exoneration of the NaMo was not an element of surprise, the washing away of bloodstains from the Khadi while someone remains in power is a standard approach in the Indian political spectrum.

Contradictions Loom Large

Interestingly, after years of the probe and thorough investigation, the Nanavati commission was unable to find any illicit linkage between the government and the culprits involved in the riots. However, the commission has mentioned the members of Bajrangi Dal and VHP (Vishva Hindu Parishad), which are a member of the Sangh parivar (BJP is the electoral wing) of the ruling party, were involved in the crime. Although the report criticized the state police department for its inactivity and incompetence but cleared the government authorities from all allegations. The police department comes directly under CM and the state’s Home Minister. The convictions ordered by the trial court against the people inside the government including the former BJP minister Maya Kodnani contradict the findings of the commission. The report redundantly denies the direct involvement of the BJP government and its machinery in the riot. However, it misses the bigger picture. One of the worst crimes that an authority can involve in such a situation is not only active participation in the crime but also the inaction or hesitation to prevent the havoc. The detailed report of the Nanavati commission seems to neglect such crucial analysis. Such discrepancies are largely evident in the voluminous report submitted in the assembly.

NaMo Had the Last Laugh

The commission was appointed in 2002 by the then state chief minister Narendra Modi to probe the riots, that took place after the burning of two coaches of Sabarmati Express train near Godhra railway station, in which 59 ‘karsevaks’ were killed. “On an overall consideration of the entire material, the commission finds that the communal riots which followed the Godhra incident were really by way of aftermath of that incidents,” the report said. It was because of the Godhra incident that large sections of the Hindu community became very angry and ultimately indulged in violent attacks on Muslims and their properties,” it said. The commission questioned the credibility of three former IPS officers – Sanjiv Bhatt, Rahul Sharma, and R B Sreekumar, who had alleged that there was the role of the state government in the riots. However, these IPS officers have claimed to submit incriminating evidence to the commission to prove the involvement of CM Narendra Modi in the bloodbath of  Gujarat riots. Allegedly, Sreekumar has provided 9 affidavits and Rahul Sharma has tabled the proof of call records during the event. Sanjiv Bhatt, who is currently languishing in jail claims that in a meeting the CM asked the police officers to allow the Hindus to vent their anger. Sanjeev Bhatt was arrested this year in a 25-year-old case. Many human rights organisations had called his arrest as political vendetta. The Nanavati Commission also criticised the two NGOs Jan Sangharsh Manch, then led by the late Mukul Sinha, and Citizens for Justice and Peace, led by Teesta Setalvad. These two organisations have been working tirelessly to get justice to the victims of communal riots in Maharashtra and Gujarat. Teesta Setalvad and Jan Sangharsh Manch have been a vocal critic of Narendra Modi and the Gujarat government. The BJP leader Pradeepsinh Jadeja clamoured that, those police officers and NGOs have tarnished the name of Modi, Gujarat and Gujaratis in front of the world. However, this is an eloquent claim made by Jadeja to equate Modi with Gujarat. Modi might be a Gujarati but Gujarat couldn’t be a synonym of a single individual. Moreover, exhibiting discontent and claiming suspicion in the conduct of the government or a public servant in the most legitimate method by approaching court is not under any circumstances diminishing the pride of a particular state or its people. Such rhetorical speech is to blindfold the people with sub nationalistic prejudices and to divert from the crux of the matter.

Injustice Well Served

Justice delayed is Justice Denied: Tabling a report of an incident which occurred 17 years earlier itself is an injustice towards the victims. The lethargy of the Indian judicial process couldn’t be anymore condemned in delaying the situations of such gravity. Obviously, if people in high offices were involved in the felony, then 17 years is ample time for them to manipulate and tamper the judicial process. Even in such cases which attracted international attention, the sluggishness would hamper the image of the country. The much-lauded independence of the judiciary is questioned and suspected by the common public due to these actions. Allowing the government to easily wash away its hands from such a huge public order turmoil would be read as a shedding of all sorts of responsibilities from the shoulders of the state to maintain public peace and order. Hence,  it would become an entity with all sets of powers to punish people without any accountability or duty to protect them. Such practices would lead to the development of dystopian states in a later period. The cyclopean view of the commission while analysing the case has led to the lack of comprehensive and objective approach towards one of the most inhumane acts in the history of the Indian republic. Obviously, it is the quality of the justice system, both in timeliness and transparency, that acts as a deterrence against the perpetuation of crime rather than the quantity of the punishment. A common occurrence in most Hindu Muslim communal riots is the presence of wealthy and affluent Muslim merchants in the location of those riots. After the riots, the Muslim community was largely displaced and their commercial prospects were significantly distorted. The commonality of sledgehammering the affluent minority class by the majority class is not surprisingly observed in the commission even after a prolonged probe. Taking strong and swift measures against all the people involved in riots is an inevitable practise which needs to be followed for protecting the secular fabric of the country and to keep it away from such bloody stains. The author is a journalism student from Tamilnadu. Views are personal.