Soon the sympathy was replaced with the dread that these migrants might carry the disease with them to other states. So they were stopped, put in isolation wards, with no food or water, so they don’t spread the virus…
But the rules don’t apply to all. Those belonging to the rich or middle class can travel around, not just that, they are even provided free government bus services to bring them back home.
Last week, some students and their families from Kota coaching classes started the hashtag #SendUsBackHome, which starts to trend. UP government promptly obliged and made arrangements to bring them back to their homes in Uttar Pradesh.
The government ordered for 200 buses to Agra and 100 buses from Jhansi to ply to Rajasthan, all buses decked with water, food, hand sanitizers, and masks for the students. Buses were to carry only 25-30 students to comply with social distancing.
The Rajasthan Chief Minister also asked other states to send buses to take students home.
One must remember Rajasthan has a few districts which are hotspots. So these students would also be possible corona carriers that the migrant workers were alleged of! This is not the first time the UP government has done this “class” act. During the first stage of lockdown, luxury buses were arranged to send 900 Gujarati tourists who were stuck in Varanasi.As the UP govt called back students of UP living in #Kota #Rajasthan, it can also be done for students from other states. Students in Kota can be sent to their home states on the consent of the concerned state govt so that these young boys & girls do not panic or feel depressed.
— Ashok Gehlot (@ashokgehlot51) April 17, 2020
Many labourers were forced to start a long March home because they did not have any means of transport to get back home.
It’s not that migrants did not spend money to return to their homes. A The Wire report reported a story about 120 migrant labourers, who had started to walk back to their home states, were stopped at Vapi. They were stopped by the police, they were offered food and water, and soon after that, they were beaten up by the police of violating the lockdown. They were then forced into water containers, which are long cylindrical containers which have to holes or ventilation. Migrants were forced to bribes to transport authorities just to be able to go back home. At least 22 migrants and kin have died of heat, hunger and exhaustion. Why no hashtags for them? Why the state could not provide any buses or them?Why the bias?
While one sympathises with anyone who wants to return home and be with their family, but why one section was thrown under the bus and the other provided luxury buses does raise uncomfortable questions? “This will open up a Pandora’s box. If you allow students, on what grounds can you stop migrant labourers who are also stuck,” Bihar Chief Secretary Deepak Kumar said in a letter to the Home Ministry urging that special permits granted by the Rajasthan government be stopped. Government policies on who gets to go back home and who has to stay is deeply entrenched in class and caste bias. State and Centre governments have been more involved in ensuring that upper-class India, 2% is comfortable during this lockdown, than the 98%. Migrant labourers, many of whom fall in the lower class and caste ladder have been largely invisibilized even as they form the backbone of urban India. Even in Pandemic, at best, they are left to fend for themselves and at worst subjected to police brutalities.


To understand why these migrants are so desperate to go home, we must first recognize the character of the migrant labour force. An International Labour Organization
are only paid when the construction season is over in lump sum, after the contractors have taken their cut. Cases of contractors disciplining workers with abuse and by holding on to wages are all too common. Dissenting workers are shunned by the contractor all together and subsequently blacklisted. For many of these workers, finding employment again is rendered impossible as most contractors know each other and often belong to similar identity-based communities.
The situation of workers in garment, food and leather factories based in slums is similar. For these workers, their workplace is also their place of stay, their issues are fundamentally different. Most live in bachelor pads where groups of upwards of 15 people are made to sleep in rooms barely 100ft
How can a centralized, weakened and top-heavy institutional apparatus cater to the needs of such workers numbering in the millions? Tracking workers and providing DBTs cannot be the only solution as these policy interventions often exclude the persons who are most desperate for survival. A plea from the state to employers of these workers, urging them to provide them with bare necessities is certainly not enough. Reducing hardworking, honest-wage earning labour into beggars lining up for handouts cannot be considered welfare. In times of such complexity, it is the civil society network that is mobilizing aid and support for such workers who have been abandoned by their employers and their government. Strengthening civil society/community-led initiatives can be a legitimate strategy for extending welfare services. Many community-based organizations have reached out to construction sites personally to hand out medicines and food.
In the name of interrogation, 8 to 9 police personnel including several plain-clothed officers arrived at the NBS office in Karawal Nagar this afternoon. Yogesh along with several others of NBS had been preparing and distributing food from the NBS office for the last two months. The police upon arrival quickly surrounded Yogesh and before anyone could intervene, he was forced into the police vehicle and taken away. None of the police officers identified themselves, nor did they provide any reason for wanting to interrogate Yogesh. Also, no information was provided regarding where he was being taken. Police did not even produce a warrant or notice. This is tantamount to abduction.
It must be noted that during the Central Government imposed lockdown to contain the Corona Virus outbreak, the actions of the Delhi Police have been disgraceful. Instead of providing relief to the countless workers trapped in the city without food or shelter, the Delhi Police has engaged in wanton brutality against workers and the violence-affected people of North East Delhi, particularly those who belong to the minority community.
Moreover, the Delhi Police has engaged in the systematic targeting of activists and students, many of whom are engaged in indispensable relief work. This is being done on the grounds that they were involved in the protests against the anti-people and communally charged Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), National Registry of Citizens (NRC) and the National Population Register (NPR) which till less than a month ago had enveloped the entire city.
News reports have indicated that over 800 persons have been arrested following the violence in North East Delhi, the bulk of whom in a mockery of justice are persons from the violence-affected minority community and activists involved the protests against the CAA, NRC, and NPR. Nonetheless, the Ministry of Home Affairs under Amit Shah has demanded the Delhi Police continue arrests “under any circumstances” despite the COVID-19 pandemic and lockdown. Consequently, the Delhi Police is using isolation and immobility caused by the lockdown to target students from Jamia Millia Islamia, members of the Jamia Coordination Committee (JCC), activists and residents of Chand Bagh, Haus Rani, Jamia Nagar, Kardampuri, Khajoori Khas, Khureji Khas, Seelampur, Shaheen Bagh, etc. Not long ago, all these areas were centres of resistance to the CAA, NRC and NPR.
Activists have been harassed via threatening phone calls, called in for interrogation and, in some cases, even taken into custody. Not only are these actions a form of state repression but they increase the risks of a COVID-19 infection. It is clear that instead of addressing the concerns being raised by the people worst affected by the pandemic and its own criminal complicity in the communal violence, the police are using a humanitarian crisis to further target and silence those who are currently involved in relief work for the worst affected. Their actions, instead of helping the people, will further aggravate the dire situation of the lakhs of daily wage workers and their families who are today bordering on starvation.
The Campaign Against State Repression (CASR) denounces these vile actions of the Delhi Police against the activists from the minority community and progressive organisations and demands the release of all persons arrested in connection with the protests against the CAA, NRC and NPR including Sharjeel Imam, Akhil Gogoi, Khalid Saifi, Soneshwar Narah, Pranab Doley, Meeran Haider and Safoora Zargar among others. CASR also demands an immediate cessation to all activities of the Delhi Police regarding the targeting of students and activists during the lockdown and the immediate release of Comrade Yogesh Swamy and all such persons detained by the Delhi Police.
Campaign Against State Repression
(Organising Team: AISA, AISF, APCR, Bhim Army, Bigul Mazdoor Dasta, BSCEM, CEM, CRPP, CTF, Disha, DISSC, DSU, DTF, IAPL, IFTU, IMK, Karnataka Janashakti, KYS, Lokpaksh, LSI, Mazdoor Adhikar Sangathan, Mazdoor Patrika, Mehnatkash Mahila Sangathan, Morcha Patrika, NAPM, NBS, NCHRO, Nowruz, NTUI, PDSU, People’s Watch, Rihai Manch, Samajwadi Janparishad, Satyashodak Sangh, SFI, United Against Hate, WSS)
Swati Chaturvedi, Kubra Sait, Reema Kagti, Farah Khan among others have spoken out against this.
There are many who have supported her Islamophobic and calling for genocide tweets but these people are themselves supporters of Muslim genocide.
There are others who support her right to freedom of speech and also since she is an acid attack survivor one should let her voice her opinions.
