Corona Chronicles: Luxury buses for Rich and long march for the poor

COVID-19 induced nationwide lockdown has put the whole country into a state of siege. Given the immense hardships that the lockdown has put on the poor, it looks like the government is not at war with the virus but with its poor and marginalised population. So, when the lockdown triggered the biggest exodus India has seen since the partition, many sighed, even sympathised with the working class, a feature unknown to the Indian elites. That did not last long!   Soon the sympathy was replaced with the dread that these migrants might carry the disease with them to other states. So they were stopped, put in isolation wards, with no food or water, so they don’t spread the virus… But the rules don’t apply to all. Those belonging to the rich or middle class can travel around, not just that, they are even provided free government bus services to bring them back home. Last week, some students and their families from Kota coaching classes started the hashtag #SendUsBackHome, which starts to trend. UP government promptly obliged and made arrangements to bring them back to their homes in Uttar Pradesh. The government ordered for 200 buses to Agra and 100 buses from Jhansi to ply to Rajasthan, all buses decked with water, food, hand sanitizers, and masks for the students. Buses were to carry only 25-30 students to comply with social distancing. The Rajasthan Chief Minister also asked other states to send buses to take students home.   One must remember Rajasthan has a few districts which are hotspots. So these students would also be possible corona carriers that the migrant workers were alleged of! This is not the first time the UP government has done this “class” act. During the first stage of lockdown, luxury buses were arranged to send 900 Gujarati tourists who were stuck in Varanasi.

Many labourers were forced to start a long March home because they did not have any means of transport to get back home.

It’s not that migrants did not spend money to return to their homes. A The Wire report reported a story about 120 migrant labourers, who had started to walk back to their home states, were stopped at Vapi. They were stopped by the police, they were offered food and water, and soon after that, they were beaten up by the police of violating the lockdown. They were then forced into water containers, which are long cylindrical containers which have to holes or ventilation. Migrants were forced to bribes to transport authorities just to be able to go back home. At least 22 migrants and kin have died of heat, hunger and exhaustion. Why no hashtags for them? Why the state could not provide any buses or them?

Why the bias?

While one sympathises with anyone who wants to return home and be with their family, but why one section was thrown under the bus and the other provided luxury buses does raise uncomfortable questions? “This will open up a Pandora’s box. If you allow students, on what grounds can you stop migrant labourers who are also stuck,” Bihar Chief Secretary Deepak Kumar said in a letter to the Home Ministry urging that special permits granted by the Rajasthan government be stopped. Government policies on who gets to go back home and who has to stay is deeply entrenched in class and caste bias. State and Centre governments have been more involved in ensuring that upper-class India, 2% is comfortable during this lockdown, than the 98%. Migrant labourers, many of whom fall in the lower class and caste ladder have been largely invisibilized even as they form the backbone of urban India. Even in Pandemic, at best, they are left to fend for themselves and at worst subjected to police brutalities.
Migrants trying to get home at the beginning of lockdown at Anand Vihar bus stand, Delhi
While the blame mostly lies with the governments, they also act on the conscience of society. Many who supported the Kota students hashtags could have started #BringBackTheMigrants hashtags. But they didn’t! They didn’t run any social media campaigns to put pressure on the governments to arrange buses for them or adequate food and shelter. The state has wilfully blocked the needs of the migrants because the migrants are the under-belly of the system. Their rights are disposable, much like their bodies and their identities for the state. The numbers at Delhi´s Anand Vihar bus stand and Mumbai´s Bandra do not lie. They might not have twitter hashtags to show their plight to the Chief Minister or Prime Minister office but the visuals of how India has ignored its poor to cater for a few Richie riches are for the whole world to see.

Bhima Koregaon case: 40 eminent poets including Gulzar write open letter demanding poet Varavara Rao’s release

0

Invisible and Unreached- Migrants remain on the fringes of Welfare Response

The Prime Minister of India, Mr. Narendra Modi, declared a countrywide lockdown on 24th March 2020. This lockdown, one of the largest in human history, was issued in wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. Out of 1.3 billion people, the poorest and the most vulnerable were scornfully overlooked, as if the precariousness of their existence was of their own making. 

Urban Poor and Precarious Work Environment

With the sudden stoppage of all public transport, production activities, markets, and private enterprises, the invisible underbelly of the city exploded onto the streets, highways, bus and railway stations. The millions of migrants that keep the Indian economy and its urbane affluence afloat were left with no money, shelter, food, and means of survival. Most were forced to choose between the horrors of launching on an impossibly long march to their village homes or languishing in the labyrinth of the urban slum squalor, cut off from the bare necessities essential for survival. Migrants were left bereft, forced to improvise in the face of absolute deprivation and precarity. Some desperate souls entrusted their fates to the dark and musty crevices of transport vehicles, hiding under cartons of vegetables, fruits, and other essential goods, while some were stuffed in milk tankers and trailers. 20 migrant labourers have perished in this exodus, unforeseen by the country since its partition in 47. migrantTo understand why these migrants are so desperate to go home, we must first recognize the character of the migrant labour force. An International Labour Organization report published in 2017 concluded that 92% of India’s workforce is in some or the other form of informal employment. This form of employment entails no social security, little to no job security and no juridical proof of employment. Each informal worker embodies multiple identities due to the precarity of their work. They can be agricultural workers for a few months in a year and urban informal workers for the rest. The Stranded Workers Action Network recently published a report based on their rapid assessment of 11,159 workers in which 79 percent of the sampled workers were daily wage factory/construction workers.  Such workers frequently move from their villages to urban areas following swells and troughs in labour demand cycles. As employment prospects in villages dwindle post-harvest, urban infrastructural development begins post-monsoon. This coinciding rise and fall in labour demand ensure that surplus labour is always present, driving the individual cost of each labourer well below minimum wage. When migrant informal workers enter the urban economy, most of them are absorbed by the construction industry. The construction industry is known the world over for its brutality and umpteen profitability, with one factor constantly reinforcing the character of the other. Following a long chain of subcontracting, wages are reduced to a mere trickle by the time they reach the migrant workforce on the very bottom. Due to subcontracting, administrative and labour costs are reduced substantially while also ensuring the workforce remains highly competitive, productive and profitable.  It is also important to recognize that the relations between the labour and their thekedars (contractors) is not a typical capitalist-proletariat relation, but is, in fact, feudal. Feudal labour relations imply that ‘wages’ are notional and promissory. Workers depend on the contractors for provisioning food, shelter and basic services. A nominal subsistence daily wage is given to the workers which is a fraction of the promised wages while hiring. Many workers are only paid when the construction season is over in lump sum, after the contractors have taken their cut. Cases of contractors disciplining workers with abuse and by holding on to wages are all too common. Dissenting workers are shunned by the contractor all together and subsequently blacklisted. For many of these workers, finding employment again is rendered impossible as most contractors know each other and often belong to similar identity-based communities.  These workers do not live in slums but rather live inside construction labour colonies located inside construction sites. These colonies are characterized by tiny huts or tin sheds, often compartmentalized for multiple families by hanging saris. Workers in these colonies are completely cut-off from mainstream society as most construction sites are barricaded with high fences and marked as private properties. The workers are often dependent on their contractors for water, sanitation, and electricity. Provisioning of these is liable to construction commencing unobstructed. With all construction activities on hiatus, living on such construction sites is rendered impossible. Distribution of grains cannot sustain these workers as many single men depend on canteens for food. Those who migrate with their families cook by procuring groceries in small amounts daily as storage provisions are often absent, largely because such colonies are often infested with rats. The situation of workers in garment, food and leather factories based in slums is similar. For these workers, their workplace is also their place of stay, their issues are fundamentally different. Most live in bachelor pads where groups of upwards of 15 people are made to sleep in rooms barely 100ft2 in size. Such workers stick out like a sore thumb in the city because they are easily recognized as outsiders. Negotiating with police for permissions and competing with established slum dwellers for handouts is challenging for such workers since they do not speak the local language, they cannot navigate the city well and they are often treated harshly due to their alien status. Most of these workers are not registered either and they often do not own bank accounts or possess ration cards. 

Strengthen Community initiatives for local welfare programs 

migrantHow can a centralized, weakened and top-heavy institutional apparatus cater to the needs of such workers numbering in the millions? Tracking workers and providing DBTs cannot be the only solution as these policy interventions often exclude the persons who are most desperate for survival. A plea from the state to employers of these workers, urging them to provide them with bare necessities is certainly not enough. Reducing hardworking, honest-wage earning labour into beggars lining up for handouts cannot be considered welfare. In times of such complexity, it is the civil society network that is mobilizing aid and support for such workers who have been abandoned by their employers and their government. Strengthening civil society/community-led initiatives can be a legitimate strategy for extending welfare services. Many community-based organizations have reached out to construction sites personally to hand out medicines and food. With large hearts, immense sensitivity and a capacity to share whatever little that could be spared, the poor have made the poor’s survival possible. This is the true nature of our society, where service and a will to help reach beyond class, caste, creed, religion, and gender. Unfortunately, the state continues taking these efforts either for granted or tramples on them with Draconian laws and policies. Greater sensitivity, non-interference, and cooperation from state authorities become pertinent in such desperate times, but it seems even this is a little too much to ask for. The lockdown extension announced on March 14th came as another severe blow to the urban poor’s underbelly. The fortunate who had received food donations keeping March 14th as the lockdown deadline in mind have been suddenly left stranded with supplies nearing exhaustion yet again.   

#SuspendBabitaPhogat trends on twitter as a reaction to Phogat’s Islamophobic tweet

0
Babita Phogat is an Indian Common Wealth Gold medalist wrestler. She joined BJP in August 2019 ahead of Lok Sabha Elections later and contested the Haryana assembly election on BJP ticket in 2019 but lost. She has been very vocal on Twitter and regularly tweets against Muslims and “anti-nationals” demanding that “they should be sent to Pakistan”. Since the Tablighi conference came into news and rise in number of cases blamed on the conference, its been a riot for Modi Bhakts. Its their chance to show their Islamophobia in full display. Babita Phogat also jumped into the Bhakt stream and put some hateful tweets against Muslims. Image On 2nd of April, Babita tweeted “It might have spread because of bats there but here it has spread because of ‘ignorant pigs’ #NizamuddinIdiots” Phogat was referring to Muslims in her tweet This tweet was taken down by twitter. But this did not stop Phogat’s Islamophobia. On 15th of April Phogat tweeted “Coronavirus is India’s second-biggest problem. Ignorant Jamati’s are still at number one. #jahiljamati.” After this tweet #SuspendBabitaphogat started trending on Twitter. Many people came to twitter calling out her Islamophobic tweet and asking twitter to suspend her account. On Friday Babita Phogat put out a video in which she says she is not scared of the trolls and will not sit quietly, I am the real Babita Phogat. She says she wrote about those who spread the virus and will not stop speaking the truth. She also said if Tablighi Jamaat had not happened then the lockdown would have been lifted and coronavirus would have left the country. Clearly this counts for fake news and hate-mongering and she joins a long list of BJP supporters who are hell-bent on blaming the outbreak on the Tablighi Jamaat instead of the government. Who initiated the lockdown only 50 days after the first case of the virus was reported. This comes a day after Rangoli Chandel’s twitter was suspended for her islamophobic tweets. Babita Phogat had lent support to Chandel for her “honesty”. She tweeted. “Today Rangoli Chandel didi stepped on someone’s tail. These days twitter is also scared of those who write the truth. #RangoliChandel”    

Kannada channel, Public TV served notice for false presentation of “Helicopter Money” with PM Modi

Indians are not just battling Coronavirus but also fake news and misinformation campaigns on TV and social media. Modi Bhakts in media are not leaving any stone unturned to show how Modi is winning the Corona war. For mainstream news channels, everything Modi does is either a Masterstroke or a surgical strike! even if its a wrong concept or just fake news. One such case happened on a Kannada news channel, Public TV. On 15th April 2020, Kannada news channel Public TV showed a report called `Helicopter Money´ where it showed that to counter the economic downturn due to the pandemic Modi government will throw money from a helicopter. The report not only presented wrong information about “what PM Modi plans to do” but gave a wrong interpretation of the concept of “helicopter Money”. For this false presentation of the show, Public TV news channel has received a notice from the Press Information Bureau of India (PIB), under the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting for their show on ‘helicopter money’ in which the channel speculated if money would be thrown to the needy from helicopters. The notice from PIB is as follows- “On April 15 Public TV broadcasted “HELICOPTER MONEY- Helicopternalli surithara Modi” (will Modi throw from the helicopter?) at 8.30 PM, which is false, mischievous, and deliberate. (It) clearly violates the Broadcasting Code and Rules. When the whole country is fighting the COVID-19, your channel, instead of creating awareness and educating the public, (is) spreading false information, creating panic and social unrest. In view of the above serious violation of Cable Television Networks(Regulation) Act, 1995 and Rules, you are hereby directed to show cause why your channel should not be taken out of air immediately.” Such kind of reporting and news pieces can create panic and anxiety among people and undo the regulations of lockdown. Additionally, PIB also tweeted saying the ‘government is going to do no such thing’.

What is Helicopter Money?

The term Helicopter money was first coined by American Economist Milton Friedman. It involves government printing large amount of money and distributing it to the public. It is meant to bring sagging economy back on track. It is an unconventional monetary policy, where Central Bank directly increase the money supply and distribute new cash to the population with the aim to boost demand and inflation. The idea has been circulating in government and in TV news channels since Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrashekhar Rao suggested this concept during the PM Modi meetings with chief ministers.

Public TV, Helicopter money and PM Modi

Public TV which is famous for being pro-BJP and staunch supporter of PM Modi showed a report on Helicopter money. In the video, the news anchor asked the question- Will Modi throw money from helicopters? The anchor explains the concept of helicopter money as literally throwing money from the helicopters. Although in practice, the money will be sent to the bank accounts of the needy people. This is not the first time that Public TV has given in to such exaggerations. During the time of Demonetisation, Public TV Editor-in-chief HR Ranganath did a show extolling the benefits of the new 2000 Rs currency note claiming that the new note has a nanochip so it can be sued to trace black money. Hence it is a masterstroke by PM Modi!  

Condemn the arbitrary detention of Youth Activist Yogesh Swamy!

0
Yesterday, in the most brazen manner, the Delhi Police’s Special Cell has picked up a young activist Yogesh Swamy. A national vice president of Naujawan Bharat Sabha (NBS) and member of Bigul Mazdoor Dasta, Yogesh was picked up from Karawal Nagar where he has been providing relief to people affected by the February 2020 violence and those suffering from a lack of food and other essential supplies during the ongoing lockdown. Yogesh SwamyIn the name of interrogation, 8 to 9 police personnel including several plain-clothed officers arrived at the NBS office in Karawal Nagar this afternoon. Yogesh along with several others of NBS had been preparing and distributing food from the NBS office for the last two months. The police upon arrival quickly surrounded Yogesh and before anyone could intervene, he was forced into the police vehicle and taken away. None of the police officers identified themselves, nor did they provide any reason for wanting to interrogate Yogesh. Also, no information was provided regarding where he was being taken. Police did not even produce a warrant or notice. This is tantamount to abduction. It must be noted that during the Central Government imposed lockdown to contain the Corona Virus outbreak, the actions of the Delhi Police have been disgraceful. Instead of providing relief to the countless workers trapped in the city without food or shelter, the Delhi Police has engaged in wanton brutality against workers and the violence-affected people of North East Delhi, particularly those who belong to the minority community. Moreover, the Delhi Police has engaged in the systematic targeting of activists and students, many of whom are engaged in indispensable relief work. This is being done on the grounds that they were involved in the protests against the anti-people and communally charged Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), National Registry of Citizens (NRC) and the National Population Register (NPR) which till less than a month ago had enveloped the entire city. News reports have indicated that over 800 persons have been arrested following the violence in North East Delhi, the bulk of whom in a mockery of justice are persons from the violence-affected minority community and activists involved the protests against the CAA, NRC, and NPR. Nonetheless, the Ministry of Home Affairs under Amit Shah has demanded the Delhi Police continue arrests “under any circumstances” despite the COVID-19 pandemic and lockdown. Consequently, the Delhi Police is using isolation and immobility caused by the lockdown to target students from Jamia Millia Islamia, members of the Jamia Coordination Committee (JCC), activists and residents of Chand Bagh, Haus Rani, Jamia Nagar, Kardampuri, Khajoori Khas, Khureji Khas, Seelampur, Shaheen Bagh, etc. Not long ago, all these areas were centres of resistance to the CAA, NRC and NPR. Activists have been harassed via threatening phone calls, called in for interrogation and, in some cases, even taken into custody. Not only are these actions a form of state repression but they increase the risks of a COVID-19 infection. It is clear that instead of addressing the concerns being raised by the people worst affected by the pandemic and its own criminal complicity in the communal violence, the police are using a humanitarian crisis to further target and silence those who are currently involved in relief work for the worst affected. Their actions, instead of helping the people, will further aggravate the dire situation of the lakhs of daily wage workers and their families who are today bordering on starvation. The Campaign Against State Repression (CASR) denounces these vile actions of the Delhi Police against the activists from the minority community and progressive organisations and demands the release of all persons arrested in connection with the protests against the CAA, NRC and NPR including Sharjeel Imam, Akhil Gogoi, Khalid Saifi, Soneshwar Narah, Pranab Doley, Meeran Haider and Safoora Zargar among others. CASR also demands an immediate cessation to all activities of the Delhi Police regarding the targeting of students and activists during the lockdown and the immediate release of Comrade Yogesh Swamy and all such persons detained by the Delhi Police. Campaign Against State Repression (Organising Team: AISA, AISF, APCR, Bhim Army, Bigul Mazdoor Dasta, BSCEM, CEM, CRPP, CTF, Disha, DISSC, DSU, DTF, IAPL, IFTU, IMK, Karnataka Janashakti, KYS, Lokpaksh, LSI, Mazdoor Adhikar Sangathan, Mazdoor Patrika, Mehnatkash Mahila Sangathan, Morcha Patrika, NAPM, NBS, NCHRO, Nowruz, NTUI, PDSU, People’s Watch, Rihai Manch, Samajwadi Janparishad, Satyashodak Sangh, SFI, United Against Hate, WSS) This post was originally published in Counter Currents

Trump decision to stop WHO funding, Ill-timed and Immoral

1
US President Donald Trump ignored the COVID-19 pandemic for more than two months has suddenly woken up to the seriousness of the disease that has left more than 34,000 fatalities in the US alone. Now to overcompensate for his ignorance and idiocy he is behaving like a typical bully. What started as a blame game accusing China of causing the Pandemic changed into bullying India into clearing the export of Hydroxyquinone or expect retaliation has shifted its finger to the World Health Organisation (WHO). On April 15th Trump announced that US will halt funds to World Health Organisation (WHO) and accused the organization of mismanaging the COVID-19 pandemic and conspiring with china to suppress important information related to the Pandemic. Trump has alleged that WHO endorsed the idea in early mid-January that “human to human transmission was not happening in spite of reports and clear evidence to the contrary and the delay in declaring it as a public emergency cost the US valuable time”. The US contribution to the WHO’s annual budget of 5.6 billion dollars is 900 million dollars. Though Trump has not specified the amount that will be stopped, this decision has to pass the US Congress to come into effect.

Widespread Condemnation

Trump’s statements since the beginning of the Pandemic have drawn sharp criticism. Many believe that the United States government is trying to politicizing the WHO, the organization which does so much vital and important humanitarian work around the world. Especially at a time when their work is needed the most in the poorer countries. The leaders of the World Health Organization have warned that such a decision could result in a lot of deaths. The WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has warned that such statements might lead to more death.  He said- “Please do not politicize this virus. It exploits the differences you have at the national level. If you want to be exploited and if you want to have many more body bags then you do it” Meanwhile, the ruling party the Republicans and the US Congress have also announced that they plan to have a congressional probe to investigate China for its role and possible culpability in the spread of coronavirus. Conjectures are being made that Trump administration and republicans plan to blame China and the WHO for the spread of Pandemic after themselves failing to tackle the Pandemic spread and resulting deaths in US. The latest move to halt funding to WHO will be the first step towards the “investigation” that would put the blame on China for the COVID-19 crisis. The death toll in US refuses to slow down with New York city resorting to mass graves. Instead of providing better healthcare to its population the US President chooses to bellow at other countries and world organisations. This is nothing but diversion tactic on part of Trump administration. To counter the claims of Trump administration, WHO and Beijing officials have released a timeline providing step by step information about how the pandemic was dealt from December onwards which show coordination and cooperation between Chinese officials and international bodies. WHO is a well renowned organisation that does humanitarian works around the world and Trump administration accusing it of being complicit with China in this pandemic is not just ill times but immoral. The management of COVID-19 needs all hands on the deck, all countries irrespective of their differences to come together, blame games, cover ups and investigations can wait for the time being.

Kangana´s Sister´s Rangoli Chandel´s account Suspended from Twitter for spreading hate

Kangana Ranaut’s sister, Rangoli Chandel’s twitter account has been suspended after she posted a tweet that encouraged violence against Muslims. Indian twitter blew up with many condemning her tweet. Swati Chaturvedi, Kubra Sait, Reema Kagti, Farah Khan among others have spoken out against this. Once the twitter account was suspended, designer Farah Khan Ali shared this. Soon after her account was suspended, she shared an official statement saying “Twitter is an American platform absolutely biased and anti-India, you can make fun of Hindu Gods call Prime Minister and Home Minister terrorists but if you say anything about people pelting stones on health workers and Police forces they suspend your account, I have no desire of empowering any such platforms with my perspective and honest opinions, so I am not reviving my account. I was my sister’s spokesperson now watch out for her direct interviews, she is a huge star she has many ways of reaching out, a biased platform can be easily avoided.” Rangoli Chandel and her sister actress Kangana Ranaut are known for their love and support for Narendra Modi and his government. She regularly tweets praising everything that BJP and PM Modi´s does. She had tweeted, when the BJP government won the elections in 2019 “Today no party, no individual won, today is that historic day when India won. We are very fortunate to have a leader like @narendramodi ji in our times, this is the beginning of a new era, time to break free and regain our lost glory…. Bharat Mata ki Jai ….Jai Hind” and her sister Kangana Ranaut had made tea and pakodas in celebration of Modi’s win. Kangana Ranaut has also said she is a big fan of Modi. Both the sisters are quite vocal on social as well as public platforms in not just her support but in vilifying any kind of opposition against him. She also regularly calls for critics of BJP and whom she deems “anti-national”. Rangoli Chandel who claims to be managing her sister Kangana Ranaut twitter handle is not new to controversies. She has taken to attacking people who do not appreciate her sister Kangana´s movies as well as BJP. Sometimes its difficult to differentiate if she is Kangana spokesperson or part of BJP IT troll team. Earlier this week, she called for suspending the 2024 Lok Sabha election given the economic crisis India is facing during the pandemic and let Modiji be the PM without elections. She calls this idea `revolutionary´ There are many who have supported her Islamophobic and calling for genocide tweets but these people are themselves supporters of Muslim genocide. There are others who support her right to freedom of speech and also since she is an acid attack survivor one should let her voice her opinions.  

Barack Obama endorses Joe Biden as the next US president

Former US president Barack Obama has endorsed Joe Biden for the 2020 presidential election through a video message. Obama also showered praise on his old friend and also acknowledges the message of his rival Bernie Sanders’ campaign. His endorsement comes at the same time as progressive candidate Bernie Sanders, who withdrew from the presidential race a few days ago, also endorsed the Biden campaign thus removing the last formidable opposition for Biden to become the official presidential nominee of the Democratic party. In supporting Biden the former president also endorsed the core message of the Sanders’ campaign. Calling Joe as someone who would ‘get stuff done’, he said that he had always shared a conviction with Bernie Sanders that “..we have to make America a more fairer, more just and more equitable society.” He also supported one of the major demands of the Sanders’ campaign which was Medicare for All, calling for the expansion of Medicare and that it should not just be made “a right, but a reality for all”. Although the former president who still enjoys massive public appeal, four year after leaving office, had not shown his support to any of the half a dozen democratic presidential candidates, his endorsement for Joe Biden does not come as a surprise to many. Biden was Obama’s Vice President and they had become close friends during their tenure. In his message, Obama said that making Biden his VP was one of his best decisions. Both during the latest democratic primary and before, Bernie Sanders’ campaign has always received a high level of support from young and working class people, the same category of Americans who had wholeheartedly supported Barack Obama in 2008. By appealing to them Obama is trying to rally a large progressive and mainstream alliance behind Joe Biden who does not have the same appeal as Sanders or Obama. Obama spoke of “The ideas” Bernie Sanders has championed, saying that “..the energy and enthusiasm he inspires especially in young people will be critical in moving America in a direction of progress and hope”. He urged the democratic party to be bold in rebuilding the economy and do more than just tinkering around the edges. He also acknowledged the vast inequalities that existed even before the Covid19 pandemic and that there was a need for real structural changes in the society. In the past, Obama’s similar appeal to the progressive minded and working class voters to support Hillary Clinton for the 2016 presidential election did not bear fruit as many among the working class instead voted for Donald Trump, and many supporters of Bernie Sanders also did not comply as they felt cheated by the Democratic party as it had openly favoured Clinton over Sanders even though he was the only candidate who had the best chance of defeating Donald Trump.

MP: Muslims cremate Hindu neighbour in COVID-19 lockdown

The COVID-19 curfew broke down religious barriers in Madhya Pradesh’s Bhopal city, after Muslims helped perform the last rites of their Hindu neighbour, whose relatives were unable to make it to the funeral. In a display of harmony during this unprecedented crisis, Muslim residents of Teela Jamalpura locality in the old city, carried the body of their 50-year-old neighbour, who succumbed to a liver ailment on Wednesday. “The woman died while undergoing treatment for a liver ailment in the early hours of Wednesday. And since none of her close relatives were around because of the lockdown, we took her body to the cremation ground at Chhola Vishraghat,” Shahid Khan, who made all the funeral arrangements, told PTI. The deceased woman’s husband Mohan Namdeo is a small-time vendor and the couple has two sons, he said. “The family is poor and the woman was ailing for a long time and died at government-run Hamidia Hospital,” he said. People were mindful that only 20 persons could participate in the funeral as per lockdown norms, or else the entire community would have shown up for the last rites, he said. Videos of Muslim men, wearing masks and skull caps, carrying the woman’s body on their shoulders to the cremation ground, were shared on social media. A similar initiative was taken by Muslim men in Indore earlier this month. Former Chief Minister Kamal Nath praised members of the Muslim community, saying such acts of humanity strengthen communal harmony, love and brotherhood.