Umar Khalid Bail Plea Rejected by Delhi High court

0
The Delhi High Court on Tuesday denied bail to Umar Khalid in the 2020 Delhi Riots case.  A division bench of Justice Siddharth Mridul and Rajnish Bhatnagar passed the order. “We don’t find any merit in bail appeal, appeal is dismissed,” the Court ordered. Khalid had approached the High Court challenging the dismissal of his bail application by the Karkardooma court in March this year. The Court had reserved its verdict on September 9 after hearing arguments from Senior Advocate Trideep Pais and Special Public Prosecutor Amit Prasad. The arguments in the High Court went on for more than 20 days. He was arrested by the Delhi Police in September 2020 and charged with criminal conspiracy, rioting, unlawful assembly as well as several sections of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA). He has remained in jail since then. He was speaking against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and National Register of Citizens (NRC). The bench relied on Umar Khalid presence in several WhatsApp groups which were formed for the purpose of coordinating protests against Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and National Register of Citizens (NRC). It further observed that a Whatsapp group “CAB TEAM” was formed consequently on December 8, 2019, whose members included Sharjeel Imam, Umar Khalid, Yogender Yadav, Nadeem Khan, Khalid Saifi. Arguments on Khalid’s bail had started in April. During the very first hearing, the judges remarked that they found his speech at Amravati obnoxious and inciteful. The judges also said that the speech might be innocuous in isolation, but could have been a bugle call for something larger.

Lula Vs Bolsonaro: Will this be the last Brazilian election?

0
On 2 October, the Brazilian elections were held. Polls predict that Former President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, representing the Brazil of Hope alliance will emerge as the new President, beating out incumbent President Jair Bolsonaro. The election is important for the entire world. In an era where climate change has become a critical issue, Brazil, as home to the Amazon rainforests will play a critical role in protecting the world from the effects of climate change. A victory by Lula would be the latest in the third Pink Wave victories. Brazil’s swing to the left would be a major victory for progressive politics in Latin America. The election would also be a swing away from the pro-military politics of Bolsonaro, which is critical in maintaining democracy in Brazil. The election will be held in two rounds. If no candidate secures more than 50% of the vote, there will be a second round run-off election to determine the winner. Most predictions show a win for Lula.

Bolsonaro tells supporters to resist election results

The election has become even more complicated when on 7 September 2022, Bolsonaro alarmed the world with two inflammatory speeches. He told his followers to take to the streets and protest if he is not voted back to power in the next election. These speeches were made in Brasilia (the nation’s capital) and Sao Paulo (the largest city in Brazil). In these speeches, Bolsonaro began spreading conspiracy theories saying that the elections are being fixed against him. He claimed that the Electronic Voting Machines were rigged against him. He would be ready to use the military to protect his position. He threatened Supreme Court Chief Justice Luiz Fux and said that he does not respect judgements by the Supreme Court. He also said that only God could remove him from office, and he would only leave office dead or arrested, but he will never be arrested. Each demonstration was attended by 1-2 lakh people, and many smaller cities in Brazil also saw demonstrations by Bolsonaro supporters.
Bolsonaro Protests
Brazil’s President Jair Bolsonaro. Source: REUTERS/Adriano Machado

Democracy or Military

Brazil has been under military rule since 1964 after an American-sponsored coup d’état. The military regime was brutal. The army relied on torture to suppress political dissidents. They received training from the American and British governments and used their training to root out communist elements in Brazil. Even after the transition to democracy, the Brazilian Armed Forces remain a powerful force in the government. The Brazilian military still controls many leadership positions within the state. Many of the reforms after the transition left the police and the armed forces untouched. Brazil has the second largest Army in the Americas, only after the United States. Like the United States, the military has strong economic ties with the police. To justify their presence, starting from the 1980s, Brazil’s armed forces, and later police, changed focus from cracking down on communists, to cracking down on drug gangs. Since the return to democracy, Brazilian police have begun to use military-level equipment and receive military training. Among former colonies, most militaries were formed to control the local population, not to protect the country from enemies. In some cases, the military occupies a small section of the country and remains an occupying force. In some cases, the military is part of the state. In some cases, the military stands waiting to take over the government in times of instability. When achieving independence, many independence leaders have tried different strategies to manage the volatility a strong military can pose. Sometimes they have been successful in establishing control by a civilian government, but not always.

If the military is a threat to democracy, then who supports the Military?

Support from the military comes from two directions. First, internationally, colonizing powers find militaries easier to negotiate with than civilian governments. Within a country, military regimes get support from the rich and middle classes. Military governments, and promilitary politicians like Bolsonaro, are usually pro-corporate and get a lot of support from corporate-owned media. The propaganda from corporate-owned media can swing support from the masses in times of elections. Even if the population is aware of the dangers of such right-wing leaders, media messaging makes certain types of debates and nuances impossible. Subtle differences of opinion in the population can be manipulated to make progressive candidates appear monstrous. Repeated messages can be used to excite fears. For those who support left-wing politicians, such messages can lose confidence. For those who support right-wing politicians, such messages can give confidence.
The Brazilian Army Command presents the military contingent that will work on the security of the 2013 FIFA Confederations Cup in Brasilia on June 13, 2013. The security forces will be formed personnel from the Army and the Paramilitary Police. AFP PHOTO/Beto BARATA. (Photo credit should read BETO BARATA/AFP/Getty Images)
Bolsonaro also has strong support from the Brazilian middle class. Many see him as a source of stability. Despite his horrific mishandling of the COVID19 Pandemic, political and economic scandals before the Pandemic, and his clear mishandling of the economy, his macho and aggressive style appeals to a group of people who do not want to make compromises on their social position. Even if they are a technical minority, Bolsanro has managed to get lakhs of people to come to his rallies, and millions to support him. Though he is behind Lula in the polls, he is still expected to have gotten 30-40% of the vote. Bolsonaro has strong support among religious voters, who see him as a conservative force. As a pro-military candidate, Bolsanaro is seen as hard on drug use and a symbol of traditional values. Playing into the frustrations of the middle class, Bolsanaro has also promoted many conspiracy theories to explain discrepancies in his policies and behaviour, making him impossible to pin down.

A Tense Future

Across the world, when the ultra-right wing party comes to power through elections, progressives ask if that would spell the end of democracy. Given Bolsanaro’s closeness to the military and the massive showing at his rallies, the future is worrying. Author is a mathematician and political observer based in Bangalore. 

Karnataka: RSS permitted to organise Camps in Moraji Desai Schools, Dalit Organisations Protest

0
Bidar: The union of Dalit Organisations protested against permissions being granted to conduct RSS camps in several Moraji Desai schools across Karnataka administered by the Department of Social Welfare. They protested at the office of the District Commissioner and demanded that such permissions granted must be repealed with immediate effect. A 9-day Sangh Parivar training camp is being organised at Kamta’s Moraji Residential School. The Dalit leaders alleged that the students are deliberately misguided in the name of Co-Curricular activities. Ex-minister Bandeppa Kashempura has also voiced against the conduct of RSS camps within schools. “The RSS which used to conduct its camps elsewhere have now started entering government schools and are troubling students’ education” he alleged.

What is the camp about?

The Minister of Social Welfare Department, Kota Srinivasa Pujari had granted permissions to organise camps in the month of October at Moraji Residential Schools that aimed to, “Inculcate amongst boys and youth, through Physical-Mental and Personality development, ideas about Yogasana and thinking about the nation.” It is alleged that the RSS has obtained permissions in the garb of training youth in Yogasana and inculcating thinking about the nation. State SFI General Secretary Vasudeva Reddy stated that “The Minister himself handing over the government schools to RSS functionaries for the conduct of RSS camps is a move to convert schools into RSS Training Camps, which is highly condemnable.” In the camp being organized by Prerna Pratishthana based in Kolar, Hindu Sanghatan activists from Chikkaballapura and Bengaluru Rural districts are participating. Apart from Kolar, the camp began on October 7th at the the Moraji Desai Residential School in Sirasi taluk of Uttara Kannada district.

Karnataka Hijab ban: Supreme Court bench delivers Split Judgment

0
The Supreme Court on Thursday delivered a split verdict in the challenge to the Karnataka government order (GO) effectively empowering government colleges in the State to ban the wearing of hijab by Muslim girl students in college campus [Aishat Shifa vs State of Karnataka]. Justice Hemant Gupta who headed the bench upheld the government decision while Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia struck it down. “There is divergence of opinion. I have held against the appellant. I dismiss the appeal,” Justice Gupta said. Justice Dhulia, however, allowed the appeal and quashed the Karnataka government order. “One thing which was topmost (priority) for me was education of girl child. A girl child in (many) areas does household work and chores before going to school and are we making her life any better by doing this (banning hijab),” Justice Dhulia said. Consequently, the matter will now be heard by a larger bench of the top court. “In view of divergent opinion, let the matter be placed before the Chief Justice India of for appropriate directions,” the bench directed. A girl child in (many) areas does household work and chores before going to school and are we making her life any better by doing this (banning hijab). Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia Justice Gupta, in his judgment, framed eleven questions. He held that wearing hijab is not a part of essential religious practice (ERP) under Islam and the State government order serves the purpose of access to education. He, therefore, dismissed the appeals. Justice Dhulia, however, held that venturing into ERP was not needed and the High Court adopted a wrong approach. “It was just a question of choice. I have held the ratio in Bijoy Emmanuel squarely covers the case,” Justice Dhulia ruled.

Hijab Ban: Muslim Girls Deprived of Right to Education, says PUCL Report

The challenge before the Supreme Court is against a Karnataka High Court decision from March 15 upholding the Karnataka government order. The Karnataka High Court had on March 15 upheld a Karnataka government order (GO) effectively empowering college development committees of government colleges in the State to ban the wearing of the Islamic headscarf in college campuses. The petitioners – Muslim girl students from various colleges in Karnataka – had approached the High Court after they were denied permission to attend classes on account of wearing hijab. A three-judge Bench of then Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi and Justices Krishna S Dixit and JM Khazi held that: – Hijab is not a part of essential religious practices of Islam; – Requirement of uniform is a reasonable restriction on the fundamental right to freedom of expression under Article 19(1)(a); – The government has the power to pass the GO; no case is made out for its invalidation. One of the pleas before the top court argued that the High Court “failed to note that the right to wear a Hijab comes under the ambit of ‘expression’ and is thus protected under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.” It is also contended that the High Court failed to take note of the fact that the right to wear Hijab comes under the ambit of the right to privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. With regard to uniform, the pleas state that the Karnataka Education Act, 1983, and the Rules made under the same, do not provide for any mandatory uniform to be worn by students.

Prohibition, A Public Policy Disaster in Manipur: How and Why

0
While it has been a trend for some time, but particularly consequent upon the Government’s decision to lift Prohibition, Manipur is right now in a situation of public policy disaster. Under this, the government has failed to convince the people about rationale of the decision; in fact, it has utterly failed to articulate one. There is mass resentment, mass protest and mass anguish. On the other hand, the inefficiency of the government and inability to frame a policy by following the principles of policy formulation have been critically exposed. A kind of social pessimism has been generated in a context of rising unemployment and price increases. First, it has been established beyond doubt that the decision to lift Prohibition is not a product of deliberated and shared discussions within the government. The Draft Liquor Policy is a sure testimony of this lack of shared deliberation and articulation to mature a will of the government. Second, the decision is not founded on discussions with Experts has been established beyond doubt despite the colossal claims of the government. There is no sign in either the initial announcement of the decision or the Draft Policy document of the government having consulted any “independent, non–interest-based, non-profit organizations that produce and principally rely on expertise and ideas to obtain support and to influence the policymaking process.” If any such consultation had taken place, there definitely would have been reflections of the values and morality behind the decision at least in the draft policy document coming as it does as a response to the public outcry against the decision and the heightened social pessimism spirit on the government. Now it is fairly established that the decision to lift prohibition was neither a product of the application of mind by the government as a holistic machinery nor an outcome of consultation with a think-tank. In this background, I recall an interesting book titled Special Interest Politics by two leading contemporary Economists, Grossman and Helpman (MIT, 2001). They define Special Interest Group as: “An interest group may be considered ‘‘special’’ if its members covet policies that would not be considered desirable by the average citizen. Thus, any minority group of citizens that shares identifiable characteristics and similar concerns on some set of issues might be termed a SIG. . …… We ask, From what features of the political landscape do special interest groups derive their power and influence? What determines the extent to which they are able to affect policy outcomes?” It is a group in society which try “to gain favourable treatment from the government based only on their voting behaviour.” This is “any identifiable group of voters with similar preferences on a subset of policy issues.” In the absence of any sign of shared government commitment and consultations with Expert groups, there is every fear if the recent decision has been the outcome of pressure by some Special Interest Groups. Special Interest Groups are present in every polity, but the issue is why it has gone wrong in the recent case in Manipur. We all are aware of the social struggle of the 1970s and 1980s to have Prohibition in Manipur. The movement was founded on real world experiences of the households and community in terms of lost individual peace and social tranquillity. After the prohibition, the shared progression in terms of globally proven capability of our boys and girls has been sound and loud. Further, the recent worsening of poverty and inequality and rising unemployment of youths have been real. Even further, the public do feel internally the uneasiness caused by the lack of a final picture of the social contract prevailing in Manipur. In these circumstances, any decision on lifting prohibition must be founded on Morality, Shared Social Values, Appropriate Understanding of the Community Culture and clear enunciation of the subsequent mechanism. Lifting prohibition in Manipur is not something like the establishment of a school in an area previously lacking education facilities. Further, lifting prohibition necessarily implies introduction of a new facet of the market mechanism. This new facet is very different from the normal dimensions of the market, and has huge cultural and demographic implications. The decision is not being taken in a post-industrialisation society like the case of Mumbai, but in a context of a society struggling for smooth modernisation. Manipur has been very unfortunate on this last aspect. Now the decision on prohibition can never be healthily founded on the pressure of the Special Interest Groups whatever their influence could have been in the voting process. The Interest Groups too on their part should be alive to the cultural, social and demographic realities of Manipur. Let us recall what the Constitution of India strikes right in the beginning: “WE, THE PEOPLE OF INDIA, having solemnly resolved to constitute India into a [SOVEREIGN SOCIALIST SECULAR DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC] and to secure to all its citizens: JUSTICE, social, economic and political; LIBERTY of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; EQUALITY of status and of opportunity; and to promote among them all.” From the part four of the Constitution, the Directive Principles of State Policy define what should be the nature of engagement and functioning of the government. In other words, India follows the principles of a Welfare State wherein none “permits natural or social contingencies fully to determine the life chances of its members. All have programmes whose explicit purpose is to protect adults and children from the degradation and insecurity of ignorance, illness, disability, unemployment and poverty.” Being a polity following the principles of a Welfare State and given the prevailing socio-eco-cultural realities of Manipur, the lifting of Prohibition in the way it is being envisaged is an undefendable step. Author is the visiting Professor at The Centre for Economic and Social Studies (CESS) Hyderabad. Views are personal.

Hate speeches sullying atmosphere, need to be stopped: Supreme Court

0
Hate speeches are sullying the atmosphere in the country and need to be stopped, the Supreme Court said on Monday. The remark was made by a bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) UU Lalit and Justice S Ravindra Bhat during the hearing of a plea alleging that no action was being taken by government authorities against such speeches. “You are correct that entire atmosphere is getting sullied by these hate speeches and that it needs to be stopped,” the bench remarked. The petitioner Harpreet Mansukhani, appearing in person, said that hate speech was given to make India a Hindu rashtra before 2024 general elections. “Hate speech has been turned into a profitable business. A party funded Kashmir Files and then I have proof how it was funded and then made tax free,” she said. The petitioner also alleged that he has cited confessions of senior BJP leaders claiming that minorities were killed. “Retired army chief, presidents etc wrote to the PM saying this but there was no response. Regarding such an earlier case, Justices Chandrachud and Hima Kohli also sought a status report regarding implementation of the Tehseen Poonawalla judgment,” Mansukhani submitted. The bench initially said that normal criminal law proceedings have to be undertaken in such cases. “Normal criminal proceedings have to be undertaken in these cases. We have to see who is involved and who is not,” CJI Lalit remarked. The petitioner, however, maintained that there needs to be some directions to prevent such conspiracies resulting in such hate speeches. “Every time a hate speech is given it is like an arrow which never return,” he contended. “For a court to take cognizance of this we need factual background. We need some sample of cases. Otherwise it is a random petition,” the CJI said. The petitioner then said that he will file an affidavit citing instances of hate speeches and whether crimes were registered on not. The bench agreed and adjourned the case for November 1. Source: Bar&Bench

Isha Foundation shifts to Nandi Hills: Illegalities and Environmental Violations Galore

The Isha Foundation headed by Jaggi Vasudev (popularly known as Sadhguru), has been mired in controversies for the illegal establishment of its base at an ecologically sensitive area at Ikkarai Boluvampatti in Coimbatore and is now shifting its base to Avalagurki village in the foothills of the Nandi Hills. Nandi Hills is a famous tourist destination in the Chikkaballapur district of Karnataka.  

On 8th October 2022, the Naga Mantapa was unveiled at the Isha Foundation’s new location in Chikkaballapur. In the background, a 112-feet tall bust of the ‘Adiyogi Shiva’ is seen to be under construction and is expected to be open to the people on the Makara Sankranti to be celebrated on January 15, 2023. Located in Avalagurki village, 70 km away from Bengaluru, this is the second center of the Isha Foundation after the Isha Yoga headquarters in Coimbatore Tamil Nadu.

Media outlet News18 has reported that “Spread over 100 acres and surrounded by hillocks on all four sides, the latest facility of Isha Foundation is expected to be fully functional in 2-3 years. The Chikkaballapur center will be a replica of the Coimbatore campus including the 112-feet Adiyogi Shiva statue, 8 Navagraha temples along with a unique Bhairavi temple, say officials at Isha Foundation.”

However, citizens have raised important concerns about the environmental impact of the project. In a detailed report published on eedina.com, LC Nagaraj has explained the ecological significance of the areas surrounding Nandi Hills and that the construction of the center by Isha Foundation is clearly in violation of the laws including the Thippagondanahalli Ordinance-2004 and the issuance of No Objection Certificate.
In the report, he notes that “Many streams which originate from the foothills of Nandi hills join together to become the Chitravati stream which ultimately flows into the ʼParagoduʼ reservoir located in Bagepalli taluk. The reservoir was built by the Government of Karnataka to provide drinking water for the surrounding areas.
These water channels flowing from various valleys of Nandi Hills are located in the area and are marked with blue color.  The 112 feet high statue alongside the Yogashala and the road connecting the same to NH – 7 is being built near Hanumathapura village which is located amidst water channels depicted by the thick blue in the above-provided picture.”
The author further states that “It is said that Sadguru Jaggi Vasudev purchased 10 acres of land belonging to farmers to build all this and install Adiyogi’s statue in this area where water flows are congested. It is said that these lands are next to common grazing lands. The area of ​​rainwater flow between the hill ecosystem and agro-ecosystem is called Ecosystem flow. All these are naturally formed pits providing for the flow of rainwater and the region is made of ​​many such pits. Blocking or diverting the flow of such natural flows of rainwater, is a violation of the law as per the ‘Thippagondanahalli Ordinance -2004’ and the issuance of a No Objection Certificate (NOC) by the concerned Gram Panchayat for the construction of Sadguru Yogashala is also a violation of the law. The flow of water into Paragodu Reservoir is understood only when one understands that the streams move towards the Paragodu Reservoir only after filling the many lakes found in its path and that this environmental flow is playing an important role in increasing the groundwater level. Therefore, it must be ensured that the water flow remains uninterrupted.
It must be noted that all these developments are taking place while the infamous Isha Foundation is still fighting its case at the Madras High Court against the notice issued by the Tamil Nadu government regarding the construction of buildings in Velliangiri hills in Coimbatore between 2006 and 2014 without obtaining the necessary environmental clearance. Providing an update on the case before the Madras High Court, noted environmental researcher Nityanand Jayaraman informed gaurilankeshnews.com that the hearings have been adjourned for now after the Union government stated that the environmental clearances weren’t required in the case of Isha foundation since it was an educational institution.
A picture of the initial stage of demographic pressure in the area where the Pinakini stream flows towards Gauribidanur taluk and Chitravati streams flow towards Bagepally and Paragodu reservoir through Shidlaghatta in the lush green area North of Nandi Hill in Chikkaballapura district.

Kumarswamy, Kanimozhi, oppose language discrimination on notification of CGL exam

0
Former Karnataka Chief minister Kumarswamy and Tamil Nadu MP Kanimozhi have opposed the union government’s SSC notification for conducting Combined Graduate Level Examination-2022 in Hindi and English Language only. These issues were brought to their notice by kannada activists by tagging them on twitter. Both of them have tweeted their opposition and displeasure over language discrimination.  Kumarswamy has tweeted “The Staff Selection Commission (SSC) of the Center is conducting the examination for the selection of 20,000 posts in Hindi-English only. Selected candidate can be sent to any state. Examination in any regional language including Kannada is not allowed. Do we need more proof of Hindi imposition, language discrimination?” It seems that the government is hell bent on to suppress the regional languages. It seems that there is more impatience and hatred towards southern regional languages including Kannada. It seems that a they are going to bury the three language formula” He has also urged the government to conduct the exams only after kannada language is included for the test. Or else the those who get selected will be at the mercy of union government. DMK’s Kanimozhi has tweeted “I strongly oppose the Union Government’s announcement that only English and Hindi will be used in CGL examinations administered by the Staff Selection Commission for Union Government departmental positions. The Indian Union’s sovereignty is rooted in its pluralism. On the contrary, trying to impose singularity on everything is going against the democratic spirit.” Karnataka MLA MB Patil, MP Prajwal Revanna also have voiced concern over this move by union government and have urged them to conduct exams in kannada and stop discrimination based on Langauge. Arun Javagal, a kannada activist has tagged many politicians around this issue and has urged them to raise their voice.  Kannada activist arun javagal tweets    

Gauri Lankesh’s Mother and Sister Join the Bharat Jodo March

Bengaluru: Indira Lankesh and Kavitha Lankesh, mother and sister of the slain journalist Gauri Lankesh, joined the walk with Rahul Gandhi on Friday as they participate in Congress’ Bharat Jodo Yatra. Rahul Gandhi tweeted about Gauri Lankesh and how Gauri represent the true spirit of India. His tweet- Gauri stood for Truth. Gauri stood for Courage. Gauri stood for Freedom. I stand for Gauri Lankesh and couples others like her, who represent the true spirit of India. Bharat Jodo Yatra is their voice. I can never be silenced. Mother-daughter duo joined the march at Bhuvanahalli village of nagamangala taluk in Karnataka. Kavitha Lankesh is a filmmaker based in Bangalore. Kavitha Lankesh’s documentary film -Gauri based on the life of her sister and slain activist-journalist Gauri Lankesh, has bagged the ‘Best Human Rights Film’ award at the Toronto Women’s Film Festival 2022. Additionally chosen for the South Asian Film Festival of Montreal, the documentary is also being considered for various films festivals across the globe, including Doc New York, International Documentary Film Festival of Amsterdam, and Sundance Film Festival, according to a report by The Indian Express. Urging everyone to participate in the yatra, Congress stated that the rally is meant to provide an alternative to the “politics of fear, bigotry, and prejudice” and to the economics of livelihood destruction, increasing unemployment, and growing inequalities. Bharat Jodo Yatra  will cover a distance of 511 kilometers across 21 days in Karnataka, the party’s state president D K Shivakumar said on Monday. The Yatra had taken a break of 2 days due to Ayudh Puja and Dusshera celebrations.

Fears of increased global oil prices as OPEC+ decides to cut oil production

0
In a summit held at Vienna on Wednesday, OPEC+ countries have decided to cut 2 million barrels per day in oil production from November. This has the potential to escalate the shadow wars over global oil prices. The global oil markets were already under stress due to existing American sanctions on Venezuela, and Iran, and the newly imposed sanctions against Russia due to its military confrontation in the Ukraine war. This collective decision by Saudi and Russia is about to trigger the immediate rise of prices in global oil markets. A 2 million barrels per day cut represents 2% less oil in the global supply chain. This decision comes at a juncture when Europe especially Germany is facing a severe energy crisis due to sanctions on Russian oil on which it is heavily dependent.  Some European countries have already begun to ration energy supply with fast approaching winter. OPEC+ refers to the 13 members of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) and 11 other non-OPEC members including Russia. OPEC holds 80.4% of the world’s proven oil reserves, while 11 non-OPEC nations represent 9.7% of proven oil reserves. Together they have the capability to disrupt or enhance the supply of crude oil on a global scale. This decision is said to be jointly taken by Saudi Arabia and Russia against the rules dictated by America. America due to its shale fracking is rising as a global energy powerhouse and is trying to sell its oil to Europe at 8 to 10 times higher. The move to cut oil production by OPEC+ has been termed as shortsighted by the west and the US administration. The west and especially America is accusing OPEC of Aligning itself with Russia and weaponizing Oil. This decision of Saudi to defy America’s orders is also seen as Saudi asserting itself in spite of being a staunch American ally in the middle east. This also foils America’s plan to price cap Russian Oil and sell its own oil to Europe at exorbitant prices due to the Ukraine Crisis. On September 27th the two main undersea gas pipelines to Germany and Europe- Nord Stream 1 and Nord Stream 2 were blown in the Baltic sea in an alleged sabotage attempt. Now it only remains to see what course of action will America take against the OPEC decision. India is enjoying a record low price oil supply from its traditional ally Russiain spite of sanctions against it. The current NDA government has been selling oil to its citizens at higher prices compared to the same price dynamics during the previous UPA regime. America recently sanctioned an Indian firm trading with Iranian petrochemicals. All the signs indicate the volatility and unpredictability of International oil markets and the geopolitics associated with them. The shadow wars being waged by rich countries to suit them are crushing the poorer countries which are already facing food shortage and famine due to Russia and NATO confrontation in Ukraine.

BJP advertises offensive identical news in 4 Kannada dailies as Sonia Gandhi Joins Bharat Jodo Yatra

On the 5th day of the Bharat Jodo Yatra, Congres former president Sonia Gandhi joined the Bharat Jodo Yatra. On the same day, BJP has advertised offensive and derogatory news about Rahul Gandhi and the congress party. The Identical news with the same text, and format appeared in 4 news dailies namely Vishwavani, Samyukta Karnataka, Hosadigantha, and Kannada Prabha. “Rahul Gandhi was having fun during Mumbai terrorist attack” was the title of the article in all four newspapers. The content went further mocked Tipu Sultan Jayanti, the National Herald newspaper and opposition leader Siddaramaiah, KPCC President DK Shivakumar, former Speaker Ramesh Kumar, Many have reacted to the ad saying it represents the abysmal level of politics that the BJP represents and the fact that it could not tolerate the success of Bharat Jodo Yatra in Karnataka. Also, they have condemned and criticized the 4 newspaper for publishing ads that goes against the spirit of journalism.
PC:newsminute.com
“This is the worst ad ever. This is proof that journalism has reached rock bottom. BJP has given lead news advertisements with design and heading to all three newspapers. The bills for this might also be expensive. Even if other newspapers have done it, Kannada Prabha should not have been tarnished and brought to the streets like this” said Dinesh Kumar Dinoo who is a journalist and an activist. Senior journalist Rajaram Thallur has opined that “After seeing the front page BJP news from the 4 newspapers one thing is clear. BJP and its sangh parivar were saying Rahul has raised a family. That is, the BJP itself has accepted that Rahul is no longer Pappu. They now feel that Rahul is a serious competitor for power. So, for the first time, without using the word “Pappu”, they have made a serious political charge against Rahul Gandhi. This is the result of the BJP and its Parivar feeling that Rahul’s Bharat Jodo Yatra is a political success. To this extent Congressmen should be happy about these advertisements”

Bellary Mine Workers demand Rehabilitation and Resettlement

0
Bellary: Bellary Zilla Gani Karmikara Sangha (Bellary District Mine Workers’ Association) affiliated to All India Central Council of Trade Unions (AICCTU) will be organizing a 70 km protest march from Sanduru town in Bellary district to the District Collector’s office at Bellary demanding the implementation of Rehabilitation and Resettlement (R & R) Policy for All Mine Workers on 11th, 12th and 13th October 2022. All the mining activities had come to a grinding halt after the Supreme Court had ordered the closure of Iron-Ore mines in the district in July 2021 and thus, 25,000 workers had lost their jobs overnight. However, no steps had been taken for their rehabilitation.

Why did workers lose their jobs post the SC Order?

Speaking at the press conference in Bellary, AICCTU State President Clifton D Rozario explained the issue in detail stating that- “With the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in July 2011, all mining activities were stopped in several mines in Bellary district without complying with several provisions relating to retrenchment of workers and several labour laws were violated in the process. As a result, more than 25,000 workers lost their jobs and were left by the streets without being provided any compensation or rehabilitation. Using the Supreme Court order as a pretext, the mine owners had denied the workers their statutory rights including retrenchment compensations.” He further stated that the mine owners had to comply with the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act and other relevant laws before dismissing the workers. However, none of these provisions were complied with and entire families including young children and elderly people were pushed to face hardships. He estimated that almost 1 lakh people were caught in trouble due to the non-compliance with various provisions.

Workers’ situation then-

The condition of the Bellary mine workers has been deplorable since the beginning and that they had even risked their lives to work at the mines. These workers are from the most vulnerable and marginalized communities and are not even paid minimum wages. The work that the workers were put into had been life-threatening and they were not even provided any basic facilities and proper safety equipment.

Workers’ situation Now-

Elaborating on the situation of workers today, Clifton stated that, “while employment opportunities are being recreated as several mines have now resumed their operations, the statutory right of first priority in employment to the workers who have undergone illegal retrenchment cannot be denied. However, some mines had taken to employing illegal system by hiring new persons, especially migrant workers from other states through contract system without following the law. He also expressed outrage that the mining companies have completely violated labour laws by not providing jobs to the miners who lost their jobs despite the resumption of mining activities. In R&R, a comprehensive plan is being prepared and implemented for environmental revival of mine-affected areas among other departments. However, the mine workers and their families who are in financial distress due to job loss are neglected.

Demands Made Under R&R

AICCTU state committee member, Nagaraj Pujar said, “All mine workers should be given comprehensive rehabilitation and employment in R&R. Land should be allotted to all mine workers and houses should be built. Anganwadi, community hall, library, labour centre, primary health centre and other necessary infrastructure must be provided in the area where the mine workers are living. A hospital should be built for the miners and free medical services should be provided miners’ families. He also demanded that free education and subsidy for higher education along with financial assistance for marriage be provided to mine workers’ children. The protest march will start from Sandur APMC market on October 11 and will continue until the Bellary district administration office is besieged on October 13. Bellary District Mine Workers Association President Y. Gopi, Vice President M. Malliswamy, General Secretary A. Yariswamy, Honorary President P. Venkatesh were also present in the press conference.

Farmers’ agitation was the inspiration for Bharat Jodo Yatra: Rahul Gandhi

Its been one year since the Lakhimpur Khiri incident where protesting farmers were mowed down by BJP MP Ashish Mishra. On the anniversary of the incident, Rahul Gandhi who is on a nationwide Bharat Jodo Yatra to unite the people of the country tweeted about giving justice to the victims. He also tweeted that Farmer’s agitation was the inspiration for Bharat Jodo Yatra. In his tweet, he said, “Even after one year Lakhimpur Kheri martyrs have not got justice because of only one reason – BJP protects the criminals. When we decided to do #BharatJodoYatra, the farmers’ movement was a big inspiration for us. This struggle will not end without providing justice to the Annadaatas.” Congress leader Rahul Gandhi launched the ‘Bharat Jodo Yatra’ (Uniting India rally) in Kanyakumari on September 7. The yatra is being billed by the party as the longest rally mounted in the country over the last century. Urging everyone to participate in the yatra, Congress stated that the rally is meant to provide an alternative to the “politics of fear, bigotry, and prejudice” and to the economics of livelihood destruction, increasing unemployment, and growing inequalities. The Congress asserted that its ‘Bharat Jodo Yatra’ from Kashmir to Kanyakumari is not a ‘Mann Ki Baat’ in any manner, but its objective is to ensure that the concerns and demands of the people reach Delhi. The march will cover 12 states and two Union territories. It will be about 3,500 km long and will be completed in about 150 days, senior party leader Jairam Ramesh told reporters last week. Jairam Ramesh said simultaneously with the main yatra, there will be separate small Bharat Jodo Yatras in states such as Assam, Tripura, Bihar, Odisha, Sikkim, West Bengal, and Nagaland. It will cover a distance of 511 kilometers across 21 days in Karnataka, the party’s state president D K Shivakumar said on Monday. On day 23 of the yatra, Rahul Gandhi received a grand reception in Mysore. He also visited the Lingayat muth and Gandhi ashram there. In the pouring rain, he gave a rousing speech saying nothing can stop the march. As the rain poured, people could be seen holding chairs over their heads. “It’s raining and we haven’t stopped the yatra. Come heat, cyclone or cold, we are not going to stop,” the senior Congress leader said. Braving the rain, he launched a scathing attack on the BJP-led state government, accusing it of corruption and saying that it took 40 percent commission for sanctioning work. “Neither has the Prime Minister taken any action against it nor has the Chief Minister,” Rahul said. The Yatra is taking a 2-day break due to Ayuda Puja Festival and the Dusshera festival. The yatra will resume from Pandavapura of Mandya district on 6th October.

Karnataka: Paresh Mesta’s death and the blood-soaked harvest of communal politics

CBI in its investigation has found that Paresh’s death was caused due to drowning and not murder as was said by state BJP leaders. BJP lies were amplified by the media and the Sangh Parivar. Paresh’s death was sensationalized by media and Sangh Parivar in the runup to the 2018 elections accusing the Congress government headed by Siddariamiah of trying to cover up the political murder of their activist. Though there is no evidence he was linked to Sangh Parivar, BJP claimed that he was a Sangh Parivar activist after his death. The intensity of the protests by Sangh Parivar in the streets, social media, and communal media had forced the Siddaramiah government to hand over the investigation to CBI 10 days after his death came to light.

Communal Politics over Death of Paresh Mesta 

18-year-old Paresh Mesta who hailed from fishermen’s community went missing in the coastal town of Honnavar on 6th December 2017 after clashes broke out between Hindus and Muslims. Two days later his body was found floating in the Shettikere lake near a temple in Honnavar town. Protests erupted in neighboring towns, villages, and districts. BJP spearheaded a campaign of “Justice for Paresh Mesta”. BJP and Sangh Parivar did a propaganda blitz and campaigned against congress in Uttara Kannada, Udupi, Shivamogga, and Dakshina Kannada districts accusing it of trying to shield the murderers and destroying evidence. BJP State general secretary and MP of Udupi Chikkamagalur constituency Shoba Karadlaje alleged that Paresh’s Body has been mutilated, castrated and the head was slipt with a weapon by ‘Jihadi elements. Uttara Kannada District MP Ananth Kumar Hedge accused the Congress government of destroying evidence and protecting Muslims from this heinous crime. He even warned the Congress government to be prepared for Marikamba Habba(Local Sacrificial Festival) alluding to violence. Every BJP and Sangh Parivar activist amplified the death of Paresh to feed their electoral needs.

Translating Communal Clashes to Electoral Gains

Though police and the doctor who conducted Post morterm in Kasturba Medical College, Mangalore, denied all the claims of torture and mutilation by the BJP. Despite that, the protests intensified. Several Muslims were attacked during this period and the local bar associations took unofficially not to take up Muslim men accused in December 6th clashes. People were urged to vote and avenge the death of Hindus under the congress government.
Media coverage of Paresh’s death
BL Santosh, the now National General Secretary of BJP tweeted about Paresh during elections along with other alleged Hindutva activists. Posters projecting Paresh as a Hindu tiger came up across the coastal and Malnadu region. The entire coastal towns were gripped with communal tensions. BJP had won only 1 seat out of 6 in Uttara Kannada and 1 in 8 in Dakshina Kannada, None in Shivamogga, 1 out of 5 in Udupi, and 2 out of 5 in Chikkamagalur districts in the previous 2013 elections. BJP after this communal campaign BJP had won 4 out of 6 in Uttara Kannada, 7 out of 8 in Dakshina Kannada, 6 out of 7 in Shivamogga, 5 out of 5 In Udupi, and 4 out of 5 in Chikkamagalur Districts in 2018 Assembly elections. As soon as CBI submitted its investigative finding Siddaramiah has tweeted “The CBI report of the Paresh Mesta death being an accidental one and not a case of murder is a slap in the face of the Karnataka BJP. The BJP should apologise for the false allegations made against us,” “Behind every seat won by the BJP in 2018, there is the blood of innocent youth like Paresh Mesta. The blood of innocent people is stuck to the seat of power that is being currently enjoyed by the BJP in Karnataka.”
Courtesy: Satish Acharya
 

Farmers Protest at Mysore: Over 150 Arrested, 1 Injured

Mysore: Police resorted to lathi charge near VC Farm Gate in Mandya enroute Mysore after farmers from the region had hit the streets protesting against the anti-farmer policies adopted by the BJP Government in the state of Karnataka. The farmers along with their cattle and pets had hit the streets at eight different locations attempting to block entry to the ‘Cultural City’ Mysore on the most important day of Dasara Festivities which is marked by the world-famous Jamboo Savari (Elephant Procession). The incident has been reported from one such blockade at VC Farm Gate near Mandya where 150 farmers have been arrested and 1 farmer was left seriously injured.

Demands of the Farmers

The farmers had hit the streets upon the call of Karnataka Rajya Raitha Sangha (KRRS), against the indifference of the chief minister Basavaraja Bommai towards farmers’ issues. While the farmers had placed before the government a 22-point demand charter, the major demands included:
  • The price for a tonne of sugarcane be set at Rs. 4500 alongside
  • Declaration of the Agricultural Support Programme
  • Permanent stopping of Illegal mining around Krishna Raja Sagar (KRS) dam and
  • Repeal of amendment to Karnataka Electricity Act
The farmers’ outfit had planned to have the roadblocks at eight different entry points to the city of Mysore including Mandya, Maddur, Malavalli, T. Narasipura, Ilwala, Nanjanagudu, Srirangapatna, and KR Pete. It was also reported that the state had heightened the security late at night by resorting to heavy police deployment across the city. Speaking to the media, Madhuchandan SC, President of Mandya District Milk Producers’ Struggle Committee and Founder of Organic Mandya stated, “The Government had to listen to the issues faced by the farmers and address them. However, it has resorted to quelling our voices. However, we, the annadatas will not back off. If a fair price is not provided for our products, a huge struggle will have to be waged and the government will have to face the consequences”.

Alt News Founders Mohammed Zubair and Pratik Sinha Nominated for Nobel Prize

0
Fact-checkers Mohammed Zubair and Pratik Sinha are among the contenders to win the 2022 Nobel Peace Prize, reports Time. Founder of the fact checking website Alt News, Pratik Sinha and Mohammed Zubair are among the contenders to win the 2022 Nobel Peace Prize according to report by Time magazine. Journalists Pratik Sinha and Mohammed Zubair, co-founders of Indian fact checking website AltNews, have relentlessly been battling misinformation in India, where the Hindu nationalist BJP party has been accused of frequently stoking discrimination against Muslims. Sinha and Zubair have methodologically debunked rumors and fake news circulating on social media and called out hate speech. Mr Zubair was arrested in June this year by the Delhi police for a or a meme he tweeted four years ago. Journalists around the world condemned the arrest and argued it was retribution for his fact-checking work. “It is apparent that AltNews’ alert vigilance was resented by those who use disinformation as a tool to polarize the society and rake nationalist sentiments,” said a June 28 statement from the Editors Guild of India. The Committee to Protect Journalists also called for Zubair’s release—pointing to his arrest as “another low for press freedom in India, where the government has created a hostile and unsafe environment for members of the press reporting on sectarian issues.”

Also Read: Ethical Journalism and Alternate Media

The winner of the Nobel Peace Prize will be announced at 11am local time on Friday in Oslo, Norway. The Peace Prize is one of six awards established by Swedish chemist (and inventor of dynamite) Alfred Nobel in 1895. The prize is considered the most expansive in its recognition, given that it awards people “who have conferred the greatest benefit to humankind.” The other five recognize contributions in literature, physics, chemistry, physiology or medicine, and economic sciences. The winner is selected by the five-person Norwegian Nobel Committee, which is appointed by Norway’s parliament. There are about 343 candidates – 251 are individuals and 92 are organizations – in the running for the Nobel Peace Prize for 2022.

Other Favourites

The other nominees include  Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky,The World Health Organization, Climate activist Greta Thunberg, Nature broadcaster David Attenborough, Belarusian opposition politician Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya,Pope Francis, Tuvalu’s foreign minister Simon Kofe, and Myanmar’s National Unity government.

Other contenders

Bookmakers also mention Uyghur activist Ilham Tohti, Hong Kong pro-democracy advocate Nathan Law Kwun-chung, the Kyiv Independent, the European Convention on Human Rights, and the Center for Applied Nonviolent Action and Strategies (CANVAS). The Peace Research Institute Oslo—which researches peaceful relations between states, groups, and people—releases an annual personal shortlist for the Peace Prize. This year, their picks for the prize included some other names and groups, such as Indian activist Harsh Mander, the International Court of Justice, Hong Kong activist Agnes Chow Ting, and the Human Rights Data Analysis Group (HRDAG).

Karnataka: VHP and Bajrang Dal gives call to ‘worship weapons’ on Ayudh Puja

0
Belthangady: Sangh Parivar outfit, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Bajrangdal known for its involvement in hate crimes and bombings across the country has evoked a controversy yet again. This time around, the Belthangady taluk unit of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) and Bajrangdal had on the occasion of the Auydha Puja had given a call to perform ‘puja of weapons’ in open. The incident was reported in Belthangady taluk of Dakshina Kannada district in Karnataka. The Belthangady taluk unit of Communist Party of India -Marxist (CPIM) has demanded that the district administration and the Police Department must immediately intervene and stop the same. They also issued a warning that if in case the district administration and the police department fails to step in and stop this, then the progressive organizations of the taluk will be forced to intervene and that the responsibility for the consequences thereafter must be shouldered by the government. They also remarked that “An RSS leader had recently submitted an affidavit to the Supreme Court stating that it was involved in bomb blasts across the across in pursuance of its political gains. In continuation of such terrorist acts, the Sangh Parivar in the name of ‘Ayudha Puja’ has openly displayed guns, pistols, swords, trishuls and are found offering pooja to the same.”

Under-cover hobnobbing of 5 Muslim intellectuals with RSS chief is both anti-national & anti-Muslim

In a significant development a delegation of 5 Muslim intellectuals namely former chief election commissioner S Y Quraishi; former senior bureaucrat Najeeb Jung; former AMU vice-chancellor and Lt Gen (retd) Zameer U Shah; politician-cum-journalist Shahid Siddiqui (presently with RLD); and businessman Saeed Shervani [Samajvadi Party] met RSS Supremo, Mohan Bhagwat at RSS Delhi headquarters (The Indian Express, September 22, 2022). The meeting was kept secret for reasons known to the participants and was held in August. According to the Muslim intellectuals the meeting held in “a very cordial” atmosphere continued for 75 minutes whereas time allotted was 30 minutes! In a post-meeting justification of the parleys Quraishi stated (The Indian Express, September 26) that their main concern was “the insecurity being increasingly felt by the Muslim community in the wake of recurring incidents of lynching of innocents, calls by Hindutva hotheads for genocide and the marginalisation of the community in almost every sphere”. This delegation consisting high-ranking former Indian government administrators, a top-most military commander and two members of Parliament was expected to be familiar with the protocols of a democratic constitutional polity that the above mentioned issues fall in the realm of governance. They should have met Indian PM or Home Minister to demand corrective measures. If not satisfied they should have approached the President of India. However, they decided to approach RSS top brass which has no legal sanctity. They may rightly argue that since RSS controls BJP [RSS does not hide the fact that BJP is its political appendage (RSS Hindi publication Parm Vaibhav ke Path Per, 1997) and BJP rulers from PM to most of his cabinet members, BJP CMs and Governors of States publically declare to be RSS members) why not approach the source of Power itself! This meeting with an extra-constitutional authority is tantamount to justify the extra-constitutional role  played by Sanjay Gandhi during the Emergency. Did these Muslim intellectuals believe that they were living in the Emergency times?
RSS
Golwakar || Courtesy: Wikipedia
This model opted by Muslim intellectuals presents a horrendous option for other minorities in India. By this logic Hindus, Sikhs and anti-Islamist Muslims being targetted by Islam-o-fascists in Jammu Kashmir should approach organizations like Hizbul Mujahideen, and Jaish-e-Mohammed for securing safety of life and property! Another troubling issue is how these Muslim intellectuals came to the conclusion that RSS represents all Hindus of India. Have they lost faith in common Hindus of India who do not support RSS and remain faithful to the democratic-secular polity of India? Muslim intellectuals wishing to open Hot Line with the de facto ruler of India, RSS should have done home work on cow-slaughter before the meeting. It was the most important ideologue of RSS, MS Golwalkar who claimed in 1966 (RSS publication ‘Spotlight’) that cow-slaughter began with the arrival of Muslims who wanted to “stamp out every vestige of self-respect in Hindus”. It is not corroborated even by Swami Vivekananda who stated (February 2, 1900): “You will be astonished if I tell you that, according to old ceremonials, he is not a good Hindu who does not eat beef.” The beef-slaughter as a Muslim crime is the creation of RSS hate propaganda. Large number of Dalits and Christians too consume beef. The Muslim intellectuals should have informed Mohan Bhagwat that RSS-BJP run governments in Goa, Karnataka and all North-eastern States allow cow-slaughter. Then why punish Muslims and Dalits only? RSS organizations have been in the forefront of spreading the bogey that Muslims in few decades would outnumber Hindus in India. The Muslim intellectuals should have shared with Mohan Bhagwat that despite 1000 years of Muslim rule (as claimed by RSS) the first census in India held in 1871-72 recorded: “140½ millions of Hindus and Sikhs, or 73½ per cent., 40¾ millions of Muslims, or 21½ per cent.” Now Muslims constitute only 14% of the population. He also should have been told that in USA, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and UK population of Hindus has increased by almost 100% in last one decade or so. Should it be a matter of alarm for Christians of these countries? Only Racists bother about increase/decrease in population of any section in their respective countries. Muslim intellectuals looking for salvation at the altar of RSS must not forget that Muslims/Islam or other minorities in India can survive only when Indian democratic-secular-egalitarian polity framed under the guidance of Dr. BR Ambedkar survives. It may have many infirmities but is the only guarantee against majoritarianism or Hindutva bigotry. In this regard RSS is not only antithetical to Muslims but Indian democratic-secular Constitution. The Indian Constituent Assembly approved the Constitution on November 26, 1949. RSS instantly rejected it through an editorial in its English organ Organiser (November 29) demanding promulgation of Manusmriti. Earlier RSS icon VD Savarkar had declared it as the most worshippable scripture after Vedas. It is to be noted that Manusmriti decrees sub-human status for Hindu women and Sudras. It was burnt on December 25, 1927 in the presence of Dr. Ambedkar during Mahad agitation who also called upon to commemorate every 25th December as ‘Manusmriti Dahan Divas’. RSS hated every symbol of democratic-secular Indian polity. On the eve of Independence Organiser (August 14, 1947) denigrated the National Flag by declaring that it will “never be respected and owned by Hindus. The word three is in itself an evil, and a flag having three colours…is injurious to a country.” In the same issue, in an editorial (‘Whither’) RSS rejected the whole concept of a secular state by arguing: “in Hindusthan only the Hindus form the nation and the national structure must be built on that safe and sound foundation…the nation itself must be built up of Hindus, on Hindu traditions, culture, ideas and aspirations.”

Hindutva & Zionism As Natural Allies Pose Great Danger to Multicultural World

Quraishi gleefully informs us that Mohan Bhagwat emphasized on 3 things: “Hindutva is an inclusive concept in which all communities have equal room…the Indian Constitution is sacrosanct, and the entire country has to abide by it. He sought to dispel the fear that RSS is seeking to abandon the Constitution at the first opportunity. And, that Muslims will not  be disenfranchised.” If Muslim intellectuals were familiar with Savarkar’s Hindutva (1923) and Golwalkar’s We or Our Nationhood Defined (1939) and Bunch of Thoughts [1966] these claims would not have gone unchallenged. The first two Holy Books for RSS demand the cleansing of Muslims (and Christians) from India as Jews were cleansed by Hitler in Germany. The last one has a chapter (XVI) titled ‘Internal Threats’ which declares Muslims and Christians as enemy number one and two and describes Indian Constitution as worthless and anti-Hindu. Mohan Bhagwat has never disowned these works. Interestingly, RSS has not issued any statement corroborating the Muslim intellectuals’ version. In fact, according to press reports RSS prachar pramukh (national publicity chief), Sunil Ambekar declined to comment. It is sad that a group of Muslim intellectuals on behalf of “the middle class and educated Muslim” as confessed by Shahid Siddiqui is legitimizing an organization which is waiting for an opportune time to finally demolish the largest democracy in the world. They did not bother to confront the RSS chief with the facts of the pauperization of ordinary Indians, mounting unemployment, hunger, and violence against women. These issues should have been the main concern as Muslims standing at the lowest pedestal socially, financially, and politically are naturally the worst sufferers. Sadly they did not touch the wide use of terror laws by the government run by the RSS cadres under which a large number of Muslim activists and non-Muslim activists are being kept perpetually in detention. These are critical times for the Indian democracy; if it is demolished there is no possibility of surviving of minorities including Muslims. India needs intellectuals who stand in defence of the Indian democracy and not restrict themselves to demand security for a minuscule section of one particular community from an extra-constitutional power centre. [An edited version appeared in the Indian Express, Delhi, September 27, 2022.

Paving the way for Fascism: Italy’s fallen Five Star government

0
On 25 September 2022, Italy held a snap election following the government crisis. The Brothers of Italy Party emerged as the single largest party with nearly a quarter of the popular vote. As head of a right-wing collation comes Giorgia Meloni. Meloni will be the most right-wing leader of Italy since Mussolini. She is a proponent of the White Replacement theory that says that the white population is disappearing and will be replaced by racial minorities, and to stop this, Italy must stop immigration and kick racial minorities out of the country. The election comes after many years of political instability and populist politics. The rightward shift in Italian politics can be seen as a result of frustration with the crisis of the previous government. The crisis began on 14 June 2022, when Italy’s Five Star Movement refused to support a proposal of Italian President Mario Draghi regarding support for the cost of the living for Italians. The Five Star Movement, which supports a uniform basic income for all Italians insisted that the bill did not go far enough. This led to the dissolution of the Italian Parliament. The coalition government led by Mario Draghi lost critical support leading to the need for new elections. The Draghi-led coalition was an unstable coalition that tried to unite political parties of conflicting ideologies. Five Star itself recently went through a split in the context of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Some members of the party felt that Italy should not be involved in conflicts regarding NATO or the EU, and opposed Draghi’s opposition to Russia.

Origins of this Government

In 2018, Italy had its most recent general election. No party was able to secure a majority. The largest party was the Five Star Party. The Five Star Party was founded by Italian comedian Beppe Grillo in 2009. He began expressing jokes and criticism against the rampant corruption of Italian politicians on his blog, which coalesced into a movement of people seeking to change the system. Grillo’s humour was profane, racist and misogynistic, but conveyed a feeling of being beyond ideology. Many people felt that he was telling the truth in a straightforward way. His followers liked his style of transcending euphemisms and political doublespeak. He did not have a clear ideology. Most of his followers would revolt against the elite classes, but they did not have many concrete political programs. Rather they were reactionaries. Most of them were suspicious of the European Union. The Five Star movement was a reactionary party that capitalized on the frustrations many Italians had with the Italian political elites. Italy had been plagued with many scandals, sexual, political and monetary. It is hard to classify Five Star as either left or right wing. They supported certain environmentalist policies. They supported a Universal Basic Income for all Italians. They opposed immigration and promoted xenophobia against the migrant population in Italy.
Five Star Movement
Initially, Five Star tried to enter into a coalition with the League, a far Right-Wing party to form the government. This coalition lasted a year when the League broke the coalition. Five Star then formed a coalition with the Democratic Party, a centre-left party, and the Free and Equal Party, a left-wing party. This coalition also lasted a year due to fighting within the Democratic Party. The split came when the European Union provided a stimulus package to its member countries. Within the Democratic Party, there were two camps. One felt it should spend the package on infrastructure projects. The other felt it should be directed by an expert committee. The fight became politicized and polarizing leading to the collapse of the government.

Enter Draghi

Unable to form a stable coalition with either the left or right parties in the Parliament, it looked as if Five Star would not be able to form another government. However, with the pandemic raging on, it was not feasible to hold another election. Former Governor of Bank of Italy and the President of the European Central Bank, Draghi was seen as a neutral technocratic bureacrat. Unlike the Five Star party, which was seen as appealing to popular sentiments and was also directionless, Draghi believed in consulting expert opinion. He was known as a banker and an administrator. This was seen as an important step in managing Italy through the COVID-19 Pandemic. Draghi was thought to be able to take hard but needed decisions, and was good at implementing policies. Italy was one of the first countries to have experienced the full weight of the pandemic the year before.
Mario Draghi
Big businesses welcomed Draghi as he was close to them as a banker. They worked with him to protect their interests during the pandemic when public sentiment turned to welfare programs and redistribution of wealth. Among the support base of Five Star, Draghi has been seen as a puppet of the European Union. His identity as a banker and a bureaucrat made him very unpopular with the constituency of his strongest ally. Outside of the Five Star support base, Draghi was generally approved. Many appreciated the stability and the direction he gave the Italian government during the later part of the Pandemic. As a result, most other political parties left and right, gave conditional support to Draghi’s government. With all of the political parties of Italy behind him, Draghi managed to keep a steady ship during the pandemic. However, tensions began to surface as the crisis ended.

Cracks in the Coalition

With the Russian invasion of Ukraine, infighting began within Five Star. Two camps emerged. One was pro-Russian. The pro-Russian faction criticized NATO for its eastward expansion and for causing the Ukraine crisis. They advocated for a diplomatic solution and were hesitant to send aid to Ukraine, for fear that it would lead to an arms race in the region. The other faction was made up of Five Star politicians who felt that the pro-Russian politicians were undermining Italy’s position within the European Union. They formed a new Party called Together for the Future and left Five Star. Things came to a head when the leader of Five Star opposed Draghi’s proposed support of Cost of living Package, insisting that it was not enough. Draghi took this opposition to his proposal as a sign that his government was on its last legs and resigned.

Future for Italy

Five Star lost a lot of support, and many of its allies have lost support among their base due to their political manoeuvres as parts of alliances with Five Star. The Brothers of Italy made huge gains. The Brothers of Italy never allied with the Five Star Party, and did not suffered the taint of politics that other parties have. The party takes a harsh stance against immigration. The future government will be xenophobic as the Brothers of Italy will make a crackdown on the Italian migrant population and consequence the informal sector of the Italian economy a priority.

The Rise of Far-Right Swedish Parliament

Default the IMF or default the people: The Argentine Dilemma

0
On 28 January 2022, the Argentine government announced a nearly $45 billion deal with the International Monetary Fund. In response, thousands of people took to the streets of the nation’s capital in Bueno Aires answering a call by leftist civil society organizations. The protesters have called for the government to cut ties with the IMF. The deal was a restructuring of a deal made in 2018 when Argentina went into extreme levels of inflation, leading to a heavy devaluation of the Argentine Peso. The economic crisis was sparked by a combination of drought and the return of many businesses from Argentina to the United States. This resulted in a huge loss of tax revenue and a drop in demand for the Peso. The Argentinan government then sought a loan from the IMF of nearly $50 billion and agreed to cut public spending, which later expanded to $57 billion, making it the largest loan by the IMF in history. The government managed to curb inflation slightly, but with the COVID Pandemic, the country fell into dire straights once again.

Debt trap after debt trap

Over the past 50 years, Argentina has spiralled into international debt traps. Nearly a hundred years ago, Argentina had a very large GDP. Many thought that it would dominate the Southern Americas the way the US dominated the northern Americas. The economy was extremely unequal and underdeveloped, but it was culturally and economically very influential. Argentina has been a democracy since 1983 with elections happening regularly. However, the government was still very beholden to foreign markets. By 1985, then President Raul Alfonsin, instituted austerity measures, leading to an economic collapse in the late 1980s. The resulting collapse led to a huge public deficit and popular upheaval. The Country began borrowing from the IMF.

Rise of the Piqueteros

The labour movement was known as the Piqueteros. Piquetero is Spanish, meaning picketer, referring to their protests outside of their place of work. As jobs were cut, the Piqueteros became a national movement to protect poor working-class people. Over time, the Piqueteros became more organized in their actions. They began to make decisions by the assembly, developing support systems across working groups, and helping build worker cooperatives. They also worked with local crime mafias, leading to disrepute with the middle class, and making them targets of attack by right-wing politicians.

The Argentine Great Depression

In the late 1990s, many of Argentina’s trading partners (Latin American countries in similar situations) were getting economically weaker. Argentina then fell into depression, sometimes called the Argentine Great Depression. The economy shrank by nearly a quarter with nearly half the country living below the poverty line. By 2001, the devaluation of the Peso snowballed, as people were getting rid of the currency however they could. The loss of value caused social unrest. Many people in Argentina blamed American and European banks. Confrontations with the police by the people were followed by the state declaring emergency at the end of 2001. The government then floated the Peso, leading many poor people to lose their savings. Many businesses left the country. In this situation, Piqueteros started to take direct control over local factories. They would face resistance from the police, but some factory cooperatives ran. Many workers began organizing assemblies to help take care of the situation created by the crisis, creating solidarity among the poor and the working class. The following year, the resurgent demands for Argentine goods (mostly from China) and the resolution of the South American economic crisis in other countries eased the Depression in Argentina. The government defaulted on the IMF loan and introduced a dual currency system to control devaluation. The years of hyperinflation also made Argentine goods competitive on the market, leading to the return of capital to the country. The crisis, though very present, began to ebb. Starting in 2005, Argentina began paying back its debt to the IMF on schedule using bonds, completing payments by 2006, despite the 2004 energy crisis. The payment was seen by many Argentinians as an end to the ignominious indebtedness. Piquetero leaders began working with local governments to provide welfare schemes, losing their radical edge. Politicians began to coopt leaders in the Piquetero movement, making them lose support from traditional left groups. In some localities, they were associated with local crime, making them targets of attacks from right-wing politicians and the middle class. Eventually, the Piquetero movement fragmented.

Debt crisis: Another time around

In 2015, with rising food prices, the Argentine economy went into another crisis. The government responded with more deregulation. They floated the exchange value of the peso, reduced subsidies, and opened up capital markets. Foreign investment grew, but trouble came around the corner. In 2018, inflation began to creep in again, and the state ran out of foreign currency reserves, leading to the devaluation of the peso, repeating the follies that led to the crisis of the late 1990s. The government then applied to the IMF for its infamous $50 billion debt. In 2020, Argentina instituted one of the strictest COVID lockdowns, leading to a 10% shrinkage of the economy amidst extreme inflation. The economic crisis led to hardships for many Argentinians who took to the streets this year. Protests continue.
IMF
Protests against IMF
Experts have argued that the popular political solutions to the Argentine crisis are too expensive, and would require higher levels of indebtedness for the country. Politicians have called for national unity in times of crisis. Protesters have demanded that the government step in and work for the people against foreign capital. Without the movements of the 1990s active anymore, the country continues to stay in gridlock. Protesters on the ground march across the country expressing anger and frustration with the current system, calling for the prosecution of its politicians and to forget its debt to there IMF. Inflation rates have reached 70% in Argentina, and have wiped out the savings of the people. They say that there is a need to pay pensions, for the education of the people, and the elimination of poverty in the country. Read more about over coverage of crises created by IMF here.