Local Body Chiefs Will Be Held Responsible For Manual Scavenging: Gujarat HC

0
The Gujarat High Court on Monday said that local officials such as the chief of the Gram Panchayat or the Commissioner of the concerned civic body would be held responsible if found that manual scavenging was used to clear manholes. A division bench consisting of Justice AJ Desai and Biren Vaishnev stated in its order that: “If any of the worker whose services have been availed by any of the Municipal Corporation, any Municipality or any Gram Panchayat for cleaning sewerage in the concerned area, the Municipal Commissioner of concerned Corporation, Chief Officer of concerned Municipality and Sarpanch of concerned Gram Panchayat shall be held liable for the action since by the Government Resolution dated June 21, 2014, such activities have been banned.” Represented by Advocate Subramaniam Iyer, the Public Interest Litigation (PIL) petition submitted before the bench demanded proper implementation of Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013, and sought criminal action against nodal officers who were responsible for manual scavenging deaths.  The State government, represented by Government Pleader Manisha Lavkumar Shah and Advocate Utkarsh Sharma, informed the bench that the state has disbursed compensation to the legal heirs of 137 out of 152 deceased who died while they were engaged in manual scavenging. It is in the process of collecting more information on the same. They further stated that manual scavenging is used by private contractors, not local authorities, and that private contractors do not contact the authorities while doing so. The bench ordered the state to pay all compensation before the next hearing on June 19 and dismissed the arguments presented by the State representatives as mere excuses. Read also: No Deaths Reported from Manual Scavenging in Past 5 Years: Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment Manual scavenging is a caste-based occupation with deep links to hereditary forced labour customs and has persisted despite technological alternatives. The extremely dangerous and demeaning task is overwhelmingly performed by dalits and sometimes by adivasis and other minorities, who become exposed to infectious diseases, poisonous gases, injury and social discrimination. Between March 22 to April 26, 2023, there have been eight reported deaths from manual scavenging in Gujarat alone. In all incidents, those who died were hired by private contractors to whom civic bodies and government agencies outsource the maintenance of underground sewer lines. None were given protective hear while entering the sewer lines and died of asphyxiation or inhalation of poisonous gas. In a recent Assembly, it was claimed that eleven people have died of manual scavenging in the past years. However, activists claim that the numbers are much higher. Despite the ban on the practice, manual scavenging deaths have been recorded across the country in large numbers. In 2022, Minister of State for Social Justice Ramdas Athawale shared data in parliament of 352 deaths over the previous five years. The actual number is likely to be much higher, with Criminal Justice Society of India claiming that  one manual scavenger dies every five days.

Patna High Court stays caste census in Bihar till July 3

The Patna High Court on Thursday, 4 May, put an interim stay on the caste-based survey initiated by the Bihar state government. The Court directed the State government to immediately stop the caste-based survey and ensure that the data already collected are secured and not shared with anybody till final orders are passed in the writ petition. The Bihar government had launched the exercise in January this year and had aimed at compiling data on each family in a two-phase process.  The second phase is presently going on. However, three petitions had been filed in the high court challenging the caste survey. One of the petitioner against the survey is filed by Youth for Equality. Only a day ago on Wednesday, the high court had reserved its judgment in the case and the division bench of chief justice K Vinod Chandran and justice Madhuresh Prasad had noted that it would grant interim relief to the petitioners if it found that the state government had:
  • either exceeded its powers to commission such a survey;
  • not followed the due process of law; or
  • if there was an infringement of privacy of the respondents
“We will grant you interim relief if there is a violation of any of the three issues, otherwise we will allow them (the state government) to continue (with the exercise),” Justice Chandran had said. The Court heard the pleas specifically on the directions of the Supreme Court to consider and dispose of the interim application filed in the matter for stay.

SC Closes Wrestlers Petition as Delhi Police Continues to Harass Protestors

The Supreme Court on Thursday closed the petition filed by three women wrestlers following the update that the Delhi Police has registered FIRs against the Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) President and BJP leader Brij Shushan Sharan Singh over sexual harassment claims.  The bench consisting of Chief Justice Of India DY Chandrachud, Justice PV Narsimha and Justice JB Pardiwala noted that the Delhi Police recorded the statement of the minor complainant on April 29 and four other statements on May 3 under Section 164 CrPC, fulfilling the petition’s purpose. Senior Advocate Narender Hooda, representing the petition, requested the bench to continue to monitor the investigation in light of the Delhi Police’s refusal to take action on the matter thus far.  “Keeping in view the conduct of the Delhi Police, I request the investigation to be monitored by either this court or a retired judge. Once it is disposed, the Delhi police will drag its feet,” he asked. The bench turned down this plea, stating that the petitioners may take up any future concerns with the jurisdictional magistrate or invoke remedy under Section 482 CrPC before the Delhi High Court.   Incidentally, just the previous day, there were two separate incidents in which those who were protesting for action to be taken against Singh were attacked by the Delhi Police. On Wednesday night, the Delhi Police attacked wrestlers who are part of the ongoing protests at Jantar Mantar demanding that action be taken against Singh. The incident occurred after the protestors brought in cots to sleep on due to heavy rainfall. Four people, including AAP MLA Somnath Bharti who provided assistance in bringing in the bed, were detained and a few protestors were injured. Tokyo Olympics medallist Bajrang Punia said that the wrestlers, who were merely sleeping on cots, were attacked by a few baton-wielding policemen. Wrestling star Vinesh Phogat further claimed that she and Sangeeta Phogat were shoved by a police officer and another a drunk police officer assaulted her brother. She highlighted that there was no female police officer present at the site.  The Delhi police denied the claims that protestors were beaten and that a policeman was drunk, instead blaming the protestors for escalating the situation. They further claimed that the beds were being brought in without permission, which is why the police were intervening. Earlier in the day, Delhi Police detained several Delhi University students who were holding a solidarity march with the wrestlers. The march was to begin at Arts Faculty, DU, however, Section 144 of the CrPC was imposed prohibiting any gathering of four or more people. When the students changed the venue of the march and arrived in hundreds, the Delhi Police began to detain them en-masse. Both the wrestlers and the students have expressed their resolve in continuing the protests against the injustices faced by the women wrestlers. Several wrestlers have even threatened to return their medals and awards, including the Padma Shri, stating that these awards are pointless in the face of the humiliation they are having to face. As the Jantar Mantar protests enter its twelfth day of  continuous protest, it is worthwhile noting that as many as sixteen out of thirty national sports federations do not have a Internal Complaint Committee (IC) as mandated by the Prevention of Sexual Harassment at the Workplace (POSH) Act, 2013. There is no guarantee that those that do meet the compliance requirement on paper have adequately functional committees.

SKM launches All Year Round Agitation Program of Farmers and Farmworkers

The National Meeting of Samyukt Kisan Morcha was held at Delhi on 30th April where more than 200 farmers leaders of constituent organisations attended. After detailed discussion and deliberation, the national meeting took the following decisions: 1) On the core issues of Demand for MSP Law, Liberation from Debt, Farmer & Farmworkers Pension, Comprehensive Crop Insurance Scheme, Arrest of Farmer Killer Union Minister of State for Home Affairs Ajay Mishra, Withdrawal of False Cases on Farmers, Compensation to Shaheed Farmers Families etc, from 26-31 May, 2023, protests and agitations will be held in all states of India. This will include leading large protest marches to all Members of Parliament and Key Political Leaders in their home constituencies and submitting Memorandum to them, warning them to immediately resolve all farmers demands failing which they will face further protests. 2) In the months of May, June and July, State and District level conventions of the SKM shall be held in every state of India to galvanise and organise farmers and farmworkers. 3) Between 1-15 August, mass protests in coordination with workers unions and organisations shall be held to put an end to sale of interest of farmers and workers to corporates by the Union Govt.

Karnataka: Farmers Release Charter Of Demands Ahead Of Assembly Elections

4) Between September to mid-November, massive all-India Yatras shall be held all over the country, which shall be led by national leaders of SKM. The Yatras will specially focus on states that will see assembly elections, such as Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh, Telangana etc. 5) On 3 October, the day on which BJP leaders murdered farmers at Lakhimpur Kheri, an all-India Shaheedi Diwas shall be held. 6) On 26 November, the day on which the historic Dilli Chalo march of farmers reached the borders of Delhi, all-India Vijay Diwas shall be celebrated by way of holding day-night dharna for at least 3 days in all state capitals. SKM national meeting also adopted the following resolutions in today’s meeting: 1) SKM firmly and unequivocally supports the protest of women wrestlers of India, who have been sitting in dharna at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar, demanding arrest of BJP MP Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh. SKM expresses solidarity with the sportspersons and demands immediate arrest of the BJP MP. A full delegation of SKM leaders visited the protest site, met the sportspersons and conveyed the support of SKM to them. 2) SKM condemns the unleashing of Central Agencies like CBI by the BJP Govt against former Governor Satya Pal Malik, who has been a steadfast supporter of the farmers movement and SKM. Shri Malik has been exposing the misdeeds of the BJP Govt with regard to the unnecessary loss of lives of our soldiers at Pulwama, corruption of the BJP leadership at the highest level etc. SKM lauds the bravery of Shri Malik. SKM shall support all efforts to resist the attempts of the BJP Govt to muzzle Shri Malik. 3) SKM condemns the de-recognition of the oldest unions of postal workers of India – National Federation of Postal Employees and All India Postal Employees’ Union – by the Union Govt, allegedly because these unions supported the historic Delhi farmers struggle and donated some funds to farmers organisations. SKM expresses solidarity with the unions, demands that the de-recognition be withdrawn, and looks forward to increased worker peasant unity against the anti-farmer, anti-worker BJP Govt. Media Cell | Samyukt Kisan Morcha Contact: [email protected]

Bengaluru’s Sanitation Workers Say No to the System’s Scraps

0
Bengaluru, India: Travel a few miles south of the upmarket enclave of Whitefield (home to the offices of Dell, IBM and Cisco) and you’ll find a settlement of shanties amid a vast tract of garbage. Thousands of Muslim migrant laborers from eastern India and neighboring Bangladesh live here. In a city famous for being India’s tech hub, workers sort garbage and clean sewers manually, under hazardous conditions, often without safety equipment. Sujith Sheikh, who came to Bengaluru a decade ago and works as a wastepicker, tells In These Times that he “segregates all the waste — broken glass, rotting food, plastic bottles, condoms — by hand, and the contractors don’t even give us gloves.” Their labor is necessary for the city’s recycling efforts, but these workers receive no salary, earning only a few cents for every few pounds of sorted garbage. Bengaluru’s sanitation workers are stratified by degrees of vulnerability. City government employees, known as pourakarmikas, are at the top of the pyramid. Even though some of them only have subcontracted or temporary jobs, pourakarmikas — who are predominantly Dalit (oppressed caste) workers — are often unionized. Pourakarmika positions include sweepers, who scour the streets and pile garbage into heaps, as well as drivers, helpers and loaders, who move garbage to dumping spots. At the bottom of the pyramid are Bengali-speaking Muslim migrants, who labor without even the nominal protection of a government job. Asked if he works for the municipal corporation responsible for Bengaluru’s upkeep, Shakir Ali Sheikh, a migrant from Bangladesh, shakes his head: ​“No. Commercial.” Migrants like Shakir Ali Sheikh are paid by contractors who act as middlemen between workers and employers (such as the city and the corporations selling water, soda and food).

Bengaluru: Fear and loathing in India’s Silicon Valley

R. Khalim Ullah, an activist working with the Swaraj India political party and a prominent advocate of migrant workers’ rights, explains that the workers were “peasants and farmers who had to leave because the profession is completely untenable [in the West Bengal/Bangladesh region].” Ever since India’s neoliberal economic reforms in the 1990s, the number of its full-time farmers has been plummeting as cultivation becomes financially infeasible, a situation exacerbated by droughts. Many who flee have turned to itinerant wage labor. Journalist Sudipto Mondal characterizes this phenomenon as the rise of “a new wastepicking class,” including millions of Bengali-speaking Muslims across India. Many are recent entrants to Bengaluru’s sanitation labor pyramid. While caste remains a deciding factor in how the labor force is organized, decades of Dalit mobilization have given pourakarmikas a modicum of bargaining power. Over the past 15 years, pourakarmikas have organized under the umbrella of the All India Central Council of Trade Unions (AICCTU), affiliated with the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist). In 2016, pourakarmika sweepers in Bengaluru went on strike and managed to get on the city’s payroll, which workers said allowed them to escape the mediation of corrupt contractors. In July 2022, pourakarmikas once again went on strike, this time across the entire state, to demand that all their positions be turned into permanent government jobs. According to reporting in The Hindu newspaper, striking workers alleged that contractors paid them less than minimum wage with payments sometimes delayed for months. “Any demand for basic rights is met with threats of termination,” one worker told The Hindu. “We demand that the contract system be abolished.” The strike, which halted garbage collection across the state for four days, was partially successful. By January, the government had agreed to convert more than 24,000 out of the state’s 33,000 pourakarmika positions into permanent jobs. The government also vowed to abolish the contract labor system and bring more drivers and helpers into a direct payment system. If this promise is fulfilled, it will usher tens of thousands of workers into more secure conditions. Even as some pourakarmika workers move up, the city’s Muslim migrant workers are replacing them at the bottom. Maitreyi, a state committee member of the AICCTU who does not use a last name, says organizing these workers is posing new difficulties. Many of them do not have addresses and voter ID cards, which makes them difficult to contact. And unlike pourakarmikas mobilized by decades of Dalit agitation, Mondal explains, migrant workers lack local organizing structures or institutions. Fissures among migrants — between Indians from the state of West Bengal and Bangladeshi immigrants, for example — only complicate the situation. But there is precedent for Bengali-speaking Muslims organizing in Bengaluru: Maitreyi says many are members of the pourakarmika union. “Yes, there is a difficulty in terms of language, but there is definitely a solidarity between them and the other pourakarmikas,” she says. “People are coming together … to fight and end the contract system.” If the city’s ragpickers and pourakarmikas stopped working for even a day, Bengaluru would plunge into disease and chaos. But, amid widespread unemployment and poverty, organizing such a movement is hard. Akbar Ali, a migrant ragpicker from West Bengal, says “All I want is a regular job, so that I can take care of my family.” Bengaluru pourakarmikas’ recent victory has shown this desire to be achievable; the challenge now is to achieve it without leaving anyone behind. (Srikar Raghavan is an independent writer and researcher from Mysore, India. He is presently working on  a narrative history of social movements in the state of Karnataka. Courtesy: In These Times.)

Jagrit Dalit and Adivasi Sangathan Activists Booked Under False Charges

0
Burhanpur, MP: Jagrit Dalit and Adivasi sangathan activists, Antram Awase and Madhuri have been booked under false changes by the Burhanpur Police since they hhave been protesting constantly about the illegal tree felling and timbre smuggling. Antaram Awase , Gram Sabha President and Forest Rights Committee Secretary of Siwal village in Burhanpur district, has been arrested by the Burhanpur police yesterday on false charges. Awase an activist of Jagrit Adivasi Dalit Sangathan, has been continuously opposing the deforestation and timber smuggling in Burhanpur district for the last 3 years. He has also played a leading role in spreading awareness about the Forest Rights Act in every village in Burhanpur district. This has put stop on scaring and looting tribals by the corrupt forest staff. JADS has exposed the role of  administration in cutting trees and smuggling of timber. To cover their actions, police has arrests the JADS activists. , to cover it, repressive action has been started against the tribal movement and its workers!

The truth behind the false cases against Antram Awase:

Fake Case of 2022 – The activist who was at the forefront against deforestation was involved in a fake case with those who cut forests! Deforestation has been going on continuously for the last 6 months in Burhanpur district – when the felling started in October 2022 – the first complaint about the felling was made by Antram Awase to the DFO on the morning of 9th October. In addition to the Home Department with the District Collector, Superintendent of Police, District Forest Division Officer, Forest Department Head Chief Conservator of Forests (Forest Force Chief), Additional Chief Secretary of the Forest Department to stop the felling of more than 15000 acres Complaints were also given to the Chief Secretary, Director General of Police. The tribals of Burhanpur district protested against tree felling and smuggling at the district collector’s office for three consecutive days from April 5. Then police came to their senses and started action against the people who were cutting trees. But, because the organization exposed the involvement of the government administration in deforestation and smuggling, the ruling and anti-tribal forces responsible for deforestation have now started attacking the activists of the organization! Fake Case of 2019: In 2019, the forest department attempted to illegally evict the forest rights claimants of Siwal village, during which 4 tribals were shot and injured by the forest department! An FIR was also lodged against the forest staff on the subsequent complaint of the villagers after the bullet challan – no action was taken on the complaint of the villagers, but action was taken on the false complaint made by the forest department against the person who filed the complaint! After the movement against illegal eviction and firing, the officers responsible for the illegal action were also transferred and the process of harassing the activists who made complaints started. The felling has now doubled over the past week, with three new areas being deforested hence new round of protests by JADS activists. JADS activists have been camped outside the police station and protesting the arrest and demading the Shivraj Singh governemnt to stop felling of trees and timber smuggling. But instead police have booked more activists under false charges. Jagrit Dalti and Adivasi Sangathan activist Madhuri has been charged with 21 cases by the Forest Department and 3 others by the police – who are making ridiculous and false accusations against Sangathan and Madhuri who has been constantly campaigning against State government’s connivance in tree felling and timber smuggling. The police is claiming that she is somehow responsible for the felling of 500 acres of trees. Apart from the various complaints given by the Sangathan tree felling and smuggling of wood, Madhuri has been constantly informing the District Collector, District Forest Officer and the Superintendent of Police, Burhanpur of instances of tree felling SINCE 9th OCTOBER – the day rampant tree felling started! In their attempt to suppress the organization and Adivasi movement questioning the government’s role in the felling and timber smuggling, the Sangathan has been ridiculously accused of extorting money under the garb of applying for Forest Rights Claims. They have claimed that Sangathan membership receipts that each Sangathan family has with them, are somehow “a proof” of extortion. In truth, these membership receipts are governed by Adivasi activists of the organization, and the money deposited into a joint account co-owned by 3 Adivasi women! All of the money in the accounts is used solely for the purposes of meeting expenses such as that of arranging for logistical needs like the sound, for protests or for Adivasi activists when they need to travel out of their districts! Such attempts to spread misinformation and discredit the Sangathan are further proof of the political vendetta against the Sangathan and its’ activists — for continuously asking questions of the role of the government in months of tree felling and timber smuggling!!  

Supreme Court Upholds Delhi High Court’s Order Granting Bail To Activists Accused in Delhi Riots

The Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed the Delhi Police’s appeal challenging the order of the Delhi High Court granting bail to Natasha Narwal, Devangana Kalita and Iqbal Tanha. The three were arrested under the Unlawful Activities Prevention (UAPA) Act after the Delhi Pogrom of 2020.  The bench, comprising Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul and Ahsanuddin Amanullah pointed out that the accused have been enlarged on bail for nearly two years and said that there is no reason to keep the matter alive. In response to Solicitor General Tushar Mehta’s argument that the High Court’s order should not be treated as precedent, the bench reiterated the same: “Purpose of interim order was to ensure that interpretation and views on a law should not be enunciated in bail hearing. We make it clear that we have not gone into legal position of law’s statutory interpretation one way or the other”, the bench added. Justice Kaul also expressed that bail orders should not be prolonged in response to Mehta’s adjournment request on behalf of the Delhi Police. The bench refused to grant adjournment, noting that the matter was adjourned on several occasions.  The case involved the Delhi Police probe into the violence that broke out in North-east Delhi in February, 2020. As per Delhi Police, Narwhal, Kalita and Tanha were part of a ‘larger conspiracy’ that led to the violence. The police claimed that following the Citizenship Amendment Act, the accused persons planned to create disruption of such an extent that it would lead to disorderliness and disturbance of law and order. Narwhal, Kalita and Tanha were in custody for almost a year. Read also: Delhi High Court Grants Bail to Asif Iqbal Tanha, Devangana Kalita and Natasha Narwal In June 2021, the Delhi High court granted bail to the three after finding that the offences under the UAPA were prima facie not made out against the student leaders. Judges Siddharth Mridul and Anup J Bhambhani held that the accused were only leading protests and “the right to protest is not outlawed and cannot be termed as a ‘terrorist act’ within the meaning of the UAPA”. In response to the state’s attempt to shift blame on the Delhi Progrom onto activists, the High Court said: “We are constrained to express, that it seems, that in its anxiety to suppress dissent, in the mind of the State, the line between the constitutionally guaranteed right to protest and terrorist activity seems to be getting somewhat blurred. If this mindset gains traction, it would be a sad day for democracy.

Railways Pocketed Additional Rs 2,242 crore From Suspending Senior Citizen Concessions

0
The Railways has earned an additional revenue of around Rs 2,242 crore from senior citizen travellers between April 1, 2022 and March 30, 2023 by revoking concession offered to them, an RTI response has found. This money has come from the pockets of senior citizens travelling by trains. The national transporter had generated Rs 1,500 crore in excess between March 20, 2020 — when the assistance was suspended after the onset of the Covid pandemic and March 31, 2022. The senior citizens’ concession that the Indian Railways used to offer remains suspended, with the elderly having to pay full price for their tickets. The senior citizens’ concession was suspended in March 2020, because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Even though the pandemic-related shutdowns have all come to an end a while ago, this concession has not been restored. The concession used to apply to men above the age of 60 and women above the age of 58.

Paulo Freire: Education, Schooling and Social Change

In a Right to Information response sent to Madhya Pradesh-based Chandra Shekhar Gaur, the Railways said about eight crore senior citizens bought train tickets at the full price in the last financial year. “The total revenue from senior citizen travellers during the period is ₹5,062 crore which includes an additional ₹2,242 crore, earned due to the suspension of the concession,” PTI cited the RTI reply as saying. “The total revenue from senior citizen travellers during 2020-22 was ₹3,464 crore which was ₹1,500 crore more than what it would have earned if they had offered the concessions to them,” the PTI report continued. For the Railways, the earnings from senior citizen fares has increased at a steady pace. Between March 20, 2020 and March 31, 2022, the Railways did not offer concessions to 7.31 crore senior citizen travellers. These included 4.46 crore male passengers aged 60 years and above, 2.84 crore female travellers over 58 and 8,310 transgender people. On April 28, the Supreme Court had dismissed a petition seeking revival of the concession. “It would not be appropriate for this court to issue a writ of mandamus in a petition under Article 32 of the Constitution. It is for the government to take a call on the issue keeping in mind the needs of the senior citizens and the fiscal repercussions. Dismissed,” the bench said then.

Supreme Court declines plea against release of “The Kerala Story”

The Supreme Court on Tuesday turned down an interlocutory application (IA) challenging the release of movie “The Kerala Story” on the grounds of hate speech and propaganda.

Directed by Sudipto Sen and produced by Vipul Amrutlal Shah, the film follows the theme of religious conversion and falsely claims that nearly 32,000 women from Kerala were forcefully converted to into Islam and made to join ISIS.

Advocate Nizam Pasha, who was representing the petition against the film, argued that it was “audio-visual hate propaganda.” Senior advocate Kapil Sibal informed the bench that the trailer for the film constituted the “worst kind of hate speech” and had already garnered millions of views across different languages.

A bench consisting of Justices KM Joseph and BV Nagarathna expressed difficulty in considering an IA. Given that the film has received certification by the Central Board of Film Certification, a court can only consider a challenge to certification in the form of a substantive petition.

“There are varieties of hate speeches. This film has got certification and has been cleared by the board. It’s not like a person getting on the podium and starts giving uncontrolled speech. If you want to challenge the release of the movie, you should challenge the certification and through appropriate forum,” Justice Joseph said.

Justice Nagarathna also asked why this was not taken up at a High Court level first. When Pasha argued that this was done due to a lack of time as the movie is scheduled to release on Friday, the judge replied that these are not valid grounds.

Advocate Sibal said that he would file a substantive petition tomorrow and seek an urgent listing by mentioning before the Chief Justice of India, but pleaded that the bench look at the IA in the meantime as they are short on time.

Read also: Supreme Court Directs States To Take Suo Moto Cognizance Of Hate Speech

Paulo Freire: Education, Schooling and Social Change

Born to a middle-class family in Recife, in the state of Pernambuco in northeast Brazil, South American philosopher Paulo Reglus Neves Freire’s (1921-1997) life experience shaped his vision of education. In his younger days he faced hunger, poverty and personal hardship because of the economic depression in his country. The turning point in his life came when Aluízio Pessoa de Araújo, the principal of a secondary school gave him an opportunity to study in his school at a reduced tuition fee. This happened to be his only life chance at formal education. To reciprocate this generosity he decided to teach in the same school in 1942. In 1947 he was invited to join a government agency called the Serviço Social da Indústria (SESI) where he began to work with the illiterate workers and peasants in Brazil. His teaching-learning experiences during these years in SESI lead him to develop adult literacy methods that are practiced the world over even today. He wrote and published extensively about his actions and reflections. One of Freire’s best-selling works, first published in 1971, is Pedagogy of Oppressed that has sold more than a million copies worldwide. In 2018 Bloomsbury published its 50th anniversary edition with a foreword by Noam Chomsky. It is widely regarded not as an ordinary book but ‘a transformative text’. There is renewed salience in re-reading Freire’s illuminating book at the current juncture. His longtime political ally and Brazil’s first working-class president Lula da Silva has re-returned to office after winning the October 2022 election. His radical ideas merit a re-visit on his death anniversary now as he continues to remain an inspiration to all educators who believe in social justice (Madan, 2022). Pedagogy of the Oppressed remains relevant because it dreams of an egalitarian, inclusive and just social order through education in socially-divided Brazil notwithstanding poverty, unemployment and inequality. This kind of socio-economic inequality is exacerbating in many countries including India. Also, post-colonial societies like ours have inherited colonial educational apparatuses that are disconnected from the life of their majority people.

It is noteworthy in this context that commentaries have pointed out that sometimes international financial agencies have in a ‘pseudo-Freirean perspective’ worked in the direction of reinforcing prevailing structures of oppression in unequal societies rather than liberating Third World’s peasants from the domination of private capital (Kidd and Kumar, 1981). A reading of Freire’s original works is valuable for an authentic re-conceptualise of education for transforming a society towards humanisation, social justice and empowerment of the poor. Also, the language of the book has been regarded as inaccessible to a non-specialist reader. This article attempts to understand three core terms of Freirean vocabulary: banking education, problem-posing education and dialogue, as presented in this illustrious book.

Banking Concept of Education

Freire came to realize that the sole purpose of education of his times was to transmit information to students who were presumed to be passive beings, or, empty vessels. Teaching was seen as a task of deposition of information in the name of knowledge. The knowledgeable teacher supposedly deposits it in the students mind, much like a banking process. In such a type of education it is the efficiency of teachers’ deposition and students’ passivity that defines their respective proficiency as,

The capacity of banking education to minimize or annul the student’s creative power and to stimulate their credulity serves the interest of the oppressors, who care neither to have the world revealed nor to see it transformed (1993:47).

Such an education is apolitical as well as devoid of possibilities for the rural and urban poor to raise their own problems ‘of agriculture, health, livelihood and ownership of factors of production’ (Raina and Mansi, 2022). Freire believed that it is a tool used by the oppressors to maintain their authority on the oppressed by making them mere meek receptors of existing ideas legitimizing the status quo of inequality in society.

Problem-posing education

Freire, a man of action, offered an antidote: problem posing education, as liberation from the dehumanizing effects of banking education. Problem posing education, instead of centering on textbook knowledge, assumes reality as a dynamic process of transformation that addresses the immediate problems faced by people in their own environment. He writes,

The problem-posing method does not dichotomize the activity of the teacher-student: he is not ‘cognitive’ at one point and ‘narrative’ at another. He is always ‘cognitive’, whether preparing a project or engaging in dialogue with the students. He does not regard cognizable objects as his private property but as objects of reflection by himself and the students (1993:54).

In this pedagogical approach, problems from the outside world are presented to the students as the educational content. Both students and teachers find out ways to solve these problems. Freire did not see education as merely mastering of academic standards or skills that prepared ‘professionals’ but as a humanizing process that developed learners who understood their social problems and discovered themselves as creative agents. Such an education transforms the students from the objects to the subjects of the process of education by overcoming both authoritarianism and their false perception of reality.

Dialogue

The foundation of problem-posing education is Freirean dialogue. A problem posing education can only be dialogical as it needs to be based on meaningful dialogue about real life and its problems; between teachers and students. Unlike banking education it isn’t just intellectual or text bookish in mode but,

Education which is able to resolve the contradiction between teacher and student takes place in a situation in which both address their act of cognition to the object by which they are mediated. Thus, the dialogical character of education as a practice of freedom does not begin when the teacher-student meets the students-teachers in a pedagogical situation, but rather when the former first asks himself what his dialogue with the latter will be about (1993:65).

Freire has gone as far as to call dialogue an existential necessity. For him human existence can never be silent because to live humanly means to speak with each other and transform the world together. It is necessary to break the culture of silence implicit in the banking model of education leading to educational practice that involves a real-world action beyond the abstract apolitical world of textual knowledge.

Educational practice in post-colonial societies

Freirean educators are confronted with the complex relationship between politics, history and social change. Most post-colonial societies like India have institutionalised a banking model of school education characterized by a tightly framed, predefined school curriculum which is mostly indifferent to human realities. Teachers are expected to transact the copious chapters of several textbooks of the many school subjects. These chapters constitute the credit that has to be put in the bank which is the student. The government’s education department, which serves as the certifying and standard-setting body, expects that the students have a basic understanding of the material covered in these chapters. The tends to an anti- dialogical tonality as the teacher teaches and the students are taught. The teacher talks and the students listen; the teacher presents disciplinary knowledge and the students follow it. The teacher remains the subject of the learning process, while the students become its objects. Freire distrusted formal school curriculum, as according to him education should be based on generative themes from the student’s real life. The exploration of these themes should be dialogical which can provide an opportunity to stimulate learner’s awareness regarding the themes. Problem-posing education aims to liberate humans, of which the first step is to break the authoritarianism between teachers and students, which is not possible in a transmission model of banking education. The educational systems in most societies (global south in particular) follow a vertical relationship between teachers and students where communication (not dialogue) is between the teacher-of-the-students and the students-of-the-teachers obviating a pedagogy of hope. Yet reading Freire continues to keep alive the dream of education for social justice among educators the world over.

References

  • Freire, P. (1971/ 1993). Pedagogy of the Oppressed. England: Penguin.
  • Kidd, R. and Kumar, K. (1981). ‘Co-opting Freire: A critical analysis of pseudo-Freirean adult education’, Economic and Political Weekly, 16(1-2), 27-35.
  • Madan, A. (2022). Book Review Walter Omar Kohan, Paulo Freire: A Philosophical Biography (Jason Wozniak & Samuel D. Rocha, Trans.), London: Bloomsbury, 2021. 296 pages INR 1742 (E-book). Contemporary Education Dialogue. 19(1), New Delhi: Sage.
  • Raina, J. and Mansi. ‘Education in post-colonial societies and Paulo Frere’s Insights’, The Armchair Journal, 21 August, 2022.
(Jyoti Raina teaches at the Department of Elementary Education at Gargi College, New Delhi. Mansi is her student at a four year undergraduate pre-service teacher education program at the same department. The article was first published in Countercurrents.org.