Rahul Gandhi Disqualified from Lok Sabha After Defamation Case Verdict

2
India’s parliament on Friday disqualified opposition Congress party leader Rahul Gandhi as a lawmaker after a lower court found him guilty of defamation and sentenced him to two years in prison, according to a parliament notice. “Rahul Gandhi, Member of Lok Sabha representing the Wayanad Parliamentary Constituency of Kerala, stands disqualified from the membership of Lok Sabha from the date of his conviction i.e. 23 March 2023…,” reads the LS Secretariat in a notification issued today. Responding to the notification, senior Congress leader Manish Tewari called the decision erroneous. “Lok Sabha secretariat cannot disqualify an MP. The President has to do it in consultation with the Election Commission,” he told NDTV. Congress units in several states this morning launched simultaneous protests, accusing the Centre of political vendetta. Karnataka police detained Congress state president DK Shivakumar and other party leaders and workers who were protesting against the Surat court verdict against Mr Gandhi.

Mere Membership Of Unlawful Organization Is UAPA Offence : Supreme Court 

1
The Supreme Court on Friday held that holding membership of an association declared unlawful by the Central government is sufficient to constitute an offence under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA) as reported by Bar &bench. In doing so, Supreme Court overruled its 2011 judgments in Arup Bhuyan vs State of Assam, Indra Das vs State of Assam and State of Kerala vs Raneef which held that mere membership of a banned association is not sufficient to constitute an offence under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act 1967 or the Terrorism and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, unless it is accompanied with some overt violent. A bench comprising Justices MR Shah, CT Ravikumar and Sanjay Karol also upheld Section 10(a)(i) of the UAPA which makes membership of an association, which has been declared to be unlawful, to be an offence.

UAPA 2011 Judgements

The 2011 judgment in Arup Bhuyan was delivered by a 2-judge bench comprising Justices Markandeya Katju and Gyan Sudha Mishra while deciding a bail application under TADA filed by a person accused of being a member of ULFA. “Mere membership of a banned organisation will not make a person a criminal unless he resorts to violence or incites people to violence or creates public disorder by violence or incitement to violence”, the bench had held. Earlier, in State of Kerala vs Raneef(2011), while deciding a bail application under the UAPA, the same bench had taken the same view. Same view was taken in Indra Das too by the same bench.

Are we living in a police state? Justice Gupta Questions UAPA, Sedition and NSA

The top court had held that the TADA court had relied on an alleged confession statement, and mere membership of a banned organisation under the Act could not be ground for conviction. Pertinently, the 2011 Bench, relying on its decision in State of Kerala v. Raneef as well as the American Bill of Rights and some US Supreme Court rulings, had observed in the context of the TADA Act that, In our opinion, Section 3(5) cannot be read literally otherwise it will violate Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution…Hence, mere membership of a banned organisation will not make a person a criminal unless he resorts to violence or incites people to violence or creates public disorder by violence or incitement to violence.” In 2014, the Supreme Court had observed that the larger issue in three cases should be heard by a larger bench. This led to the present reference. The Central government argued that the Court could not read down the provisions of an anti-terror legislation without hearing its arguments, and by relying on possible abuse of the law. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Central government, had argued that official membership of banned organisations was anyways difficult to prove. The provisos read down were a deterrent and preventive measure, he added. The SG had stressed that the current scheme of things could allow terrorist activity if allegedly not done under the banner of banned/terrorist organisations. Senior Advocate Sanjay Parikh, appearing for an intervenor-NGO, had argued that in matters involving susbtantive rights like personal liberty, provisos could be read down even when not under direct challenge. He had submitted that civil liberties are a part of both Indian and American Constitutions, and therefore, it would be wrong to nullify the orders under challenge merely for relying on US court judgments.

Remembering Avtar Singh ‘Pash’ on his Death Anniversary

Avtar Singh Sandhu, popularly known as Pash was born in the village of Talwandi Salem in Jalandhar, Punjab, on September 9, 1950. Pash’s poetry always had political overtones akin to the verses of poets such as Faiz Ahmad Faiz, Bertolt Brecht, Yiannis Ritsos, and Mahmoud Darwish. Pash was against religious fanaticism and strongly criticised the authoritarian nature of the state. He was killed by Khalistani militants on March 23, 1988 in New Delhi. Decades after his death Pash’s ideas still reverberate to the contemporary socio-political milieu.  With the increasing communal tensions in the country, it is timely to remember the revolutionary spirit of Pash.  Satyam Tiwari is a theatre actor, writer, a passionate orator of poetry and editor currently working with Newsclick.in. recites two of Pash’s poetry. 

Ghaas (Grass)

Image courtesy: The Metropolitan Museum of Art
I am like grass you can chop me mow me down
 but I shall sprout again
 grow and bounce back
 you can obliterate my signposts
 you can bomb the Universities
 reduce the hostels to rubble
 you may scorch the slums
 but you cannot erase my identity
 because I am like grass
 I will sprout again
 and my mantle shall cover everything
 you may bomb Banga
 you can destroy Sangrur
 and reduce the whole district of Ludhiana   to ashes
 but it will be only a matter of time
 two years ten years
 before my green mantle covers everything   again
 I will become a vast green jungle
 the green jungle of Barnala
 where tourists will visit me
 visit my green jungle
 because I am like grass
 you can chop me
 you can mow down
 but I  will sprout again
 and cover everything

Sab ton Khatarnak (The Most Dangerous)

Joseph Wright (Wright of Derby) / Image courtesy: The Metropolitan Museum of Art

The most dangerous occurrence is not a robbery of hard work,

The most horrifying act is not torture by the police,

A merger of betrayal and greed is not the most dangerous.

To be trapped while asleep is undoubtedly miserable,

To be buried under the silence is undoubtedly miserable,

But it is still not the most dangerous.

To remain silent in the noise of corruption is undoubtedly miserable,

Reading covertly under the light of a firefly is undoubtedly miserable,

But it is still not the most dangerous.

The most dangerous deed is to be filled with dead silence,

Not feeling any agony against the unjust and bearing it all.

Getting trapped in the routine of running from home to work and from work to home,

The most dangerous accident is the death of our dreams.

The most dangerous thing is that watch which runs on your wrist, but stands still for your eyes,

The most dangerous is that eye; which witnesses it all but remains frozen,

The eye that forgets to kiss the world with a passion,

The eye lost in the blinding haze of a materialistic world,

The eye captivated in the aimless monotony of life.

The most dangerous is the moon which rises in the numb yards after each homicide,

But it still does not bother your eyes.

The most dangerous is the song which mourns to reach your ears,

And sounds like a knock of a goon at the door of the frightened people.

The most dangerous is a night which covers the sky of living souls,

In which only owls scream and wolves growl,

With everlasting darkness covering all the doors and windows of existence.

The most dangerous is the direction where the sun of soul sets,

And a ray of dying sunlight pierces the east of your body,

The most treacherous is not the robbery of hard work,

The most horrifying act is not torture by the police,

A merger of treachery and greed is not the most dangerous.

(Translation Courtesy: http://feelingbuddhaful.com/translation-paash-poem/)

Journalists Have a Lot to Learn From Bhagat Singh

G20 Meet in India: A Giant PR Exercise and Free Pass to Suppress Dissent

0
The Jammu and Kashmir administration is preparing to host one of the  G20 event meetings as part of India’s presidency of the Group of Twenty (G20) in 2023. The G20 is a self-appointed group that sets financial and economic guidelines for the world. The G20 Summit is a series of formal and informal meetings between world leaders. The summit is notorious as it excludes the voices of the people that it affects. The meetings lack transparency. Transnational corporations set the recommendations and decisions, with free trade regimes and economic growth being the primary drivers rather than social and economic justice and human rights. This economic “growth” only fills the pockets of the rich, and these free trade and investment agreements have destructive effects on people’s lives and the environment. Whenever it is held, the summit attracts protests from groups calling for change on topics such as environmental policies, trade deals, and labour laws. These protests center around corporate greed as the G20’s decisions are made behind closed doors and lack transparency. The G20 was founded in 1999 in the aftermath of the SouthEast Asian economic crisis. Summits had been held annually since 2008, with the first one being held in the United States. The motive of the summit was to create a revived Bretton Woods system to reinvent neoliberalism in the twenty-first century. In an almost ironic turn, the Indian government has been able to leverage a conflict region to host a controversial event. G20 Summit is an anti-people event. It is always marked by resistance. Protests are usually met with policing by the local governments. By using a conflict zone as the venue, the Indian government has been able to prevent any protest before it began. G20 Summits have been marred by violent street protests by international activists in the past. The expected controversy now is being used by authoritarian governments to repress the local population. How Right-wing Governments take advantage of Crisis: Case of Türkiye

G20 summits are so unpopular it is an embarrassment

Since the second meeting in London in 2009, the G20 summits have been the focus of mass protests. Previous G20 Summits have seen high-profile demonstrations, with allegations of police brutality and civil rights violations.
G 20
Thousands of demonstrators marched through London on 28th march 2009 to demand action on poverty, jobs and climate change at the start of a week of protests aimed at the G20 summit in the capital.Toby Melville / Reuters
The G20 summit held in Bali in 2022 was a major concern for Indonesia, as they had the responsibility of hosting a secure and smooth-running event. Indonesia mounted an unprecedented security operation with over 18,000 personnel from the Indonesian Armed Forces deployed to safeguard the event. In 2021, thousands of protesters marched at the G20 summit in Italy. Protesters included workers who had lost their jobs from globalization, climate activists, communists, and trade unionists. In 2020, the G20 summit was held in Saudi Arabia. As the Saudi Arabia government already had a repressive structure, the event was relatively uneventful. In 2019, at the G20 summit in Osaka, Japan, an estimated 30,000 people came to the city from outside. More than 32,000 police were to keep protesters from getting too close to the world leaders attending.
G20 protests in Hamburg 2017
In 2018, thousands of demonstrators marched in Buenos Aires to protest the G20’s economic policies as the world’s leading industrialized nations opened their annual summit in the Argentine capital. Police, coast guard, and border patrols cordoned off a 12-square-kilometre area around the riverside Costa Salguero convention centre where the summit was held. Buenos Aires was largely locked down for the march, which was organized by a coalition of labour unions and rights groups.
G20
G20 protests in Hamburg 2017, where protesters clashed with police
In 2017 in Hamburg, Germany, around 100,000 protesters came for the G20, and almost all of them were peaceful. These stories go back years, as the G20 summit is a tool of anti-people neoliberalism. Protests have happened at the G20 summit almost every year since the second summit in London in 2009.

Why Kashmir? Using the infamy of G20 to promote repression

The G20 Summit is known for inviting protests from those who oppose neoliberal policies. These policies are believed to marginalize communities and prioritize order and beautification over the needs of marginalized groups. The Indian government is taking advantage of the summit to rearrange parts of the map in Srinagar. This move is part of a larger effort by the government to deploy the army in more urban areas. Kashmir, which is already highly militarized, could potentially see draconian measures implemented by the Indian government without consequence. Given that Kashmir is recognized internationally as a conflict zone, the Indian government is prepared to shift the narrative in its favour, regardless of whether protests or violence occur during the summit. With many countries participating in the event, the Indian government is expected to be in control. Domestically, holding an international conference in Kashmir is seen as a way for the Indian government to imply that the international community supports its position on Kashmir. However, this move has been met with objections from Pakistan and China, who have both claimed the areas where the summit is being held. These objections highlight the complex geopolitical tensions at play in the region. The G20 Summit in Srinagar presents an opportunity for the Indian government to reinforce its position on Kashmir and to take advantage of the international attention on the summit to deploy further militarization and potentially implement harsh measures in the region.

How the G20 is being sold in India

Narendra Modi has touted the summit as a matter of national pride, it is little more than a showcase for neoliberalism and authoritarianism. The entire event is a giant Public Relations exercise by the government to show the Indian people that this government has strong international standing. Modi hoped that the summit could have been held in 2022 to coincide with India’s 75th Independence celebrations. Modi has even made the rotating post of G20 president a matter of nationalistic pride, suggesting that India’s hosting of the event is a sign of its growing global influence. The choice of location is a deliberate attempt by the Indian government to prevent protests against the summit, which would symbolize the disenfranchisement of many people around the world. The G20 summit will have significant implications for people across the world, and decisions made behind closed doors will affect millions of lives. This anti-democratic summit has the added effect of justifying the suppression of dissenting voices worldwide.  This is the first major international summit in Kashmir since the abrogation of Article 370. India’s decision to place the summit in Kashmir shows an eager willingness to crack down on any protests or dissent even before it happens. The promotion of the event by the government shows a wilful disdain for the concerns of the people. Author is a mathematician and activist based in Bangalore. Views are personal. 

Rahul Gandhi sentenced to 2 years jail in criminal defamation case for “all thieves have Modi surname” remark, gets Bail

0
A Surat Court in Gujarat, on Thursday convicted Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, in a 2019 defamation case for his remark “all thieves have Modi surname”. He was sentenced to two years in jail for the offence, PTI reported. Gandhi was granted bail in the matter by the trial court and the sentence would remain suspended for the time being to enable him to file appeal. Gandhi had, in a political campaign in Karol, linked Prime Minister Narendra Modi with fugitives like Nirav Modi and Lalit Modi. He had said, “Nirav Modi, Lalit Modi, Narendra Modi. How come all the thieves have ‘Modi’ as a common surname?” The case filed by former Gujarat minister and BJP MLA from Surat West Purnesh Modi pertains to the alleged remarks Gandhi made on April 13, 2019, at a Lok Sabha election rally in Kolar, Karnataka. Rahul had said, “Why all the thieves have Modi in their names whether be it Nirav Modi, Lalit Modi, and Narendra Modi?” According to the petitioner- Gandhi defamed all the persons with ‘Modi’ surname.He, therefore, filed a defamation suit against the Congress leader. The Gujarat High Court recently vacated the stay on the trial in the case pursuant to which the trial resumed. Moments later, Gandhi was granted bail by the court and the order was stayed for a period of 30 days so the Congress leader can appeal in a higher court. “We are not satisfied with the verdict passed by the court as some of our arguments were not taken into consideration. The issues we raised were, there is no community by the name of Modi and even the complainant is not a Modi as his earlier surname was Bhootwala and later changed to Modi. We will take up our issues to higher courts in coming days,” defence lawyer Kirit Pawala said.

Remembering Bhagat Singh: Ideas That Can’t Be Killed

Much has been spoken about the revolutionary life of Bhagat Singh. Be it in history books or movies, his revolutionary actions which had trembled the British imperialists have been sufficiently presented and his martyrdom is rightly venerated. But what is seldom spoken about is his ideas which are clearly reflected in his writings, and which guided his actions that transformed him from a romantic revolutionary into a socialist.

In the current context when the attack on the toiling masses is intensifying with every passing day, one needs to study his writings more closely in the quest to achieve complete revolution in this country.

In recent times, when the scientific temper of educational institutions is under threat with the promotion of pseudo-sciences and non-sciences in the name of ancient Indian sciences and anti-people outlook, his article “Why I am an Atheist” has to be studied with the greatest attention.

He said: “It is necessary for every person who stands for progress to criticize every tenet of old beliefs. Item by item he has to challenge the efficacy of old faith.”, and only after rigorous reasoning and analysis one should stand in favor of any philosophy or faith.

His thoughts stand staunchly against any kind of blind belief and he states that such practice deprives a man of his understanding power and makes him stand against progress of the society.

Bhagat Singh said, “The peasant who grows corn for all, starves with his family, the weaver who supplies the world market with textile fabrics, has not enough to cover his own and his children’s bodies, masons, smiths and carpenters who raise magnificent palaces, live like pariahs in the slums.”

The above mentioned lines seem like a very recent picture of our society, but to the surprise they were loudly said by Bhagat Singh around 90 years back in court to the magistrate. These lines by Bhagat Singh clearly speak of the naked truth about our society which remains the same even after a century.

Bhagat Singh/ Image courtesy: Leftword

Bhagat Singh writes about the importance of participating in political activities by the youth and students of this country in one of his important writings ‘Students and Politics’. In the article he writes,

‘We understand that the main task of the students is to study, they should pay full attention towards it; but is it not a part of the education to gather knowledge regarding the situation that our country is in and develop the ability to think about measures to improve it? If not, we consider this education, which is only obtained to gain some clerical skills, of no use. What is the use of this kind of education?’

When India is going through a Brahminical Hindutva fascist regime of RSS-BJP with the increase in an onslaught on Dalits, Muslims, Adivasis and the working people, Bhagat Singh’s vision becomes more and more relevant. His articles named “Communal Riots and its Solutions” and “Problems of Untouchability” clearly condemns the division of working people in the name of religion and caste and exposes it to be a policy of the ruling establishment to keep the people away from revolting against their real problems. He wrote:

“The root cause of communal violence is probably economic… To prevent people from fighting each other, ‘class consciousness’ is the need of the day. The poor laborers and the farmers must be clearly taught that their real enemies are the capitalists.”

He warned the Dalits to stay away from the imperialist bureaucracy as he identified the same to be the cause of their slavery and poverty. He emphasized the need for organizing Dalits and to revolt against the present system and bring a revolution to come out of the menace of caste.

As a Marxist, Bhagat Singh defined revolution as “the complete overthrow of the existing social order and its replacement with the socialist order” as written in the article “To Young Political Workers”. Against the Gandhian way of compromise and reforms under the British structure, he showed the alternate path to the youth of organizing the working class and the peasantry and to work for a destruction of the present system and rebuilding the economic and political structure of the nation.

He analyzed the prevailing conditions, and advised the youth to adopt Marxism as the ideology and form a Communist Party. He stressed that the involvement of huge masses in revolution is elementary, but it would not follow the Gandhian path of non-violence. At that young age, he was quite mature to use all forms of struggles (legal and illegal) in order to complete the revolution. He said,

“The sanctity of law can be maintained only so long as it is the expression of the will of the people.”

While acting as the vanguard of the national liberation movement of India, he envisaged that revolutionaries had to be part of the international communist movement.

Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev and Rajguru remembered at Singhu border during farmers protests 2021.

Had Bhagat Singh been alive in today’s day, he would have surely been dubbed as an Urban Naxal and his organization, Hindustan Republican Socialist Organization Association, would have been banned in the country. If today anybody dares to think, say or act in the same way as Shaheed Bhagat Singh did, he would probably be charged with UAPA and put behind bars. It is precisely in this context that we should remember him and take inspiration from his life.

Just a glimpse of his writings exposes the lies that the right-wing forces uses in their attempts to appropriate him by organizing Tiranga marches and paying tributes. He had done detailed studies of the history of Bolshevik revolution and writings by various Marxists. He was clear that it did not matter whether Purushottam Das Thakur (a wealthy industrialist of his times) ruled India or the British if the exploitation of man by man has not ended. He said:

“Let us declare that the state of war does exist and shall exist so long as the Indian toiling masses and the natural resources are being exploited by a handful of parasites. They may be purely British Capitalist or mixed British and Indian or even purely Indian.”

This understanding perfectly sums-up the present struggles of labourers, farmers and working people nationwide against the Brahminical Hindutva fascist forces.

Network of indigenous communities on padyatra for rights in Nagarhole Tiger Reserve

Nagarhole: Last Wednesday, several indigenous communities across the country came together in Nagarhole and launched a week-long padayatra across the villages inside Nagarhole Tiger Reserve to protect their rights. The padyatra began on 15 March 2023 from Kumbarakatte village and reached the forest department office, Nagarhole Tiger reserve yesterday. The sit-in in front of the office will continue indefinitely. Some community leaders will also hold a two-day intercommunity dialogue and press conference at the Indian Social Institute, Bangalore from 22-23 March 2023.  The padyatra is being organised under the name of Community Network Against Protected Areas (CNAPA), a newly formed network of people’s movements and groups resisting the capitalist and neo-colonial conservation model adopted by the government, and foregrounding the idea of radical community ownership where forests, animals, and peoples equal. The network includes Adivasis who have been displaced or who face eviction due to conservation projects in Uttar Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Arunachal Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh, Odisha, and Karnataka. Two important organisations leading the fight are Nagarhole Adivasi Jamapale Hakkusthapana Samiti and Budakata Krishikare Sangathan. Even after the padyatra is over, they will continue to be on indefinite protest until their rights are recognised.  In the past, the Nagarhole Tiger Reserve has seen several protests by Adivasi communities such as the Jenu Kuruba community, who in the face of forceful evictions and violence, demanded that the Forest Rights Act be implemented and that their ancestral rights to the forest be respected.  

The extractive and neo-colonial nature of India’s conservation practices:

India’s conservation policy and practice are rooted in a “fortress conservation” model which involves creating Protected Areas (PAs) or exclusive human-free “wilderness” zones such as wildlife sanctuaries, national parks, and reserves. This model has a colonial and romanticised view of nature and propagates a false dichotomy between people and animals.  The declaration of Adivasi land as a PA is a violation of constitutional rights vested in Gram Sabhas and forest rights committees (FRCs). It is also a violation of the Panchayat (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act or PESA, 1996 applicable in Schedule Areas.  When a region gets declared as a PA, thousands of Adivasi communities are evicted. The National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) is supposed to offer a ‘relocation package’ consisting of cash compensation and housing, healthcare, and education infrastructure to displaced families. However, many families are evicted without receiving packages. Out of the 56,257 families that have been evicted since the inception of the tiger projects in 1972, 44,000 families have not received relocation packages. For those that have, the living conditions are appalling and many are forced into daily wage work at construction sites. Communities who live adjacent to PAs and need to access those forests for livelihood are also stopped from going in. Instead, PAs have become extremely militarised zones, resulting in local people being shot, implicated in false cases, beaten up and killed by park rangers like the Special Tiger Protection Force in Kaziranga(Assam), Nagarhole (Karnataka), Similipal (Odisha) and Sundarbans over the years. The Kaziranga National Park even has a “shoot-at-sight” policy. 

35 Adivasis Arrested After Run-ins with the Forest Department

On the other hand, massive swathes of forested land in Tiger-bearing regions have been diverted toward mining operations. In fact, NTCA’s relocation programmes are financed from money that mining companies deposit with the government for conducting mining operations in forested areas. Tourism projects and other market-based programs such as eco-resorts and safari trails are also carried out within PAs without any care for the ecological impact. To appeal to tourists, eco-engineering practices are adopted and exotic species are imported from abroad, affecting local ecosystems. These projects are also responsible for the erosion of local people’s conservation ethos, knowledge systems, and customary resource management practices. Any resistance by Adivasis and other forest-dwelling communities results in criminalisation and harassment by the forest department and the wildlife and forest conservation lobby (NGOs and bureaucracy). Many Adivasi/Tribal leaders have been slapped with false cases, coerced, tortured, and murdered. Adivasi/Tribal people are also made scapegoats in wildlife poaching cases to protect organised syndicates of poachers. The Post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework proposes to upscale PAs by 30% by 2030, which can only be seen as another move to erode Adivasi/Tribal rights in the name of biodiversity conservation. Despite this, they continue to assert their rights and fight evictions. The two-day intercommunity dialogue at the Indian Social Institute, Bangalore will continue this conversation on the global capitalist and neo-colonial conservation model. The CNAPA challenges the cartel of forest departments, wildlife NGOs, conservationists, and corporations by exposing their collaborative exploitation of various natural resources and black-marketing of wildlife parts. undermining communities’ knowledge and agency in the practice of conservation embedded in co-existence. The meeting is like a coming together of communities and people to articulate their voices against the destructive impacts of conservation and to chart working strategies for grounding the idea of radical community ownership of forests and commons, including wildlife. 

Kisan Mahapanchayat in Delhi, Demand Govt to Fulfill its Promises

0
Delhi, 20th March 2023: Delhi’s historic Ramlila Maidan today witnessed a hugely successful Kisan Mahapanchayat on the call of Samyukt Kisan Morcha (SKM) , which was attended by tens of thousands of farmers from all over the country. More than 50 speakers at the Mahapanchayat stressed that SKM shall continue its protests against corporate control over agriculture and the anti-farmer policies of the Union Govt. Speakers at the Mahapanchayat condemned the debt-Ridden Modi govt for selling of Farm Sector, Agriculture Land, Forests, and Natural Resources to Corporate Profiteers. It was announced that SKM will immediately hold state conventions and All-India yatras to mobilise farmers. SKM will also mobilize people on farmers’ demands for the commencement of spate of Countrywide Massive Struggles to End Corporate Exploitation.

SKM submits Memorandum to Union Govt to Immediately Implement MSP Guarantee Law

A 15-member Delegation of SKM met the Union Minister for Agriculture & Farmers Welfare at Krishi Bhawan and submitted 2 memoranda to him. Discussions were held and the Govt agreed to engage in dialogue with SKM on an ongoing basis to resolve the pending and burning issues of farmers. SKM informed the Minister that if the demands are not met in a time-bound manner, SKM shall announce further protests and agitations.

An MSP scheme to transform Indian agriculture

The Delegation comprised of (1) Shri R. Venkaiya – All India Kisan Sabha (2) Dr. Sunilam – Kisan Sangharsh Samiti (3) Shri Prem Singh Gehlawat – All India Kisan Mahasabha (4) Shri V Venkatramaiya – All India Kisan Mazdoor Sabha (5) Shri Suresh Koth – Bhartiya Kisan Mazdoor Union (6) Shri Yudhvir Singh – Bhartiya Kisan Union (7) Shri Hannan Mollah – All India Kisan Sabha (8) Shri Buta Singh Burjgill – Bhartiya Kisan Union (Dakunda) (9) Shri Joginder Singh Ugraha – Bhartiya Kisan Union (Ugraha) (10) Shri Satyawan – All India Kisan Khet Mazdoor Sangathan (11) Shri Avik Saha – Jai Kisan Andolan (12) Shri Darshan Pal – Krantikari Kisan Union (13) Shri Manjeet Rai – Bhartiya Kisan Union (Doaba) (14) Shri Harinder Lakhowal – Bhartiya Kisan Union (Lakhowal) (15) Shri Satnam Singh Behru – Indian Farmers Association. Media Cell – Samyukt Kisan Morcha Contact: [email protected]

How Right-wing Governments take advantage of Crisis: Case of Türkiye

0
On 6 February 2023, a massive earthquake hit southern Türkiye and northern Syria. Over 49,000 people have died and the earthquake flattened cities. Syria has already been struggling with a decade of Civil War and this disaster will add to the refugee crisis. Over half of a crore people have been left homeless and have been forced to live in rain and temperatures that often dip below freezing.

What could have been done?

Türkiye has imposed a three-month state of emergency in many provinces. However, relief systems have been strained in both Syria and Türkiye. The Turkish government’s response has been inadequate, though defenders of the Turkish government have insisted that the Earthquake was a force of nature that could not be prevented. Though the earthquake could not have been prevented, given the vulnerability of the region, it seems odd that a more robust emergency system could not have been properly developed. This is stranger given the history. In Türkiye, Erdogan had come to power in 2002, following the similarly devastating earthquake that hit 1999. In that earthquake, 17,000 people died, and Erdogan promised to make hard choices to prevent a similar disaster from happening again. However, in the aftermath of the recent earthquake, there have been valid criticisms of Erdogan’s government’s response, particularly around centralization and poor response. The earthquake highlighted the weaknesses of the government’s neo-liberal policies and its lack of local control.

How Right-wing governments redirect blame

Rightwing governments have tried to shift the burden of social security, emergency response and social service from the public sector to the private sector. Religious organizations and other identity-based organizations are often propped up, and given an advantage in terms of funding and state support. These organizations are majoritarian and can spread the image that the government should stay out of these activities. In times of crisis, they can spread pro-government messages without making the government liable when things go wrong. At the same time, these governments try to shift the focus from the government’s role to inflammatory issues that can redirect public attention. In Türkiye, anti-Kurdish sentiments have been flagged, as the Turkish government has been increasing its attacks on the Kurdish population, both in Türkiye and in Northern Syria.

Also Read: The Rise of Far-Right Swedish Parliament

The Kurdish people in Syria have already been fighting a multi-side war. In 2012, guided by feminist, anarchist and socialist principles, the people of Rojava Syria declared their region as an autonomous region. They have tried to construct a society which is not accountable to the state or patriarchy. They have built radical self-defence units to protect the freedoms of the people from the area. They have been attacked by the Syrian government at first. During the course of the Syrian Civil War, they have come against fundamentalist groups, like ISIL. Since 2016, the Turkish government had escalated the attacks on the Kurdish regions of Syria, claiming that they are a terrorist group. The Turkish state’s attacks against the revolution in Kurdistan are expected to continue and intensify in the coming weeks and months. The state’s suppression of democratic forces in order to maintain power and conceal the crisis of the Turkish state has a long history, with the use of poison gas being a sad tradition in Kurdistan. The AKP-MHP regime is planning its next steps to crush self-governance in Kurdistan, relying on the backing of international powers to supply war equipment that is used to commit brutal crimes on a daily basis. The war in Syria also played a significant role in Turkish politics. The government switched its focus to terrorism and continued its attacks on Kurds. International players, such as the USA, Russia, and Syria, were also involved in the conflict. Recent attacks, such as ongoing poison gas attacks in Southern Kurdistan, targeted drone strikes on the autonomous area of Northern and Eastern Syria, the upcoming elections in Türkiye, and the catastrophic earthquake that recently occurred in Türkiye, are all part of this continuation of the genocidal policy against Kurdish society. The rulers continue to resort to the cruellest means in their fight against the aspirations for freedom of the people in the Middle East.

Inadequacy in the Turkish response

The rescue systems in Türkiye were not prepared for an earthquake of this magnitude, and NGOs often took the slack when they were ineffective. These NGOs can be used by the right wing to promote their propaganda. In 2009, the government established the Disaster and Emergency Management Authority (AFAD) to coordinate disaster relief. The government also promoted faith-based organizations, particularly during the aftermath of the earthquake, which was seen as a way to gain more support for the ruling AKP party. However, the government’s response to the earthquake was slow, and there were criticisms that it was being used for propaganda purposes. The earthquake occurred during a period of political uncertainty, with the 2023 elections looming. Erdogan was losing ground to the main opposition party, the Republican People’s Party (CHP). In response, Erdogan declared a State of Emergency, which enabled him to make use of crisis points like earthquakes and pandemics to maintain his grip on power. The rising racism in Europe was also a significant issue in Turkish politics. The Syrian Civil War had been used by the right wing to promote fearmongering against Turkish refugees. The Turkish government used the hurt response to the earthquake to gain more support for their policies. The right-wing playbook is similar across many countries, with rising racism being a common tactic. The comparison with India is significant, particularly around how the Gujarat earthquake was mobilized and then used for propaganda purposes. The government declared a State of Emergency, similar to Erdogan’s, to maintain its grip on power. The manipulation of these events might seem distant, but the patterns can be seen in governments across the world. Even in India, we have seen how such a pattern was deployed during times of crisis, such as the 2001 Gujarat earthquake, where Hindu organizations took advantage of foreign funding to organize the local populations against minorities, or even during the pandemic, where the failure of government response was taken advantage of, by Hindutva elements, to spread messages to affected populations that worked in favour of the government. Author is a mathematician and an activist based in Bangalore, India. 

Slum Demolitions and the Everyday Construction of Urban Citizenship

Last Friday, eight-night shelters for the homeless and a few jhuggis were demolished in Yamuna Pushta, near Nigambodh Ghat and Qudsia Ghat. These shelters, built by the Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board (DUSIB) and managed by NGOs, have allegedly been around for eight-ten years. They were set up with the aim of providing basic medical care and support to homeless people with injuries or illnesses, and are used by many who perform informal or contract work in nearby areas.

The demolitions were carried out by the DUSIB themselves and nearly 200 police personnel were involved in the demolition process. Many occupants claim that they were not given any prior notice or even a chance to take their belongings. Some people were supposedly taken away to another shelter but many are still on the banks of the river and have been rendered completely homeless.

On 9 March 2023, activists from the Centre for Holistic Development filed a petition in the Delhi High Court on behalf of the shelters on Yamuna against the demolition drive. The court scheduled a second hearing for 14 March, but the shelters were bulldozed that very night. Despite this, on the 14 March hearing, the Delhi High Court dismissed the petition and merely asked the government to provide prior notice while carrying out future demolitions and relocations.

Many activist groups claim that this particular round of Yamuna Pushta demolitions has to do with the upcoming G20 Summit in September 2023, which would bring a large number of foreign delegates to New Delhi. While officials deny any connection to the G20, this conclusion is more likely than not. While high-profile international events like sports competitions, pageants, music festivals, and diplomatic events bring excitement and bustle to the country’s middle and upper classes, these events are an existential threat to the city’s poorest. In welcoming important external guests and opening the country up to an international audience, governments across the Third World resort to razing slums, criminalising poverty, and driving the residents out of the city. Over 2,50,000 were left homeless in preparation for the Commonwealth Games in New Delhi. A report by the Housing and Land Rights Network lists at least 10 separate instances of demolitions in the name of the Commonwealth Games between 2004 to 2010.

Khori Gaon Demolition Continues Amidst Police Brutality and No Rehabilitation by State

Officials, however, stated that the encroachers were being removed because the Yamuna floodplains are an eco-sensitive zone. L-G VK Saxena acknowledged that the encroachers are poor and in need of support, but he also referenced the NGT and Supreme Court orders to remove encroachments on the Yamuna floodplains, and argued that the support cannot come at the cost of the environment. 

The Yamuna Pushta demolitions are not ahistorical, but representative of a complex history relating to Delhi’s urbanization process. This particular incident has all the same elements as previous Pushta demolitions over the past two decades: false rhetoric of opposition between the environment and the poor, evictions in the name of high-profile international events, judicial complicity, and the use of aesthetics of a ‘world-class’ city rather than evidence-based documentation to determine who deserves ‘the right to the city’. Asher Ghertner, in Ruled By Aesthetics (2015), argues that the world-class city is an idealized vision of a modern, privatized, and slum-free city that has been assembled from transnationally circulating images of other so-called global cities. Not just an idea in people’s heads, it is a material practice that shapes the character of urban development. Creating a world-class future requires attracting foreign capital, encouraging rising valuations of existing capital stock, and producing a citizenry desirous of cities in which they can enjoy the benefits of world-class consumption and lifestyle. While external events like the G20 represent both an anxiety around and an aspiration to appear like a world-class city, the same aesthetic sensibility drives everyday judicial decision-making that determines urban citizenship.