A special National Investigation Agency court on Thursday rejected the bail petition of activist Gautam Navlakha in the Bhima Koregaon case, reported Bar&Bench.
Navlakha, a former secretary of the People’s Union for Democratic Rights, had moved the High Court after the special National Investigation Agency court rejected his bail plea on September 5.
The National Investigation Agency had opposed Navlakha’s bail plea alleging that he is a member of the banned Communist Party of India (Maoist) and that he possessed incriminating documents related to the group.
Navlakha had challenged the special court’s order in the Bombay High Court. Last month, the High Court had directed the special court to conduct a fresh hearing. The High Court had noted that the special court’s order was cryptic and did not consider an analysis of evidence carried out by the prosecution, reported The Indian Express.
On November 10, the Supreme Court had allowed Navlakha to be placed under house arrest in Navi Mumbai for a month. The house arrest was extended by a month on December 14 on account of his medical condition.
The Bhima Koregaon case, in which Navlakha has been named as an accused person, pertains to caste violence in a village near Pune in 2018. A total of 16 persons were arrested in the case. The 73-year-old was arrested in April 2020.
Elgar Parishad Event ‘Had No Role’ in Bhima Koregaon Violence
On 22nd January 2022, a senior police official investigating caste violenceon members of the Dalit community at Bhima Koregaon on January 1, 2018, has, on oath, admitted that the Elgar Parishad event, organised 30-kilometres away in Pune city, had no role in the violence.
This significant revelation by Sub-Divisional Police Officer Ganesh More, made before the two-member judicial commission to investigate the violence, rips to pieces the Pune police and subsequently the National Investigation Agency’s claims against the 16 human rights defenders arrested in a separate case.
Pakistan’s parliament on Thursday rejected a Supreme Court order to conduct provincial snap polls, in the latest move in a power struggle between the government and the top court amid political and economic instability.
The top court had on Tuesday ruled illegal the government’s move to delay the snap polls in two provinces where former prime minister Imran Khan had dissolved his local governments earlier this year.
The speaker, in a live broadcast, said a motion was adopted by a majority of lawmakers to reject the court decision by a three member panel headed by the chief justice and to demand a full court panel consisting of all judges hear the case.
Pakistan court strikes down colonial-era ‘sedition’ law
The court’s Tuesday order said that the elections in two provinces should go ahead despite government reluctance to hold the votes now as it struggles with an economic crisis and a political challenge from the opposition.
It gave a date of May 14 for voting in Pakistan’s largest and most prosperous Punjab province, and a pending date for voting in the northwestern Khyber Pakkhtunkhawa province due to some technical issues.
The government and judiciary have been at odds over cases related to political-wrangling, and parliament last week introduced a draft law to clip the chief justice’s powers.
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif’s government has been saying the country’s poor economic condition didn’t allow spending on the snap polls and then on a general elections due later this year.
Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party and its allies had dissolved the provincial governments, hoping that it would force Sharif’s government to hold snap polls across the country, his longstanding demand since he was ousted a year ago.
Separately, Law Minister Azam Tarar said that a full court bench should be set up to look at the issue of elections and give a single date for the general elections in the country.
The resolution has laid bare the political fault lines and threat of further instability in the country as the tussle between the judiciary and executive has also drawn the parliament in it.
On 24th March 2023, the cabinet of ministers of Karnataka state arbitrarily and in absolute haste scrapped the reservationsthat were provided for the Muslim community under the head 2B of the Other Backward Classes (OBC) category. Instead, they have been moved to the Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) quota. The 4% share in reservations that were released by the scrapping of the 2B Category of Other Backward Classes has been shared equally amongst the two dominant communities of the state – the Lingayat and Vokkaligas – each of them allotted an additional 2% share in reservations.
The order goes to make two major claims as the reasons for the scrapping of the reservations under the 2B category. Evoking the judgement in the case of T. Muralidhar and Others v. State of Andhra Pradesh, it states that the 7 judges’ bench in its order dated 8.02.2010 ruled that the reservations provided in Andhra Pradesh Reservation was unsustainable and in violation of Articles 14, 15(1) and 16(2) and that an appeal against the said order was pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
Union Home Minister who has been making frequent visits to the poll-bound state of Karnataka was speaking at the India Rising Summit where he said, “I agree, we got a bit late doing it (scrapping reservation for Muslims). Reservation on the basis of religion is illegal and it is not in the constitution. There cannot be any reservation based on religion. Congress did it for polarisation and we corrected it” thereby spreading misinformation amongst citizenry that the reservations provided to Muslims was based on religion.
However, it must be noted that in the case of Andhra Pradesh the reservations provided to Muslim community was struck down by the judiciary on the grounds of procedural impropriety, improper information and the possibility of increased conversions. The case of Karnataka has been very different. Reservations provided to the Muslim community in Karnataka is on the basis of their socio-economic and educational backwardness.
The order goes further to note that “Whereas at the time 2B category was created and the members of Muslim Community were included/classified as Backward Classes for the purpose of reservation, there was neither any recommendation by any body, nor was there any empirical data nor any materials for granting them the said status. Whereas the members of the Minority community have adequate protection under the Constitution for establishment and administration of Minority Institution/Students. Whereas the Government has taken into consideration the above amongst other factors”.
However, the order’s claim that the Muslim community was provided reservations under the 2B category without being recommended by anybody or in the absence of empirical data is a blatant lie that has found a place not just in the rhetorical narratives of the Sangh Parivar and the Bharatiya Janata Party leaders as was the case of CM Basavaraja Bommai’s statement on the issue but also in a Government Order!
On one end, the order clearly overlooks Para 6 of the GO it cites as a reference! The said paragraph reads as “Now the Karnataka State Commission for Backward Classes have submitted special report and 71 advices vide their letter dated 04-12-2000 read at Sl. No. 4 above. Pending consideration of the entire report, the Government have examined in detail the Creamy Layer Policy contained in the Special Report and 71 Advices, relating to inclusions, deletions, correction of spellings etc. and have made the following orders” there by clearly establishing that the reservation were provided on the basis of recommendations made by the Karnataka State Commission for Backward Classes.
On the other end it also disregards the over-a-century long history of affirmative actions in Karnataka. The reservations provided to the Muslim community dates back to the pre-independent times wherein the then Maharaja of Mysore, Krishna Raja Wadiyar IV fondly known as Nalwadi Krishna Raja Wodeyar amongst the people of Karnataka implemented it based on the recommendations made by the Justice Miller Committee in 1918 which continued to be in place until Independence. In the post-independence era, all the Karnataka’s Backward Classes Commissions with only the LG Havanur Commission being the exception have, after considering various parameters recommended that a majority of the Muslim community be provided reservations on grounds of socio-economic and educational backwardness. This was later also affirmed by the Sachar committee report.
In fact, the order in question violates the principles laid out by the Supreme Court in the Indira Swahney case which stated that any changes to be made to the categories that have the rights of reservation must be based on empirical data-based study.
The government order that the Muslim community can avail reservations under the EWS quota is nothing but a mockery of social justice! The socio-economically and educationally backward Muslim communities in Karnataka are now expected to compete with the more better off communities under the EWS quota thereby killing the very idea of social justice where the other dominant communities placed alongside the Muslims are expected to corner the provisions of reservations.
It must also be noted that Karnataka is the first state in India to implement the National Education Policy 2020. The NEP is a nexus of neoliberal model of privatisation and Hindutva as is very evident from its promotion of public-philanthropic-partnership model and ‘Sanskrit knowledge systems’ coupled with Bramhinical ideals like ‘dharma’, ‘karma’, ‘swachchhata’ that form the ideological basis of the caste system. The document has nowhere used the word ‘reservation’, implying that the New India under Modi doesn’t care about social justice policies in education sector as well. In this backdrop, the move comes forth as a very toxic mix of casteism and communalism.
However, it is clear that the BJP government, fearing that they will be voted out of power in the only South Indian state they have gained some ground at, has used reservations as a tool at their disposal to be able to please and garner votes from certain sections of the electorate. This is evident when we understand that all the changes with respect to reservations – be it the case of SC/ST reservations, Internal reservations and OBC reservations have been introduced in the last three months (since December 2022) in the run-up to Karnataka Assembly Elections 2023 after sitting on people’s demands over the last 3 years.
As students’ organisations, we understand this as yet another attack by the ruling BJP regime on the rights of minorities, more so the educational rights of Muslims. After closing the gates of education to Muslim women students in the garb of Hijab and the scrapping of Maulana Azad National Fellowships and the Minority Scholarships of the PhD Scholars, by scrapping the reservations, the ruling regime is determined to deny educational opportunity to the Muslim community.
It is in this regard, that all pro-people students’ organisations demand the BJP Government to take back its order. Else, the changes brought in by the BJP government with scant regard to social justice and history of Karnataka shall mark the beginning of end of BJP in the only Southern state it has a footing!
As students’ organisations that uphold Preambular values of Socio-Economic and Political Justice and the constitutional values of Liberty, Equality and Fraternity; we understand that the ploy employed by the BJP government in this case to incite communal conflicts in the garb of reservations in the run-up to elections. However, people of Karnataka and students in particular shall rise above such petty communal ploy.
Students’ organizations hereby resolve to work with all communities in our quest to uphold the Right to affirmative action and thereby ensure that social justice is served to not just the Muslim community but to every person of Karnataka!
Participant organisations: AISA, ASA, Bangalore University Students’ Union, Collective, DVP, GIO, KVS, PARIVARTHANA & SIO
The Congress has named 42 candidates in its second list for Karnataka Assembly elections scheduled on May 10. Out of the 42 seats, the party has marked Melukote constituency for Sarvodaya Karnataka Party. The party had announced 124 names in its first candidate list that it released last month.
In the first list, Congress announced that state party president DK Shivakumar will be contesting from the Kanakapura constituency. Priyank Kharge will be contesting from Chitapur (SC) constituency.
Amid expectations that former chief minister and leader of the oppositionSiddaramaiah will contest from Varuna, the leader was allotted the same constituency by the Congress’s high command.
Amid speculations of joining BJP ahead of the state assembly elections scheduled on May 10, Kannada actor Kichcha Sudeep confirmed that he will not contest elections, but will support BJP leader and Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai. Sharing a stage with CM Bommai, he said, “He (Bommai) is like a father figure. If he requires my help, I will help him. I am here to support my uncle.” Meanwhile, expelled JD(S) leader and former Mandya MP LR Shivarame Gowda joined the BJP in presence of party’s state chief Nalinkumar Kateel in Bengaluru on Wednesday.
Congress releases second list of 42 candidates for Karnataka Assembly elections pic.twitter.com/wzpumgNTf3
The Supreme Court Wednesday refused to entertain a plea by fourteen political parties alleging that the Central government led by Bharatiya Janata Party was misusing central agencies like Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and Enforcement Directorate (ED) against leaders of opposition parties.
A bench of Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud and Justices PS Narasimha and JB Pardiwala said that political leaders do not enjoy an immunity higher than common citizens as reported by Bar &Bench.“You are trying to extrapolate the statistics into solid legal guidelines. So now these statistics only relates to the politicians,” CJI Chandrachud said.
“How can we start laying down guidelines in abstract context. Laying down general guidelines de hors the facts of the case cannot be done. If an individual comes to us, then the law can be laid down as highest court of the country.. it is in context facts of the case and also a general law. (But) we need to have facts in a case or group of cases,” the Court said.
Sorry we cannot entertain this, the bench added.
The petition was filed by Indian National Congress (INC), Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK), Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD), Bharat Rasthra Samithi (BRS), All Indian Trinamool Congress (TMC), Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), Shiv Sena (UBT), JMM, JD(U), Communist Party of India (Marxist), CPI, Samajwadi Party, J&K National Conference.
The petitioners contended that has been an alarming rise in the use of coercive criminal processes against opposition political leaders and other citizens exercising their fundamental right to dissent and disagree with the union government.
Madras HC Calls CBI ‘caged parrot’, Asks Union Govt to Make it Autonomous
Investigating agencies such as the CBI and ED are being increasingly deployed in a selective and targeted manner with a view to completely crush political dissent and upend the fundamental premises of a representative democracy, it was submitted.
The petitioner also shed light on the following statistics to buttress their claims.
– The action rate on raids in terms of complaints filed following raids reduced from 93 per cent in 2005-2014, to 29 per cent in 2014-2022;
– Only 23 convictions have been secured as of now under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) despite a rise in the number of cases registered by the ED from 209 in 2013-14 to 981 in 2020-21, and 1180 in 2021-22;
– Between 2004 and 14, of the 72 political leaders investigated by the CBI, 43 (under 60 percent) were from the opposition of the time. Now, this figure is over 95 percent.
In ED investigations, proportion of opposition leaders from total number of politicians investigated rose from 54 percent before 2014 to 95 percent after 2014.
The petitioners, therefore, sought guidelines to fulfil and realise the guarantee of personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution for all citizens including those targeted for exercising their right to political dissent and for performing their duties as the political opposition.
– For arrest and remand
The petitioners prayed for the triple test to be used by police officers, ED officials and courts alike for the arrest of persons in any cognisable offences except those involving serious bodily violence.
Where these conditions are not satisfied, alternatives like interrogation at fixed hours or at the most house arrest be used to meet the demands of investigation.
– For bail
The petitioner prayed the principle of ‘bail as rule, jail as exception’ be followed by all courts especially in cases of non-violent offences.
They also prayed that bail be denied only where the triple-test is not met.
In cases where special laws such as PMLA with stringent bail conditions are concerned, the petitioners sought directions to harmonise such bail with Article 21 of the Constitution.
Where it appears that trial is unlikely to complete within 6 months, the accused be released on bail even under special laws unless the conditions under the triple-test are not fulfilled.
During today’s hearing, Senior Advocate AM Singhvi appearing for the petitioners, stated that there was clearly a skewed used of the CBI in jurisdictions of opposition ruled States which led to a skewed democratic playing field.
“Thus opposition is only fighting these cases… democracy has been held as a basic structure of the constitution”, he argued.
It was further contended that the petitioner-parties represent 42 per cent of the electorate and if they are affected, the people are affected.
“These are parties all across the spectrum.. thus, level playing field has to be maintained.”
The senior counsel asked,
“What is democracy when the leaders are just fighting these cases?”
Further, he underscored that the process itself was the punishment the triple test could not be satisfied in almost 95 per cent cases. Thus, he argued that when there is a conscious weaponisation of an entire branch of law, then focusing on individual cases was not the answer.
However, the Court declined to allow the plea.
Karnataka police on Wednesday arrested right – wing activist Puneeth Kerehalli, who is accused in the alleged murder of a cattle trader in Ramanagara district. Puneeth along with four others were caught in Rajasthan and they were arrested by the police.
According to police, Kerehalli runs ‘Rashtra Rakshana Pade’ a right-wing organization. He had also organized campaigns against halal meat and sought a ban on Muslim traders at Hindu temple fairs in the past.
His arrest comes four days after he went absconding. Puneeth is accused of killing Pasha and assaulting his two associates — Syed Zaheer and Irfan — for transporting cattle. Pasha was chased, assaulted and killed by a gang of Hindutva extremists led by Puneeth on March 31. Through videos posted on social media, Puneeth has been known for using a stun gun to inflict pain during his ‘cow vigilante’ outings, and Pasha’s body also had burn marks on it.
Puneeth has been photographed with top Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leaders in Karnataka. He and four others were booked by the police under Sections 302 (Murder), 341 (wrongful restraint), and 504 (Intentional insult with intent to provoke breach of the peace) of the IPC, based on a complaint lodged by Pasha’s family members. The FIR stated that although Pasha had documents to prove that the cattle he was ferrying was from the local market, Puneeth and his gang continued to threaten him. They even demanded a fee of Rs 2 lakh to release him and threatened to kill him if the amount wasn’t paid.
In a significant judgment, the Supreme Court on Wednesday ruled against the telecast ban imposed by the Union Government on Malayalam news channel MediaOne.
The Supreme Court on Wednesday quashed the Centre’s denial of security clearance to Malayalam news channel MediaOne, and pulled up the Ministry of Home Affairs for raising national security claims in “thin air” without facts.
A bench headed by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud set aside the Kerala High Court order which had upheld the Centre’s decision to ban the channel’s telecast on security grounds.
The top court said critical views of the channel against government policies cannot be termed as anti-establishment as an independent press is necessary for robust democracy.
“National security claims cannot be made out of thin air, there must be material facts backing it,” the bench said.
The Court passed the judgment in a special leave petition filed by Madhyamam Broadcasting Ltd (MBL) – the company running the channel- assailing the Kerala High Court’s judgment of upholding the decision of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting to not renew the broadcast license of the channel for want of security clearance from the Ministry of Home Affairs. The channel’s editor Pramod Raman and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists had also filed separate petitions challenging the High Court’s judgment.
The top court was hearing the plea of the news channel against the Kerala High Court’s order which had upheld the Centre’s decision to ban its telecast on security grounds.
On January 31, 2022, the Centre barred the telecast of the Malayalam channel andrevoked its licence on grounds of national security. The government’s directive was challenged by the channel in the Kerala High Court which upheld the telecast ban order.
Last year in June, the Centre told the Supreme Court that the denial of security clearance to MediaOne is based on intelligence inputs, which are “sensitive” and “secret in nature”. It said that as a matter of policy and in the interest of security of the State and its establishments, the MHA does not disclose the reasons for denial.
The Supreme Court heavily criticised the High Court’s approaching in upholding the Centre’s decision solely on the basis of the sealed cover documents submitted by the Ministry of Home Affairs.
On 2 April 2023, opposition leader, Raila Odinga called off the mass demonstrations that he was leading in Kenya since late March 2023, where thousands came out on the streets. This came in response to an appeal by President William Ruto to engage in talks. While protests have been suspended, Odinga has been clear that they could restart within a few days.
The protests were led by Odinga when he blamed the Kenyan President for a failing economy and also claimed that Ruto’s victory in the 2022 election was fixed, despite a ruling from the Supreme Court upholding the validity of the results. During the protest, Odinga demanded that the government allow access to the 2022 election results from the electoral commission’s main computers. Police have been violent at the protests using force to disperse protesters, resulting in four deaths since the protests started.
Many Human rights groups, including the Kenya Human Rights Commission, have expressed concern over the abuse by the police during the protests and urged restraint. The Media Council of Kenya reported that journalists have been attacked during the demonstrations.
The current protests are the aftermath of controversy in the 2022 elections though they have a long history. The then Deputy President William Ruto was declared the winner of the 9 August 2022 poll, beating Odinga by a very narrow margin. The voting process was relatively peaceful. However, almost immediately, the announcement resulted in protests where supporters of Odinga took to the streets in protest, setting fire to tires and clashing with police.
The political landscape is heating up!
Kenya is witnessing a huge anti-government protest organized by opposition leader Raila Odinga. pic.twitter.com/Qp0NZvNoR2
— The International Magazine (@TheIntlMagz) March 29, 2023
Despite previous pledges by both candidates to handle any disputes in court rather than on the streets, protests erupted in many of Odinga’s strongholds. This was partially expected, as every presidential election outcome has been contested in Kenya since 2002. Kenya had been grappling with severe drought leading to high prices, and widespread corruption.
Kenya has undergone significant political changes in the past few decades, marked by several key events, beginning with the 2002 general election. In the 2002 general election, 62% of voters rejected Kenya Africa National Union’s (KANU) presidential candidate, Uhuru Kenyatta, voting in the National Rainbow Coalition (NARC) into power. The Incumbent Daniel arap Moi could not run for a third term due to the two-term limit in the Constitution of Kenya. This was the first time in Kenya since independence in 1964 when KANU was not in power. Kenya had a de facto one-party rule in 1969. The general election saw the end of the dominance of the KANU, which had governed the country since independence, including 23 years as the only legal party. KANU had been a pro-market conservative party and ruled Kenya without contestation until the 1992 election when other parties were allowed to contest.
Mwai Kibaki became the President of Kenya, and Daniel Arap Moi, the longest-serving president in Kenya’s history, stepped down from power. In 2003, Crispin Mbai, the head of a key and contentious committee in Kenya’s constitutional reforms that led to the elections, was murdered. Many perceived this as a political murder, sparking outrage and protests, leading to the current cycle of protests following the elections.
In 2005 a constitutional referendum was held. This was perceived by the people as a move against President Mwai Kibaki. 57% of voters rejected the draft constitution.
In 2007, the general elections were held, and the campaign and election period were heavily polarised along ethnic lines. The results were contested by the Orange Democratic Movement, led by Odinga, and the Party of National Unity led by Mwai Kibaki. Mwai Kibaki was declared victorious. The post-election crisis of 2007–2008 began shortly after the election, with at least 1,133 people killed and more than 600,000 displaced. Ruto was one of the people indicted to stand trial at the International Criminal Court for their involvement in Kenya’s 2007/2008 political violence, but these charges were later dismissed.
In 2010, Kenya held a constitutional referendum, with two-thirds of voters approving a new constitution. In 2013, Uhuru Kenyatta was voted in as the fourth President of Kenya, with Ruto as his deputy president, following the 2013 Kenyan General Elections. In 2016, the International Criminal Court dropped its case against the deputy president of Kenya, Ruto.
In 2017, the Kenyan General Elections were held, with Chris Msando, the head of IT at the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission found murdered. The election was highly contested with allegations of rigging, leading to protests in Nairobi, Western Kenya, and the Coastal region. The police response was lethal, leading to the deaths of at least 12 people and over a hundred injured. The Supreme Court annulled the election results, and fresh elections were called for within 60 days. In the second Presidential election held on 26th October 2017, Odinga refused to participate, citing uncorrected issues within the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission, leading to Kenyatta being declared the winner with 98% of the vote.
In 2018, amidst a media blackout, Raila Odinga was sworn in as the “People’s President” in an effort to persuade Uhuru Kenyatta to come to the negotiation table. Kenyan lawyer Miguna Miguna officiated the ceremony but was deported in February following treason-related charges. The same year, an investigative report revealed that Cambridge Analytica, a data analytics firm, played a critical role in the elections.
Faith in Kenyan elections are at a low owing to the long history of corruption by the political elite in Kenya. Mass Protests after the election had become common since the country moved away from the draconian rule of KANU. Since then, every election, the results have been challenged by the great mass of disenchanted Kenyan voters. As elections are always suspect, protests are one place where the people find their voice.
Palakkad: A court in Kerala on Tuesday convicted fourteen persons for lynching and murder of a tribal man Madhu in 2018.
The verdict, that comes 5 years after a murder that created much outrage across communities, was delivered by SC/ST Special Court Judge Ratheesh Kumar.
According to Mathrubhumi, the order was passed by a special court constituted for trying cases under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act (SC/ST Act)
The prosecution case was that Madhu, a mentally challenged tribal youth, was tied up and brutally beaten to death by the accused in Palakkad’s Attappadi.
The accused had allegedly caught Madhu from a nearby forest and assaulted him after accusing him of stealing rice from a grocery shop.
The accused who were found guilty today by the Special Court were accused of committing offenses punishable under Sections 143, 147, 148, 323, 324, 326, 294(b), 342, 352, 364, 367, 368, and 302 r/w 149 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Sections 3(1) (d), (r) (s) and 3(2) (v) of the Scheduled Caste and SC/ST(PoA) Act.
The High Court had granted bail to them earlier subject to several conditions.
However, the Special Court later cancelled the bail after noting that several witnesses had turned hostile at the behest of accused.
The High Court subsequently upheld the cancellation of bail in 2022.’
The Incident
On 23 May, 2018 a gang of men from Mananthvadi village ganged up against Madhu, a mentally unstable tribal youth. The assailants bound his hands and beat him up for what they said was stealing grocery from shop. Madhu spent most of his time in the forest and ventured to the village only on lookout for some food. The brutal lynching of a marginalised tribal over picking a pack of rice and some basic grocery, created shock and outrage across communities.
The prosecution case was that Madhu, a mentally challenged tribal youth, was tied up and brutally beaten to death by the convicts who accused him of stealing rice from a grocery shop.
On 30th March, 2023, the Lahore High Court declared Section 124-A of the Pakistan Penal Code unconstitutional for violating several of the rights guaranteed in the Pakistan Constitution, such as the freedom of speech and expression. This follows on the heels of the Indian Supreme Court putting the Indian equivalent of the same provision in abeyance while a process of review takes place on its efficacy and need. The Indian Supreme Court order, similar to the Lahore High Court judgment, takes note of the argument that the law of sedition, as Section 124-A is known, is used as a tool for the prosecution and targeting of views and activities that are critical of the Government or of powerful interests. The vague provision has been amenable to misuse even after several requirements were read into it by the Supreme Court most notably in 1962, such as an incitement to violence and the unlawful use of force.
The question of the constitutionality of the sedition provision has been recurrent both politically as well as legally. It has been pointed out that the provision was suited to the desires of a colonial government, and is fundamentally incompatible with a democratic and rights based legal system, where criticism of the Government should be considered an important right which cannot be suppressed by the threat of criminal law. The Lahore High Court, in its ruling, accepts this argument which leads to the conclusion of the provision’s unconstitutionality. There are obvious similarities in the rights based schema of the Indian Constitution, where the question of freedom of expression and the right to life have undergone extensive development through decades, and the question that remains to be seen is whether the Indian Supreme Court will eventually come to similar conclusions.
From a legal standpoint, it is necessary to clarify a certain argument in order to take this discussion forward. In constitutional law, it is often argued that mere misuse of a particular provision is not grounds to declare that the same is unconstitutional. This has been argued by those keen to defend these laws, that the provision by itself is perfectly valid and necessary, but has been misused. This was also the trend followed in 1962, where the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the provision but attempted to thwart its misuse by adding conditions to when the law could be used. It is possible that the same argument may be made today, and was recently made to defend the constitutionality of another notorious provision, which was Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code (the provision criminalising sexual intercourse between people of the same sex).
Read also: Same Sex Marriage is Not a Fundamental Right: Central Government to the Delhi High Court
The Lahore High Court judgment has proceeded to hold that misuse of the sedition law in Pakistan had attained such intensity and recurrence, that the law had to be held unconstitutional. Similarly, the Indian Supreme Court has held on several past occasions that the effect of a law has to be taken into consideration while deciding its constitutionality. A law can be designed and written in such a manner that on the face of it, it does not have a discriminatory nature. However, if the effect of implementation of that law is discriminatory and unconstitutional, then it should be struck down as being so. Further, if a law by its design is itself prone to misuse, it can be held unconstitutional. To an extent, this answers the use versus misuse argument if one can show that the law of sedition is so prone to misuse by its own design, that it must be held incompatible with the Constitution.
Image Source: https://www.trtworld.com/asia/tens-of-thousands-hit-pakistani-streets-to-protest-imran-khan-s-ouster-56244
It must also be kept in mind that where criminal law is involved, the question of misuse of the law attains a completely different stature than in any other case. Criminal accusations by themselves invoke a very onerous and cumbersome procedure for the accused. The filing of an FIR entails reputational loss, the prospect of arrest, being subjected to searches and seizures, and a host of indirect consequences. These arise much prior to any question of actual guilt or innocence and even use or misuse of the law. Therefore, the use of criminal law must proceed with special caution and care, and where laws are designed to be abused, constitutional safeguards have to be applied to ensure that this cannot be the result.
Finally, it must be said that the judgment of the Lahore High Court puts into perspective the question of afterlife of colonial rule in the legal systems of both India and Pakistan. The entire nature and design of the law of sedition, which was used in the colonial period to maintain control over subjects, must be re-evaluated when it comes to the question of infringing the rights of citizens who hold a legitimate participatory role in the governance of the country and are entitled to be treated with dignity and respect for their rights. There are many forms of government power that are called into question here. The almost unlimited and indefinite detention of persons in custody without trial, the use of extra-legal mechanisms such as demolition of property instead of law, and similar abuses of government power are all called into question if we evaluate the question of sedition in its right context.
The judgment on sedition opens the door to question all the ways in which a thin veneer of legality is often used to deprive citizens of some of the most cherished rights in the Constitution. Often, the arguments of public safety and order that are used to justify these laws are substitutes for the uncontrolled authority of persons in power against any form of dissent.
Kunal Ambasta, Assistant Professor, NLSIU Bangalore. Views are personal.