Petition for Uniform compensation for Mob Lynching Victims

0
The Supreme Court on Friday sought the response of the Central and State governments to a public interest litigation (PIL) petition seeking uniform and fair compensation policy for victims of mob lynching in the country. A bench of Justices KM Joseph and BV Nagarathna issued notice on the plea filed by the Indian Muslims for Progress and Reforms, through advocate Rizwan Ahmad. The petitioner-organisation, Indian Muslims for Progress, submitted that the current approach of State governments towards ex-gratia compensation for victims of hate crimes and mob lynching is ‘whimsical, discriminatory and arbitrary’, ‘meagre’ and has ‘glaring discrepancies’, reported Bar&Bench. “The approach of State Government’s … in most cases depend on extraneous factors like media coverage, political imperatives and the victim’s religious identity … such an action by the governments is not only the violation of the equality before law (Article 14) but also a breach of Article 15 which mandates non-discrimination against any citizen,” the plea said. Such incidents have a significant bearing on the rule of law, it was contended while flagging recent incidents of heinous crimes against minorities. “In the recent past, self-proclaimed and self-styled vigilantes have brazenly become law unto themselves and have targeted citizens belonging to minority community … targeted violence which mainly originate on suspicion and at times misinformation that the victims were involved in illegal cattle trade,” the petitioner submitted. The trauma caused by hate crimes and mob lynching can last a lifetime, it was emphasised. “It is the duty of the government to support the families affected by such atrocities … The antipathy attitude and discrimination in grant of ex gratia compensation to the victims of hate crime/lynching by state governments are further aggravating the suffering of the victims.” The petitioner prayed that existing compensation schemes, framed pursuant to the top court’s decision in Tehseen Poonawalla, be suitably modified in this regard. The top court gave the respondents six weeks time to file their replies.

Gujarat Court Acquits Maya Kodnani and 68 other Accused in 2002 Naroda Gam Massacre

0
A special court in Ahmedabad on Thursday, 20 April, acquitted all accused in the 2002 Naroda Gam riots case of Gujarat, reported news agency PTI. Former Gujarat minister and BJP leader Maya Kodnani and Bajrang Dal leader Babu Bajrangi are among those 86 accused in the case. Out of 86 accused, 18 have died A special court in Ahmedabad Thursday acquitted all 69 accused, including former BJP MLA Maya Kodnani, ex-Bajrang Dal leader Babu Bajrangi and Vishwa Hindu Parishad leader Jaydeep Patel, in the 2002 Naroda Gam massacre case where 11 members of a minority community were killed during communal riots. The specially designated court of Judge Shubhada Krishnakant Baxi, constituted for speedy trial of the 2002 Gujarat riot cases, had concluded the proceedings on April 5.  ‘ Of the 86 accused in the case, 17 were abated during the course of the trial, leaving 69 accused to stand the trial. All the accused are currently out on bail. Nearly 182 prosecution witnesses were examined in the case. A trial court had convicted both Kodnani and Bajrangi in the Naroda Patiya case and sentenced them to life imprisonment. However, the Gujarat High Court had overturned Kodnani’s conviction, acquitting her, and had upheld Bajrangi’s conviction in the Naroda Patiya case in 2018. The Naroda Gam case was among the nine major riots in Gujarat following the burning of the Sabarmati Express in Godhra on February 27, 2002, in which a speedy day-to-day trial was ordered. The trials were committed to designated courts, and monitored by the Supreme Court — yet the Naroda Gam case has taken years to reach a verdict. On February 28, 2002, 11 Muslims were burnt to death after mobs set their houses on fire in a locality known as Muslim Maholla, Kumbhar Vas, in the Naroda Gam area of Ahmedabad. An FIR was registered at the Naroda police station.

The Trial of Chicago 7 or the ‘trial of Bhima Koregaon and North-East Delhi Riots’? 

The report of the Justice Nanavati Commission that investigated the Gujarat riots, noted the statements of witnesses that “there was no police help received by the Muslims and they were simply at the mercy of the miscreants”, and that police help arrived only in the evening. However, several police officials deposed before the Commission that they were not able to reach Naroda Gam because they were managing the more serious situation at Naroda Patiya, which was unfolding at the same time.

Rapid Support Forces: The Unit at the heart of the Crisis in Sudan

0
Since 15 April 2023, Sudan has witnessed violent clashes in the Khartoum and Darfur region, among rival factions of the current military government. The fighting began with the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) attacking key government sites. At least 188 people have died. Both the leader of the RSF, Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo, and the leader of the military, Abdel Fattah al-Burhan, have claimed that they control certain government sites such as the Army chief’s residence, the Khartoum International Airport, the military headquarters, the Presidential palace and the Sudan TV headquarters The crisis comes after years of extreme political instability in Sudan. The instability began in 2019 when President Omar al-Bashir was ousted after ruling Sudan for almost 30 years. The end of his rule was also marked by mass protests. The protests began in December 2018 and continued for several months, calling for an end to his 30-year rule and demanding democratic reforms. The protests were initially sparked by rising bread prices, but quickly evolved into a wider movement against the government. Following his deposition, an interim joint civilian-military unity government was established. In October 2021, the military seized complete power in a coup led by Burhan and Dagalo. The military junta later agreed to hand over authority to a civilian-led government, but tensions between Burhan and Dagalo delayed the signing of a formal agreement. Burhan and Dagalo have clashed repetitively over the integration of the RSF into the regular army. The RSF was a paramilitary militia that fought on behalf of the Sudanese government during the Darfur War. The RSF was used against the protesters who agitated for the deposition of Omar Al-Basheer in 2019.
Coup in 2019
On 11 April 2023, RSF forces were deployed near Merowe and in Khartoum by Dagalo. This resulted in fighting with Burhan’s forces when they refused to leave. The conflict escalated on 13 April 2023.

Guns, Borders and IMF : The History of conflict in Sudan

Background:

Sudan has been in a state of political turmoil for several years now. Since 2019, when the military overthrew Omar Al-Bashir, they promised a transitional government and a path to democracy. However, recent events have seen the military consolidate power and take direct control of the government, leading to concerns about the future of democracy in Sudan. After taking direct control of the government, General Abdel Fattah Al-Burhan held a press conference to explain his actions. He claimed that the takeover was necessary to prevent the country from descending into chaos and promised to establish an emergency declaration and a government of technocrats. The deposal of Omar Al-Bashir was a significant moment in Sudanese history. However, the country has been facing several crises, including the COVID-19 pandemic and a failed coup attempt in September 2020. Additionally, there have been pro-military protests in Khartoum, highlighting the tension between the military and civilian government. Hemetti and the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) are a significant faction in Sudanese politics. Hemetti is a former militia leader who rose to power in the aftermath of the deposal of Omar Al-Bashir. However, the RSF has been accused of war crimes, leading to uncertainty surrounding its future role in Sudanese politics. Sudan has a long history of conflict, and recent changes in the country’s relationship with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have complicated the situation. While Sudan has received debt forgiveness and is eligible for future loans, the suspension of loans and aid by the IMF has had a significant impact on the country. Additionally, there are plans for development aid under the new government, but the country’s history of conflict may complicate these efforts.

Why is the military so powerful in Sudan?

Since the war on terror began, many Western powers have established military alliances with governments in Northern Africa, which has created a significant power imbalance between civilian governments and the military. Civilian governments have often been poor and exploited by foreign governments, while the military has gained access to money and tools of surveillance. This imbalance has resulted in military coups taking over civilian governments frequently in many African countries. Military governments often claim that they are responding to political crises and promise to return to civilian rule. However, tensions between the two branches of government have frequently erupted. This situation is further compounded by the presence of private militias from all over the world. When conflict zones demilitarize, they create new waves of private militias, exacerbating existing tensions. Africa, and Sudan in particular, have been vulnerable to these dynamics. After the Cold War, Africa became a destination for the arms trade, with private militias, insurgent groups, and governments all involved in the trade. Sudan has been particularly affected by this, with a lot of conflicts contained in South Sudan after the split. In 2019, there was a grassroots democratic movement in Sudan, but recent events have thwarted it. The uncertainty surrounding the future of the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) and the accusations of war crimes against them has led to speculation about the role they may have played in the recent takeover by Burhan. The history of conflict and power dynamics in Sudan highlights the importance of international support and involvement in Sudan’s transition to democracy. It is crucial that Western powers and the international community do not perpetuate these dynamics by supporting military governments or private militias. Instead, they should prioritize supporting the development of democratic institutions and civil society organizations.

Concerns over Indians In Sudan:

India’s Minister of External Affairs, S Jaishankar, spoke with officials from  Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates to assess the situation in Sudan. On April 16 2023, the Indian embassy in Sudan confirmed that one Indian citizen died. The Indian embassy has issued advisories to Indians in Sudan and set up a control room.

Democracy or Apartheid: You Can’t Have Both

For two consecutive nights this week, during the holy month of Ramadan, the Israeli military stormed Al-Aqsa mosque. They entered the mosque before prayer was over, firing rubber bullets, stun grenades, and tear gas at Palestinian worshippers. These events left at least 12 Palestinians injured, and over 400 were arrested on the first night. Following the raid, Israeli violence spread across the west bank. Dozens have been hurt by inhaling poisonous gas fired by Israeli forces, and a settler in occupied East Jerusalem shot a Palestinian child. Following the raid on Al-Aqsa on Wednesday night, Israeli settlers were escorted to Al-Aqsa by Israeli forces on Thursday morning. Prior to their arrival, Palestinian worshippers were forced out so that it could be secured for the settlers for the first day of the Jewish Passover holiday. This double standard is not uncommon for Israel as it is inherent to the structure of the settler-colonial state. Palestinians living in the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem (80% of the Palestinian population) under Israeli control are not citizens and cannot become citizens of the state in which they live, nor can they vote for the government which controls their lives. The other 20% of Palestinians, who have Israeli citizenship, have a 2nd class status. Recently the world has witnessed Israeli settlers come together in an ongoing protest to protect their “democracy.” Since January 7, a crowd of over 100,000 have protested every Saturday in response to a judicial overhaul that was proposed by Benjamin Netanyahu’s far-right government. The protestors consider the reform plan, which has now been suspended, a threat to democracy. But we must ask ourselves, what are these protestors really fighting to maintain? How can there be democracy in an apartheid state? Whose democracy is this? The idea that Israeli “democracy” can be protected by blocking the judicial overhaul is a myth. Any plans Israel had for democracy were destroyed when they began the Nakba in 1948. In fact, the reform plan is a product of the settler colonial state, as it would allow the expulsion of Palestinians from their homes even more efficiently than before, a fundamental goal of the Zionist movement.

Ghassan Kanafani: Palestinian revolutionary leader and martyr

This is a fight to maintain and protect the status quo for Israelis, not Palestinians who have been denied all basic democratic rights under Israel since 1948. For Palestinians, there is no democracy. Despite these blatant acts of unjustified violence committed by Israel, there is no outrage among Israelis. The tens of thousands of people who showed up just last week to protect democracy are suddenly silent. Moreover, Palestinian worshippers are beaten by Israel all the time, this violence is routine during Ramadan. In 2021, Israel unleashed an 11-day bombardment on Gaza during Ramadan and there has been no outcry by Israelis to prevent that from happening. This is evidence that the movement for democracy in Israel is not about democracy at all, but about maintaining the apartheid state of Israel as it has existed for the past 75 years – at the expense of Palestinians. It is insulting for Israelis to launch this “democracy” movement when Palestinians have been ignored for decades. Meanwhile in the the United States, our government is the #1 foreign funder of Israel, which means we have a responsibility to hold them accountable. Yet, year after year a majority of Americans sit silent while our government aids and abets in Israel’s extremely undemocratic apartheid of Palstinians. If the United States truly wants to spread democracy around the world, we must stop funding such blatant violence and human rights violations. You simply cannot have it both ways. (Nour graduated from DePaul University with a bachelor’s degree in International Studies in June 2022. She has been advocating for Palestinian liberation for over 5 years, including organizing within her university. She also organizes around related issues, such as abolition. Courtesy: CounterPunch.) . Views are personal. 

SC sets aside Bombay HC order discharging Prof. G N Saibaba in Maoist links case

The Supreme Court on Wednesday set aside a Bombay High Court judgment that had acquitted former Delhi University professor GN Saibaba in an alleged Maoist links case. A Bench of Justices MR Shah and CT Ravikumar remanded the matter to the High Court for fresh consideration, keeping all contentions open. Pertinently, the top court suggested that the case be heard by another bench of the High Court, since the previous bench had already formed an opinion on the question of sanction being needed. The verdict came in a challenge to the High Court’s judgment of October 14, 2022 that had allowed an appeal filed by Saibaba challenging a 2017 trial court decision convicting and sentencing him to life imprisonment. “It will be open for the State to argue that sanction need not be considered once accused is convicted in such a case…We request the High Court to dispose of the appeals expeditiously, preferably within four months. It is also observed that propriety demands that on appeal, the matter be placed before another bench than that which passed impugned order,” the apex court ordered. That appeal was allowed based on the fact that the sessions court framed charges against Saibaba in the absence of sanction from the Central government as per Section 45(1) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA).

Faculty, Students across India call for the Release of Varavara Rao and GN Sai Baba

The High Court had recorded that while terrorism poses an ominous threat to national security and every legitimate weapon in the armoury must be deployed against it, a civil democracy cannot sacrifice procedural safeguards afforded to the accused. The top court subsequently held a special sitting on Saturday, October 15, and suspended the High Court’s decision. The order was passed after the Maharashtra government contended that failure to grant sanction cannot lead to acquittal in view of Section 465 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Supreme Court on Monday also granted bail to Assamese activist and Sibsagar MLA Akhil Gogoi in a case registered against him under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA) for his speeches against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and alleged links to Maoist organisations.

Same-sex marriage is a ‘mere urban elitist view’: Government to SC

Centre told the Supreme Court that recognising the right of same-sex marriage is beyond judicial adjudication and the petitions before the court reflect urban elitist views for the purpose of social acceptance. A day ahead of the constitution bench hearing in the Supreme Court seeking recognition of same-sex marriage in India, the Centre urged the top court to dismiss the batch of petitions stressing that the issues should be left to the wisdom of the elected representatives of the people. A five-judge constitution bench headed by Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud, Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice P S Narsimha, Justice Hima Kohli and Justice S Narsimha is scheduled to hear the batch of petitions on April 18. The court has been seized of 15 petitions demanding legal recognition for same-sex marriages. Submitting a fresh application, Centre maintained that the petitions before the court reflect urban elitist views for the purpose of social acceptance.

LGBTQI Rights Activists Urge SC to Legalise Same-Sex Marriage

“A decision by the court in recognising the right of same sex marriage would mean a virtual judicial rewriting of an entire branch of law. The court must refrain from passing such omnibus orders. Proper authority for the same is appropriate legislature. Given the fundamental social origin of these laws, any change in order to be legitimate would have to come from the bottom up and through legislation a change cannot be compelled by judicial fiat and the best judge of the pace of change is the legislature itself,” stated the application. “This is the only constitutional approach permissible under the Constitution while recognising any socio-legal relationship as an institution with sanction under the law. The competent legislature is the only constitutional organ which is aware of the above referred considerations. The petitioners do not represent the view of the entire population of the nation,” it added. “Any encroachment on the legislative powers solely reserved for the elected representatives would be against the well-settled principles of ‘separation of powers’ which is held to be a part of the basic structure of the Constitution. Any such deviation from the concept of separation of powers would be thus, contrary to constitutional morality,” the application reads. It further states that, “The institution of marriage is necessarily a social concept and a sanctity to the said institution is attached under the respective governing laws and customs as it is given sanctity by law on the basis of social acceptance. It is submitted that social acceptance and adherence to societal ethos, common values, shared beliefs across religions, in case of recognition of “socio-legal institution of marriage” is not be confused with majoritarianism.

Macron Signs Unpopular Pension Reform Into Law After Court Approval

French President Emmanuel Macron on Saturday signed his pension reform into law, despite despite months of street protests and strikes. The legislation proposes to raise the minimum pension age from 62 to 64 and remains deeply unpopular with the French public. The publication happened before dawn in France’s official journal, just hours after Macron’s flagship pension reform was approved by France’s highest constitutional court. This prompted accusations from the opposition that Macron was seeking to smuggle it through in the depth of the night. The constitutional council, which was asked by the prime minister, Élisabeth Borne, to examine whether the pension proposals were in line with the constitution, struck down some lesser elements. These included measures designed to increase employment for older workers, which were rejected on the grounds that they did not belong in legislation that was tacked on to a social security budget bill. The government had hoped the ruling would put an end to three months of protests, but police were on high alert for more demonstrations on Friday night. Hundreds of demonstrators marched from Paris city hall through the Marais area, with several bins set alight and firefighters tackling blazes As reported by Guardian, Mathilde Panot of the radical left party La France Insoumise said the left was “more mobilised than ever” to stop the law. The Socialist party politician Olivier Faure said it was a “bad, unjust and illegitimate law” Jordan Bardella, of Marine Le Pen’s far-right National Rally party, said the pensions row had shown the “vast gap” between Macron and the people. After three months of protests, some of them violent, and clashes with police, the political crisis is not yet over. Trade unions and opposition politicians continued to urge the government to shelve the increase in the pension age to 64, with polls showing two-thirds of the French public oppose the measure. French Communist Party chief Fabien Roussel tweeted, “A law enacted in the middle of the night, like thieves, May 1, 2023: everyone in the street.” Reuters reported that protesters gathered outside Paris City Hall holding banners reading “climate of anger” and “no end to the strikes until the reform is withdrawn”, in a sign the Council’s verdict was unlikely to end widespread anger with Macron and his reform. Some burnt trash bins as they marched through Paris, singing a chant popular with anti-Macron protesters: “We are here, we are here, even if Macron does not want it, we are here.”

Popular Pushback Against Pension Proposal rocks France

Farmer Organisations Condemn Govt Reduction of Wheat Procurement Price

0
New Delhi: Samyukta Kisan Morcha (SKM) strongly condemns the Union Government’s latest assault on farmers by reducing the procurement price of wheat on the pretext of quality of grains. It is well known that the quality of crops suffered this season due to climate change and untimely rains. However, the government is now trying to penalise the farmers for this natural calamity by reducing the purchase price for grains through a value cut upto ₹ 31.87 per quintal. The government’s decision to reduce the procurement price of wheat from the farmers on the pretext of quality is nothing but an excuse to cheat the farmers and deprive them of their rightful dues. Earlier, the Government used ceilings on quantity to reduce the procurement. Now the Government is trying to reduce the procurement under the excuse of quality, which is entirely unjustified. These anti-farmer policies are clearly a vendetta against the farmers for the historic farmers’ movement which led to the PM having to bow down before the will of people.

An MSP scheme to transform Indian agriculture

SKM demands that every grain of crop must be procured at the Minimum Support Price (MSP). The SKM will not tolerate any reduction in procurement on the grounds of quality, as the quality variations due to climate change are not the farmers’ fault. SKM warns the Union Government to withdraw the circular on price-cut immediately and do full procurement at MSP as in the previous years. SKM is giving a call for a nationwide protest on April 18 against this atrocious anti-farmer policy of the Union Government. If the Government fails to withdraw this circular, larger protests will follow. The procurement and PDS from the Green Revolution period provided assured price incentives for rice, wheat and sugar (the flagships of the Green Revolution), but left out some 20 crops now under discussion for MSP including millets, coarse cereals, pulses and oilseeds. MSP could serve, in principle, three purposes — price stabilisation in the food grains market, income support to farmers, and also as a mechanism for coping with the indebtedness of farmers.

Brazil’s Lula De Silva Proposes BRICS Currency to Replace Dollar in Foreign Trade

0
Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva during a visit to Shanghai, China proposed a BRICs currency and limit the role of the Dollar as a global trading currency. The visit to China involved President Lula inaugurating his political ally and former President Dilma Rousseff as president of the development bank set up by the BRICS nations (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa) in a ceremony on Thursday in Shanghai. At the ceremony, he questioned why every country needed to be tied to the dollar for trade and whether someone had decided that the dollar would be the world’s currency. Not only that, Lula also slammed the U.S. dollar’s outsized role in the world economy and had strong words for the IMF during the visit. He alluded to the accusations the latter has received, which included that the IMF forces overly harsh spending cuts on cash-strapped countries like Argentina or Brazil in exchange for bailout loans. “No bank should be asphyxiating countries’ economies the way the I.M.F. is doing now in Argentina, or the way they did with Brazil for a long time and every third-world country,” he went on to say.

Largest strike in decades brings Germany to a standstill

This incident isn’t an isolated one. The calls to reduce dollar dependency in the aftermath of the Ukraine Crisis and the dwindling economy of the US are getting louder, clearly signaling a multipolar world. In February, it was reported that the yuan has replaced the dollar in monthly trading volume between China and Russia, and the difference between the two currencies became more pronounced in March. Another attempt at de-dollarization, this switch occurred due to additional sanctions imposed by Washington. The sanctions affected the few banks left in Russia that retained the ability to engage in cross-border transfers in dollars and other currencies of countries, leading them to switch from the dollar and the euro to currencies of countries who refused to impose sanctions on them, China being one of the most prominent ones.

Common Latin American Currency ‘Sur’

Soon after Lula took oath as the President in January, he announced that Brazil and Argentina were engaged in starting preparatory work on a common currency, something that might lead to the development of the world’s second-largest currency bloc. Other Latin American countries were welcome to join in on the bilateral proposal of creating the “Sur” (the currency name suggested by Brazil) in an attempt to boost regional trade and reduce reliance on the U.S. dollar. Lula’s criticisms on the usage of the dollar comes at the helm of his passionate call to other BRICS countries to drop the dollar and start using their own currencies for trade in a latest effort to reduce reliance on the dollar. These comments, in turn, come amid efforts by China, India, and Russia to set up streams for trade in their own currencies. At the upcoming BRICS summit, scheduled in South Africa, a new financial arrangement is expected to be announced, which might be translated to a common BRICS currency. The pushback against the U.S. dollar dominance and the attempt to de-dollarize is due to many reasons, most of which involves concerns about destabilising economies due to Washington imposing sanctions on unfriendly countries or the burden of dollar-denominated debt for other nations rising and falling with the exchange rate. As Lula’s “Brazil is Back!” slogan reverberates against the backdrop of a multilateralist foreign policy stance, what happens next depends on how he navigates the country on the international stage. Especially with a shift to closer ties with China and with both Brazil and China continuing to refuse to impose sanctions on Russia.

Nandini-Amul Saga: Corporatisation of Cooperatives

0

Amul, a dairy brand under Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation (GCMMF), announced on April 5 that it would sell its products in Karnataka, resulting in widespread protests in the state. In December 2022, Union Home Minister Amit Shah declared in Mandya that Amul would work with the Karnataka Milk Federation (KMF), whose dairy brand Nandini is the second-largest milk procurer in the country (after Amul) and largest milk supplier in Bengaluru.

Farmers’ groups, opposition leaders, Hotel Associations, and general citizens voiced their dissent against this move by taking to the streets, releasing statements, and through social media campaigns online. 

N Jagadish Gowda from Karnataka Rakshana Vedike (KRV) told Deccan Herald that – “The central government only sees Gujarati farmers, not Karnataka farmers who depend on selling to Nandini for their livelihood. This merger will hit local farmers the hardest. We oppose this mentality. We don’t need Amul here.” Indeed, Nandini has already been lurching towards a crisis due to the pandemic, lack of price revisions, rising input costs, cattle diseases, fierce competition from private dairies, and corruption allegations. However, rather than a parochial blame on Gujarati farmers, one must turn their attention to the larger developments in the dairy sector and the centralisation of state-level initiatives as a means towards corporatisation and privatisation. The outcome is not a replacement of Kannadiga farmers with Gujarati farmers, but a replacement of the cooperative structure with a corporate one, disenfranchising both farmers and consumers across the country for the private gains of a few. 

karnataka Rakshana Vedike, a pro-kannada group protests against Amul merger with nandini in Bengaluru and Bagalkote

Amul: Cooperative or Corporation?

According to the International Cooperative Alliance (ICA), cooperatives are people-centred enterprises jointly owned and democratically controlled by and for their members to realise their common economic, social and cultural needs and aspirations. Article 43B of the Constitution says that “states shall endeavour to promote voluntary formation, autonomous functioning, democratic control and professional management of cooperative societies”.

However, following the deregulation of the dairy industry in 1991, the cooperative laws were amended such that cooperatives could run on commercial lines to enable them to compete better in an open market environment. Both Amul and Nandini function within this ‘privatised’ cooperative structure. 

Amul has already monopolised milk markets in most Indian states and ranked 8th among the top 20 global dairy processors as assessed by the IFCN Dairy Research Network in 2020. It is also the largest exporter of skimmed milk powder (SMP). In fact, as Sagari Ramdas points out, several dairy companies on the top 20 ranking are ‘cooperatives’ in name and have become large producers through the exploitation of land, labour and resources, and through the destruction of millions of ‘non-member’ dairy farmers and traders. 

Amul too, when faced with price slumps in the export market, turns to local markets to dump its excess production. As the Amul-Nandini row continues in Karnataka, a KMF official himself admitted that production of milk is low from March-May making the period before May important for Amul. While BJP leaders scramble to paint a picture of two large cooperatives ‘working together’ to meet the needs of the people and bring profits to dairy farmers, it is clear that Amul’s entry into Karnataka is driven by nothing other than the opportunity to divert excess milk to Karnataka’s markets.

Centralisation As Means Towards Corporatisation

The Farm Laws of 2020 sought to liberalise the agricultural market and facilitate the involvement of corporates in procurement of produce, as well as through investments of infrastructure and technology in the agrarian sector. Following its repeal after widespread protests, corporatisation continues to be brought in through different avenues. The Union government’s focus is now on using the cooperatives as a base for collection and distribution of milk, while corporations take over marketing and exports, with private participation at the apex level. 

In October 2022, Shah announced that Amul will be merged with five other cooperative societies to form a multi-state cooperative society (MSCS). In December 2022, amendments were proposed to the Multi-State Cooperatives Act (2002) such that any cooperative society can merge with existing MSCSs, allowing Amul’s newly formed MSCS to further eat up local co-operatives and expand on its corporate production model. The amendments also empower the central government to conduct and oversee the administrative functioning of the cooperative societies, including in matters pertaining to the redemption of their shareholding, further restricting cooperative autonomy. 

Amit Shah visits KMF plant in Bengaluru

Shah directly made the link between the MSCSs and global trade by saying, “We have a huge opportunity to deliver milk to countries like Bhutan, Nepal, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka. To explore this world market, the government is setting up a multi-state cooperative which will act as the export house.”

Privatizing profits and socializing losses

In March 2023, NITI Ayog member Ramesh Chand announced that India needs to find a market for milk in foreign countries as its production is growing by 6% every year. During 2020-21, India exported 54,762.31 million tonnes of dairy products worth `1,491.66 crore (USD 201.37 million). The logic of dealing with overproduction through increased exports makes domestic markets susceptible to global trends, and small farmers take the fall. For example, In 2014, a price crash in Europe led to low procurement prices due to which Amul’s SMP was outpriced in the global market, leading to a huge domestic build-up of stocks. As a result of this, Amul entered the Hyderabad dairy market to dump the excess milk that had reconstituted from SMP, driving down procurement prices in Hyderabad and harming local farmers. 

In the price slump period of 2015-2019, Amul, like all other top corporate dairy players, drew enormous profits. Meanwhile, the losses were passed down to small farmers, many of whom were forced out of dairying or forced into enormous debt. Amul also sustained profits of over 16% throughout the lockdown of 2020, while dairy farmers in Gujarat suffered losses at the same time.

To increase exports, more private investment is needed. The Dairy Processing and Infrastructure Development Fund (AHIDF) of INR 15,000 crore has been set up to support breed multiplication farms and breed improvement technology, manufacturing of milk testing and dairy equipment, and manufacturing of feed supplements/ feed additives. It is available to multi-state dairy cooperatives, milk producer companies, self-help groups and Farmer Producer Organizations (FPOs), which will be vertically linking them to integrated dairy companies like Amul. The latter integration is taken care of by the recent MSCS amendments, but the former technological interventions require enormous capital, to which players like Reliance become key. In April 2023, Former Amul managing director RS Sodhi joined Reliance Retail in an advisory role, which many speculate could be a hint into Reliance’s future plans to foray into India’s dairy sector. 

While the Farm Laws have been repealed following popular protest, the agenda of corporatisation and privatisation is still very much alive and being pushed through other avenues. Through a joint policy of centralisation of cooperative societies and increased focus on export of dairy products, the government is able to integrate local producers and milk markets into India’s corporate dairy agribusiness. Ultimately, this is an existential threat to small producers in the country.

Inputs by Swati Krishna.