These numbers though disheartening also show that parents have also grown aware of the law and have begun to utilise it. The Unnao case highlights the multiple failures of the POCSO Act with intermediaries such as the police unwilling to file the complaint till the passing of a year, despite the fact that the law states that the cases must be tried within that period of time. Despite such instances, there has been no amendment in the law that looks into effective penalisation for the role of other intermediaries in the protection of those accused of the sexual assault of minors.
According to the Act as it stands the only form of penalisation for anyone caught in the abetting of the accused haven’t been clearly defined in the law, so if someone was to threaten the victim’s family and turn them into hostile witnesses it wouldn’t be tried under POCSO directly. In the case of Unnao the multiple individuals it has taken to orchestrate the various acts of violence would not be tried under the fast track courts, because abetment is charged under different legislation. We know in multiple cases that victims turn hostile, often due to intimidation by the accused and external help. Thus ensuring that cases are acquitted, protecting serial offenders. Though one may not be able to deter a serial offender, those aiding him should be dissuaded as far as possible. In this aspect, penalisation must be looked into the abetting of cases under POCSO with a much more intensive approach. In the case of the Kathua rape case involving the murder and rape of an eight-year-old child, large groups protested the incarceration of the accused. This example highlights how there isn’t any level of deterrence from the Act, it is in this way that the amendment doesn’t understand that the accused alone isn’t an assaulter but all those aiding him to promote sexual assault. Therefore with this degree of insulation, through social networks and power equations, capital punishment does nothing to change the social context of the individual. For that, the trial actually has to occur, for that to occur the victims and their families shouldn’t be threatened or coerced into silence.
Despite the increase in the number of cases registered under the Act (with the overall number of cases for the rape of children in 2016 were 19,765 cases (Tiwary, 2017 ), how many accused of this crime actually go to prison remains unclear. When looking at details for the number of incarcerated individuals there exists no clear differentiation in the 2016 NCRB report regarding the child sexual offenses and other forms of rape. However, we do know that in the case of Mumbai 17percent of incarcerated prisoners in the city were tried under POCSO (Hafeez, 2019 ). This could also be a product of the fact that it was a metropolitan hub, access to courts, legal aid, police stations, hospitals, etc all aid in the prosecution of such cases. Yet the states which have shown some of the most massive increases in the registration appear to be the states such as Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Odisha, etc (Tiwary, 2017 )which have a higher rural population belt.
The trying of those cases in a fair manner needs to be investigated and the incarceration rates for these states need to be verified. One of the improvements to the trying of such cases is the creation of tribunal courts for districts and towns with over 100 cases pending under POCSO mandated by the Supreme Court (Bureau, 2019 ). The judgment hopes that by doing so there could be swifter access to justice in the coming years.
However, justice does not merely begin from trying in the court it is important to look into the manner in which children are being approached in terms of medical professionals and police officers during the filing of the FIR. We know that the law attempts to ensure that the victim should be made to feel comfortable when filing the charge, that the filing of the FIR could even be done outside the police station in a place the child feels safe. Despite this and other aspects of the legislation ensuring the special courts for children should be comfortable spaces for them, often in the case of Karnataka, there have been instances where children were seated next to the accused in the waiting rooms of the special courts (Kothari & Ravi, 2016 ).
Another important Amendment to POCSO was the inclusion of a fine towards the victim and their family in addition to other incarceration charges. The fine is to be calculated based on the victim’s medical expenses and rehabilitation due to the sexual assault case. As most victims will require medical assistance for a long period of time with regards also to mental health aid and physical aid, the fine should take into account future costs incurred by the family over a longer period of time rather than the immediate medical cost of the child due to the sexual assault.
The author has previously taught as a teaching assistant for the Institute for Public policy, National Law School of India University.
The POCSO Amendment 2019: Pretends that it doesn’t take a village to raise a child
The Protection of Children against Sexual Offences Act (POCSO),2012, amendment in 2019 has shown a remarkable increase in the penalisation of sexual assault against children, now including the death penalty for cases of aggravated penetrative sexual assault. Though there are multiple ethical questions that are raised for the use of capital punishment as a deterrent to such crimes, one must introspect on whether those perpetrating these crimes are in fact deterred by any law. Since the law’s implementation from 2012 there have been increasing cases of child sexual assault registered with each passing year, the 2016 NCRB report stated that the number of cases registered under the Act had grown by 178.6 percent in 2014 with no reduction in the following years (THE PROTECTION OF CHILDREN FROM SEXUAL OFFENCES (AMENDMENT) BILL, 2019: Statement for Objects and Reasons, 2019 ).
These numbers though disheartening also show that parents have also grown aware of the law and have begun to utilise it. The Unnao case highlights the multiple failures of the POCSO Act with intermediaries such as the police unwilling to file the complaint till the passing of a year, despite the fact that the law states that the cases must be tried within that period of time. Despite such instances, there has been no amendment in the law that looks into effective penalisation for the role of other intermediaries in the protection of those accused of the sexual assault of minors.
According to the Act as it stands the only form of penalisation for anyone caught in the abetting of the accused haven’t been clearly defined in the law, so if someone was to threaten the victim’s family and turn them into hostile witnesses it wouldn’t be tried under POCSO directly. In the case of Unnao the multiple individuals it has taken to orchestrate the various acts of violence would not be tried under the fast track courts, because abetment is charged under different legislation. We know in multiple cases that victims turn hostile, often due to intimidation by the accused and external help. Thus ensuring that cases are acquitted, protecting serial offenders. Though one may not be able to deter a serial offender, those aiding him should be dissuaded as far as possible. In this aspect, penalisation must be looked into the abetting of cases under POCSO with a much more intensive approach. In the case of the Kathua rape case involving the murder and rape of an eight-year-old child, large groups protested the incarceration of the accused. This example highlights how there isn’t any level of deterrence from the Act, it is in this way that the amendment doesn’t understand that the accused alone isn’t an assaulter but all those aiding him to promote sexual assault. Therefore with this degree of insulation, through social networks and power equations, capital punishment does nothing to change the social context of the individual. For that, the trial actually has to occur, for that to occur the victims and their families shouldn’t be threatened or coerced into silence.
Despite the increase in the number of cases registered under the Act (with the overall number of cases for the rape of children in 2016 were 19,765 cases (Tiwary, 2017 ), how many accused of this crime actually go to prison remains unclear. When looking at details for the number of incarcerated individuals there exists no clear differentiation in the 2016 NCRB report regarding the child sexual offenses and other forms of rape. However, we do know that in the case of Mumbai 17percent of incarcerated prisoners in the city were tried under POCSO (Hafeez, 2019 ). This could also be a product of the fact that it was a metropolitan hub, access to courts, legal aid, police stations, hospitals, etc all aid in the prosecution of such cases. Yet the states which have shown some of the most massive increases in the registration appear to be the states such as Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Odisha, etc (Tiwary, 2017 )which have a higher rural population belt.
The trying of those cases in a fair manner needs to be investigated and the incarceration rates for these states need to be verified. One of the improvements to the trying of such cases is the creation of tribunal courts for districts and towns with over 100 cases pending under POCSO mandated by the Supreme Court (Bureau, 2019 ). The judgment hopes that by doing so there could be swifter access to justice in the coming years.
However, justice does not merely begin from trying in the court it is important to look into the manner in which children are being approached in terms of medical professionals and police officers during the filing of the FIR. We know that the law attempts to ensure that the victim should be made to feel comfortable when filing the charge, that the filing of the FIR could even be done outside the police station in a place the child feels safe. Despite this and other aspects of the legislation ensuring the special courts for children should be comfortable spaces for them, often in the case of Karnataka, there have been instances where children were seated next to the accused in the waiting rooms of the special courts (Kothari & Ravi, 2016 ).
Another important Amendment to POCSO was the inclusion of a fine towards the victim and their family in addition to other incarceration charges. The fine is to be calculated based on the victim’s medical expenses and rehabilitation due to the sexual assault case. As most victims will require medical assistance for a long period of time with regards also to mental health aid and physical aid, the fine should take into account future costs incurred by the family over a longer period of time rather than the immediate medical cost of the child due to the sexual assault.
The author has previously taught as a teaching assistant for the Institute for Public policy, National Law School of India University.
These numbers though disheartening also show that parents have also grown aware of the law and have begun to utilise it. The Unnao case highlights the multiple failures of the POCSO Act with intermediaries such as the police unwilling to file the complaint till the passing of a year, despite the fact that the law states that the cases must be tried within that period of time. Despite such instances, there has been no amendment in the law that looks into effective penalisation for the role of other intermediaries in the protection of those accused of the sexual assault of minors.
According to the Act as it stands the only form of penalisation for anyone caught in the abetting of the accused haven’t been clearly defined in the law, so if someone was to threaten the victim’s family and turn them into hostile witnesses it wouldn’t be tried under POCSO directly. In the case of Unnao the multiple individuals it has taken to orchestrate the various acts of violence would not be tried under the fast track courts, because abetment is charged under different legislation. We know in multiple cases that victims turn hostile, often due to intimidation by the accused and external help. Thus ensuring that cases are acquitted, protecting serial offenders. Though one may not be able to deter a serial offender, those aiding him should be dissuaded as far as possible. In this aspect, penalisation must be looked into the abetting of cases under POCSO with a much more intensive approach. In the case of the Kathua rape case involving the murder and rape of an eight-year-old child, large groups protested the incarceration of the accused. This example highlights how there isn’t any level of deterrence from the Act, it is in this way that the amendment doesn’t understand that the accused alone isn’t an assaulter but all those aiding him to promote sexual assault. Therefore with this degree of insulation, through social networks and power equations, capital punishment does nothing to change the social context of the individual. For that, the trial actually has to occur, for that to occur the victims and their families shouldn’t be threatened or coerced into silence.
Despite the increase in the number of cases registered under the Act (with the overall number of cases for the rape of children in 2016 were 19,765 cases (Tiwary, 2017 ), how many accused of this crime actually go to prison remains unclear. When looking at details for the number of incarcerated individuals there exists no clear differentiation in the 2016 NCRB report regarding the child sexual offenses and other forms of rape. However, we do know that in the case of Mumbai 17percent of incarcerated prisoners in the city were tried under POCSO (Hafeez, 2019 ). This could also be a product of the fact that it was a metropolitan hub, access to courts, legal aid, police stations, hospitals, etc all aid in the prosecution of such cases. Yet the states which have shown some of the most massive increases in the registration appear to be the states such as Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Odisha, etc (Tiwary, 2017 )which have a higher rural population belt.
The trying of those cases in a fair manner needs to be investigated and the incarceration rates for these states need to be verified. One of the improvements to the trying of such cases is the creation of tribunal courts for districts and towns with over 100 cases pending under POCSO mandated by the Supreme Court (Bureau, 2019 ). The judgment hopes that by doing so there could be swifter access to justice in the coming years.
However, justice does not merely begin from trying in the court it is important to look into the manner in which children are being approached in terms of medical professionals and police officers during the filing of the FIR. We know that the law attempts to ensure that the victim should be made to feel comfortable when filing the charge, that the filing of the FIR could even be done outside the police station in a place the child feels safe. Despite this and other aspects of the legislation ensuring the special courts for children should be comfortable spaces for them, often in the case of Karnataka, there have been instances where children were seated next to the accused in the waiting rooms of the special courts (Kothari & Ravi, 2016 ).
Another important Amendment to POCSO was the inclusion of a fine towards the victim and their family in addition to other incarceration charges. The fine is to be calculated based on the victim’s medical expenses and rehabilitation due to the sexual assault case. As most victims will require medical assistance for a long period of time with regards also to mental health aid and physical aid, the fine should take into account future costs incurred by the family over a longer period of time rather than the immediate medical cost of the child due to the sexual assault.
The author has previously taught as a teaching assistant for the Institute for Public policy, National Law School of India University.
Supreme Court jolts into action after nation-wide outrage over Unnao Tragedy
Its been two years since the then 17-year-old girl, a minor from Unnao filed an FIR against the BJP MLA Kuldeep Singh Sengar for raping her. The rape survivor has knocked all possible doors and offices but to no avail. The case made headlines when she along with her family tried self immolate outside UP CM Adityanath residence in 2018.
I was raped. I have been running pillar to post for the last year but no one is listening to me. I want to see all of them arrested, otherwise, I will kill myself. I had even approached the CM to no result. When we lodged an FIR, we were threatened.
Lucknow: A woman & her family allegedly attempted suicide outside CM Residence. Her family alleges the woman was raped by a BJP MLA & his accomplices & no action is being taken. pic.twitter.com/Srl5yQqhXP
— ANI UP (@ANINewsUP) April 8, 2018
During this time, the BJP MLA and his men have been harassing the family to withdraw the case. Her father was arrested on false charges and killed in custody. Her uncle is languishing in jail. The only witness was also arrested on false charges and also died mysteriously. Two days ago, a truck hit the car she was in with her aunts and her lawyer. The accident killed her two aunts and the survivor and the lawyer are in hospital with critical injuries.
She has written a letter to Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi, two weeks before the accident, alleging threats to her life from the BJP MLA. In the letter to the CJI, the young rape victim, her mother, sister, uncle, and aunt alleged that the henchmen of the accused, Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MLA Kuldeep Singh Sengar, were threatening to implicate them in false cases if they did not settle the case.

But it wasn’t till the fatal road accident and the national outcry that it followed that the supreme court has acted on the case. Supreme Court has asked to transfer all five cases in connection with the rape survivor, from Lucknow to Delhi. The court has also said the trial in the case should be completed within 45 days. The court also gave Rs 25 lakh compensation to the rape survivor to be paid by the Uttar Pradesh government.
The CBI lawyer had asked for the case to the adjourned till Friday. But the Supreme court refused to accept the plea. A bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi rejected Mehta’s contention, saying the CBI director can gather the information of the cases on the telephone and apprise the bench on Thursday.
Faced with massive public outrage, BJP which was trying to discredit the rape survivor and was protecting Kuldeep Sengar has now expelled him since the accident.
In this climate of fear and political clout, We cannot expect much from Political parties, but the Supreme court actions also look like too little too late. If the supreme court had acted a year ago, most of her family would still be alive and she would not be in a hospital with fatal injuries.
UAPA and NIA amendments: Tools to silence dissenting voices
On 15 July, 2019, the Lok Sabha passed the National Investigation Agency (Amendment) Bill (NIA), and on 24 July, 2019, it passed the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (Amendment) Bill (UAPA). These bills give even more sweeping powers to Central governments in investigating and prosecuting individuals.
If the UAPA Amendment Bill is passed in the Rajya Sabha, the UAPA will empower the central government to designate individuals as terrorists. The need to do so was defended by Union Minister Amit Shah on the grounds that other countries have provisions for their states to declare individuals as terrorists, and the Indian state requires the power to do so as well. He said that individuals who “plant terrorist literature” and promote “terrorist theory” should be designated as terrorists.
While the opposition raised voices against the amendment , notably Mahua Moitra (TMC), Asaduddin Owaisi (AIMIM), Danish Ali (BSP), and others , who raised concerns about the use of these amendments in settling political vendettas by the center and how the bill infringes on basic human rights to a fair hearing and keeps power of the central government beyond reasonable checks. The amendment would give the central government the right to designate individuals as a terrorist without the need for evidence or trial and judicial oversight. The definition of terrorism in the bill is vague, and can easily be misused to criminalize thoughts, possession of literature, and many other forms of association. The appeal process against being labeled a process is so complicated that no ordinary person innocent of charges could ever successfully remove the label.


The UAPA has been used routinely to harass and imprison people raising dissenting voices, including last year when raided the homes of various human rights activists across the country. A notable case was that of Delhi University professor, GN Saibaba, who, owing to his deteriorating health and weak physical condition, is wheelchair-bound, 90% disabled, and is physically suffering in prison.
Arbitrary use of anti-terror laws has usually been counter-productive. For example, in the case of POTA, only 13 people were convicted in the 4,349 cases it covered. Arbitrary anti-terror laws usually lead to the flawed and uncertain procedure, which often backfire in preventing violent activities and create an unending sense of undeclared war reminiscent of the emergency.
The National Investigation Agency is a central agency formed in 2008 after the Mumbai attacks with the mandate to combat terrorism across India. The Agency was created by the NIA (Amendment) Bill with only six members of parliament opposing. The NIA now has the power to investigate offenses regarding human trafficking, counterfeit, prohibited arms, explosives, and cybercrimes. The amendment has greatly increased the jurisdiction of the NIA, as it allows the NIA to investigate offenses taking place outside of India, subject to international treaties and foreign law, and allows the central government to override local police. The NIA also is empowered to constitute special courts that are capable of imposing penalties, including the death penalty.
These two amendments are steps to turning India from a modern democracy to a feudal estate. The amendment to the UAPA makes it clear that the Central government does not need evidence or procedure when deeming people criminals anymore, and makes a mockery of the judicial process by allowing the central government a free hand choosing its enemies. The amendment to the NIA gives the central government the ability to override local police and handle cases on its own. Neither amendment makes the country any safer as gathering proper evidence, the use of correct authorities and the evaluation by an unbiased judiciary are the only ways to make the country safe from anti-social evidence. All these amendments do is gives those who are in power in the center an additional weapon in their arsenal to attack those that raise a dissenting voice, and violate the rights of subjects in an undeclared emergency era.
If the UAPA Amendment Bill is passed in the Rajya Sabha, the UAPA will empower the central government to designate individuals as terrorists. The need to do so was defended by Union Minister Amit Shah on the grounds that other countries have provisions for their states to declare individuals as terrorists, and the Indian state requires the power to do so as well. He said that individuals who “plant terrorist literature” and promote “terrorist theory” should be designated as terrorists.
While the opposition raised voices against the amendment , notably Mahua Moitra (TMC), Asaduddin Owaisi (AIMIM), Danish Ali (BSP), and others , who raised concerns about the use of these amendments in settling political vendettas by the center and how the bill infringes on basic human rights to a fair hearing and keeps power of the central government beyond reasonable checks. The amendment would give the central government the right to designate individuals as a terrorist without the need for evidence or trial and judicial oversight. The definition of terrorism in the bill is vague, and can easily be misused to criminalize thoughts, possession of literature, and many other forms of association. The appeal process against being labeled a process is so complicated that no ordinary person innocent of charges could ever successfully remove the label.

The NIA Amendment bill broadens the powers of the central government in investigating cases they feel are linked with terrorism, including cybercrimes. Together the bills give the central government more power in going after individuals it deems to be a threat.In the early 2000s, NDA-I passed a series of anti-terror legislation, which allowed the state to violate due process, specifically the Prevention of Terrorism Act (POTA). When the UPA took power again, they repealed POTA, but folded many of the definitions of terrorism and anti-terror legislation into the UAPA, by amending the act. This kept the worst parts POTA alive, keeping it part of the arsenal the state could use to ban organizations and curtail individual rights without any appeal to due process, including appeals, the need for a charge sheet. When it was ratified, the Indian constitution guaranteed the right of freedom of expression, assembly, and association under Article 19 of the constitution. Article 14 (Right to Equality), Article 19 and Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberties) have been called by constitutional scholars as to the “Golden Triangle” of the Indian Constitution, which was designed to be fundamental rights on which a democratic society would grow from. The battle to safeguard these rights is a battle as old as the Indian state. In 1950, one year after the constitution was ratified, when the incipient state attempted to ban literature that was critical of it, the courts noted that the provisions under Article 19 protected even radical literature, prompting the legislature to amend the constitution. The first amendment to the constitution was to article 19 which allowed the state to make, what it called reasonable restrictions to the rights enshrined in article 19, and included protecting the “public order” as one of the grounds for reasonable restrictions. During the early 1960s, when the DMK included independence from India in its election manifesto, coupled with the fear of infiltration during the Indo-Chinese war, the Indian state set up a council to look into the issue of restricting the rights in Article 19 for the purpose of national security. In 1963, the 16th amendment to the Constitution, which empowered the Parliament to pass laws regarding the imposition of restrictions of Article 19 rights, was passed. In December 1967, the UAPA was passed, empowering the state to ban any organization that was deemed a threat to national sovereignty without the judiciary. The UAPA has been criticized as being draconian even before in the way it does not give restrictions on the state in how it pursues an arrest or ban, how it criminalizes thoughts and beliefs, the vagueness of what it defines as unlawful activity and terrorism, and its use for suppressing dissent and perpetual imprisonment of political prisoners. According to the National Crime Record Bureau statistics, nearly one thousand cases are booked under UAPA every year, but scarcely 11 convictions occur each year. UAPA cases rarely make it to court, take a long time to be disposed of, and even then, the law is not intended to punish criminal activity, but to assert power. As the UAPA forgoes judicial oversight, cases brought under UAPA are usually flimsy and serve no just purpose.

The UAPA has been used routinely to harass and imprison people raising dissenting voices, including last year when raided the homes of various human rights activists across the country. A notable case was that of Delhi University professor, GN Saibaba, who, owing to his deteriorating health and weak physical condition, is wheelchair-bound, 90% disabled, and is physically suffering in prison.
Arbitrary use of anti-terror laws has usually been counter-productive. For example, in the case of POTA, only 13 people were convicted in the 4,349 cases it covered. Arbitrary anti-terror laws usually lead to the flawed and uncertain procedure, which often backfire in preventing violent activities and create an unending sense of undeclared war reminiscent of the emergency.
The National Investigation Agency is a central agency formed in 2008 after the Mumbai attacks with the mandate to combat terrorism across India. The Agency was created by the NIA (Amendment) Bill with only six members of parliament opposing. The NIA now has the power to investigate offenses regarding human trafficking, counterfeit, prohibited arms, explosives, and cybercrimes. The amendment has greatly increased the jurisdiction of the NIA, as it allows the NIA to investigate offenses taking place outside of India, subject to international treaties and foreign law, and allows the central government to override local police. The NIA also is empowered to constitute special courts that are capable of imposing penalties, including the death penalty.
These two amendments are steps to turning India from a modern democracy to a feudal estate. The amendment to the UAPA makes it clear that the Central government does not need evidence or procedure when deeming people criminals anymore, and makes a mockery of the judicial process by allowing the central government a free hand choosing its enemies. The amendment to the NIA gives the central government the ability to override local police and handle cases on its own. Neither amendment makes the country any safer as gathering proper evidence, the use of correct authorities and the evaluation by an unbiased judiciary are the only ways to make the country safe from anti-social evidence. All these amendments do is gives those who are in power in the center an additional weapon in their arsenal to attack those that raise a dissenting voice, and violate the rights of subjects in an undeclared emergency era.
Liberals, #ZairaWasim is Not Your Key to Wokeness!
//Tara M Rai//
Zaira Wasim will not be the next Madhubala. She won’t be the child star you can fawn over, while she’s sexualized on screen. You won’t see her grow on screen, starring in one successful movie to another, until, of course, she becomes too old. You wouldn’t be updated on the changes in her figure and romantic partners, all tailored to Bollywood’s latest demands. At 18 years of age, she has had a successful five-year career in Bollywood, displaying incredible talent in hugely popular films. However, on the cusp of adulthood, she realized that Bollywood is not for her, and decided to leave. She attributed her decision largely to her feelings towards her faith, Islam, in a letter she posted on social media. Public reaction was explosive; suddenly, it seemed that our Indian public was actually indignant that a woman was stepping out of a position of power and putting her religion before her career.
The crux of the situation is that someone was unhappy and decided to leave the space making her unhappy. And instead of expressing concern and support, many actors and media personalities attacked her decision to further their own faux feminist, liberal, and Islamophobic agendas. Or in the case of Raveena Tandon, self-righteously demanded respect for a misogynistic, exploitative industry. If one stops to think, Wasim is now 18. She has just reached the legal age of consent. That means that her participation in the film industry, as it is for all child actors across the globe, lacked the complete consent of an adult. By making this decision, she is asserting her non-consent, her refusal to live the life of a Bollywood star. It is ironic that while she was a minor playing her roles in Bollywood’s attempts at progressiveness, she was lauded by the general liberal population; but the moment she exercised her right to consent, her choices were condemned with such alacrity by the same population. No one wondered why, the moment she gained more control over her life, she upped and left the film industry.
Now we know that Bollywood is, frankly, a terrible environment for young women. We were aware of this before #MeToo, albeit perhaps in various stages of denial, and the movement has made the fact inescapable. The industry is entirely patriarchal, with rampant sexual harassment and abuse, toxic beauty requirements, substance abuse, nepotism, and too much money. The same goes for Hollywood. And the harassment runs deep and disillusioning, with directors of the most ‘progressive’ films turning out to be harassers. On top of this, Bollywood celebrities are now openly supporting Hindutva fascism, with Priyanka Chopra inviting Modi to her wedding, Akshay Kumar and Kangana Ranaut endorsing Modi, and the latter loudly espousing conservative right-wing views, to name a few. Simultaneously, the content being produced feeds into the same narrative of Hindu nationalism, especially with films like Uri reaping in the profits. It is hardly surprising, then, that Wasim, a Kashmiri Muslim woman, would feel like she did not “belong” in Bollywood and was not “truly happy” working in the industry. There are enough possible reasons for her to leave, and a feminist or otherwise progressive public would be quick to understand that, without demanding explanations.
The main criticisms leveled at Wasim were that she was succumbing to the alleged oppression of Islam by giving up her Bollywood career, thereby causing a blow to feminism, and that she was simply brainwashed – the latter involving speculations of her becoming a jihadi by Payal Rohatgi with a #JaiShriRam and a nod to freedom of expression. These were espoused with some variation by men and women in the industry and the news. Despite their apparently opposing perspectives, these two points sound quite similar. Both invalidate the actress’ agency and imply a fear of Islam. The latter is the usual Hindutva assertion, fed by the fixation of ‘secular’ liberals on Wasim’s religion. The former, however, does not quite match up. Bollywood specializes in promoting misogynistic stereotypes on how women should behave, objectifying women on screen, and teaching us that consent comes in the way of ‘real’ romance. A few movies actively denounce these ideas to varying degrees, like Deepa Mehta’s Fire, for example, but an overwhelming amount contributes to this culture, idolizing toxic masculinity as always (think Kabir Singh, Sanju, Simmba). How, then, is it feminist to participate in this industry, perpetuating these stereotypes in some way or other? Neither is it immoral (for the sake of progressiveness or conservatism), for young women to act in Bollywood – this is how one makes it big, and as a young actress, one usually has little choice in the kinds of films one acts in to rise in the industry, especially if one has no contacts. It is a career choice – careers definitely being steps to empowerment – but unless one uses it to challenge the status quo, it cannot be called feminist. And leaving the industry is not unfeminist (a point to note is that Wasim’s future career plans are unknown), especially if it is having adverse effects on a woman’s well-being, which Wasim quite clearly stated was the case. What is unfeminist is expecting her to ‘push through the pain,’ as is unfortunately valorized in women – but this patriarchal notion only serves to keep women subordinated in unhealthy, painful situations.
The issue skirts close to the ever-growing practice of choice feminism, as Barkha Dutt points out in her shortsighted views on Wasim’s exit, saying “choice is sometimes a complicated word. For women, especially.” Choice feminism is simply a fallacious (but harmful) liberal interpretation of feminism, that celebrates the making of any choice by a woman as empowering – this empowerment being purely individual, and therefore it does not matter if it is significant to the larger movement. Strikingly, it refuses to take into account the basis and historical motivations of these choices – how the patriarchy plays an invisible hand in a woman’s choice to get married to a man or wax her legs. While there is nothing wrong in making these choices, there is nothing feminist about them. Now, Wasim’s choice is not touted as feminist, though detractors may accuse her supporters of being choice feminists. However, they would be wrong, as this is not a meaningless choice that only aligns with existing power structures, because the religion in question is Islam, a minority religion. This, then, becomes an assertion of her marginalized identity, as well as being a means for her to find solace after a difficult time. Neither of these would please an upper-caste, Hindu public.
In all the outcry around the oppression of religion, people seemed to ignore the biggest religious oppressor there is, which is Hinduism and its perpetuation of hierarchy and violence. Hinduism has been consistently present in Bollywood films and the public lives of celebrities. When Nusrat Jahan, TMC MLA, and Muslim, put on sindoor for her oath-taking ceremony, where were the cries of brainwashing and fears of her turning into a Hindu terrorist? These wouldn’t even have been unrealistic concerns.
Reactions of Wasim’s fellow women celebrities were perhaps most disappointing, especially as some of them were Muslim. They displayed a lack of empathy and solidarity that are crucial in such a hugely patriarchal setting, where women are constantly targeted. A few supportive and indignant voices, such as Nagma calling her courageous, lauding her work and wishing her well; Saba Naqvi asking, “Who on earth are we to judge #ZairaWasim and her choices..a spiritual path works for many people,” were relieving. However, even feminist writers like Taslima Nasreen displayed a complete lack of understanding, calling Wasim’s choice “a moronic decision,” and lamenting that “so many talents in the Muslim community are forced to go under the darkness of the burqa,” again stigmatizing the burqa.
A lot of the unnecessary backlash stems from a larger elite liberal culture of absolutely having to declare an opinion on anything that sounds remotely political, to prove one’s liberal attitudes. And liberals usually choose to ignore serious political concerns or see them as private conversation topics, rather than speaking up in public and inviting possible discomfort to their inflow of wealth. Wasim’s case seemed a safe bet, Islam and not Hindusims was being called regressive, and women doing anything could be termed feminist or unfeminist. All of this is, however, is at the expense of someone’s well-being. This ties in with the other toxic culture of inspecting and judging every move a woman, especially a celebrity, make; men get away without much judgment unless they have other marginalized identities that are weaponized against them (the Khans do not count). The more on the margins one is in the public arena, the more one’s mundane actions are scrutinised because the dominant voice is naturally the majority’s.
Tara is a Psychology student and co-heads Feminist Collective. The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the author.
References:
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/magazines/panache/zaira-wasim-quits-bollywood-nagma-lauds-courageous-girl-raveena-criticises-taslima-nasreen-calls-it-a-moronic-decision/articleshow/70018054.cms
https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/zaira-wasim-controversy-reveals-contemporary-india-190703092002011.html
https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/zaira-wasim-decision-quit-bollywood-faith-stirs-debate-190702111327288.html
The crux of the situation is that someone was unhappy and decided to leave the space making her unhappy. And instead of expressing concern and support, many actors and media personalities attacked her decision to further their own faux feminist, liberal, and Islamophobic agendas. Or in the case of Raveena Tandon, self-righteously demanded respect for a misogynistic, exploitative industry. If one stops to think, Wasim is now 18. She has just reached the legal age of consent. That means that her participation in the film industry, as it is for all child actors across the globe, lacked the complete consent of an adult. By making this decision, she is asserting her non-consent, her refusal to live the life of a Bollywood star. It is ironic that while she was a minor playing her roles in Bollywood’s attempts at progressiveness, she was lauded by the general liberal population; but the moment she exercised her right to consent, her choices were condemned with such alacrity by the same population. No one wondered why, the moment she gained more control over her life, she upped and left the film industry.
Now we know that Bollywood is, frankly, a terrible environment for young women. We were aware of this before #MeToo, albeit perhaps in various stages of denial, and the movement has made the fact inescapable. The industry is entirely patriarchal, with rampant sexual harassment and abuse, toxic beauty requirements, substance abuse, nepotism, and too much money. The same goes for Hollywood. And the harassment runs deep and disillusioning, with directors of the most ‘progressive’ films turning out to be harassers. On top of this, Bollywood celebrities are now openly supporting Hindutva fascism, with Priyanka Chopra inviting Modi to her wedding, Akshay Kumar and Kangana Ranaut endorsing Modi, and the latter loudly espousing conservative right-wing views, to name a few. Simultaneously, the content being produced feeds into the same narrative of Hindu nationalism, especially with films like Uri reaping in the profits. It is hardly surprising, then, that Wasim, a Kashmiri Muslim woman, would feel like she did not “belong” in Bollywood and was not “truly happy” working in the industry. There are enough possible reasons for her to leave, and a feminist or otherwise progressive public would be quick to understand that, without demanding explanations.
The main criticisms leveled at Wasim were that she was succumbing to the alleged oppression of Islam by giving up her Bollywood career, thereby causing a blow to feminism, and that she was simply brainwashed – the latter involving speculations of her becoming a jihadi by Payal Rohatgi with a #JaiShriRam and a nod to freedom of expression. These were espoused with some variation by men and women in the industry and the news. Despite their apparently opposing perspectives, these two points sound quite similar. Both invalidate the actress’ agency and imply a fear of Islam. The latter is the usual Hindutva assertion, fed by the fixation of ‘secular’ liberals on Wasim’s religion. The former, however, does not quite match up. Bollywood specializes in promoting misogynistic stereotypes on how women should behave, objectifying women on screen, and teaching us that consent comes in the way of ‘real’ romance. A few movies actively denounce these ideas to varying degrees, like Deepa Mehta’s Fire, for example, but an overwhelming amount contributes to this culture, idolizing toxic masculinity as always (think Kabir Singh, Sanju, Simmba). How, then, is it feminist to participate in this industry, perpetuating these stereotypes in some way or other? Neither is it immoral (for the sake of progressiveness or conservatism), for young women to act in Bollywood – this is how one makes it big, and as a young actress, one usually has little choice in the kinds of films one acts in to rise in the industry, especially if one has no contacts. It is a career choice – careers definitely being steps to empowerment – but unless one uses it to challenge the status quo, it cannot be called feminist. And leaving the industry is not unfeminist (a point to note is that Wasim’s future career plans are unknown), especially if it is having adverse effects on a woman’s well-being, which Wasim quite clearly stated was the case. What is unfeminist is expecting her to ‘push through the pain,’ as is unfortunately valorized in women – but this patriarchal notion only serves to keep women subordinated in unhealthy, painful situations.
The issue skirts close to the ever-growing practice of choice feminism, as Barkha Dutt points out in her shortsighted views on Wasim’s exit, saying “choice is sometimes a complicated word. For women, especially.” Choice feminism is simply a fallacious (but harmful) liberal interpretation of feminism, that celebrates the making of any choice by a woman as empowering – this empowerment being purely individual, and therefore it does not matter if it is significant to the larger movement. Strikingly, it refuses to take into account the basis and historical motivations of these choices – how the patriarchy plays an invisible hand in a woman’s choice to get married to a man or wax her legs. While there is nothing wrong in making these choices, there is nothing feminist about them. Now, Wasim’s choice is not touted as feminist, though detractors may accuse her supporters of being choice feminists. However, they would be wrong, as this is not a meaningless choice that only aligns with existing power structures, because the religion in question is Islam, a minority religion. This, then, becomes an assertion of her marginalized identity, as well as being a means for her to find solace after a difficult time. Neither of these would please an upper-caste, Hindu public.
In all the outcry around the oppression of religion, people seemed to ignore the biggest religious oppressor there is, which is Hinduism and its perpetuation of hierarchy and violence. Hinduism has been consistently present in Bollywood films and the public lives of celebrities. When Nusrat Jahan, TMC MLA, and Muslim, put on sindoor for her oath-taking ceremony, where were the cries of brainwashing and fears of her turning into a Hindu terrorist? These wouldn’t even have been unrealistic concerns.
Reactions of Wasim’s fellow women celebrities were perhaps most disappointing, especially as some of them were Muslim. They displayed a lack of empathy and solidarity that are crucial in such a hugely patriarchal setting, where women are constantly targeted. A few supportive and indignant voices, such as Nagma calling her courageous, lauding her work and wishing her well; Saba Naqvi asking, “Who on earth are we to judge #ZairaWasim and her choices..a spiritual path works for many people,” were relieving. However, even feminist writers like Taslima Nasreen displayed a complete lack of understanding, calling Wasim’s choice “a moronic decision,” and lamenting that “so many talents in the Muslim community are forced to go under the darkness of the burqa,” again stigmatizing the burqa.
A lot of the unnecessary backlash stems from a larger elite liberal culture of absolutely having to declare an opinion on anything that sounds remotely political, to prove one’s liberal attitudes. And liberals usually choose to ignore serious political concerns or see them as private conversation topics, rather than speaking up in public and inviting possible discomfort to their inflow of wealth. Wasim’s case seemed a safe bet, Islam and not Hindusims was being called regressive, and women doing anything could be termed feminist or unfeminist. All of this is, however, is at the expense of someone’s well-being. This ties in with the other toxic culture of inspecting and judging every move a woman, especially a celebrity, make; men get away without much judgment unless they have other marginalized identities that are weaponized against them (the Khans do not count). The more on the margins one is in the public arena, the more one’s mundane actions are scrutinised because the dominant voice is naturally the majority’s.
Tara is a Psychology student and co-heads Feminist Collective. The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the author.
References:
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/magazines/panache/zaira-wasim-quits-bollywood-nagma-lauds-courageous-girl-raveena-criticises-taslima-nasreen-calls-it-a-moronic-decision/articleshow/70018054.cms
https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/zaira-wasim-controversy-reveals-contemporary-india-190703092002011.html
https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/zaira-wasim-decision-quit-bollywood-faith-stirs-debate-190702111327288.html
BJP´s B.S. Yeddurappa to take oath as CM at 6 PM today
After a two day wait to get approval from the center, Yeddyurappa meets the governer this morning. He will be taking oath as Chief minister at 6 Pm today.
After the dramatic two weeks in Karnataka assembly, the Kumaraswamy coalition government lost the trust vote followed by Kumaraswamy resignation as the CM.
This will be Yeddyurappa´s fourth stint as a CM. Mr. Yeddyurappa has never completed a term. His last term was in May 2018 after Karnataka elections which lasted just 48 hours, not having enough numbers. This led to Congress and Mr. Kumaraswamy’s Janata Dal-Secular tying up to keep the BJP out of power.
Payal Tadvi´s chilling suicide note details horrors of caste abuse indicting three senior doctors
Dr Payal Tadvi, 2nd-year gynaecology student, belonged to Bhil Adivasi Muslim community. She was found hanging from the ceiling of her room on May 22 2019. Her family had accused three senior doctors of caste discrimination that led to the suicide of Dr Tadvi. The three doctors are in judicial custody since then. A charge sheet filed by the Mumbai police this week has substantiated her family ́s claims about the role of the three doctors in the suicide of Dr Tadvi.
The charge sheet includes 180 statements of Payal´s colleagues, other staff members and seniors of the hospital. One of the crucial statements is that of Payal’s friend, Snehal, who has told the police that Payal was harassed by the accused who targeted her for belonging to a Scheduled Tribe, the Bhil Tadvi community. In addition, the charge sheet also has the suicide note that was retrieved from Payal’s mobile phone.
A three-page suicide note written on civic hospital notepaper was found by the Mumbai police team. In the letter, She has named the three accused Dr Hema Ahuja, Dr Bhakti Mehare and Dr Ankita Khandelwal, for her and her friend Snehal ́s condition. The letter details her daily ordeal under the hands of the three senior doctors and how her complaints were ignored by the Department head. Payal said that the accused harassed them in front of everyone, patients and staff, almost every day.
Full text of Dr Payal Tadvi’s suicide note
“I am really sorry mom and dad to take away my life. I know how much I mean to you all and also you are work to me, but no, at this stage everything has become unbearable. I cannot stand a minute with them. From last one year we have been bearing them hoping one day this will end. But now I can only see the end there is no way out of it really I cannot find way out it. I’m stuck each and everyday is similar to as days are just passing off but we are moving nowhere why this is so? What is the personal thing between us that is causing you to trouble us?
I have made this decision after trying everything out. I found out no one is there to stand for us, support us in this department. In fact it is all our fault, or we are at fault has been concluded. I have chosen this branch with all passion cause I always wanted to be gynaecologist. I step into this college hoping I will get to learn under such good institute. But people started showing their colours. Initially me and Snehal didn’t come forward and said anything to anyone. The torture continued to the level that I could not bear. I complain against them but it showed no result. Condition was similar and it was still going on. Now be it a mistake or now we are so teared apart in front of everyone, patients, staff almost everyday.
I have lost my professional life, personal life, everything because it has been declared by them that they will not let me learn anything until they are here in Nair. I have been purposely posted in PMC ward so that I cannot learn about the ANC and Gynec patients. I am prohibited from handling labour room from last three weeks because they don’t find me efficient. I have been asked to stay out of labour room during OPD hours. Also they asked me to do HMIS entry on computer they do not allow me check patients, all I am doing is clerical work.
Despite putting all efforts, still the condition not improving but I am becoming mentally disturbed. Environment is not healthy to work and I’ve lost hope for anything to change cause I know it won’t. No output will come out if standing/speaking up for yourself. I hold Hema Ahuja, Bhakti Mehare and Ankita Khandelwal responsible for condition of my and Snehal. What they have made is today or what they have portrayed us in front of SHO, lecturers head of unit and hea did department. I have tried a lot come forward many times spoke with madam about this but nothing has been done. I literally do not see anyway. I can only see THE END.
With apology to my parents and beloved ones.
I don’t know how Snehal will cope up with these three. I am also sorry to leave you with them.”
Mumbai crime branch breakthrough with the suicide note
The charge sheet has revealed shocking details of how the three doctors tried to destroy evidence from Payal´s hostel room. Dr Khandelwal and Dr Mehare were the first people to reach the hostel room where Tadvi killed herself and take her body to the trauma ward, after which they returned to the room. Police believe that the original note, along with the photos, were destroyed by the accused. The police had earlier presented CCTV footage in court, showing them enter the room. The police claimed they were trying to destroy the suicide note and other evidence. The photos of the suicide note retrieved from her phone by the forensic lab corroborate the witness statements and her family claims of caste discrimination and abetment of suicide.
Doctors Hema Ahuja, Bhakti Mehare and Ankita Khandelwal are named in the charge sheet with the police claiming that they committed offences under the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, Maharashtra Prohibition of Ragging Act, Information Technology Act and abetment of suicide, destruction of evidence and common intent under the Indian Penal Code.
Mumbai crime branch breakthrough with the suicide note
The charge sheet has revealed shocking details of how the three doctors tried to destroy evidence from Payal´s hostel room. Dr Khandelwal and Dr Mehare were the first people to reach the hostel room where Tadvi killed herself and take her body to the trauma ward, after which they returned to the room. Police believe that the original note, along with the photos, were destroyed by the accused. The police had earlier presented CCTV footage in court, showing them enter the room. The police claimed they were trying to destroy the suicide note and other evidence. The photos of the suicide note retrieved from her phone by the forensic lab corroborate the witness statements and her family claims of caste discrimination and abetment of suicide.
Doctors Hema Ahuja, Bhakti Mehare and Ankita Khandelwal are named in the charge sheet with the police claiming that they committed offences under the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, Maharashtra Prohibition of Ragging Act, Information Technology Act and abetment of suicide, destruction of evidence and common intent under the Indian Penal Code. N Mahesh claims innocence in a press conference after being expelled from BSP for abstaining from Karnataka trust vote
N. Mahesh, BSP ́s lone MLA in the Karnataka government abstained from the Karnataka government trust vote, despite special orders from BSP supremo Mayawati, to vote in favor of JDS-Congress coalition in the Kumaraswamy Government trust vote. He was expelled from the party for defying the party orders.
N. Mahesh has been getting a lot of criticism from activists and political observers for skipping the crucial vote, especially during a time of crisis in state politics. Many feel that at a time like this when the whole country was following Karnataka politics, he could have used this platform to express his party ́s stand and expose BJP ́s horse-trading tactics. Ambedakartie, writer and social activist C. Krishnamurthy said Mahesh is a disappointment to the entire Bahujan movement.
In a press conference yesterday, he issued a clarification saying there has been a communication gap and that he did not disobey party orders. He elaborated that he didn’t receive any message from Mayawati to vote for the Kumaraswamy government. During the 2019 Lok Sabha elections, BSP fielded candidates independently from 28 constituencies, without seeking alliances. Post Lok Sabha elections, the coalition dynamics had changed and he had consulted Dr Ashok Siddharth, a member of the Uttar Pradesh Rajya Sabha and party’s Karnataka in-charge on the trust vote and he had told him to remain independent. He said he was in his constituency for the same reason.
In the press conference, he stated that the information sent out via Twitter, has caused this communication gap and that he has not disobeyed the party high command or violated any party instructions.
N Mahesh was the District Social Welfare Officer in Kollegal before he entered politics. Inspired by Bahujan philosophy, he resigned from his government position and joined the movement. Along with his friend Gopinath, he played a crucial role in building BSP and BVS in the state. After three consecutive defeats, an alliance with JDS helped him become an MLA. He also worked as the Minister for Primary and Secondary Education for four months, after which he was made to resign.
RTI Amendment Bill 2019: Government is trying to fix something that aint broke!
//Venkatesh Nayak//
“If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it”- is an age-old saying that has guided many a practical person, including governments. The National Democratic Alliance in its third term (NDA-III) seeks to encroach upon Parliament’s power to determine the salaries and allowances payable and the tenure fixed by The Right to Information Act (RTI Act) for Information Commissioners at the Central and State level. The motion to move the Bill to amend this law was supported by 224 MPs- a rare occasion where a vote and subsequently a division was required to merely table the Bill in the House. The bill was tabled in Lok Sabha on 22nd July 2019. Going by this vote and the composition of the House, it is likely to pass muster.
In its current form, the RTI Act equates the salaries and allowances to the Central Chief Information Commissioner, other Central Information Commissioners and the heads of State Information Commissions with that of the members of the Election Commission. State Information Commissioners are entitled to salaries and allowances similar to the Chief Secretary- the highest-ranking babu in a State. They all are granted tenure of five years and can serve for this period as Information Commissioners or head of such bodies or until they reach the age of 65 years.
The Central Government wants to remove this fixity by seeking the power to make Rules to determine salaries and allowances and tenure of all Information Commissioners across the country (except Jammu and Kashmir to which the Central RTI Act does not apply). While tabling the amendment Bill, the Union Minister of State for Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions tried to explain that such bodies established by an ordinary statute cannot be equated with constitutional bodies like the Election Commission of India for the purpose of fixing salary and allowances. What detailed justification he will give for removing fixity of tenure remains to be seen. The initial debate also demonstrated the Government’s reluctance to accede to the Opposition’s demand to refer this Bill to a Parliamentary Standing Committee.
Public memory is short. This is where historians, civil society advocates and the investigative media must come in to delve deep into legislative history and critically examine the Government’s justification for bringing in these amendments.
CVC Act lays down parity in salary with the UPSC- a constitutional body
The Minister’s justification for the RTI amendments starkly contradicts the position on the same issue taken during NDA-I. Under the Vajpayee regime, the Government introduced the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) Bill in the same house in 1998. The Bill lapsed with the dissolution of the Lok Sabha and was re-introduced in December 1999. Four years later and after due deliberations in the Parliamentary Standing Committee and both Houses, the Bill became law.
Section 5(7) of the Act equates the salary and allowances of the Central Vigilance Commissioner with that drawn by the Chairperson of the Union Public Service Commission established under Article 315 of the Constitution. The two Vigilance Commissioners in the CVC are entitled to draw salaries and allowances at par with the Members of the UPSC. Thanks to the 7th Pay Commission’s recommendations accepted by NDA-II in 2017, the salaries payable to the Chairperson and the Members of the UPSC have been hiked to the same level as that of a Judge of the Supreme Court.
Nothing in the text of the Constitution requires Parliament to establish a CVC. The necessity of such a body to deal with matters relating to corruption and vigilance in the Central Government and Central public sector undertakings was first identified by the K. Santhanam Committee in 1964. So the CVC performs a purely statutory function, albeit, to uphold the constitutional imperatives of the rule of law and corruption-free governance.
The Information Commissions established under the RTI Act are required to champion the regime of transparency envisioned by the RTI Act- this is one of the initial conditions for corruption-free governance. The Preamble of the RTI Act justifies the establishment of the regime of transparency in order to contain corruption and enable the governed to hold Government and its instrumentalities accountable. While the CVC has only recommendatory powers, the decisions of Information Commissions are binding unless set aside by a High Court or the Supreme Court of India. They can also impose penalties on errant Public Information Officers and award compensation to citizens who suffer any loss or detriment on account of wrongful denial or unreasonable delay in the furnishing of information.
If the CVC can be equated with a constitutional body by the UPSC, why can this principle not apply to Information Commissions as already enshrined in the RTI Act? In view of the NDA’s track record of according high status to such regulatory bodies, the justification that the Union Minister for Personnel gave for bringing in the RTI Amendment Bill is unconvincing- plain and simple.
NHRC Chairperson and Members receive salaries equal to Supreme Court Judges
There is another way of approaching this issue. The Statement of Objects and Reasons attached to the RTI Bill, when it was tabled in the Lok Sabha in 2004, clarified that the legislation sought to give effect to the citizen’s fundamental right to obtain information from governments. In a series of landmark judgments delivered since 1975, the Supreme Court had read this right into the fundamental right to free speech and expression guaranteed under Article 19 of the Constitution. So the Information Commissions’ work has a very important constitutional mandate- to protect, promote and fulfill a fundamental right.
Earlier in 1993, Parliament enacted the Protection of Human Rights Act (PoHRA) (gazetted on 8th January, 1994) to create a statutory framework for the establishment of the National Human Rights Commission and State Human Rights Commissions in all States (except Jammu and Kashmir where a similar body was created in 1997 by an Act of the State Legislature). PoHRA replaced an Ordinance that the President had issued before Parliament legislated on the subject. In December 1993, under the PV Narasimha Rao’s Government, the Government Gazetted Rules fixing the salaries and allowances of the Chairperson and Members of the NHRC. The Chairperson is entitled to draw the same salary offered to the Chief Justice of India and the Members are entitled to receive salaries and allowances in the manner of Judges of the Supreme Court. Click here for the Gazette Notification.
Unlike the Information Commissions which have the power to impose penalties on civil servants for contravening the provisions of the RTI Act, the NHRC admitted before the Supreme Court in 2017 that it was a toothless tiger [Extra-Judl. Exec. Victim Families Asson. Vs Union of India and Ors.]. Despite this candid admission which the Court noted with serious concern, it identified four roles that the NHRC plays under the Act, namely- protector, advisor, monitor and educator of human rights (see para 32 of the judgement). A close examination of the RTI Act indicates that the Information Commissions play a similar role with regard to the fundamental right to information deemed to be a part of Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution. Additionally, Information Commissions resolve disputes when governments unreasonably deny access to information. Both the NHRC and the Information Commissions are statutory bodies with mandates to protect one or more fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution.
Rather than maintain parity in such institutions, the Government is seeking powers to decide on the salaries and tenure of Information Commissions across the country. This move has other constitutional implications which we will reflect upon in our next despatch. However, going by the Union Minister’s justification for the RTI Amendment Bill, should citizens expect the downgrading of salaries and tenures of the heads and members of the CVC and the NHRC in the near future? If not, the proposed RTI amendments will smack of manifest arbitrariness- a ground for challenging their validity in the Constitutional Courts. All said the Government’s explanation for amending the RTI Act is unconvincing. What is the problem it is trying to fix through these amendments?
Venkatesh Nayak is a prominent RTI activist and the Coordinator of the Access to Justice Programme of Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI).
Sadhvi Prachi makes another inflammatory remark at a religious ceremony in UP
The provocative Hindutva brigade is at it again. Even after the BJP has come to power the second time, the hate-mongering of the Hindutva brigade continues unabated.
This time it is the controversial VHP leader Sadhvi Prachi who has gained a following making provocative and controversial statements. During the inauguration ceremony in Baghpat, Western UP, she called for Muslims to be shunned from making Kanwar for devotees of Lord Shiva in Haridwar.
The ‘Kanwar Yatra’ is an annual pilgrimage of Lord Shiva’s devotees. Kanwariyas (pilgrims) visit places like Haridwar, Gaumukh and Gangotri in Uttarakhand and Sultanganj in Bihar to fetch holy waters of River Ganga and worship Shiva with the same water.
Prachi was relentless in spreading venom against Muslims. She called for the boycott of Muslims who make Kanwar for the Hindu devotees. “99 percent of Muslims make Kanwar for Lord Shiva devotees in Haridwar. They should be boycotted. They should be asked to leave from there. Hindus of my country should get employment opportunities,” – She said.
She did not stop at that and further instigated the crowd with her inflammatory statements. She asked devotees to keep Maala( garland) in one hand and Bhaala (spear) in other like Lord Shiva. She exhorted the crowd to not be like Gandhis and be ready for revenge.
Pragya gained prominence for her participation in the movement that led to the demolition of the Babri Masjid in 1992. She was also the founding chairperson of Durga Vahini, the women’s wing of Vishwa Hindu Parishad.
49 distinguished personalities from film, theatre and academia write to PM Modi on lynchings
49 distinguished personalities from the world of cinema, theatre and academia along with activists have written an open letter to Priminster Modi expressing concern over the tragic events like lynchings happening in recent times in the country.
They demanded that the lynching of Muslims, Dalits and other minorities be immediately stopped.
Expressing their concern they say- “We were shocked to learn from the NCRB that there have been no less than 840 instances of atrocities against Dalits in the year 2016, and a definite decline in the percentage of convictions,” “You have criticized such lynchings in Parliament Mr. Prime Minister, but that is not enough! What action has actually been taken against the perpetrators?”
“Regrettably ‘Jai Shri Ram’ has become a provocative ‘war-cry’ today that leads to law and order problems, and many lynchings take place in its name. It is shocking that so much violence should be perpetrated in the name of religion! These are not the Middle Ages! The name of Ram is sacred to many in the majority community of India. As the highest Executive of this country, you must put a stop to the name of Ram being defiled in this manner,” the letter said.
The letter also highlighted the significance of dissent in a democracy.
There is no democracy without dissent. People should not be branded anti-national or urban Naxal and incarcerated because of dissent against the government.”
“We hope our suggestions will be taken in the spirit that they are meant – as Indians genuinely concerned with, and anxious about, the fate of our nation,” it said.
The signatories to the letter include Bengali actor-director Aparna Sen, Konkana Sen Sharma, southern filmmaker-actor Revathy, Mani Rathnam, social activist Binayak Sen and sociologist Ashis Nandy among others.


