Sonbhadra Tribal Massacre : Deceptive Mainstream Media and Political Whataboutery

What happened on 17th July 2019? Village chief Yagya Dutt came on 32 tractor-trolley with around 200 henchmen to take over the land from the tribals of Village Umbha in Sonbhadra district of the eastern district of Uttar Pradesh. When the tribals resisted, what followed was nothing short of a bloody massacre. There was firing for 1 hour from Yagya Dutt and his men. When they were done with the firing, they beat up the villagers with Lathis to ensure they are dead. The incident resulted in the death of 10 people including 3 women and another 28 injured. Villagers called police stations, DM, SDM offices but to no avail. Police reached an hour later when the perpetrators were finished with their job and left a bloody scene behind them. The village is in mourning since then. Media silence for the next two days! Except for the local Hindi newspapers, none of the mainstream newspaper reported the incident. There was conspicuous media silence until Priyanka Gandhi reached Sonbhadra and was detained to prevent her from visiting the family of the deceased villagers. Two questions… Why was media sleeping till then? Was it not a newsworthy story until the entry of political bigwigs and chance of sensational drama in it. What could have happened if Priyanka Gandhi had visited the village and assessed the situation? What is it that the Yogi government didn’t want the opposition to see? We should give credit to Priyanka for at least bringing it to national attention otherwise this issue would have been hushed away in local print newspapers. Now that the issue has created ripples in the political circles and newsrooms, mainstream Media is at its deceptive best presenting the story as a Yogi Vs Priyanka, Yogi Vs opposition spins, distracting from the main issue which was the illegal land transfer and land grab that caused the slaughter of innocent Adivasis. Killings, arrests, torture and mass displacement of Adivasis is rampant in Central and East India. Sonbhadra is no exception. Media has maintained a very tacit silence regarding tribal issues and only focuses on them for tourism photo ops or anti-Maoist propaganda.  It doesn’t care about dead Adivasis or how to bring them justice, but how can it milk the sparring between political heavyweights for TRPs. What were the ruling party and the opposition doing?  The shamelessness doesn’t stop with media ignorance. It is systematic and runs deep. Since the news made national headlines, political parties have started their usual tug of war between Congress and BJP where congress blames the present administration for the Gunda raj and BJP blames Nehru, Gandhi and 70 years for the present state of affairs. Yogi Adityanath who has already gained the reputation of running of Jungle raj in UP did not visit the Village until Monday, 4 days after the massacre. But he was quite prompt in stopping opposition leader Priyanka Gandhi from visiting the victim’s family and imposing section 144. Everyday Yogi Adityanath is coming up with claims to absolve his government from the bloody massacre. He has swiftly blamed the Congress government of 1955 for the present situation. In the next 2 days, he also managed to claim that the accused is associated with SP and BSP, rounding of all the opposition in one corner.  And an unquestioning media lapped it up and made it headlines without any fact check. Since then the issue has been reduced to a political circus and blame game between the ruling BJP and opposition parties. This was a great opportunity for the opposition to question the ruling party but they have only paid lip service to the incident on their twitter accounts. Priyanka Gandhi being the exception. This is especially inexcusable because the parliament is in session, but none of the MPs raised it in Parliament. Meanwhile, there have been protests all across north India by civil society activists condemning this heinous crime.

They Are Choking The Life Out Of The Anti-Defection Law: Devanoora Mahadeva

Ever since more than 15 legislators handed in their resignations and flew to Mumbai, the state’s politics has been taking a new turn every day, evoking disgust. Expressing their outrage the state’s conscience keepers Devanoora Mahadeva and H.S. Doreswamy wrote a letter to the speaker Ramesh Kumar asking him to take appropriate action. In this context, Naanugauri.com interviewed Devanoora Mahadeva. NG: Why did you think of writing a letter to the Speaker, Sir? DM: The media has been portraying the politics around the disappearance of the state’s MLAs as high drama. But what is really happening is filthy drama. Do you know what is actually transpiring now? It is the squeezing out of the life of the anti-defection law. In one way or another, our courts, the governor and the politicians are all responsible for this. What is increasing day by day is the doubt whether these people have any belief in or any respect for the constitution or the courts. Hence I felt that I shouldn’t keep quiet. NG: Why did you write specifically to the speaker? DM: See, some are conducting an operation here. Some are getting the operation done on them. Finally, where does this take us? We have been forced to hang our heads in shame because of this resort politics. Seeing the speaker’s words and actions it felt like he would manage this appropriately keeping a conscience. Hence our prayers were directed to him. More importantly, there is a feeling that the speaker is the custodian of the assembly as well as the legislators. This has been said many times in discussions in the legislative assembly. If he is a custodian of the legislators directly then indirectly he should also be the custodian of the voters who chose those legislators, a custodian of their right to choose. Hence we wrote a letter to him. NG: Can one say that the legislators had no right to resign? DM: Absolutely not. We never said that no one should resign. But it is fair isn’t it to ask those legislators to stay with the people till their resignations are accepted? Don’t you feel that these elected legislators are accountable to their voters? Isn’t this morally right too? The message that is being sent out by them sitting in a resort, in a different state, without even the guarantee of sticking to their decision is that there is some other immoral interest involved in this or that someone has kept them there against their will. NG: What do you think should be done to stop this Sir? DM: It should be made mandatory that people who resign should stay among their voters. We have the belief that the Speaker will bring in this new tradition. It’s true that there is no such law. We can’t change all this by only following the legal handbook. But, within today’s context of unruly, sycophantic and egotistical politicians, the speaker should make a decision that puts the fear about honour and respect in these politicians is what I feel. Translated from Kannada into English by Rashmi Munikempanna also read: Veteran writer Devanoora Mahadeva and freedom fighter H.S. Doreswamy write a letter to karnataka Speaker

Priyanka Gandhi detained on her way to visit the kin of the Adivasis killed in Land dispute

  Priyanka Gandhi was detained on her way to visit the kin of the villagers killed in Land dispute in Sonbhadra district, UP. Congress general secretary Priyanka Gandhi visited the victims of clash over the Sonbhadra land dispute at BHU Trauma Centre in Varanasi. She wanted to meet the victims of the firing at Ghorawal village where she was stopped to meet the family members, after which she sat on Dharna. She was moved from the protest site. Section 144 has been imposed in Sonbhadra. Yesterday, the village chief and his associates opened fire on a group of tribals killing 10 people over a land dispute. A total of 26 people have been arrested.   The dispute is about 36-acre land that tribals have been tilling for generations and have been demanding titles (Patta) for it. The main accused, village chief claimed he had bought the land 10 years ago from a prominent local family. The state’s scheduled tribe commission has taken cognizance of the matter and decided to send a team to the spot. Opposition members have raised concern over the deteriorating law and order condition in the state. Congress general secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra also termed the killing of the villagers in UP as “shocking” and criticized the Yogi Adityanath-led government over the spate of murders in the state. “Under the BJP government, the confidence of criminals has grown so much that murders are being committed in daylight. In Sonbhadra, the killing of 9 people, including three women, belonging to the Gond community has shaken the conscience. The chief minister, his ministers, and the administration are all sleeping. Is this how the state will become crime-free?” she said in a tweet in Hindi. Rahul Gandhi also tweeted calling the illegal arrest of Priyanka in Sonbhadra, UP disturbing. This arbitrary application of power, to prevent her from meeting families of the 10 Adivasi farmers brutally gunned down for refusing to vacate their own land, reveals the BJP Govt’s increasing insecurity in UP.

“To a hate-free society: Let’s end Lynching” event held in Bengaluru

On 16 July 2019, several Civil Society groups organized a panel talk at St. Josephs College Bengaluru to learn from the experiences of those who have been fighting the ever-rising number of cases of lynching in India. The event was called, Dwesha Mukta Samajadhade: Lynchinganna nilisonna (To a hate-free society: Let’s end lynching). The speakers were Harsh Mander, Director of the Centre for Equity Studies, Sharib Ali, from the Innocence Network and Quill Foundation, and Vidya Dinker, All India Progressive Forum.
Harsh Mander, IAS, and sicial activist
Harsh Mander spoke about his journeys in the caravan of love (Karvan-e-Mohabbat), where they had visited the homes of families of victims of 29 lynchings. He shared disturbing patterns in the cases. The violence was indescribably cruel. There was an effort by the perpetrators to make it a public spectacle, often using video and social media. In this way, they showed how proud they were of their crimes. Rather than blame the criminal, there were accusations and charge-sheets against the victim and their families. Unlike earlier cases of communal violence, the people of the locality had no compassion or sympathy for the victim. Even in communal riots, there would be stories of people reaching across communal lines to help people be safe, but in lynching cases, there was nothing but contempt for the victim. While hatred against minorities is rising around the world, what makes the Indian brand unique is that it is built on almost a century of right-wing groups organizing on hate and division. Harsh Mander outlined the need for radical love to fight this radical hate. The caravan of love went on many journeys to express solidarity to the victims of lynching, ask for forgiveness on behalf of society and promise to tell their story.
Vidya Dinker, Social activist
Vidya Dinker described the cases from Dakshina Kannada (South Canara). As a district, it ranks number one district in the country in the number of hate crimes, making Karnataka rank number two after Uttar Pradesh. She described how the Bajrang Dal once attacked Muslim mango trader who has nothing to do with cattle under the pretext of protecting cows. Such groups strike with moral impunity which needs to be understood historically. Resistance has to be ongoing, by holding police and the judiciary accountable, and making sure they take notice and pursue the correct action against the aggressors. Since there is no proper definition of a hate crime, most cases go unrecorded. It’s unclear how far back the violence goes. The RSS had established itself in Dakshina Kanara in 1941 and began cattle related movements from 1954. There is a lot of work to be done, to resist the effects of this long history. Sharib Ali of Quill Foundation, that is engaged in research and advocacy on issues of human rights, justice, and equity started by saying how complicated hate is. “We do not know what makes hate spread or how it stops. In India, there are nearly a thousand hate crimes every year, of which mob lynchings are about 15% of them. Most cases involve attacks by 1-3 people, which technically would not be called lynching since it lacks a mob. It may include vandalism to a church, and many include attempts to fuel hatred, like throwing a pig into a mosque. What hate-based attacks do is that they reorder society. They assert superiority by some groups over others. We can ask for a law, but that will not reverse the damage of this reordering. It may do a little to help, but what we need is a strengthening of institutions that protect those communities affected, and have packages that recognize the effects of this violence and this hate. Institutions like the National Human Rights Commission are slow and can take up to 30 years to recognize the violence, if at all. When the global war on terror began, it became easy for the Indian establishment to equate Muslims with terrorism and began a campaign of hate. It included formal state violence, with the rise of encounter killings of Muslims, and less formal ways, like lynchings. Citizens against hate (CAH), a collective of individuals and groups committed to a secular, democratic, caring India provides practical help to victims of hate crime, and to counter, through research, outreach, advocacy and litigation, hate in all its forms. In Sept 2017, CAH released a fact-finding Report into religiously motivated Vigilante Violence in India. The report can be found here. 

Shifting loyalties, absence of secular vote bank: How JD(S) lost its ground in Karnataka

  Ahead of Lok Sabha election results​​, noted writer Devanuru Mahadeva, in a private conversation anticipated that in future the BJP might get considerable support in the Vokkaliga dominant districts, which were hitherto the strong bastion of the Janata Dal (Secular). Mahadeva, a politician ​identified with the Swaraj India Party, had closely observed ​how youth in the old Mysuru region​ vote​. The Lok Sabha results vindicated him, though he was not expecting his fears would to reality so ​early.
The collective failure of all the ‘secular’ parties in reaching out to the youths with a strong ideology upholding the secular values ​created a climate conducive for the BJP to win 25 out of 28 parliament seats
Under the leadership of B.S.Yeddyurappa, a prominent Lingayat leader, the BJP has succeeded to expand its base in Lingayat dominant north Karnataka districts. The party had difficulty in reaching out to the old Mysuru area. However, the last Lok Sabha election has shown the party is growing strong in all regions, by recording a vote share of 51.4 percent in the state. Now, the JD(S) is losing its base allowing the BJP to take over. The JD(S)-Congress alliance in the elections benefitted the third party. The time has come for the JD(S) to introspect why it failed to retain its votes base. One among the prime reason​s​ is that, despite having ‘secular’ in its name, the party and its leaders hardly represented it on the ground. Party’s patriarch H.D.Deve Gowda, former PM, has the record of taking the minorities along with the party. But that reputation suffered a serious beating when the party under the leadership of his son H.D.Kumaraswamy joined hands with the BJP to form the government in 2006. With regard to the backward classes, particularly the Dalits, the party puts up a sorry face. Prominent leaders of the party look no better than Golwalkars or Hed​g​ewars in treating Dalits. In fact, former associates of H.D.Revanna, Minister for Public Works in the H.D.Kumaraswamy cabinet, have often accused him of rushing to take bath for the second time in the day if the person he encounters a Dalit when he steps out after his regular pooja (prayers) in the morning. The stand he took on many occasions with regard to incidents of atrocities on Dalits has made people such accusations. Even as the JD(S)-Congress alliance was in crisis, the PWD Minister was busy offering promotions to his staff in an objectionable manner. The officers from Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes were allegedly sidelined while offering promotions. Earlier, he was accused of denying posts for SC-ST officers in his department after their deputation to other departments ended. With such a track record, how can he claim to be a leader of a ‘secular’ party? The failure of all secular parties to build a strong secular vote base is the ​main reason for the present mess in the state. It is true the BJP has lured 15 legislators promising them cabinet berths, huge cash among other offers. Beyond all that, the prime reason that prompted the legislators to switch their sides is that they are confident of returning to the legislature on the BJP ticket, in face of a by-election in their constituency. The assembly-constituency wise poll turnout in the Lok Sabha elections clearly show that the BJP has increased its strength, by and large, in all assembly constituencies represented by these rebel MLAs. They have strong reasons to be confident of a victory. In all these developments the sure losers are people of the state. Take the case of Hunasur voters in Mysuru district. A majority of the voters supported A.H.Vishwanath and got him elected in the 2018 assembly elections. Among those voted him included minorities, backward classes, and fans of the H.D.Deve Gowda family. Now, he resigned to support the BJP come to power. This is a betrayal of people´s mandate. Those who elected him are the losers now.​

S.Raghunandan, eminent Kannada playwright rejects the Sangeet Natak Academy Award amid growing intolerance

Naanu Gauri news Desk S. Raghunandan, an eminent Kannada theatre director was honoured by the Sangeet Natak Academy two days ago. However, the playwright has rejected the award citing the increasing episodes of communal lynchings and hateful atmosphere against intellectuals in the country. In an open letter on social media, he has expressed his gratitude to the academy for giving him the award along with the reasons for not accepting the award. The letter: The Sangeet Natak Akademi is an autonomous institution and has been, on the whole, upholding its principles of autonomy through the years. I thank the Akademi for giving me, along with others, its award for the year 2018. However, today there is mob lynching and violence in the name of God and religion, and even in the matter of what one eats. The powers-that-be are directly, or indirectly, responsible for these deadly acts of murder and violence. They are directly, or indirectly, supporting the hate campaign that uses all means, including those offered by internet technology, to fulfill its unholy aims. An attempt is being made to put in place systems that will teach lessons of hate and irrationality to students everywhere, from those in institutions of the highest education to those in schools and colleges. The very meaning of what it is to be an Indian, and the adage Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, are being distorted and erased. But, is not hybridity Shivam indeed? Crores of people like me can only lament: Cry, the Beloved Country. Young people such as Kanhaiya Kumar who should shape the future of India and the world at large are facing charges of sedition and criminal conspiracy. Others – intellectuals and social activists – are facing trial under UAPA. Most of them have not even got bail and are spending time in prison. These are people who have always stood up for the cause of the most exploited and downtrodden of our country and everywhere else. They have argued on behalf of the exploited in the courts, have written books and articles about their suffering, have guided them to fight non-violently, have always followed the tenets prescribed by the Constitution of India, and have upheld its spirit and values. They have waged their righteous struggle with not a thought for themselves. Yet they are in prison. Our rulers have decided that the best way to silence the poor and the powerless is to throttle the voices of these conscientious intellectuals and activists. This has always been so, regardless of the party, or parties, in power. These wonderful men and women, young and old, are our truest patriots. They tread the path of true Dharma and uphold its values. They want, work for, and live for nothing but the good of all beings, sentient and non-sentient. I cannot, as a theatre artist, poet and playwright, accept this award when such injustice is being done to these dharma margis in my country, in the name of my country. My soul, my antaraatma does not permit me to. This is not a protest. It comes out of despair, a helpless inability to accept the award. I respect the Akademi and all those who have received this award, now and in the past. I thank the members of the Akademi and apologise. May there be Shivakarunya Raghunandana

Veteran writer Devanoora Mahadeva and freedom fighter H.S. Doreswamy write a letter to karnataka Speaker

I am Gauri NewsDesk We all are aware of the developments happening in Karnataka.  More than a dozen MLA’s have resigned. Speaker of assembly Mr. Ramesh Kumar has taken route to court and is supposedly weighing all the constitutional ways to either to accept the resignations or reject them. Question is, do the general public too can have a say in the process? If they do, what can they do? Shouldn’t they have the right to know the true answers for the resignations? Who will be responsible if the resignations are accepted, who will bear the cost of re-elections? In the wake of the resignation, defection and disqualification of MLAs, veteran writer Devanoor Mahadeva and freedom fighter HS Doreswamy have written a letter to the President of the Assembly. They are trying to assert the right of the common people. They say that the MLA´s who have resigned have shown no accountability to the people and have betrayed their voters. To, Honourable speaker Karnataka Legislative Assembly Bengaluru Respected Sir, Subject: When the MLA are selling their soul and our votes, the responsibility     of upholding the dignity of the state and the politics lies with us. The political developments in the state are shocking to say the least. Defections are happening towards one particular party but, we feel that all the major political parties should take onus for these unfortunate developments. We know that our parliamentary democracy is not perfect. But the makers of our constitution had put faith in the future generations and had given some opportunities. To prevent unethical defections using those clauses, anti-defection law came to place in 1985. And in 2003, it got constitutional amendments. But bypassing the law and violating the spirit of anti defection law, these MLAs resign from their position and gain much more power than they had immediately and then contest from different party. And the fact that our state Karnataka has shown the country this new short cut to violate the ethics makes our heads hang in shame. Today, another such situation has arrived in our state. As said above, all three major parties need to take responsibility for this.    Today, those who are changing the parties for the reasons of pressure, inducement or any other reasons known to them are also selling their souls and the votes that the voters have casted to them. Yes, it is true that the legislators do have the right to resign. But we should not be seeing this as just a technical issue but we need to see it as a part of public political code of conduct. There is no doubt that what is happening now is defection. Voters do not vote just for the candidates; they vote for the parties too. Many a times, even if the voters do not like the candidates, they go ahead and vote for the particular candidate because of the party they are representing. And the voters vote them for a period of five years. It is the responsibility of the voters to do justice for it. Except for death and ill health, it is irresponsibility to cite any other reasons for resignations. What is happening now is not just irresponsibility it is betrayal.  A rule which prohibits such resigning legislators to contest elections and to hold any office of power for 6 years should be brought.  This libertinism is an act of uprooting the anti defection law while being under the very law; it is rats destroying their own den. Speaker must take this with utmost seriousness. Due to these developments, soul of the political system has come under another severe attack. And we appeal you to take all the actions to make it right. We appeal you, the one who is sitting in such responsible position, not to come to any decision in a hurry or which can be termed as wrong irrespective of your personal orientation. And we request you to consider this as our complaint. If needed, we have decided to approach to higher courts and appeal to judges who have the power and responsibility to uphold the constitution. And we sincerely hope that you, having constitutional power would take actions so that such situation does not arise.    Thanks and Regards Yours sincerely  Devanoora Mahadeva and HS Doreswamy    

Chandrayaan-2 : Vijayavani newspaper did what ISRO scientists could not!

Naanu Gauri News Desk The Vijayavani newspaper, which calls itself as the “number one newspaper in Kannada”, has published a headline on its cover, “nabhakke negeda bāhubali” meaning Baahubali jumps into the sky, Baahubali is the name of the ISRO vehicle to moon. It also claimed that Rashtrapati Ram Nath Kovind who had gone for Tirupati Darshan was also present there to witness this “memorable” event. ISRO had officially tweeted at 3.09 AM that due to technical snag the Chandrayaan-2 launch is cancelled and it will take about a month for the re-launch. But VijayaVani has done a great job of even trumping ISRO scientists.   The fake news of chandrayan-2 has created confusion among the readers. By publishing the fake news of successful launch of Chandrayaan 2, Vijayavani has put the principles of Journalism to grave. It has fell into the trap of being the first and “breaking news” race. It didn’t stop at that. It wrote that due to visit to temples and blessing of Gods made the launch successful. It published that the launch happened at 2.15AM in the morning and the President Ram Nath Kovind has congratulated the ISRO staff on the successful launch. Later in the online edition it has corrected informing about the cancellation of the launch. But by that time, paper has been printed distributed and reached many people. VIjayavani has connected Chandrayaan launch to religion The news piece credited not science but religious ceremonies and blessings of Sri krishna math in the successful launch of Chandrayaan -2. It also made a big news that ISRO President K Shivan recently visited the Udupi Krishna Math and Kollur Mookkambika temples.Udupi math Sri Vidyadhishtirtha Sripad has commented- “This is a good coordination of science and spirituality. Science is not just another face of atheism. There should be coordination. ISRO chief prayed to Kollur Durga temples that is why the Chandrayaan -2 mission got successful. This news piece vijayvaani is being trolled on social media. VIjayavani newspaper lacks journalistic values. Time and again it has shown that it is only after money, name and fame. Earlier also during the demand for independent Lingayat religion it has published fake letter from M. B Patil to Sonia Gandhi.        

CBI raids and unlawful arrests of journalists and lawyers forewarn darker times

2

I am Gauri NewsDesk

 The NDA- 2 government under the leadership of PM Modi isn’t wasting any time in crushing any real or perceived opposition. It started with the life term imprisonment of Sanjiv Bhatt, who has accused Mr. Modi for his role in Gujarat riots. This was followed by bizarre arrests and assaults on journalists who were critical of Yogi government in UP. CBI raids on ex additional solicitor General, Indira Jaising ́s home and office yesterday should be also seen in the same light. She has been a vocal critic of Narendra Modi and his policies since he came to power in 2014.  Jaising and the Lawyer’s Collective have previously been involved in a number of legal cases against the Bharatiya Janata Party leadership. Among the high profile cases one was of IPS officer Sanjiv Bhatt and human rights activist Teesta Setalvad. Sanjiv Bhatt had alleged that Narendra Modi had a role in the 2002 Gujarat riots when he was chief minister of the state. Teesta´s  organisation fights for justice for the victims of communal violence during the 2002 Gujarat riots. She has also represented Teesta Setalvad where she was accused of money embezzlement.  Indira had represented a Greenpeace activist, Priya Pillai in 2015, when she was debarred from flying out of India by the government. Pillai was fighting for the rights of adivasis in Madhya Pradesh. Indira has been critical of the procedure for designating senior advocates in the Supreme Court which she also challenged in court in 2016. Last year, she raised concerns in the appointment of judges in the Supreme court in the assignment of Judge Loya death case.  Since the unlawful kidnapping and arrest of a journalist Prashant Kanojia in UP, five more journalists and rights activists have been arrested. These cases didn’t make headlines as Kanojia case because they were from small towns. 
  1. 9th June 2019, journalist and social activist, in Jharkhand Rupesh Kumar along with lawyer and activist Mithilesh Kumar Singh.
  1. 8th july 2019, Kripashankar and his wife Prabha were picked up from a hotel and arrested. Kripa Shakar is the editor of a UP newspaper, Viruddh and a member of All india forum against hindutva fascism. 
  2. 9th July 2019, Manish and his wife Amita Shrivastav, social worker and school teachers.
All these cases follow the same pattern of abduction followed by arrests.These five arrests were made for alleged links with naxal groups. We have been seeing since last six months,  Modi government has been arresting human rights activists under the farce of naxalite charges. What is the crime of these activists? They were speaking against the anti people policies of the government.  From targeting small town journalists, RTI activists to now much lauded senior lawyers and advocate generals, Modi government has shown that it doesnt care about the stature of its opponents. It is out there to crush all opposition and dissent. The question is to us- How long are we going to remain silent?

Who is Indira Jaising and Why is CBI raiding Lawyers Collective?

0
I am Gauri news Desk Yesterday, Indira Jaising and her husband Anand Grover ́s NGO Lawyers Collective ́s offices were raided by CBI for FCRA (Foreign contribution Regulation Act, 2010).  Who is Indira Jaising? Indira Jaising, a Padma Shree recipient, known for her legendary work in human rights activism is an outspoken and brave lawyer. In 1986, she became the first woman to be designated a Senior Advocate by the High Court of Bombay. In 2009, Jaising became the first woman to be appointed Additional Solicitor General of India.  Jaising has fought and won a number of landmark legal battles, particularly those dealing with Christian women’s right to inherit property, the right of the mother as the natural guardian in child custody cases, or having the Supreme Court strike down instant Triple Talaq as unconstitutional.  She also fought for justice and compensation for the victims and survivors of the Bhopal Gas disaster in December 1984 against Union carbide corporation.  Among the most prominent of the human rights and environmental work done by her include the rights of pavement dwellers during the 1980s Bombay and work on  protection of eco sensitive western Ghats region from mining.  Lawyers collective has worked on the access to lifesaving cancer medicine Glivec opposing the Novartis patent for Glivec. On 1 April 2013, Novartis’ patent was rejected by the Supreme Court of India. It has also worked on the bill against discrimination of HIV person in employment, healthcare and education.   Lawyers Collective(LC) has been under Modi government radar since June 2016, when under the orders from Home ministry, the license of LC for six months for alleged violation of FCRA. It was alleged that the foreign funds were being used for rallies, Dharnas with political “hue and colour” . The organisation was also put on the list of 25 NGOs found allegedly taking part in activities detrimental to the country’s interest in 2016. The complainant in the foreign-funding case is the Union Ministry of Home Affairs.  Indira has clarified all the charges in 2016 itself but in May 2019, another legal NGO called Lawyer ́s Voice, a BJP-backed NGO ,submitted a PIL in the Supreme Court alleging that Lawyers Collective has violated FCRA. Lawyers Voice has sought criminal prosecution of those running Lawyers Collective for alleged misutilisation of foreign funds for “activities against the nation”. Lawyers Voice convener Neeraj is the all india co-convener legal cell BJP.  Let’s take a look at these activities “activities against the nation”.  Even at a cursory glance the charges seem flimsy. According to the home ministry, Lawyers Collective illegally used Rs 13 lakh out of foreign contribution in advocacy with MPs or the media to organise rallies/dharnas for draft legislation meetings in 2009, 2011 and 2014. Any bill goes through several drafts and meetings with concerned parties. The draft legislation meetings, rallies were for the HIV bill that the NGO was working on. The travels with the foreign contribution that Anand Grover is accused of were for the Novartis case. How do any of these things anti national?  Indira Jaising is accused of accepting foreign funds while being a government servant. She had clarified it in 2016 itself that the lawyers collective received grants. She did not work for LC while being the additional solicitor general. The remuneration received during this period had government permission.  Indira Jaising has denied the charges and accused the Union government of using the FCRA as a tool for curbing dissent. Around  200 academics, activists, artists and others have signed a statement condemning the CBI ́s raids on the homes and offices of advocates Indira Jaising and Anand Grover. The Opposition MPs in Rajya Sabha also wrote to PM Narendra Modi, condemning the raids on senior advocates. In their statement, the civil society members have said that the raids are “the latest in a long line of coercion and intimidation of Ms Jaising and Mr Grover” and “nothing short of a brute show of intimidation as well as gross abuse of power”. Signatories include economists Amiya Kumar Bagchi and Jayati Ghosh, author Githa Hariharan, journalists Nitin Sethi and Pamela Philipose, and artists Vivan Sundaram and Parthiv Shah are among the signatories.