Clarify stand on bearing rail fare of migrant Workers: Karnataka HC to state
Migrant Workers gather in thousands at Bandra Station for Shramik Special Trains
According to sources, the Shramik special train was going from Mumbai to Bihar. There were rumors of the train to Bihar and that led to crowding and chaos at the station. The migrants had to register and only the ones who had registered could go.A repeat of the April incident. Crowds again gather at Bandra station in Mumbai.
— Jiten Gajaria (@jitengajaria) May 19, 2020
Where is the lockdown? Where is the govt?
CM @OfficeofUT is busy wooing Corona to live with him and @AUThackeray is either preaching to other MLAs or doing PR on sanitary pads. pic.twitter.com/x55aKYFdKc
By noon, the situation had begun to resemble the recent crowd of migrants a month ago. Police evacuated the station soon after by resorting to lathi-charge to disperse the crowd. Among those arriving at the station were a large number of women and children. Additional forces have also been called to the spot from nearby police stations. Videos from the scene show a sea of people at the Bandra terminus. In a video clip of Tuesday’s incident that went viral on social media, a large number of migrants were seen carrying their luggage and running towards the gate of the Bandra Terminus.Hunger Games, Day-60, India; In major cities, the lockdown seems to have broken. The government has lost control. Hunger and desperation have trumped the fear of the police. Despite that Indian cases are going up exponentially, many cities are opening, for they cannot enforce it. pic.twitter.com/6MMVQ7txmA
— Jayant Bhandari (@JayantBhandari5) May 19, 2020
There are 20 lakh laborers in the state who are trying to move to their own states. Most are from Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and West Bengal. So far, the Maharashtra government has sent about 3 lakh laborers to their state. There is no record of these laborers driving or walking. This has been confirmed by state Home Minister Anil Deshmukh. “Today, a Shramik Special train was scheduled for Purnia from Bandra Terminus for which passengers registered with state authorities were to travel. But many people who were not registered and not called by state authorities gathered on the bridge and the road near station,” said a Western Railways official.Who will take responsibility, if number of cases in #Bandra #Navpada increases after this mess ? Who is responsible for this mismanagement?
— Adil Khatri (@AdilKhatri12) May 19, 2020
No more sugar coated tweets !@MantralayaRoom@mybmc@PiyushGoyal@OfficeofUT@Dev_Fadnavis @zeeshan_iyc @richapintoTOI @manthanmTOI pic.twitter.com/qUV0RbXekO
The incident comes over a month after hundreds of migrant workers had assembled near the Bandra station over their demand that arrangements be made for them to return to their native places in the wake of the coronavirus-enforced lockdown.Bandra terminus managed by best CM of Universe @OfficeofUT 😡😡👎👎pic.twitter.com/JJjNhX1nZX
— 🇮🇳Sandeep Singh🇮🇳 (@sandeepfromvns) May 19, 2020
Migrant Crisis: Justice Being Denied, 57 Days and Counting
Its nothing but a Human Tragedy: Madras HC on Migrant labourers Condition
While discussing the second tranche, the Finance Minister stated that three meals a day were being provided at government shelters to migrant workers all across the country every day. Nothing could be further from the truth. In my personal experience, when these workers were asked whether they have received any cash transfers or ration from the government, almost each and every one of them have replied in the negative. Some of them received cooked food or ration from some non-governmental organisations a few times, but that’s about it. When the Atmanirbhar Bharat Abhiyan was announced by the Prime Minister, I had a small hope that maybe now the government would step up, actually help these migrant workers, and provide them some immediate relief. I was mistaken. For when you look at the fine print of the ₹20-lakh-crore economic package, there is nothing that will provide people any kind of relief right away. Millions of workers have been forced to walk hundreds of kilometres to reach their homes amidst a lockdown from an infectious disease contracted by stepping out and coming in contact with others who are possibly infected. What this lockdown has meant for the workers is that they have no jobs and no money to survive. Whatever little savings they could manage from the meagre incomes have been depleted and they cannot feed themselves or their families. What adds to their misery and destitution is the absence of any kind of relief provision by the government. They have lost all hope and faith. So, this economic package, as economists have pointed out, is too little and too late. This sad ground reality has exposed the government’s inaction towards these migrant workers. One of the measures the second tranche mentions is those migrant workers and their families will be provided 5kg rice/wheat per person and 1kg of chana (pulses) per family per month for two months, free of cost. According to official reports, the Food Corporation of India and other state agencies had an accumulated stock of around 78 million (7.8 crores) tonnes of rice and wheat by March 2020. Once un-milled paddy is added, the total stock rises to a whopping 98 million tonnes. This is much more than the officially recommended buffer stock of 21 million tonnes for the month of April in any year. If only the above-mentioned 5kg is distributed, not for two but six months, to about 80% of the population (100 crores), the total stock used would be around 30 million tonnes. This is almost half of the available 78 million tonnes. Then why have the measures been announced for only two months? The package also states that even people without ration cards would get the same amount of ration, however, this is incorrect. People holding ration cards under the National Food Security Act will get 5kg rice/wheat which they pay for besides the free 5kg, doubling their ration allowance from what unregistered people will receive. Economists have said that this relief measure of ₹3,500 crores providing free grains to migrant workers should be universalised to deal with the distress faced by the workers, seeing that the government has the ability to do so. This tranche also mentions Affordable Rental Housing Complexes (ARHC) for migrant workers travelling from one state to another. Implementation of this will really take a lot of time and these workers need homes now. It also mentions ₹5,000 crores worth special credit facility for street vendors, the official language being “the government will launch a special scheme in a month…”. Given this government’s track record I have little faith they will follow through. There are also astonishing statistics related to this issue. Of the 1.96 lakh tonnes of pulses to be distributed to more than 19 crore households this month, only 30,000 tonnes have been distributed so far (as on 28 April 2020), according to the Consumer Affairs Department. Also, only 15% of poor households have received 1 kg of pulses promised to them for April. According to my knowledge, there have been around 600 migrant deaths to date either due to accidents while travelling on highways, starvation, or suicides. Data for this has been collected by Kanika Sharma and others through the news. I was listening to a news debate where a panelist said that by now there should have been a huge revolution by these workers. But this hasn’t happened because these migrant workers have lost all hope and faith in this government and hence, hold no motivation to even revolt. The complete economic package will only help India become self-reliant in the long run. Whereas these migrant workers need immediate help now. They have been needing it since the past 57 days. The severity of the problems faced by them cannot be stressed enough.Widesprerad Condemnation of the Arrest of another Jamia student
Asif Tanha is a dear friend and has been a formidable presence in various protest grounds and events. The man was a rallying mobilizer for the protests at Jamia, a truly strong voice against injustice and untruths.#ReleaseAsifTanha #Islamophobia_In_India pic.twitter.com/d2egRhth0v
— ️Ladeeda Farzana (@ladeedafarzana) May 17, 2020
Nadeem Khan, spokesperson of United Against Hope condemned the arrest fo Asif Tanha and calls it a continuation of the relentless witch-hunt of students and activists in the middle of the lockdown caused by the pandemic. The official statement from the United Against Hate group has been circulated the continuous arrests amid lockdown and how it is dangerous to the health of students- Many other students have been called continuously for interrogation making a mockery of the lockdown and jeopardizing the health of the student. One head constable in that Special Cell Office has been tested positive with COVID 19. Asif had been earlier called for interrogation by the Special Cell on 08.04.2020 and he had cooperated with the police. Prior to this, he has been called for interrogation as many as four times by the Crime Branch. He dutifully went there and cooperated as a responsible citizen all the four times. Despite the months-long ‘investigation’ and repeated interrogation, the police have found no evidence against him for the simple reason that he has committed no crime. This is the third student of Jamia Millia Islamia that the Delhi Police has arrested since the lockdown, after the arrest of research scholars Meeran Haider and Safoora Zargar under the draconian UAPA. Besides, the President of the Jamia Alumni Association Shifa-ur-Rehman is also under custody. This is a concerted attempt by the Delhi Police to target students of Jamia Millia Islamia, which had emerged as one of the epicentre of the democratic mass upsurge against the unconstitutional CAA. It seems after JNU, the Delhi Police has found a new university to demonize, criminalize and target. A pregnant Safoora continues to remain in prison in the middle of the pandemic at grave risk to her as well as her child’s health and life. Several democratic forces across the country have expressed outrage at these actions of the Delhi Police. But it seems the Delhi Police is too keen to please its political masters. The real perpetrators and actors who incited and carried out the violence are being left scot-free. They have found the lockdown as the perfect opportunity to target these democratic voices, when there is no possibility of protests and there would hardly be any coverage of its nefarious witch-hunt. We condemn this ongoing witch-hunt of students and anti-CAA activists in the strongest possible terms and demand that all students and anti-CAA activists be released immediately and unconditionally.This is a crackdown on unapologetic Muslim leaders like Asif Tanha, Safoora, Khalid Saifi, Meeran, Sharjeel, Tahir Madni, Ishrat Jahan, Dr Zafarul Islam Khan. Ruling class (govt and section of oppn & civil society) want Muslim to be either uncle toms or silent victims https://t.co/Yt4On50IaL
— Aditya Menon (@AdityaMenon22) May 17, 2020
Each and every arrest of those who protested against the unconstitutional CAA is politically motivated and false. Govt wants to crush our voices by such arrests. Arrest of Asif Iqbal Tanha is another brazen attempt to curb powerful Muslim voices of disssent.#ReleaseAsifTanha
— Nabiya Khan | نبیہ خان (@NabiyaKhan11) May 17, 2020
These are some faces who have been arrested unlawfully during the Lockdown by making false allegations against them.
— Gabbar 🐯 (@Gabbar0099) May 18, 2020
Right to peaceful protest is one's fundamental right and these activists have been abiding by the law throughout the time.#ReleaseAsifTanha pic.twitter.com/TBKbFj3uMk
Why women leaders are excelling during the coronavirus pandemic
In India also, the state of Kerala, that reported the first case of COVID-19 has in March has successfully fought the virus and most of the credit goes to its female health minister. KK Shailaja, the health and Social welfare Minister from the Indian state of Kerala has been hailed as the reason a state of 35 million people has only lost four to the virus.
Equitable countries managing pandemic better
Let’s see how this hypothesis holds up, based on the World Economic Forum’s annual study on gender parity among countries that are members of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). Gender parity is measured in terms of the participation of men and women in society and the opportunities available to each gender in terms of access to health, education and employment, among others. The forum’s Global Gender Gap Report 2020 ranks countries in terms of their gender equality performance. Those that have fought the pandemic most effectively and are led by women rank high on the list. The report also shows those same countries rank high when it comes to having women on corporate boards. It, therefore, leads us to conclude that more egalitarian societies are better managed.Read More: Vietnam: How a small nation is leading the way in the fight against the pandemic
In those countries, power is enhanced by the complementary nature of two genders contributing. The added value of this complimentary factor in business management, for example, has been the subject of several studies. One of them, entitled “Delivering through Diversity,” by American consulting firm McKinsey, suggests that businesses with a more equitable gender balance perform better financially. Are countries with greater gender parity managed differently? We observe that in these ecosystems, leadership is driven by supposed “feminine qualities” — empathy, compassion, listening, and collaboration. These are distinct from the characteristics associated with the exercise of traditional managerial, supervisory, and controlling power. It should be noted, however, that these different gender-based attributes are more reflective of the perceptions, stereotypes, and biases that characterize our societies. Women can display supposedly male management traits and vice versa.Female-type leadership required
That means gender-balanced environments produce more robust decisions. These environments also represent leadership where female-like values dominate. The challenges of the 21st-century call for a new type of leadership, different from that based on command and control. These challenges include climate change, health, the environment, the depletion of the Earth’s resources, the aging population and the shortage of talent, the virtual management of production and employee contributions, and the development of new technologies. This new type of leadership primarily involves resilience, courage, flexibility, listening, empathy, collaboration, caring, and recognition of collective contribution. The participation of everyone’s intelligence becomes the key to success. These are all characteristics of traditionally feminine management. In order to overcome the obstacles of the 21st century and to be successful, organizations and countries must, therefore, diversify their sources of talent as much as possible, giving priority to gender. Let’s look at the Canadian business world as an example.Work-family balance
The various difficulties encountered by women due to bias, stereotypes, work-family balance, absences due to maternity and corporate policies that are not adapted to the unique challenges faced by women result in few of them reaching the highest levels of Canadian organizations. Only four percent of the positions of president and chief executive officer are held by women, and none of them are among the 60 largest companies listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange. Another area where there is a need for action is STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics). In its report, “Cracking the Code: Education of Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM),” UNESCO makes this disturbing observation:“Only 35 per cent of girls worldwide study STEM subjects … only three per cent of female students in higher education choose to study information and communication technologies (ICT). This gender disparity is all the more alarming as STEM careers are often referred to as the jobs of the future, the engine of innovation, social well-being, inclusive growth and sustainable development.There is an urgent need to increase the representation of women in all positions of influence. Our female students, among others, need female role models to encourage them to go for it. In this regard, the John Molson School of Business at Concordia University in Montréal is increasing its efforts to hire female teachers and researchers to make women’s presence in the classroom a norm, not an exception. Only this balance will pave the way for new leadership, creating a better world. Louise Champoux-Paillé, Cadre en exercice John Molson School of Business Concordia, Concordia University. Anne-Marie Croteau, Dean, John Molson School of Business, Concordia University. The article was first published at www.theconversation.com It is republished here under Creative Commons license.
Its nothing but a Human Tragedy:Madras HC on Migrant labourers Condition
“Though the Governments have taken care of every section of the society to the maximum extent possible, the migrant workers and the agricultural workforce are the neglected lot and they are the sufferers to the maximum…”“This Court would like to know whether coordinated efforts have been taken by all the State Governments in consultation with the Central Government to address the sufferings of the migrant labourers”, the Madras HC said. It, therefore, ordered to implead Union of India and Tamil Nadu government in the matter. It went on to add, “most of the workers lost their jobs, no shelter is said to have been provided apart from lack of supply of adequate food. After waiting for a considerable time, they started migrating to their native states by foot. It is very unfortunate that those persons were neglected by all the authorities”. “The heartbreaking stories are reported in the print as well as visual media that millions of workers were compelled to start walking to their native States with their little children carrying all their belongings over their head, surviving on the food provided by good Samaritans, as no steps were taken by the Governments to help those migrant workers”, the court noted in the order. “It is also reported that some people starved to death due to hunger. 16 workers working in a steel factory in Julna, Maharashtra, who were sleeping on rail tracks while returning to Madhya Pradesh were crushed to death near Karmad around 30 km from Aurangabad by a goods train on 08.05.2020. Even after the sorrow and sufferings of the migrant workers were reported in the media, nothing happened for the past one month as there was no coordinated effort between the States”, the court observed. The court also recorded in the order that “there are a number of toll gates available and those toll gates should have been made as checking points to provide food, shelter and medical help to the migrant labourers”. “However, it is very pathetic to note that neither the native States nor the States through which they were walking all along took care of them and failed to provide even the basic amenities such as food and shelter and even if the had been provided, they were negligible”, the court added. In this regard, the high court has directed both the Central Government and Tamil Nadu Government to appraise the court with the following information:
- Whether any data is being maintained by the Government of India regarding the details of migrant workers working in each State/Union Territories in India?
- If so, what is the number of migrant workers in each State/Union Territories in India and the details regarding their nativity?
- What is the number of migrant workers stranded in each State/Union Territories in India as on today?
- What are all the assistance provided to those migrant workers by the respective States as well as the Union Government?
- Whether those migrant workers are allowed to cross the State borders or prevented from crossing the borders and if they are prevented, whether they are provided with basic amenities such as food, shelter and medical assistance?
- How many migrant workers died on their way to the native States?
- To which States/Union Territories, the deceased workers belong to?
- What are the relief measures/compensation provided to the families of those migrant workers who lost their lives on their way back to their native States?
- How many migrant workers in each State/Union Territories have been evacuated from their working States to their native States through buses/trains throughout India?
- What are all the steps taken to transport the remaining people to their native States?
- Whether migration of people is one of the reasons for spread of Covid-19?
- Whether the Central Government has instructed the respective States/Union Territories to provide financial assistance, job opportunities in their native State/Union Territories for the labourers who migrated from other States?


