NO CAB in our states: CM’s from Kerala, West Bengal and Punjab

The chief ministers have called the bill unconstitutional and communal and they will not be part of BJP divisive agenda.


After West Bengal, Kerala and now Punjab government have now opposed to the implementation of the Citizenship Amendment Bill (CAB) in their respective states.

The bill was passed in Parliament this week and has become a law after the assent of President Ram Nath Kovind.

The CAB seeks to provide Indian citizenship to Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Christians, Jains, and Parsis. The bill excluded Muslims from consideration of who entered the country from Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan until December 31, 2014, for Indian citizenship.

The opposition to the bill is coming from the people in the Northeast part of the country with continuous protests in Assam and Mizoram. The states have been put under lockdown with internet and telephone blockade and curfew. Many military battalions sent from Kashmir to Assam to control the situation.

The opposition is also coming from states that do not have a BJP government.

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamta Banerjee have been a vocal opponent of NRC and CAB from the beginning. In the last couple of days, he has been joined by Kerala CM Pinarayi Vijayan and Punjab CM  and Amarinder Singh.

Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan yesterday stated that “an anti-Constitutional law will have no place” in his state.

He further added-

“The Supreme Court had made it clear on several occasions that the basic structure of the Constitution cannot be undermined. So, it is clear that this law will not stand legal scrutiny. When that is evident, there are heinous political aims behind passing anti-Constitutional laws using the arrogance of power…Kerala will not implement it. Discrimination based on religion will not be allowed,” 

Stating that the Bill has “demeaned India before the world”, Vijayan said this would only help push India to share the fate of riot-ridden countries and destroy its reputation as a place where people belonging to different religions live peacefully. “What is being staged was a conspiracy to destroy democracy and equality, and establish autocracy and divide the country on the basis of religion. The Union government is trying to realise the dream of (Veer) Savarkar and (M S) Golwalkar with the amendment… It is the offspring of a concerted attempt to sabotage equality and secularism, the basis tenets of the Constitution,” he said.

Vijayan said the CPM-led Left government in Kerala will “question the legality of this black law at all possible venues”. “The Supreme Court had made it clear that secularism is the foundation of the Constitution. With the amended Citizenship Act, the Union government is creating a division based on religion alone,” he said.

Echoing Mamata, Vijayan alleged that the Bill was a move by “communal forces” to divert attention from the “poor state” of the economy. “This strategy had been successfully experimented by British imperialism in India and Hitler in Germany. History had shown that such plans are short-lived. The protests emanating from various parts of the country against the amendment of the citizenship law indicates that’’ he said.

Punjab Chief Minister Amarinder Singh took to Twitter to address his opposition to CAB.

He described CAB as a direct assault on India’s secular character, Amarinder Singh said, his government will not let the legislation be implemented in Punjab. “We have a majority in the Assembly, and will block the Bill. We will not let it rip apart the secular fabric of the country, whose strength lies in its diversity,” he said.

“It is the duty of an elected government to safeguard the cherished values ingrained in the Constitution and not destroy them. How can you leave out a large section of the Indian population from the protection they have been getting since we declared India a sovereign, socialist, secular, democratic republic, assuring its citizens justice, equality and liberty,” Singh said.

Similar echoes were heard from Chattisgarh and Rajasthan which have congress government.

Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel said the CAB was clearly unconstitutional. “Whatever decision is made at the Congress party forum on the Bill, will be applied in Chhattisgarh.”

His Rajasthan counterpart Ashok Gehlot said the CAB was yet another attempt by the BJP to advance its agenda of Hindu rashtra. “We will go through the Bill first and wait for the verdict of the Supreme court. Their intention is not right… they are playing a dangerous game… their intentions are dangerous,” he said.

Addressing an event in Kolkata on December 6, Banerjee attacked the BJP and said: “In your (BJP) manifesto, instead of development issues, you have put in a promise to divide the country. Why will citizenship be on the basis of religion? I will not accept this. We dare you. Be it Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs and Christians, give citizenship to all and we will hit the streets and support you.”

“You can pass laws in Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha forcefully because you have the numbers. But we will not let you divide the country. If everyone keeps shut, I tell you, even if I have to die for this, I will,” she said.


Independent journalism can’t be independent without your support, contribute by clicking below.

June 2024


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here