The Supreme Court ruled on Friday that people holding government offices could not be named as Election Commissioners, noting that entrusting the additional duty of State Election Commissioner to a government officer is a mockery of the Constitution.
The High Court’s decision was affirmed by a bench of Justices Rohinton Fali Nariman, BR Gavai, and Hrishikesh Roy, who emphasised that the Election Commission’s independence must not be jeopardised and that State Election Commissioners must be independent persons.
Also read: Ghana’s LGBT People Live in Fear and Isolation
The Court went on to say that no state should designate someone who already holds a government position as ( Election Commissioner).
The decision came in response to an appeal from the Bombay High Court, which had overturned the Goa State Election Commission’s election notice in the municipalities of Margao, Mapusa, Mormugao, Sanguem, and Quepem.
The top court gave a direction to all states to comply with the constitutional scheme of independent SEC if they are in default.
Also read: WB Elections-Massive “No Vote to BJP” rally in Kolkata
The State Election Commission was allowed to continue the election process in other municipalities while five municipalities were barred from doing so because the wards were not reserved for women as required by statute.
The Supreme Court today ruled that it was troubling that a government employee was in charge of the Goa election commission while still employed by the government.
The Supreme Court also noted that a government official tried to overturn the High Court’s ruling on conducting Panchayat elections.
(This article was first published in Bar and Bench)
Click here to subscribe to our youtube channel



